The Anatomy Lesson

The Anatomy Lesson (Zuckerman Bound #3)

3.66 of 5 stars 3.66  ·  rating details  ·  1,061 ratings  ·  66 reviews
At forty, the writer Nathan Zuckerman comes down with a mysterious affliction—pure pain, beginning in his neck and shoulders, invading his torso, and taking possession of his spirit. Zuckerman, whose work was his life, is unable to write a line. Now his work is trekking from one doctor to another, but none can find a cause for the pain and nobody can assuage it. Zuckerman...more
Paperback, 304 pages
Published January 30th 1996 by Vintage (first published November 1st 1983)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
American Pastoral by Philip RothThe Human Stain by Philip RothPortnoy's Complaint by Philip RothSabbath's Theater by Philip RothThe Ghost Writer by Philip Roth
Best Philip Roth Books
15th out of 36 books — 27 voters
The Professor Of Desire by Philip RothPortnoy's Complaint by Philip RothI Married a Communist by Philip RothAmerican Pastoral by Philip RothThe Prague Orgy by Philip Roth
The essential Philip Roth reader
6th out of 14 books — 4 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,597)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Joe
Oct 12, 2007 Joe rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: aspiring writers and doctors
Shelves: jewish, fiction
What is perhaps so striking about this book is that Philip Roth depicts an aging writer who, because of undiagnosed physical pain, has stopped writing filling his world with doubt and despair. Zuckerman's pain is very much an investigation of Roth's own biographical highlights. Roth too recovered from surgery, stopped finding writing worthwhile, and was attacked over and over again for his most infamous novel Portnoy's Complaint i.e. "Carnovsky." So disillusioned with writing is Zuckerman that h...more
R.
Aug 27, 2007 R. rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: grief-stricken sons, doubtful writers
Shelves: 2007
Perhaps...perhaps the comparisons to Kafka aren't entirely unjustified.

***
My "problem" with approaching Roth has always been the instinct that his books were about him.

Well, no surprise: they are. Or at least this one is.

Even the dialogue comes off sounding like he's sitting there at his typewriter, furiously talking to himself putting the anger into Zuckerman's voice, and the dissenting opinion into the voice of the Female Who Adores Him.

"Push!"
"Pull!"

Or, more correctly:

"Jews push!"
"Jews pul...more
Ja'net
If the first half of this book didn't exist, the book would've earned three/three and a half stars. But the first 150 pages or so are completely unfocused, boring, and incredible (though I've heard much of what happens in the book actually happened to Roth in real life--a claim that is irrelevant, as far as I'm concerned)that I nearly hurled this book across the room at several points during my arduous attempts at finishing it. The Anatomy Lesson was my first and LAST experience with Roth.
Beverly
Nathan Zuckerman and his doppelganger Philip Roth have grown on me. While not exactly likable, Nathan at age 41 in this installment of the Zuckerman trilogy helped me to understand the method of Roth's fictions. They are totally centered in one single consciousness. I guess that should be obvious, but somehow the intensity of Nathan's ruminating and suffering here made the obvious hit me over the head. There was a funny section (both ha ha and strange)in this novel that showed how the novelist c...more
Justin Evans
Far and away the most rewarding of the first three Zuckerman books. Is that because Roth is just a less cliched character as he gets older? I find that hard to believe. But it makes me wonder- if you're writing what is essentially autobiography, and you're committed to not lying, how hard is it to attain any artistic unity? Not sure Roth did it in the Ghost Writer or in Z. Unbound; here he manages a bit better. Maybe that's just because the Portrait of the Young Artist thing of GW is mind boggli...more
Ryan
I continue to get sucked in by Roth -- a phrasing that Philip would indeed love, as I discover more and more his exploration of the themes of not only his Jewishness but that of sexuality. In general this book covers themes that his earlier works has as well, but what I'm really loving (especially with the Zuckerman series) is his method of playing around with the writer's mentality as Zuckerman (the fictional writer) explores his work and his art and its effect as a way of mirroring his own (Ro...more
Ioana-Maria
(Part of the Zuckerman trilogy). Zuckerman is one of Roth's first-person narrators. He's a successful writer who hasn't written in a long time. He has a constant back/neck pain, so he spends his days lying down on a mat, trying to juggle his three mistresses. To ease his pain, he takes painkillers, drinks votca, and smokes pot. In his delirious attempt to change his life, he takes a trip which will change his life. (Not really, it just sounded cool to write that.)
John
The Ghost Writer, Zuckerman Unbound, and The Anatomy Lesson are of a piece. Not a trilogy in the usual sense, but connected nonetheless: the story of Nathan Zuckerman (often called Philip Roth's alter ego) over a period of twenty something years.

Roth has said these novels are not autobiographical, and I think that is true in the most literal sense. But they seem to reflect Roth's experience, as Zuckerman evolves from young unknown to established author of a controversial book, Carnovsky, which i...more
Richard
For the first half of the book, I thought this was going to be my favorite Zuckerman book. Nathan Zuckerman, put down by some serious pain that no one had been able to find the source of, stoops to the level of possibly letting happen what he'd been resisting through Zuckerman Unbound, and that was becoming his own character, Carnovsky. Like the previous book, Zuckerman still has some struggles with his fame, but some passages are LOL-funny. The extrmism and downright horniness of the writing be...more
Steve
Sep 15, 2010 Steve rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: novel
"His father had never forgiven the mockery in Carnovsky...the wounded pride, the confused emotions, the social embarassment...his brother had claimed that he'd committed murder..he didn't consider it seemly, twenty years on, still to be complaining to his roommate that nobody from New Jersey knew how to read." (p. 621)

"The last of the old-fashioned fathers. And we, though Zuckerman, the last of the old-fashioned sons. Who that follows after us will understand how midway through the twentieth ce...more
Jeremy Allan
Do you pinch your arm to try to distract yourself from the pain of a stubbed toe?

Warning: you may start to feel sympathetic pain if you set this book down midstream. It's as if Nathan Zuckerman will leave you alone only so long as you keep on with his narrative. Otherwise, he'll start to project his suffering on you, until you've finished the novel.

My father says, "Roth can be an acquired taste." I believe everything my father says, but especially in this case. So, if you don't like Roth, fine...more
Josh
I gave it four stars because every page of it was absorbing the way Roth always is (incomparably), but it didn't seem to have a destination. I almost don't care. Every character and scene and memory described is excellent. His earlier books are less fiery and, well, perfect than his later ones. The book preceding this one in the series, Zuckerman Unbound, also seems at times unstructured, but its ending disproves this idea. This one is considerably longer and seems to end arbitrarily. Also, it's...more
Louis Dirigible
less well-received but at least the climax is funny. i don't find roth funny but he paints himself so much the boxer in the corner fighting his way out, even with the bag over his head fighting jewish ghosts you admire something of his brass-tacks perseverance.

this is the only roth book i remember where the protagonist admits he doesn't know something. once early on with some chick and later with the dolorologist. i take this as the humbling pain brings him but it's interesting to see: the one b...more
Adam
I love all the Nathan Zuckerman books.
Ben Chinn
A fitting close to the first Zuckerman trilogy, this book – referred to by Roth in an interview as "The Pain Book" – explores sickness, death, creativity, identity and yes, pain. What does it mean to be a son without parents, a writer who can't write, a Jew without Judaism? Zuckerman has to tackle all these issues in The Anatomy Lesson and I was right there with him. In this book Roth establishes a frenzied pace that keeps building and building to a furious climax in a way that made this a tough...more
Mario
What I respect about Roth's Zuckerman works is that, while they are clearly in some way autobiographical, and consistently egocentric, when it comes down to an argument between Zuckerman and anyone else, the argument is real and fair to both sides. Too often in in works of this nature, the author bends facts and tilts the playing field in their main character's favor. The books are not about the story itself at that point, but about the author attempting to strong-arm the readers into agreement....more
Paola
http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rem...



"Cosa ci insegna il dolore cronico? (...) Il dolore cronico ci insegna: primo, cos'é il benessere; secondo, cos'é la codardia; terzo, un po' di quello che significa essere condannati ai lavori forzati. Il dolore é lavoro. Che altro, Nathan, cosa soprattutto? Ci insegna chi é il padrone. Esatto. Ora elenca tutti i modi di affrontare un dolore cronico. Puoi subirlo. Puoi lottare contro di esso. Puoi odiarlo. Puoi cercare di capirlo. Puoi tentare di scappare....more
Jason Pettus
(Reprinted from the Chicago Center for Literature and Photography [cclapcenter.com]. I am the original author of this essay, as well as the owner of CCLaP; it is not being reprinted illegally.)

As regular visitors know, I'm in the midst of reading all nine of the autobiographical "Nathan Zuckerman" novels that author Philip Roth has penned over the decades, from 1979's The Ghost Writer to 2007's Exit Ghost. And that's because, as a newish book critic (only three years full-time now), I'm continua...more
Hollis
I liked this but it was just too long. I enjoyed 'The Ghost Writer' and 'Zuckerman Unbound' because they were both short and easier to absorb. This one is twice the length and that is twice as long as I wanted to spend in the poisonous world of Nathan Zuckerman. About halfway through I stopped caring about Zuckerman: I wished he would just go and kill himself so I could be finished with the story. But on it goes for another 100 pages...

As usual with Roth, he lightens things up with some comic mo...more
Daniel
It was arguably a mistake to read "The Anatomy Lesson" without first reading the previous two books in the Zuckerman series, but the third installment works fine on its own, especially if the reader has a working knowledge of Philip Roth's own history. One can easily mentally replace "Carnovsky," the book for which author Nathan Zuckerman became famous, with Roth's own "Portnoy's Complaint," and all becomes clear. (I read "Portnoy's Complaint" many, many years ago, but it's not a book one quickl...more
Mike
Aug 30, 2007 Mike rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: roth-zuckerman lovers
this is the conclusion to the first zuckerman trilogy of roth's series. From what i understand, this first collection of zuckerman books (continued with The Prague Orgy) is more about the life of the artist and the writing process and the lows and highs of being a popular author. Contrary to this, the later zuck books actually expand from these themes and deal with characters other than zuckerman himself. Of these first three, i found zuckerman unbound to be the most entertaining to read. it was...more
David
This has to be my favorite of the Zuckerman series. Maybe even one of Roth's better books outside of ones like "The Plot Against America," "American Pastoral," and "The Human Stain." Extremely visceral at times, yet wonderfully comedic at others. At the core, the mental torment the narrator struggles with seems more fully realized than in many other Roth books. I certainly wasn't expecting to get this much. A must read for any Roth aficionado.
Jill
This could have been a good read. It started out fine, but it just drowns you in smut and really crude dialogue. I wouldn't bother with this one. It's not worth what you have to put up with to get to the meat of the story. Then there's the problem of the protagonist, whom you despise even more with every page you turn. He's a total scumbag, and it's hard to care about anything that happens to him.
Phil
Dec 14, 2008 Phil is currently reading it
I have been reading Roth's Zuckerman novels for the past few years--this book is not one of the best. It is talky (nothing new), repetitive (both internally and concerning Zuckerman's family and community histories, the flapdoodle caused by the publishing of Carnovsky, and his sex life), and occasionally studded with really great moments. I plan on re-reading (or, at least, skimming) American Pastoral, which I really liked.
Krok Zero
As always, Roth's prose is breathtaking, and engaging every step of the way. But I'm getting awfully tired of whiny-ass Zuckerman. It's amazing how Roth keeps finding new ways to weave innumerable handsome sentences out of what are essentially the same three or four of Zuckerman's problems. I found it amusing that Zuck's big goal is to escape the solipsistic life of the novelist, while this novel—The Anatomy Lesson—is built entirely on a foundation of solipsism. Obviously Roth knows that, so I g...more
Marti
Magistrale. Per me da quando Zuckerman lascia l'upper east side si tocca il punto pi�� alto della trilogia.



Ci�� che me lo fa definire addirittura meraviglioso �� la descrizione dell'uomo di fronte alla crisi, della mente che lascia i suoi binari abituali. Cos�� precisa e reale, ma mai ridondante; in una parola: perfetta.
Al
Jul 03, 2008 Al rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: David
Roth has a way of moving forward thru the character known as Zuckerman where he feels tornado-like verbally. Plot points arrive and he moves through them then rotates to a surprising next point. Being Jewish is a theme here again and instead of answering a question he had one character pose, he uses action, and a change in situation to respond - Roth is one deft writer of energy, high intelligence, humor both comic and manic, as well as unafraid to deal with subjects by showing gradations rather...more
Clara
OH MY GAWD I'M IN SOOOO MUCH PAIN AND MY BACK HURTS AND I CAN'T FUNCTION SO I WILL WHINE LIKE A HELPLESS CHILD WHILE FEELING TERRIBLY SORRY FOR MYSELF AND TAKING CODEINE/WHISKEY TINCTURES...

This book was my first introduction to Zuckerman. I'm not a fan. But I won't rule out the non-Zuckerman books--I've heard that those are good.
Emily
Christoph und ich haben ja diese Diskussion über Alte-Sack-Literaten. Philipp Roth ist ein delikates Beispiel, weil er andererseits natürlich den Nobelpreis verdient hat. Aber wenn nervt noch diese Altersgeilheit und das langweilige, unstrukturierte Gelaber über Sex? In diesem seiner Werke besonders auffällig...
Nicky
The third book of the Zuckerman books sees our hero plagued by a mystery illness that forces him to spend his days sprawled on a play mat, getting soused and receiving visits from an array of ladies. In the latter half of the book he heads out to Chicago to apply for medical school. What a nut.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 53 54 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
The Anatomy Lesson (Paperback)
The Anatomy Lesson (Hardcover)
La lezione di anatomia (Paperback)
La lezione di anatomia (Hardcover)
The Anatomy Lesson (Mass Market Paperback)

463
Philip Milton Roth is an American novelist. He gained early literary fame with the 1959 collection Goodbye, Columbus (winner of 1960's National Book Award), cemented it with his 1969 bestseller Portnoy's Complaint, and has continued to write critically-acclaimed works, many of which feature his fictional alter ego, Nathan Zuckerman. The Zuckerman novels began with The Ghost Writer in 1979, and inc...more
More about Philip Roth...
American Pastoral Portnoy's Complaint The Plot Against America The Human Stain Everyman

Share This Book

Your website
“This is what you know about someone you have to hate: he charges you with his crime and castigates himself in you.” 6 people liked it
More quotes…