Moral Man and Immoral Society: Study in Ethics and Politics
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Moral Man and Immoral Society: Study in Ethics and Politics (Library of Theological Ethics)

by
4.02 of 5 stars 4.02  ·  rating details  ·  470 ratings  ·  35 reviews

Moral Man and Immoral Society is Reinhold Niebuhr's important early study in ethics and politics. Forthright and realistic, it discusses the inevitability of social conflict, the brutal behavior of human collectives of every sort, the inability of rationalists and social scientists to even imagine the realities of collective power, and, ultimately, how individual morality

...more
Paperback, 284 pages
Published January 1st 2002 by Westminster John Knox Press (first published 1932)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Moral Man and Immoral Society, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Moral Man and Immoral Society

Honor and Polygamy by Omar FarhadThe Prince by Niccolò MachiavelliThe Communist Manifesto by Karl MarxThe Republic by PlatoPolitics by Aristotle
Politics
26th out of 192 books — 219 voters
Mere Christianity by C.S. LewisThe Chronicles of Narnia by C.S. LewisCelebration of Discipline by Richard J. FosterThe Screwtape Letters by C.S. LewisThe Cost of Discipleship by Dietrich Bonhoeffer
"Christianity Today" Books of the 20th Century
28th out of 100 books — 38 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,427)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Szplug
What Niebuhr is selling* with this bad boy from 1932: It pains me to have to say this, but it's Cluebat time for all you arm-linked and well-intentioned but tunnel-of-love-visioned LOLcat lightweights, awash in pacifist dreams and tiptoeing about waiting for the Kingdom of God to answer all of your pinned-and-needled hopes. That happy realm lies in the occluded future; the present is anointed in Original Sin. It's a dark, hard, cold world, the more so as we lose ourselves within the collective—a...more
Walter
This is Niebuhr at his finest (though most dense and packed with stream-of-consciousness). Insights into human nature, society, the influences on our choices from moral, ethical, spiritual, religious, political, economic and social perspectives, etc., are plentiful. The prose is tough - and, in truth, at points, impenetrable - but ultimately the cost is worth it to access so many critical guidelines for more effective individual and collective living.

Among the incredibly abundant piercing insigh...more
Mikey B.
There were some good points raised in this book – but for the most part I find the style overly verbose - an overuse of words. I agree with the main prognosis of the individual (good) arrayed against society (conformist – evil). There are a lot of obvious statements – like society being resistant to change.

I feel the proletariat is romanticized – who will be their leader – to be a leader one must rise above the proletariat level. In Hitler’s rise to power he was supported by all levels of societ...more
Adrian Colesberry
A difficult book but essential reading for anyone wanting to engage in the conversation about how to effect improvement in the human condition. He judges society and any corporate body to be patently incapable of making moral decisions. In light of recent events, I don't know that any American today would disagree with him.
It's also nice to be reminded of a time when religious thinkers had nuanced intellectual positions. I'm sure these thinkers exist today, but the only opinions I hear from rel...more
Andre
Niebuhr brought forth a great idea on the moral problem by contrasting the ethical attitudes of the 'Privileged' and 'Proletarian' classes. This is one of his most important explanations in MM&IS. Another solid suggestion in the book is learning to harmonize the animal nature of man with the spiritual needs of man in order to achieve justice and social progress. These two cases serve as pillars for every other premise in the book.

Niebuhr's writing implies that he had little room in his hypot...more
Conor Williams
The following is part of my writeup on Moral Man and Immoral Society from my undergraduate thesis on John Dewey:

In Moral Man and Immoral Society, Niebuhr claims that Dewey underestimates the place of coercion and violence in human interactions. Niebuhr doubted that the social sciences could follow the natural sciences through experimentalism, since they were tied so carefully to various biases and predilections. From his perspective, interest-free social science was an oxymoron.

In his 1932 e...more
Isai
I loved H. Richard Niebuhr's "Christ and Culture," so I decided to pick up this book written by his brother. Reinhold Niebuhr taught for many years at Union Theological Seminary in New York in the areas of ethics, theology, and political philosophy. The ethics and the political aspects are front and center as seen by the subtitle of the work. However, the theological aspect is kept to a minimum only appearing in glimpses by means of "religion," "Christianity," as well as other words. Nevertheles...more
Hadrian
Very interesting and skeptical view of individual vs. group morality, and would be very useful for one attempting to enact positive change in society.
Trice
The final chapter was focused on what I was hoping to read all along, looking at how we reconcile ethics with politics and idealism with realism, without ignoring either. The previous 9 chapters were certainly thought-provoking, however. It was interesting, too, to come across the completely unexpected reference to Moral Man, Immoral Society in Paulo Freire's and Miles Horton's spoken book, We Make the Road by Walking: Conversations on Education and Social Change. This put a lot of what Niebuhr...more
Peter Namtvedt
May 10, 2010 Peter Namtvedt rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: masochists
A Socialist’s Ruminations about Altruism

A Review of Reinhold Niebuhr's Moral Man and Immoral Society: A Study in Ethics and Politics, New York, Scribner’s, 1932. 277 pages, $11.95

Let me first briefly state what this book is about: liberals are mistaken in thinking that individuals and society behave in the same ways and that solutions to moral problems should be the same for both. You can learn a different view here from a Christian and Marxist perspective.

Background

Before getting into details a...more
Tom
The final book in a series of theoretical readings I did at the beginning of this year. Niebuhr's thoughts on human moral behavior in groups was challenging both in style and content. Stylistically, the book is very dense, and contains long segments in which the author dwells on a certain idea that's somewhat tangential. Content-wise, the thesis of the book is that humans tend to act selfishly/immorally in groups when interacting with other groups, which contradicts my basic beliefs about human...more
Chris
"THERE ARE IDIOTS. Look around." --Larry Summers

Economics, in its standard formulation, assumes rational markets, built from a base of rational actors. Summers, though a sexist jerk, was absolutely right to question that assumption, at least for purposes of dealing with real markets. Which brings us to Niebuhr. Moral Man, his 1932 bombshell, assesses the place of ethics, reason, religion, and persuasion in human societies. Niebuhr is as forceful as Summers, somewhat less of a sexist jerk, and fo...more
Craig
One of the most influencing books on my thought on human nature. I'm not sure the book itself can be considered one of the greats, but it spoke to me in a way that resonated with my way of thinking more than other more classic texts have. Both a Christian theologian and an intellectual fluent in classical philosophy, Niebuhr's elaboration on human nature and its interaction with society brought together many different ideas and opinions I myself had been grappling with for some time. It crushes...more
Brett
A worthy read from the perspective of its influence, not from the perspective of pleasure (it long and difficult). Even though most people have never heard his name, it is difficult to overestimate how much impact this man's political/ethical theory has influenced American thought and policy. His basic thesis is that in spite of whatever moral achievement can be accomplished in an individual life or intimate relationships, it is impossible when it comes to human collectives/societies. The collec...more
Michael
A great book, but one you'll want to dig into for long stretches as it's pretty dense (every other sentence seems like a premise for another book). My primary takeaway is that governments are incapable of behaving on moral parity with individuals, and that they should not, and that looking to them to do so is a futile endeavor that misses the point of effective government.

Current events and what they've revealed about our own expectations regarding how our government should react and behave indi...more
John
Jun 05, 2012 John rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: to-buy
There is a lot in this book, and much of it is hardheaded, cool, and practical. While certain themes are repeated throughout, it seemed like every page had some new and provocative insight that challenged preconceived notions (he criticizes Gandhi at one point, and fairly, I might add). And though the book seems dated, I thought its age allowed the reader to judge the accuracy of some of Niebuhr's claims about, what was then, the future. Even then, this book has lost none of its relevance.
Bob Griffin
Read when I was in graduate school I have recently rediscovered this book and keep going back to it again and again because of the wisdom published in 1932 even before WWII. Many of these thoughts are so modern and applicable to the understanding of our present day world. Needs to be read again and again.
Tyler
The copy I read was actually printed in 1932 and it was amazing to think about how little "the course of human relations" has changed in the past seventy years. While he does make odd references to then-contemporary political scandals, all in all the book is a real classic.



Toussi21
It took me a year to finish this one. Any one who's ever questioned the role of the group in one's own personal idea of faith should definitely pick this up. Niebuhr has become my favorite theologian.
Tom
Niebuhr criticizes the naivete of socialists & moralists. But because he such an infelicitous writer, his insights are difficult to separate from the chaff that burden this overly long essay.
Andrew Brown
Anyone who wants to take pacifism seriously must first engage Reinhold Niebuhr. Purely classical text for understanding individual interaction with the structures of our society.
peter
After a lifetime of devoted pacifism, this is the one book that has made me critically re-examine not just the practicality of my views but indeed their moral and ethical import.
Charles
Can't be the final word, but an important work for Mennonites to wrestle with. Really sets the stage to read either JL Burkholder or JoHo Yo
Dan Patla
This book so far has been amazing! I love Niebuhr's interpretation of our socio-ideological quests for power. Intriguing to say the least
Ned
what's most worth noting is how powerfully predictive niebuhr's insights are with regards to the rest of the twentieth century.
Bob
Classic work that shows how we will do in groups what we would never do as individuals. Another must read.
Elizabeth
I don't think any book has influenced me more since Judy Bloom's "Just As Long As We're Together."
Alexander
Niebuhr has some invaluable insights, though there were sections I skipped. A very worthwhile read.
Megan
Dense, remarkably prescient. It has helped me square a lot of my own internal ethical conflicts.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 47 48 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Peaceable Kingdom: A Primer In Christian Ethics
  • Christ and Culture
  • Ethics (Dietrich Bonhoeffer Works, Vol. 6)
  • The Humanity of God
  • Dynamics of Faith
  • A Black Theology of Liberation
  • Theology of Hope
  • A Theology of Liberation
  • On Being a Christian
  • The Politics of Jesus
  • A Short History Of Ethics: A History Of Moral Philosophy From The Homeric Age To The Twentieth Century
  • The Quest of the Historical Jesus
31146
U.S. theologian. The son of an evangelical minister, he studied at Eden Theological Seminary and Yale Divinity School. He was ordained in the Evangelical Synod of North America in 1915 and served as pastor of Bethel Evangelical Church in Detroit, Mich., until 1928. His years in that industrial city made him a critic of capitalism and an advocate of socialism. From 1928 to 1960 he taught at New Yor...more
More about Reinhold Niebuhr...
The Irony of American History The Nature and Destiny of Man Vol 1 & 2 Leaves from the Notebook of a Tamed Cynic The Children of Light and the Children of Darkness: A Vindication of Democracy and a Critique of its Traditional Defense (Scribner library) The Essential Reinhold Niebuhr: Selected Essays and Addresses

Share This Book

“Rationality belongs to the cool observer, but because of the stupidity of the average man, he follows not reason, but faith, and the naive faith requires necessary illusion and emotionally potent oversimplifications which are provided by the myth-maker to keep ordinary person on course.” 3 likes
More quotes…