41st out of 134 books
—
169 voters
The Song of the Lark (Great Plains trilogy #2)
Perhaps Willa Cather's most autobiographical work, The Song of the Lark charts the story of a young woman's awakening as an artist against the backdrop of the western landscape. Thea Kronborg, an aspiring singer, struggles to escape from the confines her small Colorado town to the world of possibility in the Metropolitan Opera House. In classic Cather style, The Song of th...more
Paperback, 464 pages
Published
May 10th 1983
by Mariner Books
(first published 1915)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This book . . . well, it's the third Cather novel I have read, and I think I like it the least. That said, you can see I still gave it three stars, because just because I like it the least, does not mean that it is not a good novel and well written.
The book follows the life of Thea Kronborg, a Swedish-American who grows up in a small town in Colorado and ends up studying voice in Germany and becoming a famous opera star.
My main complaint is that the beginning of the book was much better than th...more
The book follows the life of Thea Kronborg, a Swedish-American who grows up in a small town in Colorado and ends up studying voice in Germany and becoming a famous opera star.
My main complaint is that the beginning of the book was much better than th...more
I made the mistake of starting this book just as I was entering a week of intense rehearsal and music-learning. So maybe I didn't focus on it as much as I might have if I had had nothing else to do.
I enjoyed this book, but I had hoped there would be more about actual singing (I'm a vocal performance major and aspiring opera singer myself). Cather does have some amazing insights into the production of the voice, but the book is less about singing than about one particular singer, Thea Kronborg,...more
I enjoyed this book, but I had hoped there would be more about actual singing (I'm a vocal performance major and aspiring opera singer myself). Cather does have some amazing insights into the production of the voice, but the book is less about singing than about one particular singer, Thea Kronborg,...more
This was the first Cather I read, and I adored it. Maybe the adult me wouldn't, but the child me did. Maybe it didn't hurt that my mother listened to the Met on the radio every Saturday (though not Wagner, not then...distinctly out of favor)- but I believed every word of this book of a Nebraska girl who grows up to be a famous Wagnerian soprano.
This book is an excellent explanation of what Art is and why it means so much to artists. It also portrays the hardships involved in reaching your full potential. I'm not sure how much of it I agree with, but there was excellent symbolism that illustrated a point without sounding forced or contrived. Cather's descriptions make Thea's world and experiences seem real. This book leaves vivid impressions. It didn't have a happy, gentle plot, but was uplifting in that it describes something worth liv...more
Why did I select this book? I'd never read Cather, and I knew that the plot included opera. Well, now I have, and it does.
The plot - the trajectory of a young girl's life from small-town Colorado to international acclaim as a Wagnerian diva - is almost incidental. The huge Colorado landscape will, one knows, transmute itself into the vistas of Valhalla. The landscape itself will be as much a character as any human being, and will be given a voice more eloquent and true than any human.
In fact, ev...more
The plot - the trajectory of a young girl's life from small-town Colorado to international acclaim as a Wagnerian diva - is almost incidental. The huge Colorado landscape will, one knows, transmute itself into the vistas of Valhalla. The landscape itself will be as much a character as any human being, and will be given a voice more eloquent and true than any human.
In fact, ev...more
In her second and longest novel Cather overreaches a bit; her ambition, which is admirable, is too big for her talent at this stage of her career. The first part of the novel is the best, with its depictions of the memorable characters and influences/restrictions protagonist Thea Kronborg lives with during her childhood in a small desert town in Colorado in the late nineteenth century. But as the novel wears on, depicting Thea's growing talent as a brilliant vocalist and artist, the narrative th...more
I'm having trouble deciding what I want to say about this book. When I don't like books I want to forget about them and move on as quickly as possible. I fell in love with Willa Cather's writing when I read My Antonia last year but this one didn't charm me in the same way. The writing is good, but it's missing.....I don't know, something. Maybe it's just a lack of likable characters.
The main character is Thea Kronberg, a girl growing up in Moonstone, Colorado. She takes music lessons, looks afte...more
The main character is Thea Kronberg, a girl growing up in Moonstone, Colorado. She takes music lessons, looks afte...more
This is a hard book to review. I felt like there were two parts - the first half and the second half and that each part suggested different ideas and themes. The first half, which I liked so much more, was about a curious and intelligent girl growing up honest and interested. She had flare and she seemed to care a great deal about people, the real person and not their circumstance. She was talented, yes, very much so, but she worked hard practicing four hours a day and she cared about her influe...more
This was Cather's second novel, much longer than the first; I loved the first two-thirds of it, but after that was disappointed. It's a portrait of an artist, a most unusual artist, who grew up in a small town with a preacher father and was never exposed to art except for the singing in the church. But she had an artistic temperament and real ability, and one thing after another led her to eventually become a famous opera singer. The stories of Thea when she was young, and during the time when s...more
Cather is one of my very favorite authors, but this book was tedious to read at times.
The thing that impressed me the most from this reading was the depiction of different relationships. I admired Thea and Doctor Archie’s life-long friendship. She says to him, “There are a great many ways of caring for people. It’s not, after all, a simple state, like measles or tonsillitis.”
There is the contrast of Doctor Archie’s marriage with that of Thea’s parents. “If wiving went badly with a man—and it d...more
The thing that impressed me the most from this reading was the depiction of different relationships. I admired Thea and Doctor Archie’s life-long friendship. She says to him, “There are a great many ways of caring for people. It’s not, after all, a simple state, like measles or tonsillitis.”
There is the contrast of Doctor Archie’s marriage with that of Thea’s parents. “If wiving went badly with a man—and it d...more
Jul 24, 2012
Lauren
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fiction,
american-classic
The Song of the Lark starts off by painting a beautifully detailed portrait of the heroine Thea's childhood in the Colorado town of Moonstone. This portion of the book is autobiographical, drawn from Willa Cather's own childhood in Red Cloud, Nebraska. Cather's characters are described in loving detail along with the unique landscape of the Colorado desert.
When Thea is a young woman, she moves to Chicago to study music with the pianist Harsanyi, and there meets a young businessman, Fred Ottenbur...more
When Thea is a young woman, she moves to Chicago to study music with the pianist Harsanyi, and there meets a young businessman, Fred Ottenbur...more
From Colorado to Chicago to Arizona to Germany to New York, this is a leisurely book that contemplates the nature of the artist. I was interested but it was also a bit of a trudge to get through—explanatory in a way that now feels put on but probably felt authentic at the time. The construction is a classic one but peopled with relatively unconventional characters. And Cather, unlike her heroine, is very observant of people and types and her characters are consistently flawed, blind, arrogant an...more
This book is so rich I don't know where to begin. From the wonderful landscapes she so intimately describes -- places I had never heard of, Panther Canyon which in real life is Walnut Canyon in Arizona, the sand hills of eastern Colorado -- to the small town railroad culture of late 1800's Colorado, to the dear players in Thea Kronberg's life, to her inner life so deeply fulfilled by these influences -- this is a story of the development of an artist from childhood. It also feels like a series o...more
Willa Cather is wonderful at evoking the feeling of the Plains. I can feel the heat of the summer in my face and the cold of the winter on my back when I read her writings. This particular book beautifully captures the struggles of an artist growing up in a society that doesn't understand her talents. I recommend it to all young artists. You won't feel alone anymore.
My favorite Cather book. Even though a lot of people complain about the last chapter (and granted, it's not the strongest part of the novel), the whole thing is such a believable, inspiring, attentively detailed account of how a girl from the middle of nowhere follows her passion for music throughout years of difficult circumstances and eventually becomes an opera star.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
A great book to read on a camping vacation. It's an amazingly complex, richly-charactered, and never predictable story that was quite delightful to read. Plus, Thea! What a name, what a girl. Very much about the pioneer spirit as it intersects with the struggle to become an artist. The vagueness of language about artistry and what it means to be an artist felt a little bit repetitive and wasn't particularly moving to me toward the end, but I have a feeling that would have only made the book more...more
I don't have very many books on my "to buy/own" list; this one definitely makes the cut.
Descriptive, painful, poignant, moving, insightful - Cather is an extremely talented writer and I look forward to reading more of her work.
Two quotes that really hit home with me:
"He knew that he was still hunting for something. He knew that this was an unbecoming and ungrateful state of mind, and he reproached himself for it. But he could not help wondering why it was that life, even when it gave so much, af...more
Descriptive, painful, poignant, moving, insightful - Cather is an extremely talented writer and I look forward to reading more of her work.
Two quotes that really hit home with me:
"He knew that he was still hunting for something. He knew that this was an unbecoming and ungrateful state of mind, and he reproached himself for it. But he could not help wondering why it was that life, even when it gave so much, af...more
I did not enjoy this book although I kept slogging through to the end, some 600-plus long pages. It is the story of an early nineteenth century girl from the Amerian mid-west who becomes a famous opera singer. I understand that this novel is considered a significant work of literature but I think Cather could have used a good editor among other things. Description heavy and repetitious. Cather uses such strange turns of phrase that I kept wondering if English was her first language. Has the lang...more
Jan 15, 2008
Summer
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
people with big dreams living in small towns, or any constricting environment
This is a gorgeous book, one of my all-time favorites. I've read it twice and taken from it numerous inspiring quotes that guide my life. "But if you decide what it is you want most, you can get it. Not everybody can, but you can. Only, if you want a big dream, you've got to have nerve enough to cut out all that's easy, everything that's to be had cheap."
I've now read six Cather books, and I probably liked this the least. It seemed to meander too much and had too many unnecessary details. I gather Cather edited down the book for later publication, but that edition would still be under copyright, and I'm kindle-bound.
The book started out quite well, making me feel like it might rank up there with O Pioneers! or My Antonia as most awesome books by Cather. The early parts deal with the life of an independent girl in a small town in southeast Colora...more
The book started out quite well, making me feel like it might rank up there with O Pioneers! or My Antonia as most awesome books by Cather. The early parts deal with the life of an independent girl in a small town in southeast Colora...more
Magical. Stunning. A profound literary masterpiece!! I went to a live stream (at the movie theater) of Wagner's Parsifal, Opera, largely in part because of this book and Dr. Heckerl's recommendation (the professor who taught the class I read this for)... in fact, he was in attendance also. 6 hours of enchanting music!!
BUT I DIGRESS... Like Wagner's Opera, this book itself is enchanting. It is in its ability to convey the glory of artistic beauty through mere words that strikes me. Any artist can...more
BUT I DIGRESS... Like Wagner's Opera, this book itself is enchanting. It is in its ability to convey the glory of artistic beauty through mere words that strikes me. Any artist can...more
Willa Cather's "The Song of the Lark" is an often brilliant, reflective, fierce story that gets deep inside the heart and mind of a rare artist who has deep wells of passion and spirit and frightening, confusing vulnerability. But, it's also a big disappointment. For 300 pages it is absolutely compelling with a stunning, singular heroine at its center, one for whom I deeply cared. The childhood development of this fierce artist, her move to Chicago (where there are some of the best, most vivid C...more
Apr 06, 2013
Joanne
rated it
1 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fiction,
didn-t-finish
Book group decided to do a Willa Cather week, and Song of the Lark was the only one I hadn't read back when I was plowing through Great Books before college. This one is about Thea, who's from a huge family in the middle of nowhere and has great musical talent. The town doctor (whose interest in her, especially her child's body in the beginning, is definitely creepy) sponsors her training.
Cather's pace is slow.
Slow.
Slow.
I'd forgotten that. She has some nice turn of phrases, as when the mother is...more
Cather's pace is slow.
Slow.
Slow.
I'd forgotten that. She has some nice turn of phrases, as when the mother is...more
Cather’s The Song of the Lark is an exquisite novel documenting the journey of a young artist, Thea Kronborg. She is gifted child whose pioneer Swedish parents’ encourage her to take music lessons. Her first music teacher Professor Wunsch discovers her talent. Although her aptitude in the piano is exception, her voice is a mark of genius. Even as a young girl, she impresses many people in a small town, Moonstone, Colorado. Her chief admirers are Ray Kenndy ( a railroad engineer) and Dr Archie, a...more
I was surprised when I read it that people hadn't told me about Willa Cather.
Why hadn't I heard of her in my excellent liberal arts training in high school? Why weren't people discussing her on public radio? Why were there no small art films, starring Helena Bonham Carter, based on her stories?
Song of the Lark is beautiful.
I tabbed the pages often, so I could remember, go back to, a turn of phrase, a way of seeing things that was true, clear, clean.
Her storytelling is vivid yet laconic, it's...more
Why hadn't I heard of her in my excellent liberal arts training in high school? Why weren't people discussing her on public radio? Why were there no small art films, starring Helena Bonham Carter, based on her stories?
Song of the Lark is beautiful.
I tabbed the pages often, so I could remember, go back to, a turn of phrase, a way of seeing things that was true, clear, clean.
Her storytelling is vivid yet laconic, it's...more
Since I have read My Antonia several times and Willa Cather is a Nebraska author, I have always meant to read more of her work. Charity nudged me to tackle this one. Definitely an American novel, the very land infuses Thea with the desire to live her life on her own terms and reach for her dream of perfection in herself and her art. It made me stop and reflect that I have always had a certain pride in my own mediocrity. It's really the only thing I'm very good at:) This novel makes me rethink my...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Wilella Sibert Cather is an eminent author from the United States. She is perhaps best known for her depictions of U.S. life in novels such as O Pioneers!, My Ántonia, and Death Comes for the Archbishop.
More about Willa Cather...
Share This Book
3 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“There are some things you learn best in calm, and some in storm.”
—
1,421 people liked it
“The world is little, people are little, human life is little. There is only one big thing — desire.”
—
1,362 people liked it
More quotes…






































Please use this...more
Jul 24, 2010 11:32am