4th out of 57 books
—
43 voters
Old City Hall (Detective Greene #1)
"Breathtaking . . . A tightly woven spiderweb of plot and a rich cast of characters make this a truly gripping read." --Jeffery Deaver, author of "The Bodies Left Behind" It should be an open-and-shut case. Canada's leading radio-show host, Kevin Brace, has confessed to killing his young wife. He had come to the door of his luxury condominium with his hands covered in bloo...more
Hardcover, 369 pages
Published
March 3rd 2009
by Farrar Straus Giroux
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,011)
I was attracted to this book because it is a murder mystery set in downtown Toronto.
I enjoyed the writing style. Though there are lots of pages, I found the book moved at a quick pace. As the characters were cluing in on things, I got some at the same time and others I had to wait for them to be revealed.
Since I live in Toronto, I knew most of the places he referred to in the story such as Old City Hall, the Vesta Lunch, etc. You can see them all here. At times, he went into a lot of detail abou...more
I enjoyed the writing style. Though there are lots of pages, I found the book moved at a quick pace. As the characters were cluing in on things, I got some at the same time and others I had to wait for them to be revealed.
Since I live in Toronto, I knew most of the places he referred to in the story such as Old City Hall, the Vesta Lunch, etc. You can see them all here. At times, he went into a lot of detail abou...more
Jun 18, 2011
Jmm
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Jmm by:
book review
Shelves:
police-procedural,
toronto
When Mr. Singh makes his last paper delivery of the morning in his adopted city of Toronto, he is looking forward to a cup of tea with his favorite customer, Kevin Brace, Canada’s leading talk show host. But when Brace comes to the door, his fingers covered in a thick red liquid, Mr. Singh feels his heart racing as Brace whispers, “’I killed her.’”
If you’re looking for a police procedural with some interesting twists, then you’ll want to check out Old City Hal by Robert Rotenberg, a criminal att...more
If you’re looking for a police procedural with some interesting twists, then you’ll want to check out Old City Hal by Robert Rotenberg, a criminal att...more
I really liked this mystery. Set in Toronto, third- person narrator, jumping from a variety of characters in the story, starting with a minor character, Mr. Singh, a 74-yer-old Indian who now delivers papers. He is delivering papers in an upscale condo apartment building, when the owner of one of the two top=floor apts. tells him he has killed his wife.
The story then introduces Dectective Ari Greene, a Jewish man (somewhat mysterious to his team) who takes care of his father, a survivor of the H...more
The story then introduces Dectective Ari Greene, a Jewish man (somewhat mysterious to his team) who takes care of his father, a survivor of the H...more
It is impossible to do OLD CITY HALL justice in a review. It is unusual in every way.
Each morning, Gurdial Singh, formerly the chief engineer for Indian Railways and approaching his 74th birthday, delivers newspapers to the condominiums at the luxury Market Place Towers in Toronto. He begins at exactly 5:05 am and exactly 25 minutes later, Mr Singh reaches the 12th floor apartment of Kevin Brace, the most famous radio host in Canada. Mr. Kevin would be waiting at the half-opened door with a ciga...more
Dec 31, 2009
Kathleen Hagen
added it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2009-audio-books,
2009-mysteries
Old City Hall, by Robert Rotenberg, A. narrated by Paul Hecht, Produced by Recorded Books, downloaded from audible.com.
Rotenberg himself is a defense lawyer, and you can tell he knows his way around a courtroom. Here we have a man who is famous on the radio, known as Mr. Canada, everyone listens to his shows. When the man who delivers his newspaper is met by the man at his door with the sentence: “I killed her, I killed my wife,” it would seem to be a slam-dunk case. The defense lawyer and the a...more
Rotenberg himself is a defense lawyer, and you can tell he knows his way around a courtroom. Here we have a man who is famous on the radio, known as Mr. Canada, everyone listens to his shows. When the man who delivers his newspaper is met by the man at his door with the sentence: “I killed her, I killed my wife,” it would seem to be a slam-dunk case. The defense lawyer and the a...more
I was looking for a Canadian mystery writer, and Robert Rotenberg was recommended to me, forget by whom. Even better for me as a Torontonian, he sets Old City Hall in Toronto. Unfortunately, that meant as a Torontonian, I got tossed out of the flow of the book when he used strange-to-monikers for common place, like "bay" for the "inner harbour" (or at least I think that's the body of water he was referring to). The strange terms may be because of his publisher as the book didn't seem to know whe...more
This is the first book by Robert Rotenberg that I have read in my ongoing project to read mystery novels/series by Canadian authors and I most assuredly intend to read the rest in the series. Of course "Old City Hall" bears quite a resemblance to William Deverell's "Arthur Beauchamp" series which is to be expected as they are both, primarily, courtroom dramas. In my opinion Deverell's books are much more humourous than this one although the situations created by the unlikely, and probably imposs...more
At first glance, where's the story? A radio host opens the door to his morning paper delivery person and says he's killed his wife. He then says not a word. literally, nothing. The police arrive, the homicide detective turns up, the lawyers for defence and prosecution and a number of other interested parties. And it turns out that this apparently open and shut case is nothing of the sort. There's all sorts of secrets hidden behind the superficially perfect life the host has, and the victim isn;t...more
This book was recommended by the 2012 Book Lover's Page-A-Day Calendar. Entry was for June 30/July 1, 2012.
I gotta say that the inclusion of this novel on the Book Lover's Page-A-Day Calendar now makes recommendations by the calendar slightly suspect. I didn't hate this novel-- I did, after all, finish it-- but it didn't "wow" me in any way, shape, or form. It's your typical cookie-cutter quick pick off an airport gift shop book rack type mystery, and it isn't even a tremendously well-done one a...more
I gotta say that the inclusion of this novel on the Book Lover's Page-A-Day Calendar now makes recommendations by the calendar slightly suspect. I didn't hate this novel-- I did, after all, finish it-- but it didn't "wow" me in any way, shape, or form. It's your typical cookie-cutter quick pick off an airport gift shop book rack type mystery, and it isn't even a tremendously well-done one a...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This is an absolutely outstanding mystery. It has it all, great characters, great plot, great setting, good pace. And the audio version is great with the narrator's voice slightly gravelly and just perfect for the book.
Radio personality, Kevin Brace, the "voice of Canada", meets his newspaper delivery person every morning with a slice of orange and and smile, while drinking his today. Except for one morning, where he isn't there right away and when he appears, he has blood-covered hands and con...more
Radio personality, Kevin Brace, the "voice of Canada", meets his newspaper delivery person every morning with a slice of orange and and smile, while drinking his today. Except for one morning, where he isn't there right away and when he appears, he has blood-covered hands and con...more
"Old City Hall" is breathtakingly good. It's a crisply paced murder-mystery with a satisfying plot and sufficient twists to keep it addictive and infectious to the very end. The novel boasts an intriguing and consistently sympathetic cast of characters, the most colourful and endearing of which is the city of Toronto itself. Rotenberg rounds out the story with historical and cultural background on the city, and behind-the-scenes legal, law enforcement and incarceration insights that add interest...more
"Old City Hall" by Rober Rotenberg, took me a while to read.
It has a good story line about a murder, but the story is not told well enough to hold your attention.
There was only brief discussion on the murder and then it went on about the Police station and investigators until about page 210 then it picked up on the true story line again.
the sexual indentations in the book are rather crude.
When the story finally get around to the person who did the murdering, it was a disappointment in who it wa...more
It has a good story line about a murder, but the story is not told well enough to hold your attention.
There was only brief discussion on the murder and then it went on about the Police station and investigators until about page 210 then it picked up on the true story line again.
the sexual indentations in the book are rather crude.
When the story finally get around to the person who did the murdering, it was a disappointment in who it wa...more
This is a fabulously detailed, realistic and entertaining view of Toronto's criminal justice system, and litigation more generally. Lots of this hit home - notably but not exclusively because the city itself acts almost like a character unto itself. Lots of familiar people (types, atleast), places and personalities in this book for me.
I highly recommend it.
One caveat - the only unbelievable bit is the hockey sub-plot. But I can't blame the author for finding it irresistible! (If you're intereste...more
I highly recommend it.
One caveat - the only unbelievable bit is the hockey sub-plot. But I can't blame the author for finding it irresistible! (If you're intereste...more
This book took me a minute to get into, it is one of those books where each chapter is about a new character so it takes a while to figure out who everyone is. Once I got past that, it was pretty darn good. The female lawyer had a potty mouth, but everyone else was pretty well-behaved. When the book began to unravel and the crime investigation and court case came together, it was really well done. I was thrown for a loop a few times, which I like!! BUT the last 5-6 chapters just got way to twist...more
This is an excellent book. This book was given to me by goodreads and I had not heard of the author so I picked it up and began to read.
The plot is wonderful, many themes going at one time, but not so many that you lose track of what is happening.
You get to know the characters well and enjoy them and their personalities which are all different.
Rotenberg has written a book that will be of interest to any mystery reader.
There are many twists to the plot which keep you hopping and wondering how it...more
The plot is wonderful, many themes going at one time, but not so many that you lose track of what is happening.
You get to know the characters well and enjoy them and their personalities which are all different.
Rotenberg has written a book that will be of interest to any mystery reader.
There are many twists to the plot which keep you hopping and wondering how it...more
It's a celebration of Toronto as much as it is a mystery. Definitely created some nostalgia for me (having lived there most my life and recently moved across country). And the courtroom tactics are accurate, if dramatized. The characters are fun, though a bit two-dimensional. And there are some real implausibilities in the plot. But the plot, assuming you're willing to roll with it, trips along very nicely. I'm not a fan of the genre in particular, but it was a fun read overall. Probably the per...more
An extremely intelligent legal/procedural by a Toronto lawyer turned mystery novelist. When was the last time you found a cast of smart prosecution and defense lawyers and police who would rather get it right than win? There are a few minor baddies but their role is so small, they're just a blip. What fun to have characters who distrust easy, seemingly obvious answers and keep on digging just to make sure they have it right. I do hope he can equal or surpass this on his next time out. If he keep...more
Starts off strong, with lots of Canadian flavor. I liked the way the multiple characters' narratives weaved together in separate chapters, leading you through the plot from different directions. Unfortunately, some mystery conventions took over in the second half, and characters make "Ah ha!" discoveries without sharing them. It's not a puzzle that the reader can figure out, and so you just have to plug along and wait for the reveal, which felt strung out in this case.
Recommended for people who...more
Recommended for people who...more
Rotenberg is a lawyer first, novelist second, and unfortunately it shows in the novel. It's a story about a fictional Canadian radio morning-show host, whose wife is found dead in the bathtub. He confesses to his newspaper delivery man that he killed her, and surrenders to the police. But, despite his confession, the things are not as straight forward as they seem.
Oh, don't worry, I'm not throwing spoilers, this all happens in the first 20 pages of the book. After that, we are introduced to a lo...more
Oh, don't worry, I'm not throwing spoilers, this all happens in the first 20 pages of the book. After that, we are introduced to a lo...more
A well-known radio personality admitted to killing his wife but refuse to talk to his counsel. The detectives assigned to the case discovered the reasons for this after many twists and turns in the investigation. A gripping murder mystery set in Toronto with interesting observations on many of its landmarks, particularly the Old City Hall. Well-written with engaging characterization of the key characters. Reads more like a novel than a mystery replete with ethical decisions and moral choices. A...more
I always enjoy reading mysteries, but I never think to pick them up when I’m looking for new books to try. I love getting a good recommendation for one, though, and when my co-worker Tom (who runs the Whodunit Mystery Book Club at North Regional Library) said his group really liked Robert Rotenberg’s debut novel, Old City Hall, I gladly picked up a copy.
It’s part legal thriller, part murder mystery, and follows the stories of the famous radio personality accused of murdering his wife, the police...more
It’s part legal thriller, part murder mystery, and follows the stories of the famous radio personality accused of murdering his wife, the police...more
Despite a rather shaky start in the legal profession, Robert Rotenberg's background in criminal law explains the perspective of his first novel OLD CITY HALL, most of the the book is being told from either the defence or the prosecution viewpoints.
OLD CITY HALL starts off in a decidedly disarming manner, with polite, proper and very Indian Mr Singh going about his daily job of distributing newspapers which always involves a chat with Mr Kevin in Suite 12A. On this particular morning the door is...more
OLD CITY HALL starts off in a decidedly disarming manner, with polite, proper and very Indian Mr Singh going about his daily job of distributing newspapers which always involves a chat with Mr Kevin in Suite 12A. On this particular morning the door is...more
Author Rotenberg has created a totally intriguing lead character in Det. Greene.
While I chose to read this book because of its setting, and the synopsis that caught my attention, the quality of the writing and the plotting of the story, populated by great characters in familiar locales, kept me totally enthralled and kept me guessing as to the culprit's identity right to the very end.
I happily and whole-heatedly recommend this book! (and I look forward to more Det. Greene adventures!)
While I chose to read this book because of its setting, and the synopsis that caught my attention, the quality of the writing and the plotting of the story, populated by great characters in familiar locales, kept me totally enthralled and kept me guessing as to the culprit's identity right to the very end.
I happily and whole-heatedly recommend this book! (and I look forward to more Det. Greene adventures!)
A great legal thriller. Lots of twists & turns and interesting characters. Fans of John Grisham will really enjoy this book. Set in Toronto, the Canadian author described the setting so well that I feel like taking a trip to Toronto (somewhere I have never been interested in visiting before). As a side note, I also found it interesting comparing the similarities and differences between the Canadian courts and U.S. courts and laws. I look forward to reading future books by Robert Rotenberg.
A very enjoyable read, especially for a Canadian audience. I would recommend this novel to anyone who likes a good cop/lawyer story.
Without taking away from this novel, or revealing any spoilers, I would just like to say that this story's greatest strength is also it's biggest weakness, and that is it's unique writing style. The storyline was negatively impacted every once and a while by the quick glossing over of minor events which affect the entire dynamic of the narrative.
However, this commen...more
Without taking away from this novel, or revealing any spoilers, I would just like to say that this story's greatest strength is also it's biggest weakness, and that is it's unique writing style. The storyline was negatively impacted every once and a while by the quick glossing over of minor events which affect the entire dynamic of the narrative.
However, this commen...more
The setting of this mystery/thriller is Toronto and the author includes a lot of local history and information about the city which I thought really added a lot to the novel. The book begins with profiles of the lawyers and police officers, and a few other folks, then moves into the investigation. The point of view switches among the various investigators so as the book goes on you only know as much about the crime as the investigative team does. Overall I thought this was an effective way to pr...more
Dec 13, 2012
Jina Howell-Forbes
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Crime and courtroom mystery lovers
Recommended to Jina by:
Amazon
Shelves:
canadian-authors,
great-series
This is the first book in Robert Rotenberg's "Ari Greene series. The book is set current day in Toronto Ontario. The novel is a combination of crime solving and the follow-up courtroom drama. The story follows the lives of multiple significant characters with complex relationships to each other. I loved the writing style, the twists and turns of the mystery, the variety of characters, their interactions with each other, and the descriptions of Toronto and Canadian culture.
Engaging. I'm not much of a crime/courtroom buff unless the focus of the book is something broader. This is not To Kill a Mockingbird. Nor is it a Tour Guide to Toronto although sometimes it seems like it's written for American visitors. The characters were well drawn and the overall plan (revolving points of view) was well-handled. In the final chapters I had some difficulty finding motives and actions plausible, but on the whole it hung together and I enjoyed it.
It might have been a nicer rea...more
It might have been a nicer rea...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
After graduating from law school in Toronto, Robert Rotenberg became the managing editor of Passion, the English-speaking magazine of Paris. He then returned to publish and edit his own magazine, T.O. The Magazine of Toronto.Eighteen years ago he opened his own law practice and is today one of Toronto’s top criminal lawyers, defending, as he likes to say “everything from murder to shoplifting.”Rot...more
More about Robert Rotenberg...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...




























This is Andy. I am helping Robert with the online reaction to his book. Thank you so much for this review. I also felt like Toronto cam...more
17 fév. 20:24