Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress
In this enchanting tale about the magic of reading and the wonder of romantic awakening, two hapless city boys are exiled to a remote mountain village for reeducation during China's infamous Cultural Revolution. There they meet the daughter of the local tailor and discover a hidden stash of Western classics in Chinese translation. As they flirt with the seamstress and secr...more
Paperback, 184 pages
Published
October 29th 2002
by Anchor
(first published 2000)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
A charming book, written with astute quickness, Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress is both erudite and approachable. It is full of details that absolutely make the scenes pop with vividness, but it does not dawdle over what is not necessary. It is a story with a point.
Which is where this book falls apart. Despite its captivation of the reader, its quick pace, its interesting plot, this short novel begins to come apart when perspectives are suddenly shifted (why?) and then again at the end...more
Which is where this book falls apart. Despite its captivation of the reader, its quick pace, its interesting plot, this short novel begins to come apart when perspectives are suddenly shifted (why?) and then again at the end...more
Imagine for a moment that all the books you own are taken from you, pulped or set ablaze, labeled as libelous, unworthy to what your new home now thinks and practices. What would you do? How would this make you feel? Then, as if the act of destruction upon your books was not enough, you, too, are taken to a place where you can be re-educated. All the mysteries or romances or science fiction or literary fiction that you one vigorously pumped into your brain was now going to be methodically replac...more
ه
لا أعرف ماذا تعني إعادة تأهيل ولكني شعرت بالإهانة .. وكأن هؤلاء البشر غير مؤهلين للحياة ويتم إعادة تربيتهم من جديد عموما هذا النهج الذي إرتآه الزعيم ماوالذي وضع سياسة إعادة تأهيل الشباب المتعلم فأرسلهم للقرى على أساس أن الريف هي المعلم وهناك يجب أن يتعلم الإنسان كيف تكون هي الحياة .. وهكذا يذهب بطلا الرواية لو ورفيقه الراوي إلى القرية الواقعة قرب جبل طيور فينق السماء وتشاء الصدف أن آباءهم من الأطباء الذين اعتبرا من أعداء الشعب وفي مفارقة ساخرة والد ليو هو طبيب أسنان وقد سبق أن عالج الزعيم الصي...more
لا أعرف ماذا تعني إعادة تأهيل ولكني شعرت بالإهانة .. وكأن هؤلاء البشر غير مؤهلين للحياة ويتم إعادة تربيتهم من جديد عموما هذا النهج الذي إرتآه الزعيم ماوالذي وضع سياسة إعادة تأهيل الشباب المتعلم فأرسلهم للقرى على أساس أن الريف هي المعلم وهناك يجب أن يتعلم الإنسان كيف تكون هي الحياة .. وهكذا يذهب بطلا الرواية لو ورفيقه الراوي إلى القرية الواقعة قرب جبل طيور فينق السماء وتشاء الصدف أن آباءهم من الأطباء الذين اعتبرا من أعداء الشعب وفي مفارقة ساخرة والد ليو هو طبيب أسنان وقد سبق أن عالج الزعيم الصي...more
أن تكون السبب في تغير أحد ما ،، شعور مذهل وقاتل في الوقت نفسه
مذهل حينما ترى نتائج أفعالك وقد تبينت ملامحها في قسمات ذلك الشخص
عندما تراه يتبدل في كل شيء ،، ملبسه ،، لسانه ،، بل وثقافته
عندما تكسوه الحضارة والتعلم ،، بفضل سعيك المتواصل لإبرازه بهذا الشكل
وهذا ما تمناه صديقنا المتمرد (لو) ورفيق دربه صآحب الكمنجة في أن يحدث لأميرتهم "الخياطة الصغيرة"..!
تلك الفاتنة الصغيرة
من كانت عزائهم الوحيد في ذلك الاقليم المضجر !!
***
هذان الشابان ،، المنفيان من المدينة إلى أعالي الجبال
تم نفيهم لأنهم إبناء لطبق...more
مذهل حينما ترى نتائج أفعالك وقد تبينت ملامحها في قسمات ذلك الشخص
عندما تراه يتبدل في كل شيء ،، ملبسه ،، لسانه ،، بل وثقافته
عندما تكسوه الحضارة والتعلم ،، بفضل سعيك المتواصل لإبرازه بهذا الشكل
وهذا ما تمناه صديقنا المتمرد (لو) ورفيق دربه صآحب الكمنجة في أن يحدث لأميرتهم "الخياطة الصغيرة"..!
تلك الفاتنة الصغيرة
من كانت عزائهم الوحيد في ذلك الاقليم المضجر !!
***
هذان الشابان ،، المنفيان من المدينة إلى أعالي الجبال
تم نفيهم لأنهم إبناء لطبق...more
This story is cute, kind of odd, and without much plot or character development. Dai Sijie's first novel tells the story about two teenage boys sent to the mountains in China for "re-education" under the Maoist regime. Sijie himself was re-educated from 1971 to 1974, which is when this novel takes place. While Sijie builds tension very well he never really delivers. Towards the end the perspective changes for what feels like absolutely no reason and I found myself saying, "what?!" in my head and...more
I chose this excerpt from the book because it seems to sum up the changes seen in the characters:
“Picture if you will, a boy of nineteen still slumbering in the limbo of adolescence, having heard nothing but revolutionary blather about patriotism, Communism, and ideology and propaganda all his life, falling headlong into a story of awakening desire, passion, impulsive action, love, of all the subjects that had, until then, been hidden from me”
There is a series of revolutions taking place through...more
“Picture if you will, a boy of nineteen still slumbering in the limbo of adolescence, having heard nothing but revolutionary blather about patriotism, Communism, and ideology and propaganda all his life, falling headlong into a story of awakening desire, passion, impulsive action, love, of all the subjects that had, until then, been hidden from me”
There is a series of revolutions taking place through...more
One of the reasons why I join bookclubs is to encourage myself to read books I wouldn't normally read, to get me out of my comfort zone. And one of the hopes of any bookclub I think, for me at least, is to find a gem, a book that you had never wanted to read but, having read through coercion, have been spellbound by. This is that book. Descriptions of it that I'd read when it was first released had turned me off - it sounded boring - but with such low expectations I was so into this story that I...more
I very much liked this book. I first watched the movie, and loved it so much I bought the DVD. When I found out it was based on a novel, I was quick to buy that too. The imagery in this book is beautiful. I had just returned home from asia before I read Chinese Seamstress, and had to literally put the book down for a few moments while I reminisced over the beauty of the rice fields and weather-battered people and houses that I came across in Malaysia. This book is so vivid, the scenes took my br...more
This is a gentle, magical book, quite unlike any other I have ever read. The author really gets into the minds of the two boys and the seamstress and the tiny, colourful life they create together despite the poverty of mountain village and the oppression of the Cultural Revolution. The ending is just perfect too.
On its surface, this book has all the ingredients for a really interesting read: a fascinating historical period, potentially interesting characters, and the frequently quite compelling topic of the use or function of literature within literature. Unfortunately, I felt like Sijie failed to live up to the greatness of his own project.
The Cultural Revolution is supposedly the force that propels this story forward. It is, after all, the reason for which the main character and his best friend Luo a...more
The Cultural Revolution is supposedly the force that propels this story forward. It is, after all, the reason for which the main character and his best friend Luo a...more
كثيرا ما كتب عن الرئيس الصيني ماو وأغلب ما كتب يصوره بشخص سادي مزعج. ولكن ألم يعيد الرئيس ماو للصين سيادتها واحترامها بغض النظر عن الأفكار الشيوعية التي تبناها؟
الكتاب كله يتحدث عن التغيير الجذري الذي يمكن أن تحدثه الثقافة في الأفراد. بالنسبة لي أحببت أكثر التغيير الذي أحدثه إعادة التأهيل على الشباب الصيني. أحيانا أتمنى إعادة تأهيل النشء الجديد في صحراؤنا الخصبة
الكتاب كله يتحدث عن التغيير الجذري الذي يمكن أن تحدثه الثقافة في الأفراد. بالنسبة لي أحببت أكثر التغيير الذي أحدثه إعادة التأهيل على الشباب الصيني. أحيانا أتمنى إعادة تأهيل النشء الجديد في صحراؤنا الخصبة
There was a legendary writer in the Hungarian literary world, István Örkény, who beyond doubt is one of the finest absurdist (writer of absurd prose) in the world. He wrote a collection of short stories - really, really short ones, so much so that the title of this legendary book is One Minute Stories (available in English as well). One of the most beautiful pieces is about the magic of literature - although the original Hungarian title is "Ballad about the Power of Poetry" (check it out here -
...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
تحديث: كنت أقلب مواضيعا قديمة، فمررت على موضوع كنت كتبته قبل عامين عن هذه الرواية
أتحدث فيه عن فكرة الفن و الجمال و عن معناه، بما أن الرواية تعالج فكرة الجمال و الفن في وسط الشقاء
كان من السهل علي حينها الحديث عن هذا الموضوع و بمثل هذه الطريقة حين كنت فايقة و رايقة
لكن المفارقة التي ليست مضحكة إطلاقا
أني الآن و بعد عامين من معايشة كل هذا الظلم و المجازر و التوحش
أتساءل إن كان ما كتبته عن المعنى من الجمال، حقا له معنى
على كل المقال جميل فعلا، و إن كنتَ من المحظوظين الذين ما زالوا يستشعرون الجمال فاستمت...more
أتحدث فيه عن فكرة الفن و الجمال و عن معناه، بما أن الرواية تعالج فكرة الجمال و الفن في وسط الشقاء
كان من السهل علي حينها الحديث عن هذا الموضوع و بمثل هذه الطريقة حين كنت فايقة و رايقة
لكن المفارقة التي ليست مضحكة إطلاقا
أني الآن و بعد عامين من معايشة كل هذا الظلم و المجازر و التوحش
أتساءل إن كان ما كتبته عن المعنى من الجمال، حقا له معنى
على كل المقال جميل فعلا، و إن كنتَ من المحظوظين الذين ما زالوا يستشعرون الجمال فاستمت...more
2.5 stars, really. I'm being generous. This was an easy (though hardly light) read. It was generally interesting, but I never grew to care deeply about the characters. The horror of the Cultural Revolution was not made especially real to me. The Little Seamstress herself was utterly underdeveloped. The dialogue was unrealistic: no one speaks in such a manner. There is an abrupt but brief shift in narration toward the end of the book, for no apparent reason; the fact that a particular event is to...more
Set during the Great Proletariat Cultural Revolution under Mao Zedong, the book is largely a story of the power of storytelling. T wo teenage boys have been sent to live in the country (their parents are class enemies) on a mountain known as Phoenix in the Sky. Told mostly from the point of view of one of the boys (although this changes toward the end), it is the story of how in the midst of carrying buckets filled with excrement on slippery trails, they find a stash of books owned by another bo...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
A 50BookChallenge recommendation, I signed up for a Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress Bookcrossing bookcircle a month or two ago & received it in the mail earlier this week.
This novel is a simply-told story about two young men, sent to the Chinese countryside for "reeducation" during the Cultural Revolution. They work long hard hours, but still make time to savor the culture of their former bourgeois life: the main narrator plays his violin and Luo, his friend, retells stories from m...more
This novel is a simply-told story about two young men, sent to the Chinese countryside for "reeducation" during the Cultural Revolution. They work long hard hours, but still make time to savor the culture of their former bourgeois life: the main narrator plays his violin and Luo, his friend, retells stories from m...more
I'm not sure what i was expecting from this book, but i was disappointed by what i got. Not because it was a bad story, on the contrary, it just lacked the emotional aspect i thought it would/should have. These two boys were sent away from their homes, their families and their former education, and neither one --the primary narrator and latter his friend-- had nothing to reflect on, but the fact that they discovered some forbidden books?
I was hoping to feel their loss in their being separated f...more
I was hoping to feel their loss in their being separated f...more
A charming little story as cute as the red shoes on the cover. Touches on a lot of serious and sobering historic themes, specifically the surge of Communism in China, but ultimately is a universal coming-of-age story about two best friends and the love triangle that forms between them and a village girl. I especially liked the ending as I did not foresee the novel taking such a surprising turn to reflect upon the girl's development, which ultimately turns out to be the most substantive of all. A...more
The writing is as sparse as was the fiction of the time. Set in a remote mountain area during the middle of the Chinese Cultural Revolution (1971), where two teenage boys, Luo and the narrator, have been sent to be re-educated because their doctor parents are 'enemies of the people'.
The boys discover and eventually acquire a treasure trove of forbidden books, Western literary classics, including Balzac. It's a bittersweet testimony to the danger of knowledge for knowledge's sake. But it isn't q...more
The boys discover and eventually acquire a treasure trove of forbidden books, Western literary classics, including Balzac. It's a bittersweet testimony to the danger of knowledge for knowledge's sake. But it isn't q...more
"The Cultural Revolution of Chairman Mao Zedong altered Chinese history in the 1960s and '70s, forcibly sending hundreds of thousands of Chinese intellectuals to peasant villages for "re-education." This moving, often wrenching short novel by a writer who was himself re-educated in the '70s tells how two young men weather years of banishment, emphasizing the power of literature to free the mind. Sijie's unnamed 17-year-old protagonist and his best friend, Luo, are bourgeois doctors' sons, and so...more
I always heard such rave reviews about this book when I was working at Barnes and Noble but for some reason never read it until now. I can't say that I share the rave reviews. It's a rather small book, under 200 pages with the pages themselves being very small. I think I didn't care for it that much because I didn't feel like there was much depth to it. The story centers around 2 teenage boys in China who are sent to a small town in the country for "re-education". They also keep in contact with...more
The little Chinese seamstress is the picture of innocent, young love, kept within the boundaries of her simple countryside village. She is pretty and chased after by the local boys. However, she has never reciprocated those romantic or lustful feelings.
Then come two boys from the city. These boys are educated and knowledgeable, so different from the local boys. In the countryside, her father is an authoritative, rich figure, and she is viewed by the others as a lady, someone above them. However...more
Then come two boys from the city. These boys are educated and knowledgeable, so different from the local boys. In the countryside, her father is an authoritative, rich figure, and she is viewed by the others as a lady, someone above them. However...more
I remember when this book came out and everyone was reading it. It just didn't think it would interest me. I was wrong. This is a little gem, although it has a few flaws. The unnamed narrator and his friend, Luo, are teenagers during China's Cultural Revolution. As the children of doctors, they are seen as "intellectuals" and sent to the countryside to be "re-educated" by the peasant class. They find themselves in a remote village carrying manure and mining coal. But unlike other books about the...more
There was a lack of emotional depth to this book, but I still felt drawn into this vivid account of rural China in the communist era. I felt somewhat removed from the horror of the protagonists' situation, that there was only an echo of their homesickness and despair; the casualness of the narrator's account of the trials in the mine was particularly unnerving.
Interestingly, the seamstress is never explicitly named, nor are any of the other surrounding characters. I suppose it's meant to focus...more
Interestingly, the seamstress is never explicitly named, nor are any of the other surrounding characters. I suppose it's meant to focus...more
“Years later I learnt that the translator was himself a great writer. Having been forbidden to publish his own works for political reasons, he spent the rest of his life translating French novels.”
Two city boys are sent to a mountain village for re-education during China’s Cultural Revolution. They encounter the beautiful daughter of the local tailor and manage to steal a stash of Western classics in translation; as they gorge themselves on the forbidden writing, they are released from their gri...more
Two city boys are sent to a mountain village for re-education during China’s Cultural Revolution. They encounter the beautiful daughter of the local tailor and manage to steal a stash of Western classics in translation; as they gorge themselves on the forbidden writing, they are released from their gri...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| صالون الجمعة: * بلزاك والخياطة الصينية الصغيرة | 5-2013 | 117 | 225 | 2 hours, 32 min ago |
Dai Sijie was born in China in 1954. Because he came from an educated middle-class family, the Maoist government sent him to a reeducation camp in rural Sichuan from 1971 to 1974, during the Cultural Revolution. After his return, he was able to complete high school and university, where he studied art history.
In 1984, he left China for France on a scholarship. There, he acquired a passion for mov...more
More about Dai Sijie...
In 1984, he left China for France on a scholarship. There, he acquired a passion for mov...more
Share This Book
10 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“I was carried away, swept along by the mighty stream of words pouring from the hundreds of pages. To me it was the ultimate book: once you had read it, neither your own life nor the world you lived in would ever look the same.”
—
32 people liked it
“In the end we had changed the position of the hands so many times that we had no idea what the time really was.”
—
10 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...








view all 9 comments
































