Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Scotch Verdict” as Want to Read:
Scotch Verdict
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Scotch Verdict

3.79  ·  Rating Details  ·  42 Ratings  ·  3 Reviews
The year: 1810. The place: Edinburgh, Scotland. A student, Jane Cumming, accuses her school mistresses, Jane Pirie and Marianne Woods, of having an affair in the presence of their students. Dame Cumming Gordon, the wealthy and powerful grandmother of the accusing student, advises her friends to remove their daughters from the boarding school. Within days, the school is des ...more
Paperback, 320 pages
Published January 20th 1994 by Columbia University Press (first published 1983)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Scotch Verdict, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Scotch Verdict

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 133)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Moira Russell
Apr 20, 2013 Moira Russell rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Wonderful and heartbreaking. This is almost like a lost fictional historical novel by Virginia Woolf -- yes, it really is that good, except even more empathic (Judith Halberstam's fairly useless introduction overemphasizes "Faderman's own commentary on Cumming," which seems to ignore the very heartfelt description of her fate at the end). I feared the framing device of the narrator-scholar and her lover Ollie commenting on the trial would be tiresome, but it is a wonderful addition to the story. ...more
Sep 26, 2007 K. rated it it was amazing
Shelves: non-fiction
An incredibly important book about how racial prejudice trumps even homophobia and misogyny. It's the true, well-documented and imaginatively-written story of the two "old maid" school teachers accused of lesbian activity by a dark-skinned (Indian) student. Who will be believed? The two white single women with no man to protect them, or the dark-skinned child with no whites to vouch for her? This book of social and historical commentary reads like a mystery novel, full of suspense.
In a case that over one hundred years later inspired the 1934 play The Children's Hour (adapted into a movie in 1961), the reputation and livelihood of two Scottish schoolmistresses was ruined when a girl under their care accused them of engaging in a sexual relationship in the same room as their sleeping charges. After the girl's influential grandmother removed her from the school and recommended to the other families that their children be removed as well, the two women sued the grandmother, c ...more
Country rated it really liked it
Jul 22, 2016
Elana marked it as to-read
Jul 10, 2016
Gillian marked it as to-read
Jul 05, 2016
Fallen marked it as to-read
Jun 27, 2016
Jane marked it as to-read
Jun 26, 2016
Kira marked it as to-read
Jun 11, 2016
M.E. Logan
M.E. Logan rated it really liked it
Apr 27, 2016
Rory marked it as to-read
Apr 25, 2016
Linda Stern-Siegel
Linda Stern-Siegel marked it as to-read
Mar 28, 2016
S. rated it really liked it
Mar 27, 2016
Bemy Simbajon
Bemy Simbajon marked it as to-read
Mar 25, 2016
Shellii Huff
Shellii Huff marked it as to-read
Mar 23, 2016
Mia La monica
Mia La monica marked it as to-read
Mar 02, 2016
Parker Ronquest
Parker Ronquest rated it liked it
Mar 03, 2016
Leeann added it
Jan 21, 2016
Lina Zerbarini
Lina Zerbarini marked it as to-read
Dec 31, 2015
Freya Gordon
Freya Gordon rated it did not like it
Dec 26, 2015
Steven Chang
Steven Chang marked it as to-read
Dec 22, 2015
Juliana marked it as to-read
Dec 21, 2015
Kristina Hoppe-schaus
Kristina Hoppe-schaus marked it as to-read
Nov 14, 2015
Lyla rated it really liked it
Dec 05, 2015
Nobuhle marked it as to-read
Nov 03, 2015
H marked it as to-read
Oct 02, 2015
Elizabeth marked it as to-read
Aug 29, 2015
Jen rated it it was amazing
Nov 30, 2015
« previous 1 3 4 5 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Lillian Faderman is an internationally known scholar of lesbian history and literature, as well as ethnic history and literature. Among her many honors are six Lambda Literary Awards, two American Library Association Awards, and several lifetime achievement awards for scholarship. She is the author of The Gay Revolution and the New York Times Notable Books, Surpassing the Love of Men and Odd Girls ...more
More about Lillian Faderman...

Share This Book

No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »