The Overspent American: Upscaling, Downshifting, And The New Consumer
An in-depth look at the corruption of the “American Dream,” the follow-up to the the Overworked American examines the consumer lives of Americans and the pitfalls of “keeping up with the Joneses.” Schor explains how and why the purchases of others in our social and professional communities can put pressure on us to spend more than we can afford to, how television viewing c...more
Hardcover, 272 pages
Published
April 26th 1998
by Basic Books
(first published 1998)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,078)
I don't even know where to start on reviewing this book other than to say that every once in awhile I read a book that can completely shake me to the core. I haven't lost this much sleep since my youngest was an infant. I am up at 2 a.m. wondering, "Am I trying to keep up with the Joneses? (my sister incidentally.) Or am I fitting in okay with my reference group, and do I care? If I do care, why? Did I buy designer jeans because of status or just because they feel and look good? Do I think they...more
Do you know what I always seem to buy too much of? Bananas. I am always tossing brown bananas in the trash. But I never slow down my banana purchasing. I think it's because I feel lame buying just one or two bananas. I feel like you need to buy a whole bundle to justify the purchase. I am also afraid I might REALLY want a banana, and there won't be any in my fruit bowl.
1. Our society's constant desire to upgrade everything (cars, homes, furnishings, clothes, etc.) is a relatively new trend.
2. Studies show that we have more than ever, but we aren't any happier than earlier generations.
3. True or false? On average, for every hour people watch tv per week, their annual savings decrease by more than $200.
2. Studies show that we have more than ever, but we aren't any happier than earlier generations.
3. True or false? On average, for every hour people watch tv per week, their annual savings decrease by more than $200.
Three, maybe 4 stars. Some excerpts:
Twenty-seven percent of all households making more than $100,000 a year say they cannot afford to buy everything they really need. Nearly 20 percent say they "spend nearly all their income on the basic necessities of life." - p6
For centuries, aristocrats passed laws to forbid the nouveaux fiches from copying their clothing styles. At the turn of the century, the wealthy published the menus of their dinner parties in the newspapers. And fifty years ago, America...more
Twenty-seven percent of all households making more than $100,000 a year say they cannot afford to buy everything they really need. Nearly 20 percent say they "spend nearly all their income on the basic necessities of life." - p6
For centuries, aristocrats passed laws to forbid the nouveaux fiches from copying their clothing styles. At the turn of the century, the wealthy published the menus of their dinner parties in the newspapers. And fifty years ago, America...more
i really cannot say enough good things about this book. it's well-written, well-researched and incredibly interesting. the most shocking thing to me is that the content is so relevant to today and yet it was written in 1998.
also, it was good timing for me since we just rented 'what would jesus buy,' directed by morgan spurlock, and that film discusses something a little similar in terms of people's shopping habits at christmas - how the spending has spiraled out of control and how americans go i...more
also, it was good timing for me since we just rented 'what would jesus buy,' directed by morgan spurlock, and that film discusses something a little similar in terms of people's shopping habits at christmas - how the spending has spiraled out of control and how americans go i...more
Jul 03, 2007
Hollie
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
people trying to make a budget
Shelves:
whenlivingpaychecktopaycheck
I re-read this book whenever I feel like spending a huge amount of money on things I don't really need. Its an excellent snapshot of lower middle class spending since the 1970's and into the 80's. If you want to read this book, pick up the updated version published in 1998 - this one is too outdated to be helpful much longer. This book reminds me of the power of advertising and envy.
As good as this book is, it’s outdated. The most recent research is about 1998, and a lot has changed in 10 years. It’s a shame that things haven’t been updated, since I think as time goes on the information has only become more relevant.
If it’s good enough to keep in print, why isn’t it good enough to update?
If it’s good enough to keep in print, why isn’t it good enough to update?
From buying stuff we don't need to overextending ourselves on credit, we give Juliet Schor plenty of ammunition for her thesis. Her book has good anecdotes and lively writing, but also is backed by solid research on our spending patterns and the relationship between consumption and happiness (limited, as you might expect)
Meh.
First of all, the edition the library had was published in 1998. It was more than slightly outdated. I think the author genuinely enjoys writing but perhaps a non-fiction book isn't the best place to over use the thesaurus for uncommon words as well as make up words when the thesaurus failed.
The first chapter was a fantastic synopsis of the entire book, rendering the rest of the book to be somewhat redundant. This book seemed to get hung up on the driving force of "keeping up with the Jone...more
First of all, the edition the library had was published in 1998. It was more than slightly outdated. I think the author genuinely enjoys writing but perhaps a non-fiction book isn't the best place to over use the thesaurus for uncommon words as well as make up words when the thesaurus failed.
The first chapter was a fantastic synopsis of the entire book, rendering the rest of the book to be somewhat redundant. This book seemed to get hung up on the driving force of "keeping up with the Jone...more
This book, being published in 1998, was entertaining in the way that I was brought back to my childhood (I was 11 at the time). All the talk about Air Jordans, Ninja Turtles, Osh-Kosh, and MTV gave me a slightly comical sense of nostalgia.
As for the message Schor is sending, as a student of economics, I can't say I haven't heard it all before. Perhaps it is because of this that I was not very captivated by her writing style, which I feel was influenced by a need to drag out certain points just...more
As for the message Schor is sending, as a student of economics, I can't say I haven't heard it all before. Perhaps it is because of this that I was not very captivated by her writing style, which I feel was influenced by a need to drag out certain points just...more
Feb 12, 2008
Kathy Beatty
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
everyone
Recommended to Kathy by:
Mae Boscana
Another life-changing book! I thought that I was "above" being manipulated by corporations. But, I learned that I was not. Read it, you will never impulse buy without thinking again.
May 18, 2009
Connie
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
anyone who spends money
Recommended to Connie by:
book club read
Not a self help book, but helpful nevertheless. It has triggered self intervention on my spending habits which are out of control. I took copious notes and can read them as a Reader's Digest book anytime I need a refresher course. I would not buy the book, however, because the references are somewhat dated--amusing actually to look back of the idols of the past decades.
My children grew up in that difficult era without the funds for the popular clothing; they got the BTS (bangs to the sky) becau...more
My children grew up in that difficult era without the funds for the popular clothing; they got the BTS (bangs to the sky) becau...more
Interesting read although a little dated, 1998 (mentions that some people think the reliance on credit is unsustainable - ya think?). Would be nice to see an update. Am somewhat relieved that I can't identify lipstick brands at any distance. A little patronizing in the explanation of regression models etc. but not written for an academic audience, so nice to see some of the methods used to analyze the data. Interesting commentary on materialism, consumerism, and the pressure to keep up with thos...more
Americans have (literally) "bought into" the work-and-spend lifestyle, and we consequently have given up balance, meaning, time and peace in our lives. We are fooled into believing that we are what we have so we will spend beyond our means to acquire things we don't need or even want. We've allowed ourselves to become envious, selfish, greedy and competitive, and are raising children with an even stronger sense of discontent and entitlement. Bottom line: we need to be more mindful about the life...more
I saw The Story of Stuff about five years ago, and that made a pretty profound impact on the way I spend money.
If I'd read this book five years ago I'm certain it would have had the same effect. Even though it was published in 1998 it's still scarily relevant today—maybe even moreso. In fact, I'd love to hear Juliet Schor's thoughts re: how social media has transformed the way we form our reference groups, as well as the intersection between conspicuous consumption and conspicuous curation. K,...more
If I'd read this book five years ago I'm certain it would have had the same effect. Even though it was published in 1998 it's still scarily relevant today—maybe even moreso. In fact, I'd love to hear Juliet Schor's thoughts re: how social media has transformed the way we form our reference groups, as well as the intersection between conspicuous consumption and conspicuous curation. K,...more
Below are key lessons in the form of excerpts that I found particularly insightful from this book in which Juliet "analyzes the crisis of the American consumer in a culture where spending has become the ultimate social act":
1- "While I believe all Americans are deeply affected by consumerism, this book is directed to people...whose income afford comfortable lifestyle. I focus on more affluent consumers not because I believe that inequalities of consuming power are unimportant. Far from it. They...more
1- "While I believe all Americans are deeply affected by consumerism, this book is directed to people...whose income afford comfortable lifestyle. I focus on more affluent consumers not because I believe that inequalities of consuming power are unimportant. Far from it. They...more
First note: This book was published 15 years ago. Although it's meant to examine the broader social context, and there are a few timeless/relevant observations, 90% of the book describes contemporary social science research. The continual reference to fax machines as a luxury must-have made me lol. Overall, it's too dated for me to recommend to anyone.
Second note: Schor could not decide what kind of book she wanted to write. As mentioned, 90% of the book is descriptive social science research. W...more
Second note: Schor could not decide what kind of book she wanted to write. As mentioned, 90% of the book is descriptive social science research. W...more
Good book. Maybe more like a 3.5. It's wasn't like some other money realization books I've read, but still eye-opening and recommend-worthy. The difference between this book and other money type books was that it went more into the psychology of why we spend. Why we buy the fancy lipstick, but the no name face cleanser (basically, it all comes down to you impressing your friends, your co-workers, the person on the bus who might ask where you got that pretty colored lipstick). While I couldn't re...more
On rereading this book I had to downgrade it from a four-star review to a three. Schor's argument in this book is extremely persuasive, but on close inspection, it's pretty easy -- a little too easy considering she's at Harvard -- to poke some pretty big holes in it.
Schor details the way that Americans have become mired in debt and saddled with things they don't need via upscaling, competitive consumption, and misused credit cards. Yes, this all makes sense, and yes, she is prescient about the c...more
Schor details the way that Americans have become mired in debt and saddled with things they don't need via upscaling, competitive consumption, and misused credit cards. Yes, this all makes sense, and yes, she is prescient about the c...more
This book is really excellent for anyone who cares about consumerism, but find themselves estranged by the harshness or extremeness of Adbusters and other anti-consumerism/anti-corporate books and groups. Schor’s argument is essentially the same, but her method is more explanatory and empirical.
Juliet Schor, Harvard Professor, explores what increases the tendency for people to consume (television, education, neighborhood where they live), focusing mostly on the role of status and the symbolic p...more
Juliet Schor, Harvard Professor, explores what increases the tendency for people to consume (television, education, neighborhood where they live), focusing mostly on the role of status and the symbolic p...more
I find it interesting that this was published 10 years ago. Even so, the material is still relevant. For instance, the concluding chapter poses the question - will consuming less wreck the American economy?
The themes of over consumption, massive credit card bills, and down-shifting and mindless consumption are just as important now. Unfortunately, we didn't learn these lessons 10 years ago.
The themes of over consumption, massive credit card bills, and down-shifting and mindless consumption are just as important now. Unfortunately, we didn't learn these lessons 10 years ago.
In this book Ms. Schor goes through the pitfalls being a member of the consumer society has on us. I learned about a new group of people, called "downshifters", that are making a lifestyle choice to consume less. Downshifters have found that through reduced consumption, they can work less and spend more time living a life that is more in tune with their goals and values.
Jun 03, 2009
Danielle
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
non-fiction,
did-not-finish
I wanted to read this as affirmation of a position I already strongly hold (consumerism is of the devil). I got that, but found it didn't hold my attention very well because the information was so outdated. It's based on research done in the early 90s, and while you know every scandalous statistic she presents must be that much worse a decade or two later, it does lose some of its immediacy. After watching this book languish on my nightstand for three weeks, with the bookmark advancing only bare...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Juliet Schor’s research over the last ten years has focussed on issues pertaining to trends in work and leisure, consumerism, the relationship between work and family, women's issues and economic justice. Schor's latest book is Born to Buy: The Commercialized Child and the New Consumer Culture (Scribner 2004). She is also author of The Overworked American: The Unexpected Decline of Leisure and The...more
More about Juliet B. Schor...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...
view all 8 comments




















