6th out of 80 books
—
31 voters
The Song of Troy
The Song of Troy As urgent and passionate as if told for the first time, the narrative is passed from one character to another: Priam, King of Troy, doomed to make the wrong decisions for the right reasons; the Greek princess Helen, a self-indulgent beauty who deserts her boring husband for the sake of an equally self-indulgent beauty, the Trojan prince Paris; the haunted...more
Paperback, 483 pages
Published
January 7th 1999
by Orion Paperbacks
(first published January 1st 1998)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,490)
Feb 13, 2008
Mariana
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Anyone who is interested in the story of the Trojan War - a must read!
Song of Troy is, probably, the best recollection of the Trojan War I've read so far. Colleen McCullough, with her stupend writing and style, presents us with this book on a well-known subject which, nevertheless, manages to keep the reader's interest from first page to last.
Colleen masterfully lays down the story of the most famous war of the ancient world, all the while bringing a new scope to the narrative, as each chapter is written through the eyes of a different character: the beautiful, bu...more
Colleen masterfully lays down the story of the most famous war of the ancient world, all the while bringing a new scope to the narrative, as each chapter is written through the eyes of a different character: the beautiful, bu...more
I think I liked the idea of this book more than I liked the book itself. Getting inside the story of Troy? Sounds great! And in some ways it was. There were parts that were interesting.
The problem is, that the characters just didn't come alive to me. It's always annoying when you have your character do the explaining for you, because nobody does that naturally. I'm not sitting here wearing woollen socks thinking: "she knew that in some cultures woollen socks weren't as common as in Finland. Smil...more
The problem is, that the characters just didn't come alive to me. It's always annoying when you have your character do the explaining for you, because nobody does that naturally. I'm not sitting here wearing woollen socks thinking: "she knew that in some cultures woollen socks weren't as common as in Finland. Smil...more
Colleen McCullough gives us a modern retelling of the ancient story, which on the surface is about war but really is about what makes us human – valor, love, loyalty, pride, leadership and deceit.
McCullough’s pacing is great; the action moves along so quickly it’s hard to find a place to put the book down. She starts off 30 years before the war to set up the story and characters. This is in my opinion the strongest part of the book, perhaps because the author’s strengths seem to be historical re...more
McCullough’s pacing is great; the action moves along so quickly it’s hard to find a place to put the book down. She starts off 30 years before the war to set up the story and characters. This is in my opinion the strongest part of the book, perhaps because the author’s strengths seem to be historical re...more
This is the kind of historical fiction that I love to read. I've always had a passing interest in mythology, but sometimes it can be so dry! "So & So, son of Such & Such, did A, B, C, & D, had son Whatchamacallit with Whatshername who was the daughter of Whosthatguyagain?..." That's one of the reasons I've put off reading the Bible. Too many begats.
But McCullough manages to work all of the necessary begats in, while at the same time still moving the story along, and further making y...more
But McCullough manages to work all of the necessary begats in, while at the same time still moving the story along, and further making y...more
There is no group of characters I am more enamoured with in mythology, legend, and history than those of the Trojan and Greek forces whose legend centers around the action on the plains of Troy. I appreciated that Colleen McCullough tried to show me each of their unique perspective as the years crawled on. And while this book is not perfect (but what is?) and there are many things I question, I liked reading it. I looked forward to ,reading another chapter, even though I know everything that hap...more
I have two favourite stories set in Troy, and this one seems a nice choice for my First Book. The war comes to life, the characters step out of Homer and breathe - the good, the bad, and the slightly derranged - and Odyseus is my kind of hero, just a guy who wants to get the job done properly and go home.
Colleen McCullough vuelve a mostrar su dominio de la ficción histórica acercándonos esta vez a la guerra que tanto influyó en la literatura occidental. Los personajes se nos muestran cercanos, con sus dudas y flaquezas, narrándonos algunos en primera persona momentos clave de la misma historia. Helena, Aquiles, Ulises, Príamo, Héctor, y tantos, tantos iconos de la Grecia Clásica. La narración hace que la historia nos parezca verosímil, intentando unir la mitología con las realidades descubiertas...more
Dec 05, 2007
Bookish
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
anyone who loves a good story about troy
Shelves:
goodreads
wow! what a great book! this author continues to dazzle me - she has always been one of my favorites! the way this story is told is unique - each "chapter" told by a different character and it all blends in beautifully! i didn't think i'd like this approach but it worked and well!
I...I don't know what to think of this book. I started reading it thinking that I would either love, or hate it, but it turns out that I was wrong.
This was one of the most frustrating books I've ever read. On one hand, there are stuff here that I really like, for example, the story is very well written and it flows nicely, I can tell that Collen McCullough has a deep respect for the Trojan War legendarium, and there are part that are really engaging and interesting.
On the other hand, there is...more
This was one of the most frustrating books I've ever read. On one hand, there are stuff here that I really like, for example, the story is very well written and it flows nicely, I can tell that Collen McCullough has a deep respect for the Trojan War legendarium, and there are part that are really engaging and interesting.
On the other hand, there is...more
the story of the Trojan war told in a manner more akin to today`s readers. so if you don`t have the stomach for The Iliad this could act as a nice substitute.
it is epic in scope (as it should be) beggining with the young years of the many important characters, and then after many stories set them off to the war. the war in itself is also long and with many tribulations but this is not a complaint, since the book delivers what the movie failed to.
also of interest you should see that each chapter...more
it is epic in scope (as it should be) beggining with the young years of the many important characters, and then after many stories set them off to the war. the war in itself is also long and with many tribulations but this is not a complaint, since the book delivers what the movie failed to.
also of interest you should see that each chapter...more
I had to order this from Amazon UK as it has not been published in the US; it was worth every penny & after reading the paperback I ordered the hardback version so I could loan the paperback. This is more approachable than the Odyssey and Iliad, bringing to life the stories of Greek heroes & villains other than just Achilles & Hector, Odysseus & Agamemnon, and fleshes out the the women as well: Helen, Iphigenia, Clytemnestra, Cassandra and more. I would recommend this to anyone w...more
I really really liked this books but there were some points which prevented me from giving it 5 stars.
1) Not everyone can pull off first person narrative. She had many characters telling the story but it seemed liked it was one person just every chapter he called himself different.
2) lack of development in relationships. It just states: a loves b, b is the father of c and so on.
3) Briseis, Achilles, Patroclos triangle. So clished, of cource on person had to be the jelous one, the other — noble o...more
1) Not everyone can pull off first person narrative. She had many characters telling the story but it seemed liked it was one person just every chapter he called himself different.
2) lack of development in relationships. It just states: a loves b, b is the father of c and so on.
3) Briseis, Achilles, Patroclos triangle. So clished, of cource on person had to be the jelous one, the other — noble o...more
This is the story of the Iliad, retold by Colleen McCulough, one of the big and most meticulous historical fiction writers around.
However, this book fails to live up the the usual McCulough expectations. Her research is meticulous, as usual; she's clearly read the Iliad, dug into the history of ancient Greece, etc', but somehow, unlike in her vast and significantly superior Masters of Rome series, she fails to engage.
Her problems in this book are threefold:
She strikes a poor balance between revi...more
However, this book fails to live up the the usual McCulough expectations. Her research is meticulous, as usual; she's clearly read the Iliad, dug into the history of ancient Greece, etc', but somehow, unlike in her vast and significantly superior Masters of Rome series, she fails to engage.
Her problems in this book are threefold:
She strikes a poor balance between revi...more
I was moved to tears by this book, and felt ridiculous shedding them. I knew who would live and die, and exactly how it all turned out. That's McCullough's genius, though. She gives us all the little details, history books leave out, that make us feel for, and in some instances love, or hate a character. Everyone knows Odysseus was brilliant, but we don't think about how much that brilliance would have cost him. Achilles was brave, but he could have been sweet, kind and fair alongside his ruthle...more
It has been a few years since I read this book, but I do remember that I love this story. I actually happened upon this book by accident and decided it was worth reading after having a quick browse of the first "chapter" - I had never read a book by this author nor did I know a great deal about the Trojan War.
I was sucked in to this tale, and loved reading it from each characters point of view. In fact I have just decided I'm going to pull it from the bookshelf and read it again!!
I was sucked in to this tale, and loved reading it from each characters point of view. In fact I have just decided I'm going to pull it from the bookshelf and read it again!!
This concentrated more on the fighting and wars than I thought that it would when I picked it up. I thought that it would look more into the relationships e.g. the Helen situation. This was mentioned but I thought that there would be more of a love story behind it. I might not have picked it up if I knew how much was going to be about fighting. Even so, it was nice to learn about many of the stories that I heard brief bits about and get to know more about them. It made me realise more about the...more
Greatly enjoyed this novel!
Being a hardcore fan of McCullough already, I've expected much and, surprisingly, I got more.
As expected she once again succeeded in bringing to life a very ancient, and mainly forgotten, world of a legend, but she did more than this for me with the ever-changing, first-person point of view.
Deserves 5 stars in my opinion :)
Being a hardcore fan of McCullough already, I've expected much and, surprisingly, I got more.
As expected she once again succeeded in bringing to life a very ancient, and mainly forgotten, world of a legend, but she did more than this for me with the ever-changing, first-person point of view.
Deserves 5 stars in my opinion :)
Jul 27, 2011
Mel
added it
I really enjoyed the vibrancy of the characters. I loved how the war and the lead-up to it was narrated by different characters. It really gave you a well-rounded view of what was going on. However, the last 100 pages dragged by for me. I knew the Trojan horse was coming and I was impatient for it to arrive and the war to end. Other than those 100 pages, the rest of the book was intriguing and kept me turning the pages.
This is an amazing book that follows the story of The Iliad, only this time told from the points of view of those who "lived" it. The book adds humanity to those characters we associate with The Iliad: Helen, Paris, Achilles, Odysseus, among others, which makes this a much more modern telling of the Trojan war story. I definitely recommend it.
Aug 06, 2011
Laura Christoffersen
added it
A very good book. Gives a great historical aspect to the Trojan War. Very, very well written and as usual with this author, both gripping, intelligent and interesting!
Più che una versione in prosa dell'Iliade, Il canto di Troia è una sorta di enorme calderone in cui l'autrice riversa una marea di fonti diverse, creandone una sua personale rilettura (perciò, se pensate di trovare attenta fedeltà al testo di Omero, cambiate libro).
La storia è scorrevole, fatta apposta per lasciare che il lettore si appassioni ai personaggi e viva con loro le vicende di cui sono protagonisti, ma alla fin fine non lascia nulla di più di un qualsiasi altro discreto romanzo storico...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Colleen McCullough AO (born 1 June 1937) is an internationally acclaimed Australian author. Colleen was born in Wellington in central west New South Wales to James and Laurie McCullough.
She grew up during World War II. In her first year of medical studies at the University of Sydney she suffered dermatitis from surgical soap and was told to abandon her dreams of becoming a medical doctor. Instead,...more
More about Colleen McCullough...
She grew up during World War II. In her first year of medical studies at the University of Sydney she suffered dermatitis from surgical soap and was told to abandon her dreams of becoming a medical doctor. Instead,...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...










view all 6 comments





























