69th out of 97 books — 1 voter
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Genesis Debate” as Want to Read:
The Genesis Debate
Are the Genesis creation days 24 hours long? Ages of time? Or a literary framework? In The Genesis Debate, three teams of evangelicals committed to the infallibility and inerrancy of Scripture tac
Paperback, 319 pages
Published November 1st 2002 by Global Publishing Services
(first published November 24th 2000)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Westminster Theological Seminary Recommended Reading
More lists with this book...
(showing 1-30 of 209)
I came to this text not particularly interested in the subject matter, but became more interested as I read along. As with most perspective books, the quality of the essays are uneven. The twenty-four hour view is not well represented as it tediously refers to church history ad nauseum (and in my opinion engages in a reverse form of chronological snobbery). The day-age view often deviates from the immediate context of Genesis One to exposit all the ways the natural sciences are compatible with i ...more
This is a good introduction for anyone wanting to see interaction between multiple views of the days of Genesis. I found the Framework view to be the best argued and presented view of the three. Duncan and Hall (who represented the 24 hour view) have the weakest presentation of the three. At times I found myself skipping through many of their arguments because they were either repeated or just plain frustrating to read. I thought they could have gotten better representatives for this view or at ...more
I found The Genesis Debate: Three Views on the Days of Creation incredibly helpful and thought-provoking. The book is set up like a debate, with proponents of each of the three creation views deemed orthodox by reformed Christians presenting an opening essay, and then the other positions writing an essay in response, with a concluding essay by the initial team. I appreciated that all of the authors were committed to “the infallibility and inerrancy of Scripture from Genesis to Revelation” and th ...more
Tone. Tone. Tone. An excellent example of the weight of our tone when we dialogue with others, especially when we disagree. The Genesis Debate is a unique and exemplary presentation of three understandings of the nature of the creation days- 24 Hours, Day- Age, and Literary Framework... A readable introduction to three understandings that are held by scholars who all affirm the inerrancy of Scripture. I learned a lot from each presentation and the subsequent interactions among the scholars, but ...more
When addressing the interpretation of the opening chapters of Genesis, one must first identify the most important question, “What does Scripture itself say about the Genesis creation days? Even more precisely: Are the creation days 24 hours, ages, or a literary framework?" This is the question and these are the views propounded in this book. For my part I found the authors of the 24 hour view least convincing and the authors of the literary framework view most convincing.
A very through look at three different views on the days of creation. It has a better format than most "3 views" books in that the author of the original essay gets a chance to respond to the critiques of his position. Good for teaching preparation, which is what I used it for. What view am I? I couldn't say...
This is a great book for those interested in the debate over how to interpret the "days" in Genesis. It features the three currently most popular view points (Framework hypothesis, Day-Age view, and 6 24-hour days). Each author is given a chance to present their view point, comment on concerns they have with the other views, and defend their view against the criticisms of the other authors. It is also the only major book I know of in which Lee Irons (a personal favorite theologian of mine) has c ...more
set in a form of a debate, this book give a overall arguments for the 3 most popular views on the creation narrative. because of the nature of the book, some may feel there is not much depth in discussion for each of the positions. but, the authors provide enough references to help the readers do further research if desired. personally, i came to this book subcribing to the framework view and my position stands.
J. Ligon Duncan III is an American Presbyterian scholar and pastor.More about J. Ligon Duncan III...