Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “M Is for Magic” as Want to Read:
M Is for Magic
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

M Is for Magic

by
3.83  ·  Rating Details ·  10,937 Ratings  ·  1,148 Reviews
Stories to delight, enchant, and surprise you.
Bestselling author and master storyteller Neil Gaiman here presents a breathtaking collection of tales that may chill or amuse readers - but always embrace the unexpected. Collection includes:
"The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds,"
"Troll Bridge,"
"Don't Ask Jack,"
"How to Sell the Ponti Bridge,"
"October in the Chair,"
"
...more
Hardcover, 260 pages
Published July 1st 2007 by HarperCollins Publishers (first published January 1st 2007)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jason Koivu
Jul 22, 2014 Jason Koivu rated it liked it
M is for the many things I always hope to get out of reading a Neil Gaiman book. Then the usual happens...

Some of these stories - "Sunbird", "October in the Chair", and "How to Talk to Girls at Parties" - appear in his excellent short story collection Fragile Things, and apparently others also appear elsewhere, mostly Smoke and Mirrors. Add to that, "The Witch's Headstone" is the precursor to The Graveyard Book. So, M is for Magic is really just a repackaging of old material.

That's been a runni
...more
Phrynne
Oct 17, 2015 Phrynne rated it really liked it
I am not a fan of short stories. Once I get my teeth into a good book I want it to go on and on which is why I read a lot of series. However if I am going to read short stories then ones written by one of my favourite authors is the only way to go. This book contains some absolute treasures. A few of the stories use nursery rhymes as their source, a couple are almost science fiction and of course there is a lot of Gaiman's trade mark fantasy. Pure entertainment:)
SomePig
Apr 05, 2009 SomePig rated it really liked it
The problem with assigning a star rating to this book is that, like any book of short stories, it is a mixed bag. Especially considering that this particular book of stories is by Neil Gaiman who can pen novles that are original enough that the only resemblance they bear to one another is the name on the front cover.

What I gather from this book (intended for a YA audience) is that Gaiman allows himself to get more experimental with stories than perhaps with his novel. As always, the writing is s
...more
Наталия Янева
„К като Котка“ любовно, макар и не особено кратко, си я наричах аз заради любопитно душещата въздуха черна котчица на корицата. В този бутиков сборник с разкази Нийл Геймън отваря обковани с желязо и потайно скърцащи врати и оставя на ваша отговорност да прекрачите прага им, защото никога, съвсем никога, не се знае къде точно ще се озовете.

Тези разкази категорично не са (само) за деца. В някои от тях имаше неща, които според мен деца не биха разбрали напълно, а на едно-две места дори аз се посму
...more
P. Aaron Potter
Jan 29, 2013 P. Aaron Potter rated it it was ok
Shelves: fantasy
R is for Recycled.

Seriously, I thought these stories were good enough, many of them, the first THREE times they were published. Five times, in at least one case, and possibly two. But there is not a single new story in this collection, folks. I almost titled this review "R is for Ripoff."

So, no original work. Maybe that would be okay if there were a good theme tying these together.

The problem is the anthology's premise: somebody got to Neil Gaiman and said "hey, you should publish an anthology o
...more
Obsidian
I am kind of annoyed. I had hoped for a nice collection of short stories to sink my teeth into. But instead I ended up skipping over a lot of stories I had previously read in this one. So I ended up only taking a few short hours on this one (I think it took me around 2) to finish up. For the really new to me stories I thought some were just okay, and others didn't make a lick of sense and did not appeal to me. The only really one I enjoyed was "The Price" and that featured a black cat.

For those
...more
Amin
Sep 03, 2014 Amin rated it liked it
این کتاب با این که یک سری داستان های گیمن بود ولی واقعا خوب بود . به خصوص داستان های مرغ خورشید یا داستان ترول . البته داستان های ضعیف تر هم داشت ولی در کل خوب بود .
Eva
Jun 20, 2016 Eva rated it liked it
И 5 звездички за "Цената". Без съмнение е любимият ми разказ от сборника.
Hamster
Nov 05, 2011 Hamster rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Nobody!
I was impressed with Neil Gaiman for doing a great job narrating his own stories. He's one of the few authors that can get away with it. Unfortunately I didn't enjoy the material quite as much. While I've never been a fan of twisted nursery rhymes (translation: I hate them; if you can't come up with original material you shouldn't be writing) Gaiman did a reasonably good job of making the Humpty Dumpty parody palatable (but just). When I got to the completely pointless second story about a troll ...more
Behdad Ahmadi
مجموعه داستان کوتاه، از نویسنده عزیز و کم نظیر انگلیسی، نیل گیمن.

اکثر داستان ها جز یکی دو مورد بیشتر حالت تمرینی داشتن و انگار مشق گیمن بودن برای کارهای بزرگترش که تا به حال خوندیم،
مثل از عروسک نپرس، اکتبر روی صندلی، پرونده چهار و بیست توکای سیاه.

اما این بین آثاری هم بودن که میتونن به عنوان کار های شاخص گیمن باشن. داستان های شگفت انگیزی مثل تاوان و پل ترول.

در داستان چگونه می توان پل پانتی را فروخت، جدا از داستان غیرخاص و دنیایی که ترکیب حس کودکانه و بزرگسالش یه جور طنز عجیب بهش بخشیده بود و یک
...more
Ana Rînceanu
The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds- a detective investigates Humpty Dumpty's death (3 stars)

Troll Bridge- a boy makes a deal with a troll (3 stars)

Don't Ask Jack-a never used, always waiting Jack-in-the-box (2 stars)

How to Sell the Ponti Bridge- a master con (3 stars)

Chivalry- an elderly English lady finds the Holy Grail and gets an unexpected guest (4 stars)

The Price- a lovely homage to black cats everywhere (3 stars)

The Witch's Headstone- a vignette about Bod from The Graveyard Book
...more
Serena.. Sery-ously?
May 27, 2015 Serena.. Sery-ously? rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2015
M is for magic.

N is for Natty-Neil.
G is for Genius-Gaiman.
Andrew
Nov 01, 2014 Andrew rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Four stars to this book, which would have been five with a touch of "black" more pronounced.
Eleven stories, to be exact, in between the fantastic and visionary, bizarre and fascinating.

"The Witch's Headstone": it is a story that also appears in the book "The Graveyard Book". A young man, raised in a graveyard by ghosts, struggling with an adventure that will bring him in contact with the outside world. Enjoyable and exciting.

"Troll Bridge": it is not a story for children and leaves the reader w
...more
Ricardo
Oct 16, 2016 Ricardo rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: own
4 / 5

Algunos en extremo oscuros. Otros un tanto divertidos. Y un par a los que no se le entiende nada. Así de brillantes y locos son los cuentos de esta antología.
JG (The Introverted Reader)
I'm trying out audio (again), this time during my commute to work. My commute isn't bad, about 30 minutes, so a collection of short stories, written and read by Neil Gaiman no less, seemed like a good place to start. I was right!

I'll say first of all that I love Gaiman's voice. I could listen to the man all day. I don't really have any other narrators to compare him to, but just the fact that I actually finished this audio book should be a testament to his greatness!

I've read a lot of these stor
...more
Monique
M Is For Magic is a collection of short stories, including a story lifted from Neil Gaiman's award-winning children's novel, The Graveyard Book. I enjoyed this book immensely.

My personal favorite would be The Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds, a retelling of children's nursery rhymes, but which mainly told of the mystery of who murdered Humpty Dumpty. [Okay, I'll give you just a few seconds here to recite the nursery rhyme to yourself... ;) ] Indeed, the nursery rhyme merely said Humpty Dum
...more
Philip
Jun 16, 2009 Philip rated it it was ok
Clive Barker tells us "Gaiman is a star," but he sure is not shining in this book. Granted, some of the stories are entertaining. I especially liked Sunbird, the tale about the Epicurean club that had sampled every taste imaginable and have nothing left to try. I also thoroughly enjoyed The Witches Headstone which Gaiman introduces as, "...a story that will be part of my next children's book, The Graveyard Book, about a boy who lives in a graveyard and is brought up by dead people..." I imagine ...more
Suad Shamma
Dec 14, 2014 Suad Shamma rated it it was amazing
Shelves: own, 2014
I am usually a little wary around short stories and anthologies etc. But this one, I must say, was one of my favorites! I did not hate any of the stories, but I did love some more than others.

The creativity and genius behind the writing of these stories is what really secured this book right at the top for me. The first story "The Case of Four and Twenty Blackbirds" was my favorite by far! As a detective tries to solve the murder of Humpty Dumpty, the story goes on to involve many more nursery
...more
Niloo Beygi
I read this persian translation of M is for magic by Farzad Farbod and i like 3stories of 9 stories on it:Don't Ask Jack , Chivalry , The Price.

باید بگم بیشتر داستان ها تم بومی ای داشت به خصوص داستان اول که در واقع به نوعی بینامتنی هم بود چون باید1شناخت کامل از داستان آلیس در...می داشتی و اون شخصیت ها و اتفاقات رو خونده بودی که توی این داستان هم بپذیریشن هم بتونی وقایع رو هضم کنی و شعر آخر کتاب. بعضی جاها از داستان های دیگه هم یه رنگ بومی ای داشت که برای ماهایی که خارج از اون فرهنگ هستیم غیرقابل
...more
Rose
DNF. Read up until 38%.

I kept reading in hope for a short story that will impress me or that I'll at least care for or like but I don't have the patience anymore. This should seriously be titled M is for Meh instead of M is for Magic because I just don't see the magic.

This is my second attempt at a Gaiman book (my first being Fortunately, the Milk) and I'm still not impressed. I liked none of the stories, all of them bored me to no end and I just don't have it in me to read on in hope of finding
...more
Luann
On the whole these were nice enough stories - some stranger than others. None of them were incredibly memorable, but none of them were incredibly horrible, either.

My favorite short story in this collection was Chivalry, followed by How to Sell the Ponti Bridge. My least favorite was Sunbird - the one with the Epicurean Club.

I was interested that the first three stories each had a character named Jack. I thought the trend might continue throughout the book, but it didn't.

My favorite part of the
...more
Jim
2.5 stars. This is titled as a homage to Ray Bradbury. The stories were OK, but didn't speak to me the way Bradbury's did. The last one was the best & could have easily become a novella. I wish it had. Instead, the end was rather abrupt & unsatisfying. Some of the stories were quite off the wall & kind of fun.

Gaiman read this himself & his voice is great. Unfortunately whoever equalized the sound didn't have old ears or any noise in mind. When Gaiman's voice dropped low, I could
...more
Magrat Ajostiernos
Es triste que mis tres historias preferidas ya las hubiera leído, dos (El puente del trol y El precio) forman parte de la muchísimo más interesante recopilación de relatos "Humo y espejos", la otra (La lápida de la bruja) es directamente un capítulo "robado" de "El libro del cementerio".
Las demás son entretenidas, pero pocas tienen la magia a la que nos tiene acostumbrados Mr Gaiman.
Knigoqdec
Някои разкази присъстват другаде...
Може би дори всички присъстват другаде, но аз все още не знам това.
Повечето ми допаднаха, някои - не.
За пореден път си мисля, че трябва да опитам поне веднъж с "Алиса в Страната на чудесата". Тогава може би последният разказ ще го видя в много по-хубава светлина. Не я разбирам тази Алиса... макар че и не съм сигурна дали е нужно да я разбираш...
Dan Schwent
Aug 18, 2008 Dan Schwent rated it liked it
Short and to the point: M for Magic is good but all of the stories except for the Graveyard Book excerpt are in other recent Gaiman short story collections. That being said, the selection from the Graveyard Book has me dying to read the rest of it.
Arybo ✨
Il cimitero senza lapidi: 4,5
Il ponte del troll: 4.5
Non chiedetelo a Jack: 3
Come vendere il Ponte dei Ponti: 4.25
Ottobre sulla sedia: 3,5
Cavalleria: 3,5
Il prezzo: 5
Come parlare con le ragazze alle feste: 3
Avis Soleus: 3,5
Il caso dei ventiquattro merli: 2,5

Punteggio totale approssimato per eccesso perché di tratta di Gaiman. :D
X
Oct 15, 2010 X rated it liked it
I was a bit disappointed by this book as I had already read half of the stories in Smoke and Mirrors and The Graveyard Book. It's a nice collection though, and I really liked some of the stories.

Odette
May 07, 2012 Odette rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: x-done-endicott
I read two Gaiman novels in the last 6 months or so & it's interesting to compare his stories to them. I prefer the novels because I usually prefer novels, but two of these stories will stay with me & several others were just plain fun.

4 & 20 Blackbirds, How to Sell the Ponti Bridge & Sunbird reminded me of the kinds of stories that were popular in a creative writing class I took years ago. Kind of gimmicky, humorous, smart & slick. Those stories leave me cold for the same re
...more
Mary
Dec 29, 2011 Mary rated it liked it
Recommends it for: People who like fantasy, short stories, or Neil Gaiman
3.5 Stars

This book's weak point is also its strong point. With so many different stories, of course you will have some gems and then some that feel lacking.I did like quite a few of the stories though.

I didn't like: Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds, How to Talk to Girls at Parties, and How to Sell the Ponti Bridge.
I disliked these for different reasons.
Case of the Four and Twenty Blackbirds seemed like a good idea for a story, but the story itself just bored me.
How to Talk to Girls at P
...more
Kat
Nov 20, 2011 Kat rated it really liked it
This is a volume of previously published Neil Gaiman stories. The premise here is that he picked out some of the stories best suited to a younger audience and put them into a single book that can be put onto a young person's shelf. Thinking back to my younger days, when the picture books just didn't have enough "meat" to them for me anymore, this is EXACTLY the sort of book I would have grabbed. Moreover, it is the sort of book I would have been a favorite, being checked out multiple times over ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
  • City of Time (The Navigator Trilogy, #2)
  • The Faery Reel: Tales from the Twilight Realm
  • Hanging Out with the Dream King
  • The Poison Eaters and Other Stories
  • Voices in the Dark (The Last Descendants, #2)
  • We Never Talk about My Brother
  • Sophie's Secret (Sophie, #2)
  • Samurai (Simon St George #2)
  • The Sea of Adventure (Adventure, #4)
  • Mostly Sunny with a Chance of Storms
  • To the Blight (The Eye of the World, #2)
  • Fiendish Deeds (Joy of Spooking, #1)
  • The Book of Ballads
  • The Sea Fairies
  • Winter Door (The Gateway Trilogy, #2)
  • Le meraviglie del possibile: Antologia della Fantascienza
  • Brimstone and Marmalade
  • The Brimstone Key (Grey Griffins: The Clockwork Chronicles, #1)

Share This Book



“Stories you read when you're the right age never quite leave you. You may forget who wrote them or what the story was called. Sometimes you'll forget precisely what happened, but if a story touches you it will stay with you, haunting the places in your mind that you rarely ever visit.” 2088 likes
“I fell for her like a suicide from a bridge.” 89 likes
More quotes…