Messenger of Truth (Maisie Dobbs #4)
by
Jacqueline Winspear (Goodreads Author)
Sue Feder/Macavity Award for Best Historical Mystery Award Nominee
London, 1931. On the night before the opening of his new and much-anticipated exhibition at a famed Mayfair gallery, Nicholas Bassington-Hope falls to his death. The police declare it an accident, but the dead man's twin sister, Georgina, isn't convinced. When the authorities refuse to conduct further invest...more
Paperback, 322 pages
Published
June 12th 2007
by Picador
(first published 2006)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This was my latest experience with Maisie Dobbs, the post-WWI British heroine created by Jacqueline Winspear. This fourth book in the series was good, but somehow I didn't enjoy it as much as the third three- don't know why. I highly recommend the whole series though!
I was excited to read in the p.s. section of the third book, "Messenger of Truth", that the series will be adapted for British television and that Winspear envisioned Anthony Hopkins and Maggie Smith as playing roles, although I don...more
I was excited to read in the p.s. section of the third book, "Messenger of Truth", that the series will be adapted for British television and that Winspear envisioned Anthony Hopkins and Maggie Smith as playing roles, although I don...more
Mar 09, 2011
Hannah
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2011-reads,
mysteries
Rating Clarification: 2.5 stars
This series seems to be getting weaker and weaker, or more likely I'm getting more and more fed up with Maisie Dobbs: "New Age Geru Detective Extroidinaire".
#4 in the series finds Maisie on the hunt to determine whether her client's artist brother fell from some scaffolding, or was pushed to his death on the eve of his big art exhibition.
Along the way, Maisie discovers an appreciation for "ART", and Winspear tries to breath some color and emotion into her characte...more
This series seems to be getting weaker and weaker, or more likely I'm getting more and more fed up with Maisie Dobbs: "New Age Geru Detective Extroidinaire".
#4 in the series finds Maisie on the hunt to determine whether her client's artist brother fell from some scaffolding, or was pushed to his death on the eve of his big art exhibition.
Along the way, Maisie discovers an appreciation for "ART", and Winspear tries to breath some color and emotion into her characte...more
I'm a Maisie Dobbs fan. Her character is developing over the series. In this book, she tests her independence on several fronts: professionally, by not calling on her mentor, Maurice Blanche, domestically, by living alone, and romantically, by separating from her suitor. She is investigating the death of an artist, meanwhile observing much about the society around her (1931, London), including veterans, the brutality of war, the rise of fascism, class differences, poverty, family relationships,...more
Oct 27, 2007
Sharon
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
anglophiles, Sally Lockhart fans
Shelves:
mysterythriller,
series
This book, the fourth in the series, is a failure as a mystery. Maisie Dobbs is asked to investigate a death that might be murder, and eventually she uncovers not only the truth but also a smuggling ring. Unfortunately, although the reader can follow the trail of the smugglers, the resolution of the central death seems to depend on Maisie's psychic abilities--abilities that the reader doesn't have. The resolution makes sense, but it seems to come out of the blue.
There are, however, a number of r...more
There are, however, a number of r...more
Again, the theme of these books is the consequences of decisions. Lady Rowan, the patroness of Maisy, decides that she cannot maintain her wasteful, upper-class lifestyle, and closes her house in London, choosing to maintain it only if her son returns from Canada. That leads to her household staff being thrown out into the Depression of England. We applaud her commitment to thrift, but we are horrified by what the staff faces. Maisy chooses between her relationship with the perfect man and her f...more
Maisie Dobbs has had an unconventional up-bringing. She started working as a servant as a young girl when her mother died. Then a visitor to the family discovered that she was reading some of the most difficult books in the estate library and trying to learn foreign languages to read some of the books. So Maurice becomes her teacher and mentor, training her in psychology and detection.
This is the 4th book of her cases. The books are set pre and post World War I - mostly post although the beginn...more
This is the 4th book of her cases. The books are set pre and post World War I - mostly post although the beginn...more
I wanted to like this novel. Maisie Dobbs could be such a great heroine, but she's just not. She thinks too much like a modern woman, is always telling people high up on the social pyramid how they ought to treat those further down and they just do it. More nuance would have been appreciated. If I'm looking for a smart, appealing heroine, I'd prefer Amanda Fitton from the Allingham novels, and she's just the protagonist's fiance/wife.
As for the plot, I figured out everything except who did it (m...more
As for the plot, I figured out everything except who did it (m...more
Fourth in the Maisie Dobbs historical mystery set in December 1930 London and revolving around a woman who incorporates a meditative psychology with her detective work.
My Take
In this story, we explore the lives of artists, painters, a writer, and a musician. What makes them tick, the places they work. What spurs them on. As for the coast at Dungeness, I don't think it has anything to do with all the red herrings in this.
Oh, god, this was so incredibly sad. Such talent ended. A family devastated...more
My Take
In this story, we explore the lives of artists, painters, a writer, and a musician. What makes them tick, the places they work. What spurs them on. As for the coast at Dungeness, I don't think it has anything to do with all the red herrings in this.
Oh, god, this was so incredibly sad. Such talent ended. A family devastated...more
This is the 4th installment in the Maisie Dobbs series. Maisie is hired by a well-to-do journalist to investigate the presumed accidental death of her artist twin brother. With her usual methods blending traditional investigation techniques and psychology, Maisie dives into the life of the dead artist. In the process she illuminates some truths about the unique bohemian family to which the siblings belong.
This is a pretty solid addition to the Maisie Dobbs Series. The case being investigated wa...more
This is a pretty solid addition to the Maisie Dobbs Series. The case being investigated wa...more
May 18, 2012
Nancy
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
mystery-or-something-akin-to-it
Funny I liked this book more than the last couple, but can't put my finger quite on why that is... the parts don't add up to my feelings about it as a whole, but nonetheless...
The not so good: A lot was happening with the main plot and several subplots, a rather scattershot approach: the main mystery with a smaller one trailing along; Billy's dilemma; and Maisie's own interpersonal adventures (Dr. Dene; Maurice and Lady Rowan; and the Bassington-Hopes; Maisie's own triptych, if you will). This s...more
The not so good: A lot was happening with the main plot and several subplots, a rather scattershot approach: the main mystery with a smaller one trailing along; Billy's dilemma; and Maisie's own interpersonal adventures (Dr. Dene; Maurice and Lady Rowan; and the Bassington-Hopes; Maisie's own triptych, if you will). This s...more
For months now I've been reading other bloggers' reviews of Jacqueline Winspear's Maisie Dobbs mysteries. Everyone likes them. So, I looked in the box of books given to me a while ago and found Messenger of Truth. This isn't the first in the series, but I don't usually have the opportunity to read a series in order so I plunged right in.
This story is set in London in 1931. The setting is of a changed city after World War I where some women have taken on new types of jobs but the poor are still a...more
This story is set in London in 1931. The setting is of a changed city after World War I where some women have taken on new types of jobs but the poor are still a...more
I am a great fan of Winspear's Maisie Dobbs books but this particular one just didn't appeal to me.
Maisie has a budding reputation as a psychologist and investigator with uncanny sensitivity and intuition. Her intuition was totally intact in this book but she could have used a training session on interpersonal relationships. She blew off her lover with little explanation (and less regret) and she was barely civil to her benefactress, and then her mentor, when they attempted to "connect" with her...more
Maisie has a budding reputation as a psychologist and investigator with uncanny sensitivity and intuition. Her intuition was totally intact in this book but she could have used a training session on interpersonal relationships. She blew off her lover with little explanation (and less regret) and she was barely civil to her benefactress, and then her mentor, when they attempted to "connect" with her...more
http://iwriteinbooks.wordpress.com/20...
Scotland Yard doesn’t have time for reporter, Georgina Bassington-Hope’s paranoid theories. That’s why they’ve sent her packing to see Maisie.
Her acclaimed artist of a twin brother fell off of his scaffolding while working and it’s been ruled, over and over, an accidental death. Case closed.
Georgina can’t fight that lingering malicious feeling, though, and it soon finds her on Maisie’s front step, begging the question: if he didn’t fall of his own mistake...more
Well, Jacqueline has done it again. Made me Mad for Maisie all over again. Just when I think I can’t love the next one as much as the last, I read the next and love it more.
One of the issues I sometimes have with series is the character either never changes, grows, or evolves or he or she change in ways I do not enjoy. This cannot be said about Maisie. I love the way she grows and develops over each novel. She learns more about her self and we learn more about her. This entry in the series is no...more
One of the issues I sometimes have with series is the character either never changes, grows, or evolves or he or she change in ways I do not enjoy. This cannot be said about Maisie. I love the way she grows and develops over each novel. She learns more about her self and we learn more about her. This entry in the series is no...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
It is something of a challenge to respond to the fourth book in a series of novels that I have been reading in rapid succession. I think the element that most impressed me in this novel, even though it has been present in each of the others, is the mission Ms. Winspear's protagonist, Maisie Dobbs, pursues to not merely discover the truth, but to bring healing to all parties involved.
Once again, the ravages of World War I haunt the various cast of characters as they deal with the apparently accid...more
Once again, the ravages of World War I haunt the various cast of characters as they deal with the apparently accid...more
A war does not end with an Armistice. The fall-out goes on and on, as long as the survivors are alive. And maybe longer. Ms. Winspear sets her series of murder mysteries in London and environs just in-between the two world wars. Her plots involve the lingering effects of war, the reactions and feelings of those survivors, as well as the plight of ordinary citizens at a time of financial recession. Her sleuth, Maisie Dobbs, an unmarried still-young woman who has risen from the servant class to th...more
Dec 13, 2012
Rusty
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
contemporary-fiction,
historical-fiction
It's 1931 in London when an emerging artist, Nicholas Bassington-Hope, dies in a fall from the scaffolding from which he is hanging paintings for his latest and most talked about show. Is it an accident or murder? Nicholas' twin sister, Georgina, believes that it is murder and hires Maisie Dobbs to investigate and find out.
In the process Maisie discovers much about herself. Her determination to be a self-supporting and independent woman in a time of change leads her to evaluate her romantic life...more
In the process Maisie discovers much about herself. Her determination to be a self-supporting and independent woman in a time of change leads her to evaluate her romantic life...more
I like the characters of Billy Beale, Frankie Dobbs, Lady Compton, even Maisie's friend Priscilla (who doesn't really make an appearance in this book), but for some reason, I just don't feel the same toward Maisie. I'm not sure why; I don't really have reason to dislike her.... I just can't explain it. Part of me feels that there is just more vibrancy to these other characters than to Maisie herself. She has the backstory, but it just doesn't help me to see her as fleshed out as the other charac...more
Set in London after the Great War, Maise Dobbs has quite a mystery on her hands. Nicholas Bassingon-Hope, upcoming artist, has fallen to his death. His sister Georgina feels in her heart that her twin brother has been murdered and when the police do not believe her, she turns to Maisie. Without any clues to point to murder, Maisie takes the case, determined to bring peace to the Bassington-Hope family one way or the other.
Before I write anything else, I have to state how much I LOVE this cover....more
Before I write anything else, I have to state how much I LOVE this cover....more
Messenger Of Truth, the fourth book in the Maisie Dobbs mystery series, is filled with a pervasive melancholy that casts its shadow upon Massie and her clients. Jacqueline Winspear masterfully creates a tangled emotional web in which Maisie, with her fine-tuned skills of sensitivity, is ensnared. The war is over but the devastation and dire economic situation have resulted in crime, disease, death and desperation throughout Maisie’s beloved London. When Miss Dobbs is called upon by a fellow form...more
I listened to this on Audio, and I must confess a preoccupation of mine is the British accent. I know I am not the only one, since many commercials are done with a British voice to attract our attention. That keeps me listening to Maisie Dobbs. I started this one and about 1/3 of the way through,I thought , oh I am tired of this one. However just as I was feeling flustered, and tired of the tale, Jacqueline Winspear, the author, makes the whole story come together and I want to hear the end.What...more
This was definitely better than Birds of a Feather, but not quite as good as Maisie Dobbs and Pardonable Lies. I will say that she didn't fall prey to the one small quibble I had with Pardonable Lies, that of feeling the need to put the heroine in a dangerous situation that didn't feel organic to the plot, simply to adhere to the conventions of the mystery genre. I really appreciate that she is becoming confident enough in the character and series to tweak the genre as she sees fit. I expect to...more
This might be my favorite so far of the Maisie Dobbs series. A few notable quotes:
"it was always best to allow a person who had something important to say, perhaps a declaration or a complaint, the courtesy of an uninterrupted statement."
"hadn’t Maurie told her once that the most important question any individual could ask was, “How might I serve?”
"the excitement, the thrill, and it was a thrill, when she embarked on the work of collecting clues to support a case"
"Truth........that bolt of recog...more
"it was always best to allow a person who had something important to say, perhaps a declaration or a complaint, the courtesy of an uninterrupted statement."
"hadn’t Maurie told her once that the most important question any individual could ask was, “How might I serve?”
"the excitement, the thrill, and it was a thrill, when she embarked on the work of collecting clues to support a case"
"Truth........that bolt of recog...more
I have been reading along all of the books in this series fairly quickly until I got to this one. It is so sad I had to put it aside for awhile before finishing it. The problem for me in this book is that I am starting to not like Maisie very much. Would it have killed her to go check on Billy's daughter when she found out she was sick. She was after all a nurse and she knew that he didn't have the money to take her to the doctor. She could have at least given him the money. He has put himself o...more
I'm giving three stars instead of four for this book, which had some of the best and worst moments of the series so far. The mystery involves a painter, Nick Bassington-Hope, who falls from a scaffolding on the eve of unveiling his newest work at a gallery. Nick's twin sister, Georgiana, engages Maisie Dobbs to investigate whether his death was really an accident, as the police claim, or murder, which she suspects.
The piece of art itself hasn't been seen by any of Nick's closest friends or fami...more
The piece of art itself hasn't been seen by any of Nick's closest friends or fami...more
I started in the middle of the series since my local library did not have the first few available. I was very happy to find that I was able to get into the story without having read the beginning books. Although I am going to go back and read them.
Maisie Dobbs is an independent woman in England and is not following in the footsteps of other women her age. The experiences that have led her to her current occupation as an investigator are alluded to as well as her humble background. She went to a...more
Maisie Dobbs is an independent woman in England and is not following in the footsteps of other women her age. The experiences that have led her to her current occupation as an investigator are alluded to as well as her humble background. She went to a...more
Feb 01, 2011
DJ
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
read-and-returned,
who-dunnit
This is the 4th book in Ms Winspears "Maisie Dobbs" series.
I have previously read the first one, and I do think that I have possibly missed out on the evolution of the characters by coming in to this book without reading the middle 2 books.....
Whilst I loved Maisies character in the first book, there was something just a little too" preachy" for my taste, hence my previous comment.
In saying that,I adored the way that this story was put together and showed the after effects of WW1 on Britain. I t...more
I have previously read the first one, and I do think that I have possibly missed out on the evolution of the characters by coming in to this book without reading the middle 2 books.....
Whilst I loved Maisies character in the first book, there was something just a little too" preachy" for my taste, hence my previous comment.
In saying that,I adored the way that this story was put together and showed the after effects of WW1 on Britain. I t...more
This year the tenth book in the Maisie Dobbs series by Jacqueline Winspear is being released. To celebrate, there is a month long blog tour called The Month of Maisie which will focus on the whole series, with the first seven books in the series being featured in this first week of the month, leading up to the newest book at the end of the month.
Because I was a bit slow in jumping on board this series, I have just read the fourth book, Messenger of Truth. Once again, investigator/psychologist Ma...more
Because I was a bit slow in jumping on board this series, I have just read the fourth book, Messenger of Truth. Once again, investigator/psychologist Ma...more
I love this series but found this entry to be the weakest. The principal problem, I think, is that unlike the other books, the central figures in the case Maisie was investigating lacked the personal connection to her that existed in the cases in previous books, and beyond that none of them were very sympathetic or engaging. The subplot involving Billy's family was also unconvincingly worked into the book and I was bothered by Andrew Dene's treatment of Maisie, which is understandable in many wa...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Book Signing!! | 1 | 18 | Mar 14, 2008 01:21pm |
Jacqueline Winspear was born and raised in the county of Kent, England. Following higher education at the University of London’s Institute of Education, Jacqueline worked in academic publishing, in higher education and in marketing communications in the UK.
She emigrated to the United States in 1990, and while working in business and as a personal / professional coach, Jacqueline embarked upon a li...more
More about Jacqueline Winspear...
She emigrated to the United States in 1990, and while working in business and as a personal / professional coach, Jacqueline embarked upon a li...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“She closed her eyes, silently continuing the pleas that she be given words that might soothe, words that would begin the healing of bereaved parents. She had seen, when she entered the kitchen, the chasm of sorrow that divided man and wife already, each deep in their own wretched suffering, neither knowing what to say to the other. She knew that to begin to talk about what had happened was a key to acknowledging their loss, and that such acceptance would in turn be a means to enduring the days and months ahead.”
—
2 people liked it
“She had always told herself that she did hti job because she wanted to help others; afterall, hadn't Maurice told her once that the most important question any individual could ask was, "How might I serve?" If her response to that question had been pure, surely she would have coninued with the calling to be a nurse.... But that role hadn't been quite enough for her. She would have missed the excitement, the thrill when she embarked on the work of collecting clues to support a case.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...




















Jan 14, 2012 10:37am
Oct 04, 2012 08:15pm