The Skull Mantra (Inspector Shan #1)
by
Eliot Pattison (Goodreads Author)
Winner of the 2001 Edgar Award for Best First Novel, Skull Mantra was a sensation when first published and received wide acclaim from critics and readers alike. The Skull Mantra was ranked with Gorky Park and Smilla's Sense of Snow as a novel as much about a people and a place--the Tibetans of the high Himalayas--as it is a gripping thriller. The corpse is missing it...more
Paperback, 416 pages
Published
September 30th 2008
by St. Martin's Minotaur
(first published 1999)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,191)
I just couldn't get into this book. It was so slow-moving and the descriptions of the torture just too horrific. It's too bad because it sounded like it would be right up my alley.
I knew it was good from the get go, not simple, not easy, but a very well built story, full of details, making it difficult for you but still grabbing your attention every step of the way. And it is indeed a very good crime story.
What I especially liked though, were the details of the characters' names. It's a very cunning way to keep you sharp while you read, and also to state the difference between the Chinese and the Tibetan - it's very hard to keep track and if you don't pay attention...more
What I especially liked though, were the details of the characters' names. It's a very cunning way to keep you sharp while you read, and also to state the difference between the Chinese and the Tibetan - it's very hard to keep track and if you don't pay attention...more
(read in 2005)
As a debut mystery, this one turned out pretty well, which is something I do not say often. The plot was good, the characterization done well, and the writing kept me interested until I finished.
Shan Tao Yun was a highly placed investigator in Beijing who has found himself in the Chinese version of a gulag in the Tibetan mountains. His mates in the prison camp consist largely of Tibetan monks who have been arrested at various times with the takeover of the PRC i...more
As a debut mystery, this one turned out pretty well, which is something I do not say often. The plot was good, the characterization done well, and the writing kept me interested until I finished.
Shan Tao Yun was a highly placed investigator in Beijing who has found himself in the Chinese version of a gulag in the Tibetan mountains. His mates in the prison camp consist largely of Tibetan monks who have been arrested at various times with the takeover of the PRC i...more
I loved this book. It has such a unique and creative setting and conceit, a Chinese Detective who was a good party member but a bit too honest, is sent to the Gulag in Tibet, and is transformed by the Tibetan Buddhist priest he is imprisoned with. He becomes transformed and bonded to their struggle, trying to keep the Chinese military from abusing them more. He vividly depicts the landscape, the Buddhist subculture, beliefs, practices, and the unremitting genocidal practices of the Chinese. He ...more
I really did love this book. The reason for four stars instead of five is that I had some difficulty with patching together the engrossing scenes to make sense of the whole plot. This is probably user error on my part- the book is rich and densely written and I think I tried to read it too quickly. The author uses a mystery framework to explore the situation between Tibet and China, Chinese politics, and China's relationship with Western business. There is so much in here. Shan is a wonderf...more
I usually try to make sure to read series in the correct order, but because of ~various circumstances~ I didn't do that in the case of this series and I ended up reading the first book after having read the second and the third.
It's been a while since I've loved a series of books as much as I love these, so please don't expect an objective review here.
What was interesting for me to see was that in comparison to the second and the third book, the first one resembles much mor...more
It's been a while since I've loved a series of books as much as I love these, so please don't expect an objective review here.
What was interesting for me to see was that in comparison to the second and the third book, the first one resembles much mor...more
For those of you who enjoy reading mysteries and/or for those of you who are interested in Tibet, I have a book recommendation for you. As you may or may not know, I've been slowly working my way through the rather large collection of paperback mysteries in my employer's library. There's one that's been sitting there for a while that I'd been ignoring due to its horribly cheezy title. I finally picked it up the other day and read the back of the book and decided to give it a try. The book is The...more
The Skull Mantra follows the investigations of Shan, a Chinese prisoner in a Tibetan labor camp, exiled for his mis-steps in the political minefield of Beijing. When a headless corpse is discovered on the road leading out of town, Shen is recruited by the local military leader, Colonel Tan, to run a parallel investigation alongside the official Ministry of Justice inquiry. The ensuing adventure digs down to the core of the Chinese presence in Tibet, to the essence of contemporary Communism and...more
I'm being generous in giving this 3 stars. In a way, it reminded me of a Tony Hillerman book: a body found in mysterious circumstances, which can only be explained by delving into the native culture/religion, which is at odds with the modern, conquering culture, so someone must bridge that gap to understand, thus find, the killer(s). Add a remote, beautiful, exotic location, an intricate plot, and you may have a great book.
The main problem with this book was the overly intricate ...more
The main problem with this book was the overly intricate ...more
Hearing Nancy Pearl on NPR this morning reminded me that I had read this gripping mystery a few years back, and I highly recommend it.
Summary: The corpse is missing its head and is dressed in American clothes. Found by a Tibetan prison work gang on a windy cliff, the grisly remains clearly belong to someone too important for Chinese authorities to bury and forget. So the case is handed to veteran police inspector Shan Tao Yun. Methodical, clever Shan is the best man for the job, but...more
Summary: The corpse is missing its head and is dressed in American clothes. Found by a Tibetan prison work gang on a windy cliff, the grisly remains clearly belong to someone too important for Chinese authorities to bury and forget. So the case is handed to veteran police inspector Shan Tao Yun. Methodical, clever Shan is the best man for the job, but...more
This mystery is intriguing and well written. However, more intriguing to me is its cultural and political description and commentary, occurring in Tibet and portraying the tensions between the Chinese rulers and the Tibetan people. The monastic and Buddhist culture is fascinating, and their intimate place in daily life is illuminating. The protagonist, Shan, is a Chinese man on a largely Tibetan work gang in the gulag, sentenced to an indefinite number of years on trumped up charges when hi...more
If you have ever been interested in Tibet, you will proabably be as fascinated by this book as I was. I think critics' comparisons to Smilla's Sense of Snow and Gorky Park are right on the money. I don't normally read mysteries, but my aunt recommended it highly years ago, and I am glad I read it.
You should know that the author is very critical of Chinese politics and its justice system, not only what it has done to Tibet, though there are sympathetic Chinese characters, especial...more
You should know that the author is very critical of Chinese politics and its justice system, not only what it has done to Tibet, though there are sympathetic Chinese characters, especial...more
A few months ago, I listened to a podcast by an author/hero of mine, Richard K. Morgan. He was talking about 'Air' by Geoff Ryman. He said it wasn't a great science fiction novel. It was a great novel period.
The same is true of Eliot Pattison's 'The Skull Mantra'. It's not a great mystery novel. It's a great novel period. It's an intricate mystery set in modern-day Tibet. It will keep you guessing until the very end. For me a great mystery is one where you feel like you have all the ...more
The same is true of Eliot Pattison's 'The Skull Mantra'. It's not a great mystery novel. It's a great novel period. It's an intricate mystery set in modern-day Tibet. It will keep you guessing until the very end. For me a great mystery is one where you feel like you have all the ...more
A first class mystery! A Chinese political prisoner, now on a road gang in Tibet finds himself forced to investigate a beheading when the corpse turns up on the construction site. I learned a lot about Tibet history and its people, and almost as much about Buddhism. Pattison does this while not breaking the plot. He has a great sense of characterization and, at the end, you don't doubt that things happened in the way they did. One question remains: How soon do I pick up another of his books?...more
This is one of the most unusual mysteries I've ever read--the detective is a Chinese policeman who was unjustly imprisoned in a Tibetan prison camp. He is temporarily released (under guard) to solve the murder of a Chinese official serving in Tibet. What makes this book extremely rich are the conflict/comparisons between the detective's own Chinese culture now being imposed on Tibet by the Chinese government and the Tibetan Buddhist culture. Many of the characters in the story stand between wo...more
I found Pattison's most recent Inspector Shan mystery at the library a few weeks ago and was impressed, then thrilled when I discovered that I was reading the latest of about 10 in a series. I have lots of great mystery reading ahead of me. Living in Tibet, Shan, a displaced Han Chinese, is frequently called upon to use the skills of an earlier life as an inspector in Beijing. Although the books are contemporary, they seem to simultaneously span multiple centuries in the diversity of Tibetan lif...more
For some strange reason I found this book to be a relaxing read. It did take some time to get into the storey but I found the descriptions of Tibetan culture and religion woven into the storeyline to be a nice way to gain insight into the situation in Tibet. I find the ending to be an interesting contrast to the Tibetan monks spirituality and approach to their lives. Trying to keep track of the characters and their relationships to the bigger picture was difficult at times as I was primarily ...more
In the ranks of the murder mystery genre, entirely unique (in my limited experience-- I'm a casual devotee of MM, not an addict). 'Exotic' hardly says it. If plot is strategy and characterization tactics, the novel is militarily flawless. However both depend upon logistics, the downfall of many a campaign. I have to say that the logistics of this story are far from transparent. The details are confusing, especially as regards geography. Some authors go into extensive detail about places and the...more
I don't often opt to read mystery novels placed in a contemporary setting but The Skull Mantra by Eliot Pattison has hooked me on a new series featuring Inspector Shan, a former Beijing prosecutor who, for obscure reasons (we can assume his quest for truth and justice has worried a certain high party official) has found himself on a prison work detail in Tibet.
When the workers discover a headless corpse dressed in western clothes, Shan is "asked" to investigate by the Ch...more
When the workers discover a headless corpse dressed in western clothes, Shan is "asked" to investigate by the Ch...more
I checked his out because I read Ashes of the Earth and liked it so much. This book is quite different but has the same thoughtful prose integrating the past with its effects on the present.
Chinese former inspector displeased highly place party bigwigs in Beijing so was sent to a conscript camp in Tibet. Because of his background the lead camp officer forces him to solve the murder of the former inspector. Lot of info. about Chinese takeover of Tibet and the destruction of Buddhist m...more
Chinese former inspector displeased highly place party bigwigs in Beijing so was sent to a conscript camp in Tibet. Because of his background the lead camp officer forces him to solve the murder of the former inspector. Lot of info. about Chinese takeover of Tibet and the destruction of Buddhist m...more
Interesting to read the mixed reviews about this book, which I freaking LOVED and blew through in three nights.
The Tibetan setting is fascinating and beautifully rendered, and I learned an enormous amount about the Buddist religion. I also liked that while the Chinese regime is depicted as horrifically brutal as most oppressive regimes are, Pattison has still created sympathetic, human Chinese characters and resisted the easy temptation to reduce the Tibetan vs. Chinese stuggle into a cart...more
The Tibetan setting is fascinating and beautifully rendered, and I learned an enormous amount about the Buddist religion. I also liked that while the Chinese regime is depicted as horrifically brutal as most oppressive regimes are, Pattison has still created sympathetic, human Chinese characters and resisted the easy temptation to reduce the Tibetan vs. Chinese stuggle into a cart...more
I'm not a huge mystery fan, but NPR had a list of mysteries you might have missed, and so far I'm two for two on loving them.
I'm extremely interested in Tibet and the history of the Chinese re-education under Mao. This is the story of an investigator who gets too close to the truth on some government issues and finds himself in a gulag in Tibet - as far away from his Beijing home as possible. While in prison, he is called out to solve a mystery - partly because he is disposable if h...more
I'm extremely interested in Tibet and the history of the Chinese re-education under Mao. This is the story of an investigator who gets too close to the truth on some government issues and finds himself in a gulag in Tibet - as far away from his Beijing home as possible. While in prison, he is called out to solve a mystery - partly because he is disposable if h...more
This book appeared magically in my stack of to read books. I don't remember who gave it to me. Excellent murder mystery that takes place in and around a prison camp in Tibet. The protagonist is a former high ranking Chinese investigator who was sent to the prison without trial for getting too close to discovering corruption in a high level Minister in Beijing. He has been pulled from the labor gang to conduct an independent investigation. Lots of detail about Tibetan Buddhism and the destru...more
This was an incredibly difficult novel to read. It takes place in current day Chinese-occupied Tibet. The protagonist, Shan, is a former investigator now prisoner working in a Tibetan labor camp.
The subject matter took me way out of my comfort zone. I felt that I shouldn't even read such a novel, for how could I root for the main character (whom I liked) when at any time he might be killed by the authorities? And even if he did solve the murder he had been assigned to tidy up, who's ...more
The subject matter took me way out of my comfort zone. I felt that I shouldn't even read such a novel, for how could I root for the main character (whom I liked) when at any time he might be killed by the authorities? And even if he did solve the murder he had been assigned to tidy up, who's ...more
This novel is set in contemporary Tibet, and the characters must always deal with the Chinese overlords. Most monasteries has been destroyed, and monks and nuns killed. Some who are left are sent to brutal labor camps. A Chinese man, previously an Inspector in Beijing, has crossed his political bosses, and is also at this camp. The prisoners find a headless body, and Shan is pulled out of the camp and told to find the murderer. There is a lot on Tibetan mysticism and custom, as well as info...more
This was an interesting book. I had never read a book that took place in Tibet and it was really exciting for me to experience that culture. I thought it was a good mystery, but I got confused often with the Chinese and Tibetan names for things. I also was a little turned off by equating whoever committed the murder with being possessed with Tamdin. But, I suppose that is there culture. All in all, it was a good book, but nothing earth shattering. The best part was learning about the terrible st...more
The Skull Mantra (Dans la gorge du gragon)
is an investigation story book, that takes place in Tibet during the 70s (about). It is very descriptive writing style, IMHO the investigation is more a pretext to walk through different places and meet various people. It presents the situation in a much more realistic way than "Chinese bad invaders against Tibetans good people". There is a fair share of politic, but it is not a blind "free Tibet", they are real people who tries...more
is an investigation story book, that takes place in Tibet during the 70s (about). It is very descriptive writing style, IMHO the investigation is more a pretext to walk through different places and meet various people. It presents the situation in a much more realistic way than "Chinese bad invaders against Tibetans good people". There is a fair share of politic, but it is not a blind "free Tibet", they are real people who tries...more
1st in the Inspector Shan Tao Yun series, set in contemporary Tibet.[return][return]Shan, a former inspector in the Ministry of Justice in Beijing, is now a prisoner in a hard labor brigade in Tibet, having suddenly fallen out of favor with the Minster. He is the only Chinese in a work gang of Tibetan Buddhist monks. After 4 years with the monks, learning from them as they continue to teach and practice their religion, Shan himself is more Tibetan than Chinese.[return][return]But after the dis...more
Thanks to Bruce for the recommendation. This was a teasing glimpse into Tibetan Buddhist spirituality and the culture and history of Tibet under Chinese rule. I'm not particularly into mysteries, but loved the setting of this one. I am intrigued by the idea of a spirituality that can resist and triumph over oppression, without being tainted by the oppressor, like water making its way through surrounding rock.
In Literary Fiction by People of Colour, I've been discussing James Baldwin'...more
In Literary Fiction by People of Colour, I've been discussing James Baldwin'...more
This book took me weeks to read!
I am not particularly complaining, as I am stating a fact. Usually, books take me a few days, maybe two weeks. The Skull Mantra took me from October 22… And I admit that I got distracted buy three other books, partially because even though it peeked my curiosity, The Skull Mantra is also an incredibly dense read.
It’s a great book, but I have to admit as an American reader, I had a hard time keeping focused. The Skull Mantra is about a m...more
I am not particularly complaining, as I am stating a fact. Usually, books take me a few days, maybe two weeks. The Skull Mantra took me from October 22… And I admit that I got distracted buy three other books, partially because even though it peeked my curiosity, The Skull Mantra is also an incredibly dense read.
It’s a great book, but I have to admit as an American reader, I had a hard time keeping focused. The Skull Mantra is about a m...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Edgar Award winning Eliot Pattison has been described as a "writer of faraway mysteries," a label which is particularly apt for someone whose travel and interests span a million miles of global trekking, visiting every continent but Antarctica. An international lawyer by training, Pattison first combined his deep concerns for the people of Tibet with his interest in fiction writing in Th...more
More about Eliot Pattison...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...











view all 3 comments































