Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “China Witness: Voices from a Silent Generation” as Want to Read:
China Witness: Voices from a Silent Generation
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

China Witness: Voices from a Silent Generation

3.67 of 5 stars 3.67  ·  rating details  ·  346 ratings  ·  50 reviews
China Witness is an extraordinary work of oral history that illuminates the diverse ways in which the Chinese perceive and understand their own history.

Xinran, the acclaimed author of The Good Women of China and Sky Burial, traveled across China in 2005 and 2006, seeking out the nation’s grandparents and great-grandparents, the men and women who have experienced, firsthan
Hardcover, 448 pages
Published February 24th 2009 by Pantheon (first published 2008)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about China Witness, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about China Witness

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,230)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
A fascinating look at what the older generation feels and thinks about China, and the stories of their lives.

This book makes a lot more sense if you've read a lot about China (I have) because much of what the author says and implies about certain events are easy to miss if you're not aware of Chinese recent history. For instance, many of the people are very guarded in their assessment of political history and seem unable to criticize some of the horrible policies of Mao. In fact, you have to rea
Ranjeev Dubey
Any book on China describing the 'dark years' between the 1940s and 1990s is welcome especially if it avoids the rich, the powerful and the elite and deals instead with the lived experiance of common folk. Xinran has ferreted out people from a variety of fields across the face of China and discussed their lives with her. Some are powerful but many are peasants or poor or stripped of all power or all of the foregoing. The result is a very interesting portrait of life in the raw in times of enormo ...more
Xinran is one of the most authentic voices from China writing today. I snap up each of her books as soon as they come out. I picked this one up with high hopes, as it's about the 'silent generation' of Chinese who lived through the Revolution and the suffering afterward -- the whole gamut of natural and political catastrophe that is modern China. Unfortunately, the 'silent generation' learned early to lie to stay alive, and that is how their interviews often come across -- they're holding back, ...more
This is a very good book that gives some excellent insights into both current China from the perspective of both the author who is in her middle years and now lives mostly in the UK and of the people that she interviews who are mostly people in their later years, most of whom were revolutionaries when the Communist Party took over China in the late 40s. To give an example of an insight. It had not occurred to me - duh, it should have - that the Chinese have always existed under rulers who foster ...more
Donna Swartz
Most interesting view, as this was a compilation of interviews of Chinese (who remained in PRC after 1949) by a Chinese journalist, Xinran, who grew up in China but now lives in London. Her sensibilities remain in sync with her interviewees, with the overlay of her western experience. The form, language and content of this book is, therefor, a wonderfully true reading of the mainland Chinese soul. What is unsaid is just as revealing as what is said. Poignant.
In this collection of interviews with elderly Chinese people, all of whom are witnesses to the great upheavals that beset twentieth-century China, Xinran aims to tell their stories and to testify about their personal experiences living in such a tumultuous century. The interviewees come from all walks of life: a traditional lantern maker, former police officer and court official, a general returned from America, a shoe repairer; these are ordinary people with ordinary lives (as they often say) b ...more
Sahel Chin
I have read everything else by this author, and she is typically a very compelling storyteller. Sadly, this book was dull and just a chore to get through. Even worse, the subject matter is interesting, but just not presented well.
I wept. Xinran effectively captures the unique personalities of each of her subjects, from a brief snippet of an overheard conversation to long interviews with people who lived (somehow!) through conditions that seem impossibly inhumane. Truly though, their stories of hardship are engrossing and emotional. What brings me to tears are the stories of parenting during such tumultuous times. Consistent are regrets of losing connection with their children, and though reasons are as varied as DNA comb ...more
a book filled with interviews. The author is very interested in telling the story of the peasants, and the price they paid with their blood and sweat to build China after the Liberation in 1949.

What we don't understand in the West is what it was like before 1949, so we have no idea why when this new nation was born people were enthused and filled with optimism.

Not as compelling as her book interviewing just women of China, but interesting to me.

"China's peasants have been treated as a part of th
This past century has been a tumultuous one for China. Until 1912, China was still ruled by the Qing Dynasty, which gave way after the Xinhai Revolution to a series of regional warlords vying for supremacy. Nationalists were finally able to consolidate power by 1928, but then war, first with Japan and then civil war within China, was followed by the Communist revolution in 1949. The “Time of the Leadership of the Party” and the Cultural Revolution caused untold suffering, including millions of d ...more
If I had read China Witness before reading other works by Xinran I would of given it more stars.
China Witness is a collection of interviews of Chinese who lived through the Revolution. Whilst the interviews are heartbreaking, tragic i feel as though I am not getting full insight into these people's lives. They tell their story's and share their pain, anguish, resilience and determination but something seems to be missing slightly. Perhaps as part of the 'Silent Generation' these people are so
Die chinesische Journalistin Xinran reiste quer durch China, von Guilin im Süden bis nach Urumqi in der nordöstlichen Provinz Xinjiang, um hochbetagte Chinesen (im Alter zwischen 70 und 80) zu interviewen. Mit diesem ehrgeizigen Projekt will sie Zeugnisse chinesischer Kultur und Geschichte dokumentieren, ehe sie in Vergessenheit geraten können. Xinran fühlt sich verantwortlich dafür, dass die Erinnerungen ihrer Gesprächspartner für die folgenden Generationen bewahrt werden. Eine chinesische Eige ...more
Gill Collins
This non fiction book takes time to read and process. Interviews and connected stories of old Chinese people and their experiences in rural China has created an intriguing series of chapters. The singing news teller,party geologist and Gobi desert pioneers etc are fascinating accounts of harsh and troubled, yet joyful lives, give an interesting sense of Chinese culture. There is some lack of cohesion and a prologue of Chinese historical markers would have helped my enjoyment of this book.
Sylvia Ttl
I sought to read this book out of a great interest over the modern history of China from the standpoint of ordinary people from all walks of life. I appreciate the author's effort to tour China to document true but publicly-unavailable stories, yet she has annoyed me in many occasions for interrupting the interviewees from telling a full account. As a result, a potentially noteworthy personal history ends up as boring and long-winded "grandmother" story that I could not bear to read on. Not to m ...more
This book is an interesting look at the lives of the older generation in China. Each chapter starts off describing the person or persons that the author is interviewing, followed by a transcript of the interview. I personally was not a huge fan of the straight transcript format, but that's just a personal preference. The people she interviewed were extraordinary, and their stories were fascinating. Sometimes I wished for more analysis to go with the interviews. I would recommend this book to any ...more
Deborah J.
I read this book before leaving on a 15-day tour of China. I found it interesting because the 'silent' older generation is the foundation of what China is today although it's no surprise that the youth don't see it that way.
I followed it up with 'What the Chinese Don't Eat' and it was a sort of mini-course in Chinese culture which I enjoyed while traveling through the country.
I read to page 231 (out of 417) before deciding to set this one aside. I find the subject, living through the turmoil of China's cultural revolution, interesting, but the presentation did not engage me. I expected it to be like her other books, The Good Women of China and Letter from an Unknown Chinese Mother, but it lacked the narrative style of those books. Instead of telling a different story in each chapter, China Witness gives only a short introduction followed by a transcript of an intervi ...more
A very important book that has given me great insight into some of the people of China on the eve of my own journey there. Xinran gives a very poignant and insightful look into the psyche of the not often enough revered older men and women who have survived the upheaval and change that has brought us to modern day China
Cj Newman
Great book for those, like myself, who enjoy learning about the culture of Chinese women. Real women, not officials or famous citizens. Xinran winnowed the initial list of 50 down to 20 solid interviews of such women for the purpose of recording a period of Chinese history for the children. Mainly people who lived through the Cultural Revolution and just before and after. She was seeking their honest remembrances. Some warmed up a little slowly, but for the most part many (and their spouses chim ...more
China's history experienced by millions during Mao's Cultural Revolution is captured in a series of interviews by a journalist. Her subjects are the grandparents and great-grandparents who survived imprisonment, re-education, famine, separation from their families and hard labor.

The author selected 50 ordinary individuals across China to interview. The interviews covered not only the tragedies and hardship that they experienced, but also their candid opinions of the changes that China has gone
A necessary book. There are not enough of these stories being told, and censorship is effectively silencing an entire generation of people who are already reluctant to reminisce over the hardships they faced in their youth. It took me a while to finish this book because while I am interested in the subject matter, I was completely put off by the style in which it was written. Too much of the book felt like I was being handheld through each interview, and being told what to feel. Parts of the boo ...more
This book is a collection of interviews with people who are 60+ years old in contemporary China. So these are people who were born after the Guomintang revolution, but before the Communist one. They survived that, plus the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution, and now the market reforms. The premise of the book is that this is a group who has both seen and done a lot, and has something important to say about what it means to be Chinese.

The life stories of the people interviewed in this bo
I love this woman and the stories she has captured. A radio show host during some of China's most tumultuous years, Xinran has worked to record the stories of ordinary people who lived through extraordinary times, before they are lost forever
The author is a journalist raised in both China and Britain. When her own kids started asking about the Cultural and Counter-Cultural Revolutions, she realized that this history (as seen through the people who lived through it) is fast disappearing as those who were young men and women during that time are becoming elderly and dying. So she sets out in the series of interviews featured in this book to try to show and explain what ordinary people were going through.

Very fascinating book; especia
The Tick
This was a hard book to read--there wasn't always enough background information, especially when it came to smaller aspects of China's recent history, the kind that wouldn't be covered in broad historical surveys. There were also some things that I felt could have been shortened or cut (especially the love letters--they were sweet, but they didn't really add to what the book's main focus was supposed to be).

On the other hand, Xinran really did an excellent job of finding people with perspectives
Here is a book that matters... If you have read Xinran's "The Good Women of China" and found it enlightening, this, too, reveals some secrets and truths yet unrecorded in Chinese historical documents.

"China Witnesses" is a compilation of Xinran's interviews of people who lived through the darkest years of China's history. If you want to dig deeper at grass roots level into the sentiments of the very generation that has witnessed China's evolution from poverty and socio-political unrest, this wo
I feel guilty for not liking this book more. Xinran travelled China, interviewing the elderly who had lived through the Communist Revolution. She is trying to give these men and women the chance to share their true thoughts and feelings - something they have been forbidden to do throughout their lives. There were many nuggets of fascinating insight, but the book mostly consisted of straight transcriptions of her interviews. I wanted to want to be drawn in by them, but the book spent a lot of tim ...more
Not as riveting as Wild Swans, mostly because the interviews were so uneven. Some were fascinating and others, minimally interesting. Also, the author was disturbingly intrusive throughout. I wanted to get more of the flavor of the Chinese subjects, without her commentary- except perhaps as a footnote. The question and answer format was annoying, especially as she kept asking key questions over and over to all the subjects. There is no doubt that the interviews are an important part of the story ...more
Ke Yu
this comes as a huge disappointment after the high expectation set by "the good women of China"--the book reads like 'raw' transcriptions of interviews (with inadquate good probings); the author's strength--intertwinning her actions, thinking and the storyline, is in the main casted away; and the stories read quite thin--at times, it seems that she had wanted to achieve too many purposes (how people expereinced the old times, how they met and raised the family..) and in the end none is adequatel ...more
Budd Dwyer
Pretty good, although it doesn't make the point that China is now leading the world in abortion without apology.

we need to cut down our population enormously and it seems to me that China is doing its best to do this.

In the US, we still allow a lot of really unsatisfactory mothers to sit on their eggs until they are turned into babies. Bad news -- we have to stop all population growth and abortion should be permitted into the 9th month. But I'm belaboring the obvious...
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40 41 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Corpse Walker: Real Life Stories, China from the Bottom Up
  • Red Dust: A Path Through China
  • Postcards from Tomorrow Square: Reports from China
  • Behind the Wall: A Journey Through China
  • From Emperor To Citizen: The Autobiography Of Aisin Gioro Pu Yi
  • Chairman Mao Would Not Be Amused: Fiction from Today's China
  • 十個詞彙裡的中國 (China in Ten Words)
  • Wild Grass: Three Stories of Change in Modern China
  • The River at the Center of the World: A Journey Up the Yangtze & Back in Chinese Time
  • Tombstone: The Great Chinese Famine, 1958-1962
  • China in the 21st Century
  • Modern China: A Very Short Introduction
  • The Song of Everlasting Sorrow: A Novel of Shanghai
  • Watching the Tree
  • Out of Mao's Shadow: The Struggle for the Soul of a New China
  • Dream of Ding Village
  • Ten Thousand Miles Without a Cloud
  • The Last Days of Old Beijing: Life in the Vanishing Backstreets of a City Transformed
Xue Xinran, who usually writes as simply "Xinran", was a radio broadcaster in China before moving to Great Britain and beginning to publish books. She currently writes as a columnist.
More about Xinran...
The Good Women of China: Hidden Voices Sky Burial: An Epic Love Story of Tibet Message from an Unknown Chinese Mother: Stories of Loss and Love Miss Chopsticks What the Chinese Don't Eat

Share This Book