251st out of 988 books
—
4,969 voters
The Dark Tide (Iron Tower Trilogy #1)
by
Dennis L. McKiernan (Goodreads Author)
Tuck Underbank is a Warrow -- think a hobbit with shoes and "large jewel-like eyes" -- living in the peaceful Boskydells. When an unnaturally cold winter strikes and the evil Modru threatens the world, he and a number of his fellow Thornwalkers go to the High King's aid. But a vast expanse of lightless blizzard called the Dimmendark (sounds bad, doesn't it?) is spreading o...more
Paperback, 304 pages
Published
August 6th 1985
by Roc
(first published 1984)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,508)
NOTE: This is a review of the whole trilogy, as I'd left a brief comment on this book first when I started reading it - why not keep it here?
First off, I don't have much to add to all the other negatives - this is likely the worst book of any kind that I've ever read. Read on if you must...
Tolkien plagiarism - well, duh. This makes the "Sword of Shannara" look like a masterpiece of originality in comparison. The very beginning, with the "young buccan Warrows" (McKiernan's strength sure isn't in...more
First off, I don't have much to add to all the other negatives - this is likely the worst book of any kind that I've ever read. Read on if you must...
Tolkien plagiarism - well, duh. This makes the "Sword of Shannara" look like a masterpiece of originality in comparison. The very beginning, with the "young buccan Warrows" (McKiernan's strength sure isn't in...more
Oh, man, this is bad. I growl and/or yell at the book approximately once per page at least. It's a fascinating train wreck of a book, and gives me both terrors (that it has so many defenders and that someone capable of reading could actually like it) and solace (in that, no matter my many deficiencies as a writer, at least I don't do what McKiernan does here). I might recommend the book to a young child just getting into fantasy, but if you can read this slog, you can read The Hobbit and not onl...more
Two things need to be established up front:
1) This is a LOTR facsimile out-and-out, and it was intentionally written to be so. Those who actually take the time to learn some of the history behind the book know that it was originally written to be a sequel to the LOTR trilogy, but the green light for publication was never given by Tolkien's family. The book was thus published after some edits to make it "its own story."
2) This is epic fantasy. In that vein, it is by nature slow in developing its...more
1) This is a LOTR facsimile out-and-out, and it was intentionally written to be so. Those who actually take the time to learn some of the history behind the book know that it was originally written to be a sequel to the LOTR trilogy, but the green light for publication was never given by Tolkien's family. The book was thus published after some edits to make it "its own story."
2) This is epic fantasy. In that vein, it is by nature slow in developing its...more
Apr 19, 2011
Teakraken
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Anyone who likes high fantasy and doesn't have a stick up their bum
Recommended to Teakraken by:
The Boyfriend
Shelves:
reviewed
Look, this book is like eating a rhubarb pie made by your friend, where you weren't expecting rhubarb pie (or maybe you did because you read the introduction), and you're surprised and kind of pissed because you thought only your grandmother could make rhubarb pie, and you always brag about how your grandmother invented rhubarb pie, before that people tried to eat the leaves and kept dying, but here's this jerk making a rhubarb pie, and the worst part is it's actually fairly tasty.
Sure, it's not...more
Sure, it's not...more
It gets four stars for nostalgic value. I read this book when I was 12 or so. Maybe 14. Anyway, I stumbled across the series at a used books store on the weekend and I had to buy them. I remember bits and pieces of the story so I wanted to re-read them to see if my memory was as good as I hope it is. I thought Merrilee comes back in this one, so I guess I'm a little off.
Anyway, actually reviewing this novel is more like a 3/5. It's reminiscent of LotR, especially with the little Hobbit-like cre...more
Anyway, actually reviewing this novel is more like a 3/5. It's reminiscent of LotR, especially with the little Hobbit-like cre...more
Somehow back in the 1980s, I missed these books. I was aware of them, I think, but somehow never read them, and that's unfortunate because The Dark Tide is a neat book. Some readers may complain that it's derivative of Tolkien, but McKiernan explains that his works were originally intended as sequels to LOTR. And really, show me fantasy from the 1980s (other than Ursula le Guin) that wasn't derivative of Tolkien.
If you can set aside your mental baggage, Dark Tide is a lot of fun. I realize moder...more
If you can set aside your mental baggage, Dark Tide is a lot of fun. I realize moder...more
I loved this series. I really don't get what everyone is being such a whino for. He clearly says how he respects Tolkien and used his framework. Plus, it was written pretty well. Tuck was such a courageous character with a humble outlook, and Galen and Danner, poor 'ol Danner. He didn't go into the characters as much (Tolkien had an entire appendix dedicated to Ent History!) but they were all inspiring nevertheless.
Just because the story has similarities doesn't make it a BAD book. Everyone who...more
Just because the story has similarities doesn't make it a BAD book. Everyone who...more
Can I wholeheartedly recommend this book? Of course not. But, reading it back in the late eighties, I was fresh off of Dragonlance (probably waiting for the next book in the series to come out actually) and I hadn't read Lord of the Rings, yet, so I wasn't aware of how derivative this series was. For a fantasy -starved voracious reader who'd already racked up all the overdue library fines I could take, finding this book in a "give-away" pile of other mass market paperbacks was like a godsend. Th...more
This is one of my all time favorite Fantasy trilogies. I think of it as a better lord of the rings. I actually read this series before I read Lord of the rings which is probably why I can commit what others will consider lunacy and rate this Higher than Tolkiens work. Yes there are many similarities to Lord of the rings and Tolkiens middle earth world, but he makes the world different enough That you can overlook it. In a time when everybody is remaking everything and putting their own spin on i...more
First of all, I will state out front that this trilogy was written to be the back-story accompanying a sequel to J. R. R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings trilogy. However, it was published as its own stand-alone series. I read this book (and the others in the series) when I was around 9, and did not have the patience to attempt LotR itself. I really enjoyed these books at the time, but would not recommend them to anyone older who is familiar at all with the LotR series. There are simply too many sim...more
McKiernan writes prose that flows very easily and frankly just draws you into the story. His characters have depth but not the point that they get in the way of the story. It is in the story that he may stray from excellence (and maybe not as I'll explain later) as he essentially is riding on the same formula as Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings". Here is a small list of like elements:
- Great evil one long banished
- Central heroes are some diminutive fairy of small stature.
- great tower in the evil...more
- Great evil one long banished
- Central heroes are some diminutive fairy of small stature.
- great tower in the evil...more
I read McKirnan’s Iron Tower trilogy many years ago. I was looking for something like The Lord Of The Rings, as I recall. Boy, did I get it. Sort of. I remember having a difficult time getting through the trilogy, perhaps that I didn’t finish it.
Now I know why. Reading this again, the best word I can think of to describe McKiernan’s writing is “tedious.” This guy describes everything. What clothes the characters are wearing, what they eat, what they’re thinking, what they’re not thinking, what t...more
Now I know why. Reading this again, the best word I can think of to describe McKiernan’s writing is “tedious.” This guy describes everything. What clothes the characters are wearing, what they eat, what they’re thinking, what they’re not thinking, what t...more
As noted in other readers' comments, this is a truly awful Tolkien ripoff. Of course,it is part of a trilogy and its multiracial cast of los...I mean heroes, is in conflict with the ultimate evil. It is a triumph of ripoff and redundancy, but that is not the worst. The totally tedious writing style is intended to be medieval and chivalrous, but it only succeeds in boring the bile right out of my liver. If you have not yet squandered precious moments of your life on this banal tale, you can bring...more
Well, I can't remember exactly when I read this, but it was a long time ago-- I'm guessing '99, but maybe earlier. Maybe I had just gotten very critical at that point in my life, because I believe it was around that time (in a space of 5-6 years) that I was finding myself disgusted with Terry Brooks and Raymond Feist as well-- possibly because I had been to several writers conferences at that point and had taken two short story classes at Las Positas and UCSB respectively, and I may have been ov...more
OK, I'm not gonna lie. You can tell the dude was just ripping off C.S. Lewis. Though, to be fair, the purpose was not to rip of the master, as much as praise the master through imitation. These stories are different. As a matter of fact, some of the imagery is just wonderful. There were some parts that, as I read them, I actually become afraid of the unseen creature, reaching though the bars without moving to grasp its prey...
*shiver*
*shiver*
I learned you can re-do what another has done, and in style, and make it wholly your own without diminishing or insulting the original in the slightest. I don't enjoy McKiernan's Iron Tower trilogy in the same way as The Lord of the Rings, but it is, in its own way and on its own terms, every bit as satisfying. If you're a fan of the one, I strongly suggest you read the other.
This was lent to me by an acquaintance who found out I'm a Tolkien fan and said, "If you love Lord of the Rings, you'll definitely love this!" A most unfortunate assumption.
I picked up the book prepared to find a certain level of inspiration from the Lord of the Rings, but instead found a mind-numbingly huge number of blatant rip-offs. Accompanied by awful writing. I was prepared to give examples, but there are too many to choose from. I can only hope that this author has come to feel shame for...more
I picked up the book prepared to find a certain level of inspiration from the Lord of the Rings, but instead found a mind-numbingly huge number of blatant rip-offs. Accompanied by awful writing. I was prepared to give examples, but there are too many to choose from. I can only hope that this author has come to feel shame for...more
The plot is ok, and it can be forgiven for borrowing lots of ideas from Lord of the Rings (the author explains in a note at the beginning that the reason he started writing in the first place was because he wanted to go on another Tolkien-like adventure, but Tolkien was dead), but the characters are over-simplified and boring and make the story not really worth reading.
I remember loving this series as a child, but unfortunately I went back to read it when I was older and found the story was too simple for my tastes. I think it has a lot of value for people starting into the fantasy realm, but if you've done a lot of heavy reading into epic series like the Wheel of Time, you probably will not enjoy this story too much.
Too often maligned as a knock-off of LotR, The Iron Tower is really a delightful tale of its own, well done with endearing characters, underlying themes, and great action. If one admits that the story does follow 'the formula' (which has stood the test of time, I might add) one can sit back and enjoy this take on it with relish. Get it.
This book will be loved by many who love the Lord of the rings style fantasy sometimes called high fantasy. Of those who prefer the low fantasy or gritty fantasy will find this novel to wordy and long and rambling. I for myself love all types of fantasy and I think this is an excellent example of Tolkien's fantasy.
The book has chomps, for sure, and McKiernan spins a tale worth reading although I felt like there was a bit too much crying from the lead protagonist as the series went on. Also, a very strong mirror to Tolkien's LotR, which might put some folks off, although I found it a pleasant enough take on the subject matter.
The Lord of the Rings, retold without any of Tolkien's flair. I read it only because I wanted to have a good grounding in the McKiernan's world before I tackled any of the books that don't read like he was typing with The Lord of the Rings at his elbow for reference. (I wish I was kidding. It really IS Lord of the Rings, but the character, place and race names are different. Ugh!) His other books better be worth the slog through this.
I would have given it 3 1/2 stars if that was allowed... just don't think it ranked a 4. At first, I thought that I was reading an almost direct rip-off of the LotR. I was waiting for the One Necklace to pop up or something. But even though it is STRONGLY influenced by the Lord of the Rings, it has enough differences to keep the interest, especially since it is not that long. His attempt at flowery speech can sometimes be a bit much to bear but if you win through to the end then the story isn't...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
McKiernan was born in Moberly, Missouri, where he lived until he served the U.S. Air Force for four years, stationed within US territory during the Korean War. After military service, he attended the University of Missouri and received a B.S. in electrical engineering in 1958 and an M.S. in the same field from Duke University in 1964. He worked as an engineer at AT&T, initially at Western Elec...more
More about Dennis L. McKiernan...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...
































Oct 29, 2011 07:05pm