Skeleton Man (Navajo Mysteries #17)
In 1956, an airplane crash left the remains of 172 passengers scattered among the majestic cliffs of the Grand Canyon - including an arm attached to a briefcase containing a fortune in gems. Half a century later, one of the missing diamonds has reappeared... and the wolves are on the scent.
Former Navajo Tribal Police Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn is coming out of retirement to h...more
Former Navajo Tribal Police Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn is coming out of retirement to h...more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published
January 31st 2006
by HarperTorch
(first published 2004)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This mystery is straightforward and pretty much predictable. I found the author kept repeating himself each time he introduced a new character and after hearing the story of the diamonds three or four times it takes a toll. This is the first novel I have read by this author and I was totally disappointed with it.
Jul 29, 2008
Susan
rated it
2 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Hillerman fans or fans of the series
Recommended to Susan by:
castoff from spouse's "done reading" shelf
Shelves:
tradeable
Interesting idea but honestly so short that with some editing it could almost have been a short story. Just winding down the series with the old retired Navajo police Lt Joe Leaphorn now marginally involved in the goings-on, and mostly by phone.
This could have been so much more but perhaps readers of this series of books aren't interested in having a fine portrait painted of character and locale nor details of landscape. Perhaps they've read it all before. Standing on its own without the backgr...more
This could have been so much more but perhaps readers of this series of books aren't interested in having a fine portrait painted of character and locale nor details of landscape. Perhaps they've read it all before. Standing on its own without the backgr...more
There are a lot of things to like about this book, which is my first Hillerman experience, but I think my favorites were the characters. This is not the first book in the series, and I was a little confused for the first couple of pages, but it didn’t take long for me to warm to the very human characters and feel like I was right there with them.
In the ‘50s, two planes collided over the Grand Canyon, killing everyone on board and sending a rain of debris and body parts over the canyon. It was th...more
In the ‘50s, two planes collided over the Grand Canyon, killing everyone on board and sending a rain of debris and body parts over the canyon. It was th...more
In Skeleton Man, a Navajo man is accused of stealing and pawning a large diamond. Sargent Jim Chee, Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn (ret.) and Chee’s fiancé Bernie Manuelito work together on this case, and find that the diamond is connected to a plane crash that took place in the Grand Canyon area fifty years ago. A diamond dealer, who died in that plane crash, had a case of diamonds handcuffed to his wrist at the time. His body was never found but someone had seen a severed arm with the case attached t...more
I recently returned from a week of hiking in Zion National Park and Bryce Canyon, in the Southeast corner of Utah. This area, which also encompasses the Grand Canyon of Arizona, has one of the most unique natural architectures you’ll encounter anywhere in the world, where wind and water have carved the mountains into deep, sensual caverns and odd desert statues called hoodoos.
I got stuck at the Zion Lodge for a few hours while waiting for my fellow hikers and ducked into the gift shop in search...more
I got stuck at the Zion Lodge for a few hours while waiting for my fellow hikers and ducked into the gift shop in search...more
Whether you like a book or not depends on why you read it. I've always loved Tony Hillerman's descriptions of the Southwest, and accordingly I have an unfulfilled desire to go there someday. His descriptions of the people and the characters are intriguing and the steady evolution of Jim Chee's relationships and Joe Leaphorn's retirement are satisfying.
Having said all that I got really stuck on some elements of the plot. I loved his descriptions of the Grand Canyon, but I've been there. The Gra...more
Having said all that I got really stuck on some elements of the plot. I loved his descriptions of the Grand Canyon, but I've been there. The Gra...more
This was a selection of the month from my local book group. While I enjoyed it, I have read many of Tony Hillerman's books and would consider this one very average. Joe Leaphorn, a primary character in earlier books is now retired, but makes a cameo/walk-on appearance in this book, playing no significant part in advancing the plot.
The plot revolves around a true-life plane crash over the Grand Canyon. The crash, which resulted in two planes and all passengers falling from the sky, happened in 19...more
The plot revolves around a true-life plane crash over the Grand Canyon. The crash, which resulted in two planes and all passengers falling from the sky, happened in 19...more
Story’s root is an actual In 1956, an airplane crash over the Grand Canyon that left the remains of 172 passengers scattered about the Grand Canyon. In this story, one of the remains is and arm cuffed to a briefcase holding a huge fortune in diamonds. Half a century later, one of the missing diamonds reappears. Then it gets interesting as those far away from the Southwest are after the prize and will stop at nothing to recover the rest of the gems and what is left of the severed arm. Former Nava...more
The following elements are involved in this book: a severed limb, a diamond heist, a mid-air collision between two airplanes, and a mummified corpse.
Wouldn’t you think at least ONE of those would be exciting on some level?
If you’re human, you would. And Mr. Hillerman would owe you an apology. Probably even an apology involving baked goods. An apolo-cake. An aPielogy. At least that way you would walk away with SOMETHING.
There were two female characters in this book that I didn’t even realize were...more
Wouldn’t you think at least ONE of those would be exciting on some level?
If you’re human, you would. And Mr. Hillerman would owe you an apology. Probably even an apology involving baked goods. An apolo-cake. An aPielogy. At least that way you would walk away with SOMETHING.
There were two female characters in this book that I didn’t even realize were...more
It's getting harder and harder to find a Tony Hillerman novel I haven't read, so running across this one was a real treat.
The story begins with a plane crash over the Grand Canyon in 1956 ... and ties into a modern-day case in which Cowboy Dashee's mentally disabled cousin Billy tries to pawn an enormous diamond for $20. The diamond is one listed as missing from the plane crash, and so Billy is hauled in to jail for theft.
There are, of course, even more complications. Retired police lieutenant J...more
The story begins with a plane crash over the Grand Canyon in 1956 ... and ties into a modern-day case in which Cowboy Dashee's mentally disabled cousin Billy tries to pawn an enormous diamond for $20. The diamond is one listed as missing from the plane crash, and so Billy is hauled in to jail for theft.
There are, of course, even more complications. Retired police lieutenant J...more
CD/unabridged: Book 17 of the Joe Leaphorn & Jimmy Chee series. I've listened to two other books by Hillerman and he is a very good story teller. This one was written about four years before Hillerman's passing and is short. I was surprised to see that it was unabridged and only six discs.
In this one Leaphorn, retired, recounts the story of an airplane that crashed in to another and fell to the Grand Canyon while trying to prove the innocence of a simple man. I like it because I learned som...more
In this one Leaphorn, retired, recounts the story of an airplane that crashed in to another and fell to the Grand Canyon while trying to prove the innocence of a simple man. I like it because I learned som...more
Ok – first of all I have to admit that pop mysteries are not my cup of tea. Someone left this book with me and I decided to pick it up on a whim. With that said, I’m afraid to say that Skeleton Man did nothing to dispel my distain for the genre.
The plot was ridiculous, the characters were wooden, the description of the Grand Canyon was inaccurate, yet these details were not the ones that chafed. The thing I found most annoying, oddly enough, was the absurdly redundant presentation of the plot....more
The plot was ridiculous, the characters were wooden, the description of the Grand Canyon was inaccurate, yet these details were not the ones that chafed. The thing I found most annoying, oddly enough, was the absurdly redundant presentation of the plot....more
I resolved some time ago to read all of the Tony Hillerman mysteries, and I've gotten to the next to last one; this one was a good one. It centers on an actual event (which I vaguely remember): two commercial airliners collided over the Grand Canyon, apparently dumping a bunch of stuff into the canyon. Hillerman created a fanciful plot out of that, about a man who was on one of the airplanes with a cache of valuable diamonds, a shaman in the canyon recovered the diamonds and began handing them o...more
Hillerman, whose crime fiction bespeaks of Native Americans' rich history, once again mines the Southwest for a story that intricately links tribal mysticism, desert landscapes, and contemporary culture. Devoted readers will find the usual mix of compelling characters, including a Paiute mystic, a Hopi, and the Skeleton Man (the Death Kachina, whose myth Hillerman brings up to date). Though Hillerman is a first-class storyteller, critics agree Skeleton Man is not his best. Leaphorn (he is, after
...more
Navajo County Deputy Sheriff Cowboy Dashee’s cousin is accused of pilfering and pawning a hefty diamond. Sargent Jim Chee, Lieutenant Joe Leaphorn (ret.) and Chee’s fiancée, Bernie Manuelito, work together on this case, and prove that the diamond is connected to a plane crash that took place in the Grand Canyon area fifty years ago. Leaphorn was the narrator of this story and he did not play a large role in the story line itself however, he visited his old friend, McGinnis, at the trading post w...more
This mystery is one of Hillerman’s collection of mysteries set in the Navaho/Hopi lands of Arizona/New Mexico/Utah. One side benefit of reading this stories is what the reader learns about historical and contemporary Hope and Navaho culture. Hillerman has created two attractive sleuths, former fabled Navaho tribal policeman Joe Leaphorn and current policeman and apprentice “medicine man”/ shaman Jim Chee. This novel features both protagonists. The mystery involves a past airline crash, mysteriou...more
Welche Erleichterung nach den eher faden "Dunklen Kanälen" - der Mann kann noch schreiben! Das Rätsel im Skelett-Mann entwickelt sich um 2 vor langer Zeit abgestürzte Flugzeuge (Pluspunkt!), windet sich quer durch und um die Traditionen von Navajos und Hopis (+ 2 Punkte) und spart nicht an ausführlichen Naturbeschreibungen (bei mir auch ein Pluspunkt). Vielleicht hätte man die Geschichte auch auf 50 Seiten weniger erzählen können, aber die Wiederholungen können gut auch als Unterstreichung des S...more
This book is set in the Grand Canyon, which is tough to beat as a fascinating environment. Like "The Wailing Wind," the plot in this book contained a few elements that were altogether too convenient. Also, the villains seemed somewhat two-dimensional and melodramatic, which made me miss the complex and multi-faceted villains of "Skinwalkers" and "Dance Hall of the Dead." Finally, the author kept explaining the basic plot over and over and over again. Each time he introduced a new character, some...more
I gave it four stars not so much as the book by itself deserved it but that it's the best Tony Hillerman I've ever read bar none.
Some people might like all the folklore and traditions, dances and singers and all stuff Navajo. I don't! This book has little to none of that and it moved right along without a hitch. Not many characters, of course Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee. But the other charaters were interesting and it was a well thought out mystery, who dunnit kind of thing. And at 240 pages it...more
My grandma had been bugging me to read the Tony Hillerman books for awhile and I found this one in a Reader's Digest. It started off kind of slow, got good, and then got a little bit predictable. It's written in an older style and when I'm in the mood for that type of book I like it. I liked reading about another culture though, that was particularly interesting. This one specifically was about a guy who had some diamonds in the Grand Canyon - they had fallen out of a plane when it had collided...more
Oct 22, 2012
David
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Dead men, diamond hunters, determined Hillerman fans
Tony Hillerman used to be one of my favorite authors, but he did that thing a lot of authors do with long-running series: said he was done writing Leaphorn/Chee mysteries, but then kept writing them. After the stinker that was The Sinister Pig, I was almost afraid to read Skeleton Man, since it's the next to last book Hillerman wrote before he died, and I'd rather remember Hillerman in his glory days, when Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee were still fresh and sharp and coming at their Navajo ways from...more
So, in two days I've read two of Tony Hillerman's books - this one and . Years ago I loved reading Tony Hillerman and found his descriptions of the southwest added tremendously to his work. Both of these books did not have the suspense about "who did it" or why as previous books. Also, there seemed to be less of the southwest portrayed. I like knowing what has happened to all of the characters over time though.
An okay way to pass some time, but nothing to highly recommend. A little tighter than some other of his recent mysteries, but nothing like the first Leaphorn/Chee mysteries. As others have said, the native American culture is no longer central to his plots, only background color. I wish he had stayed more with Leaphorn's handling of his retirement which seemed central at the beginning, but simply disappeared as the book wore on
for light reading hillerman is one of my favorites. not only are his mysteries enticing, his descriptions of the southwest and the native american cultures he writes about are fascinating. although i haven't read all his books i think i would totally recommend any of them. they are in order, but the stories are all self-contained so it really isn't necessary to read them in order. these are just sit back and enjoy books.
It's one the best Tony Hillerman I've ever read before. This book has very little to do with the Indian Lore and traditions that a lot of the other Hillerman books have, and it moved right along without a hitch. Not too many characters either, of course except Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee. But the other charaters were interesting and it was a well thought out mystery, who dunnit kind of thing. And at 240 pages it was just right.
This was a fun quick mystery read that I picked up at my family reunion last week. It gives insights into the Native American cultures and some of their beliefs throughout.
My only hangup was that I was just confused...in the beginning there are a few different diamonds and back-stories going on and I got them mixed up. You will probably be smarter than me and be able to keep them straight.
My only hangup was that I was just confused...in the beginning there are a few different diamonds and back-stories going on and I got them mixed up. You will probably be smarter than me and be able to keep them straight.
Classic Hillerman. Navajo, Hopi, and white culture collide in the search for diamonds and the remains of John Clark from a 1950s plane crash in the Grand Canyon. Sgt. Jim Chee teams up with his fiancée, Bernie Manuelito, and Deputy Cowboy Dashee to solve a murder case involving Cowboy's cousin, Billy Tuve. Finding the missing diamonds could prove Tuve's innocence.
John Clark's out-of-wedlock daughter, Joanna Craig joins the search hoping to find her father's remains to prove that she is the legit...more
John Clark's out-of-wedlock daughter, Joanna Craig joins the search hoping to find her father's remains to prove that she is the legit...more
Not normally a book I would pick up and read. I was required to read this book for a freshman writing course in college. I was one of the few in the class that I think actually read it and enjoyed it! Very interesting combination of all the characters lives and stories. Good mystery book. I would definately consider reading more of Tony Hillerman's books!
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Tony Hillerman, who was born in Sacred Heart, Oklahoma, was a decorated combat veteran from World War II, serving as a mortarman in the 103rd Infantry Division and earning the Silver Star, the Bronze Star, and a Purple Heart. Later, he worked as a journalist from 1948 to 1962. Then he earned a Masters degree and taught journalism from 1966 to 1987 at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, wh...more
More about Tony Hillerman...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...










view all 4 comments


















