The Alphabet Versus the Goddess: The Conflict Between Word and Image
by Leonard Shlain
|
|
Sign in to Goodreads to see your friends' reviews of The Alphabet Versus the Goddess: The Conflict Between Word and Image.
discuss this book
friend reviews (0)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
lists with this book
This book is not in any lists. Go add it to a list.
other reviews (showing 1-20 of 389)
bookshelves:
currently-reading,
non-fiction
What I appreciate about this book is that it doesn't put itself forward as a sure thing. (Clear to those who read forewords or introductions.) He disclaims very clearly that this is a hypothesis that he feels is very likely true. Naturally, he spends the book trying to support that hypothesis strongly.
Some of the connections he makes feel like he's stretching: linking the binding of Chinese women's feet with the surge of printing at the same time, because they use the same type of material, ...more
Some of the connections he makes feel like he's stretching: linking the binding of Chinese women's feet with the surge of printing at the same time, because they use the same type of material, ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in July, 2006
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
recommends it for:
lateral thinkers; people not afraid to ponder the consequences of literacy
Ok, for bibliophiles, this book is like being told that the parents you've admired and cherished and emulated for so long were drunken, abusive, misanthropes.
But if you tough it out, accept the possibility that this habit, this passion that keeps making life worth living, has had possible side-effects, then the pay-off is astounding.
Shlain provides copious examples for his thesis--that the invention of the abstract alphabets (western and, to some extent, eastern pictograph-alphabets) sub...more
But if you tough it out, accept the possibility that this habit, this passion that keeps making life worth living, has had possible side-effects, then the pay-off is astounding.
Shlain provides copious examples for his thesis--that the invention of the abstract alphabets (western and, to some extent, eastern pictograph-alphabets) sub...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
science-spirituality-sociology
Read in July, 2007
Dr. Shlain definitely takes some liberties in his review of history, but he also asks himself questions that you find yourself equally as curious about as he is when he presents them. The historical flux between word and image, masculine and feminine is often filled with reversals of fortune, tales of religious zealotry, attempts to wipe out the past, sweeping changes by rulers, and equally as sweeping changes back by their successors. History is by no means boring when you are looking through ...more
Like this review?
yes
(1 person liked it)
add a comment
Read in January, 2008
The ultimate book for any feminist library. Here's a summary: You'll learn how paleolithic man in almost all ancient cultures worshipped an earth and fertility Goddess (like an ancient pornography - my opinion). Men finally realized their own sperm had something to do with procreation and decided women should be their property so they could make sure their kids were their own. Soon men invented male "Gods". Then with the appearance of the alphabet, the Torah, Koran, etc., all humans we...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in June, 2008
I'm loving the ideas in this! Shlain hypothises that the invent of linear, written language is responsible for humans' shift to left-brain (masculine) thinking, and the demise of female-centred worship.
There are some gaps in logic/history, but I love anything that forces me to re-examine something that was a stable force in my life.
Most interesting to me, as a woman in a text-based career that also relies on the Internet - "The computer and the Internet will once again reconfigure the b...more
There are some gaps in logic/history, but I love anything that forces me to re-examine something that was a stable force in my life.
Most interesting to me, as a woman in a text-based career that also relies on the Internet - "The computer and the Internet will once again reconfigure the b...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in March, 2008
I am amazed that I was able to force myself to finish this book. It is filled with so much speculation touted as fact, and wide generalization it makes me sick. Even the author himself admits at one point in the book that correlation of events in time is not evidence of causation, and yet that is exactly what he continues to base this book on. I see no factual evidence in this book that the author's thesis is backed up by any of what he says. Again, and again he interprets history in a way t...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
science
Read in August, 2003
I picked up this book in a used book store one summer and didn’t think it was going to be more than a skim over read. Nope, from page one I was marching through mud, but I marched through because I found it stimulating and eye opening. The author, Leonard Shalain, really takes liberties in his view of human history, but with that being said, his ideas are clever and exposing. I liked this book and thought a lot about it. I recommend it, but don’t worry about finishing it, the second half is ...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
science,
spirituality
Read in July, 2003
This book revolves around the central thesis that literacy and the alphabet reconfigured the human brain, and subsequently brought serious changes into human culture: religion, history, etc. The oldest religions worshipped the Mother Goddess figure, yet, when reading and writing came into the picture (roughly 5000-4000 BCE) the supremacy of the female deity faded, and the male deities became more and more prominent. Shlain traces this fundamental change throughout history... a phenomenal book th...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
goddess-worship,
non-fiction,
reference
This books presents an interesting premise: as humans began to use written alphabets, we slowly switched from an intuitive, holistic, feminine, right-brained way of thinking to a linear, left-brained, masculine way of thinking that shifted our concepts of the Divine from a feminine image to a masculine one.
Shlain presents some interesting, thought-provoking theories and examples to illustrate them. Even though there is at least one instance where it appears to me that he wasn't completel...more
Shlain presents some interesting, thought-provoking theories and examples to illustrate them. Even though there is at least one instance where it appears to me that he wasn't completel...more
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
currently-reading
recommends it for:
feminists; anyone fascinated with language; open-minded people interested in spirituality
This is an amazing book.. Shlain has a theory about the process of most of humanity losing contact with the immense importance of the feminine aspect and perspective on our world view. He goes all the way back and before to the early development of language and subsequently the alphabet and the written word. His research is vast and quite stunning. It is not a new book, and I have had it for years--- it is very dense so I am slowly chipping away at it. I heard the author interviewed on NPR.
Like this review?
yes
(1 person liked it)
add a comment
bookshelves:
literarytheory,
womens-lit
Read in February, 2008
I am tentative about recommending this book to just any one. The first four chapters did not sit well with me and his whole premise challenges our faith in literacy and the written word. Personally, I found the book insightful and it triggered a lot of questions I had to wrestle with (and still am). However, the more I become interested in reclaiming women's discourse and a balanced power structure between men and women the more I enjoy reading books that challenge everything we hold dear.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in April, 2007
recommends it for:
Diana
I should have NOT highlighted the good parts, instead of vice versa. That way, my book would not currently resemble a yellow neon sign. Everything in this book is high-light-able. It's astonishing. Really.
If you've ever wondered why God became a man in every culture around the world before 6000 BC... why it's so often denied that God once was a woman EVERYWHERE... and why all cultures become violent upon their first encounter with the written word, take heed. This book is HERE.
If you've ever wondered why God became a man in every culture around the world before 6000 BC... why it's so often denied that God once was a woman EVERYWHERE... and why all cultures become violent upon their first encounter with the written word, take heed. This book is HERE.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
nonfiction
I'm currently reading the chapter, Illiteracy and Celibacy, in which Shlain links the rise of monasticism to the deforesation of Europe, the rise of prostitution and illegitimate births; and links the invention of the devil, a transsexual, to Marianism, which is reverence for Mary, mother of Jesus. It's a thought provoking and irreverent look at European history. I'm not sure what to make of it, but it's fun to read, even if reading is a different sort of devil, in his theory.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Sometimes slow because it is a well researched book, but a fascinating concept that resolved a question about Rianne Eisler's theory on why civilizations changed from worshiping the Goddess to worshiping God. This neurosurgeon explains why/how the brain shifted from right dominance to left about 5,000 years ago causing male traits to be valued more than female. He says he thinks we are shifting back and he hopes to a more balanced left/right and he explains why. Fascinating.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Read in June, 2004
recommends it for:
people who know what the Venus of Willendorf is, pagans, Wiccans..just not rabid Christians
This was the first of Leonard Shlain's books that I read - and it's full of facts and history that's sometimes awful to read (oh those bloodthirsty Catholics! The Inquisition was just a start..)but it's definitely worth it. In fact, I think I need to reread it because it's been awhile..You may find a few similarities between this book and some of the things in the Da Vinci Code - however, this book doesn't have an infuriating layout and Shlain knows how to write.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
currently-reading,
treading-water
Read in February, 2008
I like it a lot, I think Shlain has some very interesting observations and opinions, but I don't know that I trust his authority on all of the subjects involved.
Favorite Sentence (so far, though I will be impressed if he can top this):
" And like the shepherd (Jesus) was, He herded His followers back across the corpus callosum."
(have to re-find this so I can make sure it's exactly right, and to get the page #, but that's the gist)
Favorite Sentence (so far, though I will be impressed if he can top this):
" And like the shepherd (Jesus) was, He herded His followers back across the corpus callosum."
(have to re-find this so I can make sure it's exactly right, and to get the page #, but that's the gist)
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
Phenomenal over-view of many cultures of the world, main premise: that the rise of written language over images altered our perceptions/brain function and shifted us towards monotheism and patriarchy - all this from a male! But it is not all lost - he postulates that the rise in images (TV - movies, etc) may help create a shift towards balance. Hmm? Beautifully tied together, lay-person friendly, intellectual exercise.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
currently-reading
This book is unbelievably dense, leaving me to wonder if I will ever finish it, but the premise is fascinating. This is an inverted look at the social constructionist vs. biological determinist gender debate through a (vast) historical lens. The author manages to propose a theory which, in my opinion, could very well leave both sides of the debate feeling very satisfied. I am very much enjoying it.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment
bookshelves:
currently-reading
Read in December, 2007
Wow. This is a bit controversial viewpoint that the invention and introduction of the written word is partially responsible for the massive changes in the world. But I have to say that it seems to align with many of my own suspicions and sentiments. I feel a bit religious towards it, like it is my new bible. Maybe not for academic use but surely interesting.
Like this review?
yes
add a comment





















