70th out of 520 books
—
626 voters
Cadillac Desert: The American West and Its Disappearing Water
by
Marc Reisner
The story of the American West is the story of a relentless quest for a precious resource: water. It is a tale of rivers diverted and dammed, of political corruption and intrigue, of billion-dollar battles over water rights, of ecologic and economic disaster. In Cadillac Desert Marc Reisner writes of the earliest settlers, lured by the promise of paradise, and of the ruthl...more
Paperback, 582 pages
Published
January 1st 1993
by Penguin Books
(first published 1986)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,890)
A year later, I've given CD a second read and must, finally, award it the 5th star (for whatever that's worth) that it so deserves. One of the most scathing, witty and instructive books of political /environmental/economic journalism that I've ever had the pleasure (and horror) to read. I do so wish Reisner was still around to bring us up to date on this most vital and fascinating subject. (Afterward to revised 1992 edition is as close to contemporary as CD gets).
Brilliant enough ...more
Brilliant enough ...more
I'm stealing a review from a guy on Amazon that sums up my thoughts better than I could...and I completely reiterate that the PBS 4-part series (which I got from the local library) is HIGHLY recommended...standalone or as a prelude to the book. More specifically, I'd recommend the first 3 tapes, the 4th is a bit too much environmentalist for my taste (related, not Reisner narrated).
By J. Charles Hansen (San Jose, CA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)
I enthusiastically told ...more
By J. Charles Hansen (San Jose, CA) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)
I enthusiastically told ...more
this book is a stunning chronicle of the damming of america's rivers, mainly in the west. i felt that i had to wade through far too much detail about the people (politicians, newsmen, townfolk, MORMONS...), and their motives, the paradigms of the old west that contributed, the bills, and the agencies (bureau of reclamation, army corps of engineers...) responsible for these horrors. BUT it was worth it in the end to see the big picture. unfortunately at this point it seems that there is no turnin...more
This book was a slog for me, and yet one of the most important I've ever read. I guess my main complaint is style (he often takes off for too long on a tangent before finally circling back around to pick up his original point). But that's my only complaint, and it might just be the best book I've read that shows in matter of fact ways (as opposed to partisan) the devastating effectiveness of what happens when conservative's worst nightmare ("Big Government") and liberal's (the corrupti...more
In 1986, Marc Reisner published a book called Cadillac Desert: The American West and its Disappearing Water. In it, Reisner fastidiously documents the appropriation of the West’s most valuable resources, water. The book, now 20 years old, prophetically detailed many of the problems of water supply and land degradation that we are now facing today. Water is the lifeblood of humanity and how we care for this resource will determine our fate. Cadillac Desert is scathing critique of American pol...more
this is a subject i find fascinating, but if you are not into reading about the west and more specifically its water supply, don't read this book. if however, you do like that subject, this is a great book. it is a bit long, and some of the chapters get repetitive (the bureau of reclamation builds a huge, stupid dam, the corps of engineers builds a huge, stupid dam, the bureau builds another huge, stupid dam...), however the history of water policy in the west in one of the biggest nation...more
Why would anyone read a 500 page book about irrigation and dam building? If you are curious why Los Angeles has a population of 10 million, and why California has one of the richest economies in the world, this book has the answers. What began as an attempt to deliver water to poor, struggling farmers, became a nearly unstoppable machine that made wealthy men richer, concentrated political power in the hands of a few, and made a mockery of the notion that our country is based on a free-market ec...more
Water, water everywhere and not a drop of it to drink...or in this case, to irrigate the American West. This book painstakingly chronicles the stories and political hoo-ha behind the major water projects that opened up the American West. The most fascinating story was about the watering of Los Angeles, but from there, the book gets really tedious. It makes me glad I'm moving back to the slightly more sustainable lands of the east coast.
This book was dense and hard to keep straight at times (so many people, so many locations), but it is a fantastic history of our country from the point of view of our most precious resource. I do get the feeling it is a bit biased, as the book rails against the Bureau of Reclamation (unendingly), the Army Corps of Engineers, big/factory farms, and many politicians. I couldn't help but agree with everything he said. Government agencies that are only motivated by continuing to create work for t...more
A read based on the Good Reads rec of Mr Patrick Harris. Harris apparently tolerates idealism more than me. An interesting topic--the West and its water troubles--is mired in writing long on polemic for sections and needing more facts. I was confused for long stretches what Reisner wanted. He was very close to no-growth, but not quite there, and maybe just anti-farming, which is reasonable. Also, the book has been out for almost 30 years and been revised, but suffers from editing problems s...more
This book is still incredibly relevant, despite being published 20+ years ago. The history of the American West is so closely tied to water politics. Overlooking the issues Reisner covers here would give an incomplete picture of what really happens behind the scenes of Western development.
When I first moved to California's San Joaquin Valley as a newspaper reporter, I read a few passages from this book to better educate myself on the history and long-standing battles of the region, a...more
When I first moved to California's San Joaquin Valley as a newspaper reporter, I read a few passages from this book to better educate myself on the history and long-standing battles of the region, a...more
Fascinating and journalistic look into the way that water has built the West and the barely-believable boondoggles that occur[red:]. Interesting biographical - almost titillating - information on certain bureaucrats and colorful outrage at some of the more egregious episodes of public bilking too. My main criticisms are 1) the book bogs down a bit after exciting, page-turning episodes involving the Colorado River, Los Angeles, or the foundations of the Bureau of Reclamation, and 2) the subject ...more
This was a fascinating history of dam-building in the American West. I did not know that the book would be primarily about dams when I bought it, because the subtitle is "The american west and its disappearing water" which seems like it could be more broad, but I got somewhat intrigued by dams after seeing some big ones out west, so the potentially misleading subtitle didn't reduce my enjoyment of the book.
Key points:
1. The Bureau of Reclamation and the Corp...more
Key points:
1. The Bureau of Reclamation and the Corp...more
gr8 history about how the western usa was turned from an arid, unlivable hellscape with no water into an arid, unlivable hellscape with lots of water at great economic and environmental cost. thanks.
An amazing exposition of talent and research. Reisner details the discovery and mapping of the Colorado river personifying the Grand Canyon and giving identity, animation and character to the water. The river becomes more anorexic and salinated as the book nears its conclusion, mirroring the river it is describing.
As a scientist, Reisner researches the qualities of living created throughout the Western United States, discusses in detail the farming practices of California, Texas, Utah,...more
As a scientist, Reisner researches the qualities of living created throughout the Western United States, discusses in detail the farming practices of California, Texas, Utah,...more
For anyone interested in the history of the West and all those who live in the American West and are concerned with its future, this is a must read book. Chalk full of little known, scandalous, and emblematic tales of the settling, development and growth of the primarily desert West, Cadillac Desert is a great read in the sense that it mixes the great academic historical research with good story-telling. One of the best history books I've read and learned from, there is more to know in this book...more
...just a chapter or two in, i already predict this will be one of the more important books i read this decade
An interesting work. Water in the American Southwest is a key issue. The land itself is pretty arid and water is at a premium. Simply, there is not enough water for the many competing demands--from native Americans to water promised Mexico to water in the American West. This work chronicles the struggles for various regions to get the water that they need. It is not always a pretty story (Los Anegeles' thirst for water and some of the tactics used is, at least, unsavory). Sometimes, I think that...more
If you drink water you should read this. It will tell you how you filled your glass. Water is at the center of all human life and the process of funneling it into a form that can be used by millions of people in predominantly dry areas is astounding, entertaining, and quite grim. The book is an interesting mix of good story telling, good history, good questions, and deep knowledge. Can't recommend this enough, both for it's subject matter and for the kind of clear non-politicized information i...more
This book is the reason I dislike textbooks, every high school/college student should read books like this. Any more of a comment would get too political but everyone should read this book. The best synopsis of US (particularly western US) history, politics, environmental science, civil engineering, etc. Very well written and eye opening. If anyone reads it and wants to discuss, let me know. I am badgering my dad with questions when I see him next as he worked for the DWR for many years and...more
This nonfiction account of our society's utter failure to manage our water resources is the best nonfiction book I've read since I was 16 and obsessed with Carl Sagan. Read it if you've ever appreciated a wild and scenic river, if you want to know how LA became a sprawling mess, if you want to know how the Grand Coulee Dam made world war II winable, and if you want to know how big dams helped bring down Jimmy Carter's presidency. This book is awesome and terrible. I read this book over a year...more
I wish the book were more current however the astute follower of the water issues in our country today should be able to pick up where Reisner leaves off. It is fun to view the areas spoken of in the book with Google Earth, while reading about them. Follow American's great rivers and see the stair-stepping dams in succession. See the snaking aqueducts and the islands of green they create in the middle of barren deserts. This book does indeed make you stop and think but the genie is out of the bo...more
So, as somebody who works in this field, I may be a little more interested in the topic of water resources than the average reader. But that doesn't mean that I should be any more vested than anybody else who lives in the West or pays federal taxes for that matter. Because as Cadillac Desert so deftly demonstrates, it's about all of us.
Yes, the book is over 500 pages. Yes, it can be dense at times. Yes, there's an entire chapter dedicated to delving into the extremely nuanced rivalr...more
Yes, the book is over 500 pages. Yes, it can be dense at times. Yes, there's an entire chapter dedicated to delving into the extremely nuanced rivalr...more
No matter how hard I tried, I just couldn't keep with this book.
The first part of the book discusses the manner in which officials from Los Angeles hijack the water from the Owens Valley in order to line the pockets of several businessmen, while ostensibly securing water for the future of Los Angeles. It is a compelling story, but early on, you get the sense that Marc Reisner is writing with a pretty irritated tone.
That tone persists as Reisner details a series of dam co...more
The first part of the book discusses the manner in which officials from Los Angeles hijack the water from the Owens Valley in order to line the pockets of several businessmen, while ostensibly securing water for the future of Los Angeles. It is a compelling story, but early on, you get the sense that Marc Reisner is writing with a pretty irritated tone.
That tone persists as Reisner details a series of dam co...more
Marc Reisner describes the complexities that accompany the history and issues regarding the West's most valuable resource; water. He chronicles the formation of and subsequent power struggles between the Bureau of Reclamation and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers including their vast dam building projects over the past century. Like any good book, rather than trying to push a particular conclusion, it presents the reader with many new (and sometimes unanswerable) questions.
Is it a...more
Is it a...more
Wow! This book, which is a history of water development in the western US from about 1880 to about 1990, is astounding. What I found most fascinating, and appalling, was the rampant, wasteful and shortsighted dam projects build by the Bureau of Reclamation and the Army Corps of Engineers. Through an inexplicable interagency competition and a perception that rivers with freshwater flows reaching ocean are wasting water, the Corps and Bureau have dammed nearly every damable site on nearly every...more
So it's a little nerdy to give this book a 5-star rating, but I embrace it. Marc Reisner tells the tale of American history through the lens of water development (particularly focusing on the west). The science, economic and politics of construction and consumption come to life through the feuds that all-too-often ended in disenfranchisement and even death. While a couple years old at this point, it sets the table for the abuse this precious resource is taking in our country.
Sensatio...more
Sensatio...more
Reisner has a delightful way with language, making this some of the most gripping, page-turning nonfiction I've read. I'm convinced that beyond opposable thumbs, the main thing that sets humans apart from other animals is our unquenchable desire to transform the landscape around us to our own desires instead of conforming to the limitations of nature. Reisner highlights the efforts in that direction, related to water in the western U.S, with an attention to detail and an eye to characterization ...more
I mean, this does not sound like a good read - important and interesting maybe, but the benefit of reading a journalist's book is that journalists know that it's about finding the story that makes in intriguing to learn the stuff that's important to know.
And so this book changed the way I think about the world. Because it kept me interested in learning how pork-barrel politics push expensive projects that make water "flow upwards towards money and power" as Reisner quotes ...more
And so this book changed the way I think about the world. Because it kept me interested in learning how pork-barrel politics push expensive projects that make water "flow upwards towards money and power" as Reisner quotes ...more
I'd probably give this 3 stars for me personally, because it wasn't quite what I thought it would be and I wasn't terribly engaged in the topic. But if you're interested in the history of the politics of water, it's a 5. Well written and often funny. I was expecting more on environmental impact, but that's scattered and minimal. While the devastation of the West, in particular, and the untenable state we're in is the ultimate result of the actions he chronicles, the actions themselves are the fo...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cadillac Desert | 2 | 5 | Jan 27, 2012 05:41pm |

Loading...











view 1 comment








































