The Color of Earth (Color Trilogy #1)
First love is never easy.
Ehwa grows up helping her widowed mother run the local tavern, watching as their customers – both neighbors and strangers – look down on her mother for her single lifestyle. Their social status isolates Ehwa and her mother from the rest of the people in their quiet country village. But as she gets older and sees her mother fall in love again, Ehwa...more
Ehwa grows up helping her widowed mother run the local tavern, watching as their customers – both neighbors and strangers – look down on her mother for her single lifestyle. Their social status isolates Ehwa and her mother from the rest of the people in their quiet country village. But as she gets older and sees her mother fall in love again, Ehwa...more
Paperback, 312 pages
Published
March 31st 2009
by First Second
(first published 2003)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,048)
Katanya lelaki itu layaknya kumbang. Entah karena ia kuat seperti kumbang atau karena rela menerima saiapa saja menjadi pasangannya. Terserah.
Katanya perempuan itu layaknya bunga.
Apakah dia bunga labu yang cantik di kala orang terlelap.?
Apakah dia seperti bunga Tiger Lily yang cantik ketika tak ada yang menyaksikan?
Apakah dia seperti kamelia yang walau cantik harus bertepuk sebelah tangan?
Ya benar katanya, Wanita itu makhluk yang aneh. Selalu berubah dan sulit ditebak. Wanita sendiri katanya ad...more
Katanya perempuan itu layaknya bunga.
Apakah dia bunga labu yang cantik di kala orang terlelap.?
Apakah dia seperti bunga Tiger Lily yang cantik ketika tak ada yang menyaksikan?
Apakah dia seperti kamelia yang walau cantik harus bertepuk sebelah tangan?
Ya benar katanya, Wanita itu makhluk yang aneh. Selalu berubah dan sulit ditebak. Wanita sendiri katanya ad...more
#2010-81#
“Jadi bukan karena kita cacat, melainkan karena kita perempuan? Lalu kenapa Dongchul dan Moonsho punya burung sementara anak-anak perempuan tidak punya?”(h.35)
Orangtua, sesulit apa pun, harus bisa menjelaskan tentang seksualitas pada anaknya. Pertanyaan-pertanyaan Ehwa di buku ini cukup menggelitik, membayangkan beberapa tahun lagi mungkin anak perempuanku akan bertanya hal-hal serupa. Kalau sekarang hanya bisa menjelaskan pertanyaan tentang bedanya laki-laki dan perempuan, hanya sebata...more
“Jadi bukan karena kita cacat, melainkan karena kita perempuan? Lalu kenapa Dongchul dan Moonsho punya burung sementara anak-anak perempuan tidak punya?”(h.35)
Orangtua, sesulit apa pun, harus bisa menjelaskan tentang seksualitas pada anaknya. Pertanyaan-pertanyaan Ehwa di buku ini cukup menggelitik, membayangkan beberapa tahun lagi mungkin anak perempuanku akan bertanya hal-hal serupa. Kalau sekarang hanya bisa menjelaskan pertanyaan tentang bedanya laki-laki dan perempuan, hanya sebata...more
”Untuk apa membeli sesuatu yang pasti akan mati” – The Painted Veil
Sebagai penggemar bunga, saya tak pernah bisa memberi jawaban pasti bila ada teman yang menanyakan kegemaran saya ini. Terutama bagi teman-teman yang tahu kalau saya berlangganan bunga. Setiap lima hari sekali, satu buket besar bunga pasti akan datang ke rumah, yang kemudian saya taruh dalam vas-vas besar di beberapa sudut. Sebuah pemborosan di mata beberapa teman yang tak suka dengan bunga.
Tapi kemudian, buku Warna Tanah ini me
...more
Sep 30, 2012
Fiction State Of Mind (Kai Charles)
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Shelves:
graphic-novels,
series
CROSSOVER SUNDAY
I love books. All Genres: Fiction, Non-Fiction, Comic Books and Manga. My wish with crossover sunday is to introduce readers to new genres.
My first review is The Color Of Water .
"In a timeless village in rural Korea young Ehwa and her widowed mother live quietly together,best friends and confidantes" Kim Dong Hwa
The color of earth is a gorgeously illustrated Black and white Manga. The First in a triology of books about the life and loves of a mother in daugter in rural Korea. Ma...more
I love books. All Genres: Fiction, Non-Fiction, Comic Books and Manga. My wish with crossover sunday is to introduce readers to new genres.
My first review is The Color Of Water .
"In a timeless village in rural Korea young Ehwa and her widowed mother live quietly together,best friends and confidantes" Kim Dong Hwa
The color of earth is a gorgeously illustrated Black and white Manga. The First in a triology of books about the life and loves of a mother in daugter in rural Korea. Ma...more
Melukis kehidupan para wanita dengan hujan dan bunga
Melukis cinta dengan hujan dan bunga
buku yang penuh dengan kata-kata indah dan sarat makna.
Kamelia adalah satu-satunya bunga yang mekar di tengah salju, kamelia benar-benar bunga yang tahan cuaca. Mereka nyaris kelihatan seolah-olah begitu tak sabar menantikan seseorang. Namun mereka sangat lelah dengan penantian itu hingga berubah jadi merah. Kamelia satu-satunya bunga yang cintanya bertepuk sebelah tangan.
Akankah aku menjadi seperti bunga ka...more
Melukis cinta dengan hujan dan bunga
buku yang penuh dengan kata-kata indah dan sarat makna.
Kamelia adalah satu-satunya bunga yang mekar di tengah salju, kamelia benar-benar bunga yang tahan cuaca. Mereka nyaris kelihatan seolah-olah begitu tak sabar menantikan seseorang. Namun mereka sangat lelah dengan penantian itu hingga berubah jadi merah. Kamelia satu-satunya bunga yang cintanya bertepuk sebelah tangan.
Akankah aku menjadi seperti bunga ka...more
The graceful and expressive illustrations in this graphic novel capture a tender relationship between a mother and daughter. Ehwa, a young Korean girl, blossoms into womanhood, and with each passing season, her mother imparts information about romance and sexuality. While the lyrical and frequently humorous dialogue is well crafted, the illustrations are the best part of the novel. The graphic panels communicate more cultural information than could be conveyed by words alone. Illustrations give...more
I really don't think this story would have been successful as anything other than a graphic novel. The artwork (particularly all the flowers) paired with all the metaphors about growing and blossoming into a young women are wonderful, and without the illustrations some of the text could seem trite or overworked. I don't see this as a book that many teens - male or female - would immediately jump to reading (and I didn't either), but once started I think that the universal appeal of this coming-o...more
o APA citation: Kim, D. H. (2009). The color of the earth. New York, NY: First Second Books, ALA's list of Top Ten Challenged Books of 2011
o Genre: Controversial/Banned
o Format: Graphic novel
o Selection process: Sanders, J. (2010). Cutting-Edge Manga. Teacher Librarian, 37(3), 27.
o Review: In this beautifully illustrated graphic novel, originally written in Korean, author Dong Hwa Kim tells the story of Ehwa, a young Korean girl who is beginning to wrestle with classic coming-of-age questions....more
o Genre: Controversial/Banned
o Format: Graphic novel
o Selection process: Sanders, J. (2010). Cutting-Edge Manga. Teacher Librarian, 37(3), 27.
o Review: In this beautifully illustrated graphic novel, originally written in Korean, author Dong Hwa Kim tells the story of Ehwa, a young Korean girl who is beginning to wrestle with classic coming-of-age questions....more
Recently I decided to start reading different genres of books so I saw this graphic novel at my local library and decided to try it. I've only read a few graphic novels so I wouldn't call myself an expert on manga or anything.
It was decent. I am glad it wasn't trying to be funny, because that tends to annoy me in manga/graphic novels, and The Color of Earth actually had a story and read like any other literary work. It is an interesting display of culture, love, and sexual awakening.
Some parts...more
It was decent. I am glad it wasn't trying to be funny, because that tends to annoy me in manga/graphic novels, and The Color of Earth actually had a story and read like any other literary work. It is an interesting display of culture, love, and sexual awakening.
Some parts...more

[Girl in a field of grasses and flowers? Ban it!]
A couple weeks ago it was Banned Books Week, a national celebration of those works that have been challenged by adults who believe in sequestering away literature that does not adequately line up with their particular ideological yardstick. It's rare that these challenges are meant as outright bans. Rather than seek to remove a work completely from the range of literature available to a society, these challengers wish to keep the targeted books fr...more
This is an odd little book. It is a collection of episodes in the life of Ehwa, a little girl growing up in Korea of a few generations ago--so far, so good. But it is basically just all the incidents where Ehwa learns something about sex, starting with her first realization at age 7 (really? she's 7 and apparently the women sometime bathe together in the creek, and she never figured this out?) that boys' and girls' bodies are different. Okay, it's not just sex ed; many of the stories are about E...more
After looking at a banned book list for something to read in celebration of banned book week, I was met with a huge number of familiar books. Resolved to read something I had never heard of, I picked The Color of Earth without reading any of the descriptions. The cover art looked promising, and, hey, it was a banned book so it had to have something worthy to say, right?
It was both disappointing and surprising to realize I had actually purchased a manhwa--or Korean Graphic Novel. I am not a part...more
It was both disappointing and surprising to realize I had actually purchased a manhwa--or Korean Graphic Novel. I am not a part...more
I had put this book aside on a bookshelf, read but unreviewed, until a student borrowed it. Once she returned it, I reread it, liking it just as much the second time as the first. In this graphic novel, a woman and her daughter experience love, the mother for the second time with a traveling artist who leaves a brush behind when he visits, and the daughter with a monk-in-training and a wealthy landowner's son. The storyline is engaging, almost leisurely, and filled with sensory images described...more
Some of the absolute finest art I've seen in Eastern comics. Such delicate lines! The contrast between the minimalist characters and the lush backgrounds really immerses the reader in the setting. The sparse designs of the characters are offset by the wonderfully precise facial expressions. I rarely see such depth portrayed with so few strokes, especially in a manwha/manga style.
The artwork perfectly compliments the story, a coming of age tale for a young woman named Ehwa and her relationship wi...more
The artwork perfectly compliments the story, a coming of age tale for a young woman named Ehwa and her relationship wi...more
I happened upon The Color of Earth and was intrigued by its lovely cover and the description of it as a youth romance trilogy. This book tells the story of Ehwa and her mother, a young widow who runs a tavern to support herself and her daughter. The Color of Earth is essentially Ehwa's coming of age story and the author does skimp on details. We witness Ehwa receive both accurate and inaccurate information from her peers about sex. Each time, Ehwa shares this information with her mother, so addi...more
It is hard for me to know exactly how to rate this trilogy. There's clearly something lost in the cross-cultural translation since so much of this trilogy circles around the cultural beliefs and ideas about sexuality that existed during a specific era in a small Korean village. Not having access to that context, I'm sure my perspective on the series may lack some broader insight. I also totally have no background knowledge on how women's sexuality is regarded in Korea currently. From the introdu...more
Buku ini, buku yang indah kerena penuh dengan metafora yang indah juga gambar yang memanjakan mata, membuat saya hanyut dalam ceritanya.
Kisah tentang seorang anak bernama Ehwa yang beranjak tumbuh dewasa bersama seorang Ibunya yang janda dan berprofesi sebagai pejaga kedai teh. Berbagai pertanyaan Ehwa tentang sesksualitas dijawab dengan bijak oleh Ibunya. Bagaimana Ehwa mulai mengenal dirinya sebagai seorang perempuan, mulai memahami Ibunya yang merindukan cinta, mulai mengenal cinta pertama,...more
Kisah tentang seorang anak bernama Ehwa yang beranjak tumbuh dewasa bersama seorang Ibunya yang janda dan berprofesi sebagai pejaga kedai teh. Berbagai pertanyaan Ehwa tentang sesksualitas dijawab dengan bijak oleh Ibunya. Bagaimana Ehwa mulai mengenal dirinya sebagai seorang perempuan, mulai memahami Ibunya yang merindukan cinta, mulai mengenal cinta pertama,...more
Saya dan adik saya punya minat baca yang berbeda.
Saya gila novel, dia gila komik. Dari semua komik yang berderet-deret di rak buku kamarnya dan direkomendasikannya seja SMP dulu sampai sekarang, saya cuma berhasil membaca sampai tuntas: Candy-Candy. Sebaliknya dari semua novel yang berderet-deret di rak kamar saya dan saya rekomendasikan kepadanya, kelihatannya cuma Totochan yang berhasil dia baca sampai tuntas. Hehehe.
Nah, suami saya juga penggemar komik, tapi gak tau tuh, saya tidak juga terl...more
Saya gila novel, dia gila komik. Dari semua komik yang berderet-deret di rak buku kamarnya dan direkomendasikannya seja SMP dulu sampai sekarang, saya cuma berhasil membaca sampai tuntas: Candy-Candy. Sebaliknya dari semua novel yang berderet-deret di rak kamar saya dan saya rekomendasikan kepadanya, kelihatannya cuma Totochan yang berhasil dia baca sampai tuntas. Hehehe.
Nah, suami saya juga penggemar komik, tapi gak tau tuh, saya tidak juga terl...more
WARNA TANAH
Penulis : Kim Dong Hwa
Penerjemah : Rosi L. Simamora
Penerbit : PT. Gramedia Pustaka Utama
Cetakan : Juni, 2010
Tebal : 320 Halaman
Kekasihku tiba, tapi bukan menyambutnya,
Aku hanya bisa menggigiti ujung celemeku dengan ekspresi hampa ---
Betapa kikuknya diriku.
Hatiku merindukannya, sebesar dan senyalang bulan yang purnama
Namun aku malah menyipitkan mata, tatapanku
Setajam dan setipis bulan sabit.
Namun bukan aku melulu yang bertingkah begini.
Ibuku dan ibu dari ibuku sama konyol dan canggungn...more
Penulis : Kim Dong Hwa
Penerjemah : Rosi L. Simamora
Penerbit : PT. Gramedia Pustaka Utama
Cetakan : Juni, 2010
Tebal : 320 Halaman
Kekasihku tiba, tapi bukan menyambutnya,
Aku hanya bisa menggigiti ujung celemeku dengan ekspresi hampa ---
Betapa kikuknya diriku.
Hatiku merindukannya, sebesar dan senyalang bulan yang purnama
Namun aku malah menyipitkan mata, tatapanku
Setajam dan setipis bulan sabit.
Namun bukan aku melulu yang bertingkah begini.
Ibuku dan ibu dari ibuku sama konyol dan canggungn...more
Saat membaca mahnwa ini, terbayang di imaji gue adalah scenery dari K-Drama karya Yoon Suk-Ho yang terkenal dengan drama musim-nya; Endless Love, Winter Sonata, Summer Scent. Yaitu Spring Waltz Bener-bener penggambaran alam dan keindahan musim seminya sama dengan yang ditampilkan dalam drama tersebut.
Plus saat membaca kisah hidup Ehnwa dan Ibunya dengan backsound dari ost Spring waltz sendiri, One Love
One Love
Higher than the sky above you
Clearer than blue
Brighter than the rays of sunshine
Warmer...more
Plus saat membaca kisah hidup Ehnwa dan Ibunya dengan backsound dari ost Spring waltz sendiri, One Love
One Love
Higher than the sky above you
Clearer than blue
Brighter than the rays of sunshine
Warmer...more
'hujan dan bunga membawa aroma tersendiri….dan bagi diriku sendiri, aroma tanah sehabis hujan…membawa kembaraku ke masa lalu, masa kecil yang indah….'
Novel grafis ini sangat ciamik, indah, memukau, puitik, lucu dan menggemaskan…
Si kecil Ehwa, begitu lugu, imut, cantik dan naïf…., transformasi dari anak perempuan kecil menjadi gadis dewasa…; dengan lugunya Ehwa yang hidup hanya bersama ibunya…selalu bertanya dan mencari tahu apa yang berubah dengan dirinya dan mengapa laki-laki dan perempuan berb...more
Novel grafis ini sangat ciamik, indah, memukau, puitik, lucu dan menggemaskan…
Si kecil Ehwa, begitu lugu, imut, cantik dan naïf…., transformasi dari anak perempuan kecil menjadi gadis dewasa…; dengan lugunya Ehwa yang hidup hanya bersama ibunya…selalu bertanya dan mencari tahu apa yang berubah dengan dirinya dan mengapa laki-laki dan perempuan berb...more
Aku suka membaca novel grafis. Namun aku cenderung membacanya lebih lama dibanding membaca novel biasa, karena menikmati guratan-guratan gambarnya.
Novel ini indah, mengguratkan karakter-karakter di dalamnya dengan lembut, tak banyak arsiran atau goresan, lebih berupa garis-garis yang sekali jadi. Aku tak terampil menggambar, namun aku menikmati gambar dan lukisan, walau bukan dengan mata seorang kritikus seni.
Kim Dong Hwa awalnya kusangka adalah seorang perempuan, karena pendekatan feminisnya da...more
Novel ini indah, mengguratkan karakter-karakter di dalamnya dengan lembut, tak banyak arsiran atau goresan, lebih berupa garis-garis yang sekali jadi. Aku tak terampil menggambar, namun aku menikmati gambar dan lukisan, walau bukan dengan mata seorang kritikus seni.
Kim Dong Hwa awalnya kusangka adalah seorang perempuan, karena pendekatan feminisnya da...more
Jul 19, 2010
Roos
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Syl and Palsay
Recommended to Roos by:
Curious
Buku ini membuatku merindukan seseorang yang masih dalam mimpiku. Buku ini juga membuatku merindukan aroma tanah saat bercengkerama dengan hujan, serta wanginya bunga-bunga yang bermekaran di setiap musimnya.
KIM DONG HWA. Pertama membaca buku Graphic Novel seri Chinken Soup, langsung membuatku jatuh cinta pada karya-karya ilustrasinya. Terkenal akan kemampuannya di dunia Manhwa atau Manga di Jepang. Pak Kim, tidak saja menyajikan gambar yang cantik tapi juga kisah yang menyentuh di buku Warna Ta...more
KIM DONG HWA. Pertama membaca buku Graphic Novel seri Chinken Soup, langsung membuatku jatuh cinta pada karya-karya ilustrasinya. Terkenal akan kemampuannya di dunia Manhwa atau Manga di Jepang. Pak Kim, tidak saja menyajikan gambar yang cantik tapi juga kisah yang menyentuh di buku Warna Ta...more
http://tinyurl.com/y9pxrk3
As I've said before, I don't often review the graphic novels or comic strips that I read. This one, however, was for book club, so I feel a bit obliged.
Having a bit of knowledge on the history of manga graphic novels, or at the least a vague understanding of where they started and how they've spread, this particular selection was, um, different. I know there are all types: samurai-based, tween love, erotic, heck there's even one based on the life of Buddha (and it's fan...more
As I've said before, I don't often review the graphic novels or comic strips that I read. This one, however, was for book club, so I feel a bit obliged.
Having a bit of knowledge on the history of manga graphic novels, or at the least a vague understanding of where they started and how they've spread, this particular selection was, um, different. I know there are all types: samurai-based, tween love, erotic, heck there's even one based on the life of Buddha (and it's fan...more
The Color of Earth is the first in a trilogy of graphic novels about a young girl named Ehwa and her widowed mother who owns a tavern in a small Korean village. The story takes place in a time before that country was geographically split by war.
Author Kim Dong Hwa creates beautiful images that work with the narrative to tell this story of two generations of women. While the story may seem simple as it follows Ehwa from young girl to young adult, it is filled with rich symbolism that you will wan...more
Author Kim Dong Hwa creates beautiful images that work with the narrative to tell this story of two generations of women. While the story may seem simple as it follows Ehwa from young girl to young adult, it is filled with rich symbolism that you will wan...more
Summary: This is the story of two women, one a little and the other her young widowed mother. The story focuses on the little girl and her awakening identity as a woman, and also as a side story is her mother who finds love again for the first time since her husband's death. As the back of my book says "first love and second chances."
Comments: This first book in a trilogy follows the little girl from the age of about six to fourteen. It takes place in a small Korean village in a time period unkn...more
Comments: This first book in a trilogy follows the little girl from the age of about six to fourteen. It takes place in a small Korean village in a time period unkn...more
This artwork is stunning. I took my time with this work in part simply so I could linger over the images. Not only are the images breathtaking but the construction of the volume itself is pure craftsmanship. Heavy paper and rich colors and a glossed cover compliment this classic story about first love, crossing the threshold of childhood and finding love again.
The writing is poetic, simple in construction but rich with metaphor, and there is a tenderness that can only really be appreciated with...more
The writing is poetic, simple in construction but rich with metaphor, and there is a tenderness that can only really be appreciated with...more
The artwork is amazing! The detail just blows my mind away - the patterns on clothing, the blossoms and leaves on the trees, the gorgeous landscapes - let's just say that I would kill to have such talent and vision!
And who can resist a story about young love in all its innocent glory? Ehwa experiences her first crush with a young monk and, when she is rebuffed (for monks should not reciprocate such feelings, though he definitely felt attracted to her), then her second and more secret crush with...more
And who can resist a story about young love in all its innocent glory? Ehwa experiences her first crush with a young monk and, when she is rebuffed (for monks should not reciprocate such feelings, though he definitely felt attracted to her), then her second and more secret crush with...more
I love the cover of The Color of Earth, and it's the reason I even picked it up at all. Then I opened the book and was swept away by the captivating story of a little girl who is growing up and learning about love and life.
Ehwa is seven years old when we meet her, and she's found out that the villagers in her town can be cruel and thoughtless, men can be pigs, and little girls don't have the same parts as little boys... Two years later she wonders about babies, her widowed mother falls in love,...more
Ehwa is seven years old when we meet her, and she's found out that the villagers in her town can be cruel and thoughtless, men can be pigs, and little girls don't have the same parts as little boys... Two years later she wonders about babies, her widowed mother falls in love,...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Kim Dong-Hwa is a widely revered Korean comic artist. Since his debut (with My Sky, serialized in the Daily Hanguk, one of the most prestigious Korean newspapers) in 1975, he has become a mainstay of the Korean manhwa (comics) landscape. He is best known for his tender stories and uncanny ability to write from a profoundly feminine perspective.
The three books that make up The Color Trilogy – The C...more
More about Kim Dong Hwa...
The three books that make up The Color Trilogy – The C...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“My beloved has arrived, but rather than greeting him,
All I can do is bite the corner of my apron with a blank expression-
What an awkward woman am I.
My heart has longed for him as hugely and openly as a full moon
But instead I narrow my eyes, and my glance to him
Is sharp and narrow as the crescent moon.
But then, I'm not the only one who behaves this way.
My mother and my mother's mother were as silly and stumbling as I am when they were girls...
Still, the love from my heart is overflowing,
As bright and crimson as the heated metal in a blacksmith's forge.”
—
5 people liked it
All I can do is bite the corner of my apron with a blank expression-
What an awkward woman am I.
My heart has longed for him as hugely and openly as a full moon
But instead I narrow my eyes, and my glance to him
Is sharp and narrow as the crescent moon.
But then, I'm not the only one who behaves this way.
My mother and my mother's mother were as silly and stumbling as I am when they were girls...
Still, the love from my heart is overflowing,
As bright and crimson as the heated metal in a blacksmith's forge.”
“When that part of the woman meets with a man, all the flowers in the world suddenly bloom! All the birds of the world gather together and sing. The entire world turns golden, and your body becomes completely relaxed and you're not sure whether you're floating on clouds of feathers. The universe comes alive, like fireworks in the night.”
—
4 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 11 comments


























