Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Devil in Massachusetts: A Modern Enquiry Into the Salem Witch Trials” as Want to Read:
The Devil in Massachusetts: A Modern Enquiry Into the Salem Witch Trials
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Devil in Massachusetts: A Modern Enquiry Into the Salem Witch Trials

3.57 of 5 stars 3.57  ·  rating details  ·  493 ratings  ·  53 reviews
This historical narrative of the Salem witch trials takes its dialogue from actual trial records but applies modern psychiatric knowledge to the witchcraft hysteria. Starkey's sense of drama also vividly recreates the atmosphere of pity and terror that fostered the evil and suffering of this human tragedy.
Paperback, 320 pages
Published August 5th 1969 by Anchor (first published 1949)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Devil in Massachusetts, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Devil in Massachusetts

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,286)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Shea Mastison
This book is one of the best bits of evidence I can think of, which shows how people rarely need religion to behave well; but equally, how they can use it to behave poorly. The fanatic persecution of "witches" in the Massachusettes colony is one of the most ominous in early European-American history: it turned family members against one another, and cast an awful suspicion upon one's neighbors and friends.

This historical book reads much like a novel; and presents an interesting interpretation o
In truth, this book is a near-failure.
Historically it sucks, and it reeks of the sense of postmodern superiority often found in books written by social scientists.
Apparently, Ms. Starkey "...applies modern psychiatric knowledge to the witchcraft hysteria," yet that psychiatric element absolutely ruins and undoes any of the actual historical claims from the primary sources which she did cite.
Problem is, she takes an unnecessary and excessive amount of "creative license" and over-characterizes th
I started doing some genealogy research recently and that I have ancestors that were from Salem Village in Massachusetts and may, possible be descended from a woman who was hanged as a witch. I still have a fair amount of research to prove that, but the possibility got me interested in learning more about the trials and what happened.

Starkey's book is a pretty quick overview of the events though he doesn't limit himself to pure history and tries to "get inside the people's heads." He also claims
Religion is dangerous. So are teenage girls. This seems to be the main theme of this book. Starkey has gathered myriad sources on the Salem Witch Trials and managed to put together a cohesive account which is neither dry nor dense. Though written in 1949, it is comprehensible to the modern reader and also fascinating. Starkey has taken great care not to fabricate action or dialogue in order to add drama to her tale; she hardly needs to. She has copied entire sections of dialogue from court repor ...more
Given that this originally appeared in 1949, it might be ungenerous to label it as trite supposition, heavily reliant on emotive adjectives and conjecture as much research has been conducted into what went on in Salem Village for several months in 1692 since this first appeared. Starkey claims to be applying 'modern psychiatric knowledge' to the behaviour of the afflicted girls (adults were also involved, though she seems to frequently forget this), but that does not stop her from labelling Abig ...more
Breanna Whipple
Incredibly informative and an entertaining read. So many myths regarding the Salem trials... Was nice getting to know what actually occurred. Differs greatly from the trials that had occurred in Europe, which I think is where the confusion spawns from. Definitely recommend it!
Starkey has successfully turned the events of the Salem Witch Trials into a compelling narrative, explaining not only the social reasons for the hysteria but also the personal, psychological conditions that precipitated it.
The author tries to delve into the minds of the historical figures of the time and show what they might have been thinking. This often reads as hammy dramatization rather than any real insight. There's no way anyone can really know what these people were thinking. Historians c
Jan 03, 2012 Lori added it
Recommended to Lori by: Tanya Marie
I liked this book a lot, I really enjoyed how the Author separated the people that were involved with The Witch Trials and what they're rolls were in it.

What a sad but fascinating part of our New England history.

Amanda Zucksworth
Amanda Zucksworth
English 232

The author's purpose for writing The Devil in Massachusetts: A Modern Enquiry Into the Salem Witch Trials was to inform readers of the events of the Salem Witch Trials. The book actually takes it's dialogue from real trial records, but Marion L. Starkey also applies her knowledge of the trials and her knowledge of psychiatry to the book as well.

One theme that is quite prevalent in this novel is that religion can be dangerous. The reason that the trials in Salem even
Cindy Dyson Eitelman
Well, darn. Fascinating book, well researched, well told. The author did her job well, pulling no stops and naming all names. She followed up, too--didn't just stop with the first witch hanged but kept the story moving until the close. Well...there's never really a "close" to history, but you know what I mean. Until the people were moving on with their lives, making amends (or not), and the history was history--not current events.

But I yearned for details, explanations, even theories. When I rea
Finished at last. The end was thought provoking. Some individuals involved felt tremendous remorse and offered written and oral public appologies. But the Rev. Increase Mather and his son Rev. Cotton Mather did not have the humility to to apologize or express any remorse for their public support of the witchcraft trials and hangings. Rev. Increase Mather was the president of Harvard University, the theological leader of the Massachusetts colony, and "ambassador-extraordinary from Massachusetts t ...more
If one really wants to learn about the infamous Salem witch trials this is the place to start. This gives a thorough accounting of the witch trials that took place in Salem Village(present day Danvers, Massachusetts) in colonial Massachusetts in 1692-1693. When the daughters of the local minister fell ill the local doctor diagnosed the with "bewitchment". The ensuing investigation eventually overcame the community and surrounding area. Many accused witches were only spare lives if they repented ...more
Today, we put the utmost faith in justice. We hope that the men responsible for any crime will be brought to justice; we decide before a trial is over who is guilty, and are borderline angry if the accused is acquitted. We watch thousands of hours of police shows, we are obsessed with stories of the CIA and FBI hunts, and who can help but admire Sherlock Holmes' deep dedication to finding the source of wrong in the world.

Yet, justice can sometimes be this dark, terrifying thing. In the case of t
Zach Ulrich
The Devil in Massachusetts by Marion Lena Starkey is a book about the Salem Witch Trials through a psychological perspective. The author's purpose in writing this book is to inform us about the motives and thoughts of the human mind through the witch trials. If i could give a theme to this book, it would be "keep your head down" because through the witch trials, crazy stuff happens and everyone is getting accused of witchcraft left and right and you did not want to get involved....take my word f ...more
Originally published in 1949, this "modern enquiry" into the Salem Witch Trials attempts to explore the psychology of the people involved. I think someone with a modern psychology background would have a lot more to say about the young girls who were the accusers, but Starkey's interpretation doesn't bog the story down.

Starkey does a good job painting a picture of what Puritan life was like during the Salem witch hunt hysteria in 1692. The text comes off a bit schlocky and dated, but it is stil
Lori Schafer
Being a native of Massachusetts, I'm perhaps more drawn to this particular subject than I otherwise might be, particularly since Salem was a mere two hours away from my hometown and we actually visited the Salem Witch Museum on a school field trip during my formative years. A skeptic even at twelve, I was impressed most by the illogic of the proceedings, in particular the torture devices by which “confessions” were sometimes obtained. But I can’t say I had a fair recollection of the actual histo ...more
The Devil in Massachusetts is a factual recount of the witch trials in Massachusetts in 1692.

I found this an amazing book. It is a perfect example of a completely factual book that doesn't get boring. Marion L. Starkey uses a variety of sources (that are all listed in the back, including which were used for what) and brings the world of long ago back to life.

The writing is a bit old fashioned, which makes it a bit tough to get through. I can't really tell if it is because the book is a bit out
We have all had some Grade School learning on the subject of the Salem Witch Trials but, this is the first that I have read on my own of the subject. The author has taken the liberty of writing a narrative in the pace and excitement of a novel. He has incorporated his own diagnosis of the accusers’ as learned from the Freudian school of psychology. I thoroughly enjoyed this book however, I need to follow up with a more modern; less Freudian; point of view.
Joshua  Myers
This book is about the Salem Witch Trials in Salem, Massachusetts in 1692. This book talks about the Witch trials, What happened before that influence the trials, during the trials and after. Describes personalities of the Parris family, such as Betty and Abigail. See How Abigail wanted power and how she rose to the top and took control of Witch trials. How Puritan region had a huge impact.

This was not made into a movie.

I really love this book because it historical,it very interesting and how it
This is a riveting account of the Salem Witch Trials. Marion Starkey includes just the right amount of detail to portray all the elements of this horrifying story. From the hysteria spun out of fanaticism to the economic and social background that provided a fertile ground, the events unfold in a way that kept this reader spellbound. The author highlights the relationships of the people in the community and how their bonds were broken by the reactions of the accusations of the young girls. This ...more
Sue Mortensen
I read this book for a colonial history course I took. And then later, when looking at my husband's genealogy realized that he was related to Rebecca Nurse, Mary Esty and Sarah Cloyce! What an amazing find. All my children have used this book in preparing reports for school. In fact, while pulling this book out to check out the publishing date, I found notes made by one of the kids in the book. And while my son was in first grade, he drew a picture of me reading a "Book about Witches" in a famil ...more
Carla Remy
Very mixed feelings but mostly horror at the things people can do to each other (in the name of the Bible). It is such a disturbing story. Spectral Evidence. This book predates the modern theory of ergot poisoning, but knowing more of what actually happened, I say the theory of ergot poisoning could only account for a fragment. I mean, spectral evidence (people's fantasies and feelings admitted in court). Neighbors turning on neighbors. Way too much power being given to teenaged girls. Obvious p ...more
This book was a complete departure from the other books on the Salem Witchcraft trials that I have been reading for a research paper. While the others were more scholarly in tone, Ms. Starkey's book reads more like a novel. She has admitted in the foreword that she took some liberties in certain places to make the story more vivid, but this wasn't a bad thing. While the other books reported the facts and asked certain questions, Ms. Starkey's tome actually brought the main people of that sad tim ...more
Again, like many of the other books I've place on my books-i-teach shelf, this is a supplementary book that I use sections of in my unit. This one being The Crucible. I liked this. It seemed pretty well-researched and was interestingly written.
Debra S
A little old but a very readable account of the Salem Witch trials. I believe it might fit in the category of narrative non-fiction.
The scholarship is outdated at this point, but it's still a really good, readable account of the Salem witch trials.
This was an excellent resource for my research, filled with lots of information in a story-like format.
Facts are not checked against primary sources.
For sheer drama I give this book three stars, but for its reliance on psychoanalysis I caution readers against its melodrama. This is an interesting read but don't rely on this book for history. Read the actual transcripts, which you can access as e-texts from University of Virginia, Carol Karlsen's "The Devil in the Shape of a Woman," Increase Mather's "Wonders of the Invisible World," and, my favorite, Mary Beth Norton's "In the Devil's Snare."
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 42 43 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Entertaining Satan: Witchcraft and the Culture of Early New England
  • Witchcraft at Salem
  • The Salem Witch Trials: A Day-By-Day Chronicle of a Community Under Siege
  • Salem Possessed: The Social Origins of Witchcraft
  • The Salem Witch Trials Reader
  • The Devil in the Shape of a Woman: Witchcraft in Colonial New England
  • Judge Sewall's Apology: The Salem Witch Trials and the Forming of an American Conscience
  • Witch-Hunt: Mysteries of the Salem Witch Trials
  • In the Devil's Snare: The Salem Witchcraft Crisis of 1692
  • Salem Witch Judge: The Life and Repentance of Samuel Sewall
  • A Storm of Witchcraft: The Salem Trials and the American Experience
  • Escaping Salem: The Other Witch Hunt of 1692
  • Damned Women: Sinners and Witches in Puritan New England
  • Death in Salem: The Private Lives behind the 1692 Witch Hunt
  • Women's Indian Captivity Narratives
  • Home Life in Colonial Days
  • The Witchcraft of Salem Village
  • The Americans, Vol. 2: The National Experience
Marion Lena Starkey was Editor of the Saugus Herald newspaper, and a teacher at the Hampton Institute and the University of Connecticut at New London, having attended the Harvard Graduate school of Education. A descendant of Mayflower passenger Peregrine White, Starkey has published extensively on the Salem Witch Trials and the history of New England.
More about Marion L. Starkey...
The Visionary Girls: Witchcraft in Salem Village The Cherokee Nation (Native Americans) The Tall Man from Boston Land Where our Fathers Died: The Settling of the Eastern Shores, 1607-1735 A little rebellion

Share This Book

“But Mather's smile faded as he thought of what other provisions the charter contained. What would the godly say when they learned that the electorate was no longer to be limited to members of the Covenant but broadened to include propertied members of every Christian sect this side of papistry? This was a revolutionary innovation, whose consequences would be incalculable. Hitherto the limitation of the privilege of voting to the elect had been the very corner-stone of theocracy. It had been a wise and human provision designed to keep the faithful in control even when, as had long ago become the case, they were heavily outnumbered by lesser men without the Covenant. God who had not designated the majority of men to salvation surely never intended for the damned to rule. Yet now, under the new charter, it very much looked as if they might.” 3 likes
More quotes…