Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Magician of Hoad” as Want to Read:
The Magician of Hoad
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Magician of Hoad

3.4 of 5 stars 3.40  ·  rating details  ·  238 ratings  ·  55 reviews
A hero, an ageing magician, a farm boy, a noble daughter and a mad prince meet on the edge of a city of tents. So begins an intricate tale of a boy with a troublesome eye, who is capable of extraordinary things. Forced from home, twelve-year-old Heriot's unwilling steps lead to Diamond, first city of the Hoadara, who conquered his people generations before. By tradition, K ...more
Published November 1st 2008 by HarperCollins New Zealand (first published January 1st 2008)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Magician of Hoad, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Magician of Hoad

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 448)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Margaret Mahy's The Tricksters is one of my very favorite books in the entire world, so it is with great sadness that I report that The Magician of Hoad has some wonderful bits and some very good bits and some really not at all wonderful bits that all add up to, well, not adding up in the end. It has one of those endings where a character has to explain everything that just happened to the audience, which is almost always a bad sign, and where large chunks of the plot happen because a mysterious ...more
Anne Hamilton
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Noah W
This is one of the most unusual fantasy novels I’ve ever read. It’s written by New Zealand author Margaret Mahy; I’d heard great things about her but never read anything by her and this book seemed like it would be to my liking--it sounded like a good, hearty, old-fashioned stand-alone YA fantasy adventure.

But it definitely defied my expectations. For one thing, though it’s ostensibly YA, the story follows the main characters from about age 12 to about age 25. There’s also some sex and even a f
The way everything ties together in the end is interesting, but I don't feel like everything makes sense. Particularly the motivations of the characters. (And especially the three princes. They all felt like sketches that suddenly became real but you have no idea why or who they are.) I wanted to give it 4 stars, but I am still feeling like I didn't get the full story. Or maybe that I got a lot of parts of a full story.

Also, I am still trying to figure out the following puzzle:
When Heriot is 17
This book held great promise. A lot of promise actually. The first part of the story held my interest greatly. It was intriguing fast paced. Then things hit a wall. The plot got and story got weaker. Things started to lag. Pretty soon i'm yelling "edit" at the book every five minutes and unable to enjoy the story. I think this is because looking at the authors other stories this type of book is not her forte. She usually writes children's or young young adult books. Most of the dialog in this se ...more
This is a wonderful book. With all the debates about high fantasy vs. low fantasy and what makes something one or the other (with all the conflict about world-building and which world where and why), I can't decide where this would fit. The descriptions of Diamond and the islands and the countryside remind me of those in A Wizard of Earthsea--that level of high-flown romantic realism.

Its simplest description is that it's about a boy who becomes a magician through no conscious choice or knowledge
Jennifer Heise
This lyrical ya fantasy reminds me a bit of early Patricia McKillip, among other things-- with a side order of Leona Wisoker, Diana Wynne Jones, and Megan Whalen Turner.

One cannot help being fond of the titular Magician, Heriot, who suffers through a sort of divided mind and seizures; but also has magical dreams and a magical connection to the world around him. Dysart, the king's third son, known as the Mad Prince, seems to have some mystical connections of his own, and Linnet, a duke's daughter
Okie dokie, this book caught me off guard many times, but it's interesting nonetheless!~ I'll have to warn future audiences out there though, that this is book is surprisingly very adult themed for being written for children and young adults...! There's sex in it, some disturbing violence, and an F bomb dropped in dialogs too. I think this book would be more suitable for OLDER teenagers and adults instead. :)

It took me awhile to get into the story, mainly due to the writing style! With all my re
A Ramdom
I would be lying if I said I didn't enjoy this book to some degree but it was just confusing. One thing I struggled with is the book seemingly has no plot. I found myself in the middle of the book searching for it desperately but never finding it. There is always something going on but the way there was no head antagonist and the ones we have were at times really vague when they should have been sympathetic and the story is all over the place, drags at times, and can be at war with itself on whi ...more
this is the 2nd re-read for this novel.
I remember liking it when first read it, but it was a mystery for me. I didn't quite get it, maybe cos it was one of the very early kinda complicated novels I began with and was left with a feeling that i want to re-read it to make sure I digested it, and so I DID...

in this 2nd re-read I felt more at ease while reading it ,I understood it ,I knew what is going on, the confusion was gone at last, and AGAIN I enjoyed it, it is a magical story, an old story,
The Magician of Hoad is a must for any Margaret Mahy fans on facebook it was really funny like all of Margaret Mahy books it was a page turner of a book it was an interesting read it was an awesome book Margaret Mahy was such a good new Zealand author that when she passed away it was a sad day for New Zealand Literiture
All her books are a must read for fans or anyone
The Magician of Hoad is the story of a boy, Heriot, a boy that is discontent with his place in the world, has always seemed to not fit in. Then one day he finds out that he is actually so much more than he expected. He is a magician, but not just any magician. He is to become the official Magician of Hoad.

But the boy, realizes quickly that he does not want his destiny to be determined by his new title. He wants to be the man he decides he wants to be. He realizes that his powers can be a danger
Shanshad Whelan
So much of Mahy I've always enjoyed. My two faves being The Haunting and The Changeover. I have some idea of the kind of thing to expect from this author as far as her treatment of magic and transformation within a story. However, I can't give this fantasy more than three stars. The book is over-long, over-wordy and winds and weaves through the story until I'm left going "huh?" and not in a good way. There's a good plot in there and some interesting characters--but a lot of it gets lost behind t ...more
Heriot Tarbas runs away from his home and family instead of going with the member of the King's Court who has appeared to take Heriot away. Unfortunately, he runs into some difficulties and inadvertently ends up with the Court after all. There it is decided that the headaches and visions he has suffered from all his life actually are signs of his true ability and he is made the Court Magician. As the years pass, Heriot becomes more troubled and unhappy with life in the Kingdom - but he is not th ...more
This is the first time I have read one of Margaret Mahy's novels for young adults. I have always loved her books for children.
A really interesting story, I particularly liked the way the characters all came together having previously "known" each other.
The main character is a young magician who finds himself during the course of the novel. Relationships are handled very gently in this story, with some very complex characters. The individual histories of Heriot and Cayley were particularly inter
Sep 29, 2011 Discoverylover added it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: alkaline-kiwi
Recommended to Discoverylover by: Dad
I finished this a few days ago, and it was really compelling! It made me think about words - how in fantasy/sci fi there are words that we use (for example in this book there was a city called Diamond) but are used slightly out of context and still make sense, and how there are just some made up words (for example Hoad), but then they still use the same words we do (like apple, city, things like that)...I guess if you have too many made up words for things then the book becomes unintelligible.

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Natalie Neville
I think this book is absolutely amazing, Im still reading it but I recommend it as a good book, I think everyone should read it.
Most unlike the other books I've read by her and not my type of fantasy at all, but really well-written and compelling.
This won't be for everyone. Mahy's writing can be decidedly strange, but I find it beautiful, sometimes visceral. Despite my love for it, also wasn't perfect; one storyline and point-of-view was disappointingly predictable and occasionally even felt extraneous. The rest, however, asks some interesting questions about the power of symbols, traditions, and stories in making a person who they are. A different sort of fantasy book and very much my sort indeed.

full review at a book a week
This one was a bit of a struggle early, as there were jumps forward in time with little revelation of characters' history and motivations. Once I got used to having large chunks of their lives missing and unexplained, and just went with the flow, my appreciation for the book grew. Although there is a bit of traditional fantasy plotting, this is mostly an exploration of the characters' interior lives and how those interior lives influence their relationships in the world. And given the characters ...more
Wowzer! This is another winner from Margaret Mahy. In some ways this story reminded me of trying to put together a jigsaw puzzle without referring to the picture of the complete puzzle. I was given many tiny details that I read right over, and it was only in the last three chapters that I saw how they fit into the larger story.

I don't want to do a synopsis of the plot, because, really, the less you know going in, the more you'll enjoy this. But questions of love, loyalty, lust for power, betray
Charlie Boucher
I am a massive Margaret Mahy fan, but this book is almost too full of her usual tricks... I didn't think one of her books could be too full of her particular style, but apparently it can. Mahy fans will probably be a bit more forgiving than those new to the author, who might find some of the phrasing and dialogue over-done. Don't start with this one if you think Margaret Mahy is an author you'd like to try - any of her earlier novels is a much more gripping read (and my particular favourite is T ...more
A strange book. Something about the style of story telling kept me at a distance from the characters. The cover, by the way, is deceptive. There are absolutely no dragons in this book. Rather it's a story of political intrigue and courtly jostling for power, and Heriot, the title character's attempts to manage the magical power he processes and reconcile it with what happened to him as a child. Some nice twists but nothing too amazing. I found the solution to the problem of Bethony unconvincing.
A traveler recognizes power in the farm boy, Heriot. After being tested he is invited to become the King's Magician. Turbulence and conflict surround Heriot as he grows into manhood. He finds not everything is as it seems in Diamond, the capital city of Hoad.
This is a complex and entertaining story. The characters are well developed: The king is a tad naive and the villains are power hungry. It is a little slow to start, but once Heriot gets to Diamond, it is a great adventure.
I gave this 110 pages and had to give up--1.5 stars. There were some interesting and promising parts, but overall there were too many "huh?" moments in the writing--where things were not described or explained properly, or were explained too late, so I was completely disoriented at several points. I hear some of the author's other works were good, so I might give those a try--the good parts did show promise, even though they petered out later--but this book was a miss.
This is a very strange fantasy that is hard to get into and that I wasn't able to finish. A young man is legendary in his close-knit family for having fits and spells, but he's not ill--he's a magician, and his fate is tied into that of the Mad Prince, the King of Hoad's youngest son. The characters are odd, unpredictable, and unappealing; the storyline is weird and hard to understand, and I can't recommend this to anyone! Don't bother with it.
This book started out fascinating but lost some momentum as the plot unfolded. I enjoyed revisiting Mahy's singular writing style, which I found exhilarating at certain moments. But the final third of the book went on too long, with too much repetition and rehashing of predictable elements. I feel something close to despair that none of her other books has been as utterly singular and breathtaking as The Tricksters was.
This is another fantastic book by Margaret Mahy- a master of teen literature! I have been bemoaning the fact that there has been very little really good, sink-your-teeth-into-it fantasy lately, but here's one that has shot to the top of my list for this year! Lyrical language, complex characters and story, and the inner lives that often rule our lives, with touches of magic that doesn't always work as wished.
Maureen E
I read some fairly negative reviews of this on Goodreads, which surprised me. Okay, I know Goodreads is often not a reliable source for reviews, but I really enjoyed this book. I liked the characters, and the setting, which is important to me in general. I wasn’t overly confused by it, and in places I was reminded of the Dalemark Quartet. It’s not The Changeover at all, but I don’t think it needs to be. [March 2011]
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 14 15 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
I read this under the title Heriot btw 1 1 Mar 07, 2013 07:26PM  
  • I am Rebecca
  • Betrayal in the Highlands (The Riddle in Stone, #2)
  • The Girl from Snowy River
  • The Ciphers of Muirwood (Covenant of Muirwood, #2)
  • Lady of Magick (Noctis Magicae, #2)
  • The Pillow Book of Lotus Lowenstein
  • The Other Way Round (Out of the Hitler Time, #2)
  • Not Bad for a Bad Lad
  • The Fatal Child  (Cup of the World, #3)
  • On the Many Deaths of Amanda Palmer: And the Many Crimes of Tobias James
  • Pennington's Last Term
  • Waterlog
  • The Ring of Allaire (Winter King's War, #1)
  • In Lane Three, Alex Archer (Alex Archer, #1)
  • Whimsey: A Novel
  • And Baby Makes Two
  • The Dragon of Never-Was (Hatching Magic, #2)
  • The Rebel Prince (Moorehawke Trilogy, #3)
Margaret Mahy was a well-known New Zealand author of children's and young adult books. While the plots of many of her books have strong supernatural elements, her writing concentrates on the themes of human relationships and growing up.

Her books The Haunting and The Changeover: A Supernatural Romance both received the Carnegie Medal of the British Library Association. There have 100 children's boo
More about Margaret Mahy...
The Changeover The Seven Chinese Brothers The Haunting The Tricksters Bubble Trouble

Share This Book