Enemy at the Gates: The Battle for Stalingrad
Stalingrad, the bloodiest battle in the history of warfare, cost the lives of nearly two million men and women. It signaled the beginning of the end for the Third Reich of Adolf Hitler; it foretold the Russian juggernaut that would destroy Berlin and make the Soviet Union a superpower. As Winston Churchill characterized the result of the conflict at Stalingrad: " the hinge...more
Hardcover, 457 pages
Published
July 15th 2003
by Barnes & Noble Books
(first published 1973)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
One would not be entirely correct if one thinks that the movie Enemy At The Gates was based on this book, even though the movie posters claims it to be so. Somehow, it resembles more with the book War of the Rats by David L. Robbins, which is a fictionalized account of the duel between two sharpshooters in the warzone of Stalingrad. In my opinion, Stalingrad (1993) is a way better movie than the Hollywood one.
This book in fact covers the whole battle of Stalingrad from the German perspective.

Fo...more
This book in fact covers the whole battle of Stalingrad from the German perspective.

Fo...more
Mar 29, 2009
Evan
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
epic,
my-faves,
world-war-ii,
__in-my-collection,
warfare,
russian-soviet-etc,
nazi,
survival,
freezin-ur-ass-off
Don't even harbor the thought that the film version of "Enemy at the Gates" bears anything but cursory relation to this book. The movie was actually based on a fictionalized book called "War of the Rats." If you want to read one book about the Hell that was World War II, this is the one. This is a sweeping chronicle of the most heinous campaign in the history of human warfare - Stalingrad. William Craig's command of the material is complete; the realities of everyday life and death are essayed t...more
This book is an account of one of the most decisive battles of World War II. It marks the spot in history when the Russian Army stopped retreating from the relentless German invasion which was started in June 1941, and when the utter, catastrophic defeat of the Germans gave the Russians and their allies in the United States and Great Britain a huge morale boost. This was one of those turning points where the ultimate outcome of a great conflict could trace its origins.
The invasion of the Soviet...more
The invasion of the Soviet...more
This title was the catalyst for my enduring fascination with books covering the fighting on the Eastern Front during World War Two. This is a great story of the fighting at Stalingrad endured by the German and Russian armies. Although not as deeply researched as Glantz’s titles this book offers an insight into the soldier’s war and does it brilliantly. This is still one of my top ten books ever which isn’t bad considering it was first published in the early 1970’s. Recommended for anyone who lov...more
Stalingrado fue, junto a El Alamein, una de las batallas en las que se invirtió el rumbo de la II Guerra Mundial. En ella, los alemanes perdieron a varios de sus mejores ejércitos, además de la iniciativa, que tomaron los soviéticos al empezar a avanzar hacia Berlín.
Napoleón fracasó al invadir Rusia y Hitler cometió los mismos errores, y algunos más. Intentó hacer una campaña relámpago y cuando se quedó atascado se le echó el invierno encima. Después de eso, los rusos sólo tuvieron que contener
...more
For WWII history buffs, this book is mandatory. The Russians had no idea that they had trapped so many Germans in Stalingrad during their November 1942 pincer movement. The bold Russian move along with diminishing supplies and brutal weather sealed the German's fate. This book details the day-by-day and hour-by-hour deterioration of German existence inside the Stalingrad pocket or "kessel" (Cauldron).
Descriptive personal testimony of trauma, starvation, frostbite and even post-war follow up on...more
Descriptive personal testimony of trauma, starvation, frostbite and even post-war follow up on...more
Enemy At The Gates is by William Craig. This book is mainly about the battle of stalingrad there are two main characters the two main snipers of each side of the brute force between Zaitsev and Konigs they were both the best ones of there elites sides. The intense moments of lief or death would keep you going crazy to read more. This story takes place during WWII When we were trying to take over stalingrad. I believe that the author (William Craig) wrote this book to inspire some of us to join t...more
I really never knew anything about the eastern front half of WWII so I decided to read this book which Kate found on her grandfather's shelf. The movie was about this one tiny little part; a sniper duel that took place during the months of battle. The book is about the battle as a whole, which took months and totally destroyed the entire German Sixth army of a quarter million men. Two interesting things about this book, one, it's the only thing I've ever read that actually manages to make you fe...more
The Jude Law movie from a few years ago is loosely based on about ten pages of this book (120 to 130 in my edition).
A lot of research and interviews were done for this book, and there are many interesting little anecdotes probably derived from those interviews. I'm reminded of the note at the beginning of 'A Bridge Too Far', which mentions the great deal of material that was very moving and interesting but could only be single-sourced and was therefore left out- I'm not sure the same high stand...more
A lot of research and interviews were done for this book, and there are many interesting little anecdotes probably derived from those interviews. I'm reminded of the note at the beginning of 'A Bridge Too Far', which mentions the great deal of material that was very moving and interesting but could only be single-sourced and was therefore left out- I'm not sure the same high stand...more
This is one book that will haunt me for a long time. It was published in 1973 after 4 years of research on the part of the author who also interviewed hundreds of survivors. In the prologue, the human losses are listed: Red Army, 750,000 dead, wounded or missing; Germans, about 400,000 men; Italians, 130,000 men; Hungarians, 120,000 men; Rumanians, about 200,000 men and unknown is the number of civilians from a population of half a million before the months of battle for Stalingrad (now known as...more
I knew the basics about Stalingrad before reading this book: that it was perhaps the most important battle of the war and a huge turning point, that it involved sniper battles, house-to-house fighting, huge casualties on both sides, and entire armies from Germany and Romania pretty much disappearing. This book gave me a more complete picture of the battle, its scope, and how it unfolded.
It wasn’t a happy read. The Soviets get pushed back almost all the way to the Volga and barely hang on. They s...more
It wasn’t a happy read. The Soviets get pushed back almost all the way to the Volga and barely hang on. They s...more
I liked this book very much. It was about two snipers that are pretty much just hunting each other. One sniper was a Russen and the other was a German. The Russen was the hero of his country, because the was killing alot of men and alot of generals. The German sniper was sent in just to kill the Russen. The two came very close to killing eachother many times befor the Russen finley ended it with a bullet to the Germans brain.
My favorite part of this book was when the Russen and his spoter were...more
My favorite part of this book was when the Russen and his spoter were...more
William Craig manages to create the tension felt by all participants: army headquarters, soldiers in the field, civilians caught up in the battle.
He explores the human nature of the battle and brings the horror of it straight into your home.
The style is almost of a fictional account and to me, that lends a certain authenticity to the unfolding drama since Mr. Craig superbly intertwines the thoughts of the combatants gleaned from letters into the narrative as triumph becomes defeat for one side,...more
He explores the human nature of the battle and brings the horror of it straight into your home.
The style is almost of a fictional account and to me, that lends a certain authenticity to the unfolding drama since Mr. Craig superbly intertwines the thoughts of the combatants gleaned from letters into the narrative as triumph becomes defeat for one side,...more
This book really surprised me. At first I was thrown off by the detailed narrative, since this book is categorized as history and not memoir or historical fiction, and as I had just come out of reading straight-up German Army history, I didn't quite trust it's accuracy. After a little research and checking out the bibliography, I read on. After the first quarter it just flew - quickly moving, engaging, and relatable (as much as war can be for civilians), I couldn't put it down. I still don't com...more
Good,solid,coherent descriptions of The Plan of Battle...or,so it seems to this non-Historian...the anecdotal material made the book for me,though I found some of those interviewed were a bit too eager to place all blame,Moral and Military,on Hitler and Stalin...the tragedy wasn't just that two men were "Evil" but that millions more followed them into The Abyss...to say that "War shows Man at his best and worst" is trite but true and testimony about atrocities and acts of great valour can be hor...more
This is an interesting book on the battle for Stalingrad. As many USA historians seems to do (like Stephen E. Ambrose), Craig digs on the experiences and memories of the soldiers and civilians who struggle there for survival. So it comes to the personal experiences of the people who were right there, through all the horror that was that German's fumble.
Then, it is a book more directed to the mass readers rather than to the interested on history. And this is clear since the beginning from the nov...more
Then, it is a book more directed to the mass readers rather than to the interested on history. And this is clear since the beginning from the nov...more
Stalingrad, the bloodiest battle in the history of warfare, cost the lives of nearly two million men and women. It signaled the beginning of the end for the Third Reich of Adolf Hitler; it foretold the Russian juggernaut that would destroy Berlin and make the Soviet Union a superpower. As Winston Churchill characterized the result of the conflict at Stalingrad: " the hinge of fate had turned."
William Craig, author and historian, has painstakingly recreated the details of this great battle: from...more
William Craig, author and historian, has painstakingly recreated the details of this great battle: from...more
Saw the movie, with Jude Law and Ed Harris, and didn't realize that it was based on a book. When I saw this on the discount table, I had to have it am I'm glad I did. Lots of history based on examination of historical archives, military records, and people who where present. The description of the plight of captured Italians was harrowing, the collapse of the Germans proof that their slavo-phobic (I may have made up this word) bigotry flawed. If you like the movie, you'll like this historical th...more
I knew I was going to like this chronicle of history's bloodiest battle the moment I picked it up and saw The Longest Day and A Bridge Too Far author Cornelius Ryan's favorable review on the back cover. Let me start by saying that this is a mammoth undertaking, one that the author spent five years preparing for with hundreds of survivor interviews and countless hours of historical research before ever writing a paragraph. My biggest critique of this work is the same as my criticisms of the two w...more
Personally I find micro history a much more fascinating methodological approach than macro history. Actually, it's a bit of both: I like to gain an overall appreciation of a period or topic first before examining it in detail and finding out what it was like for those who lived through it. But I find the second part the most interesting.
Enemy at The Gates is the most compelling, disturbing, and brilliantly written attempt to relate what being involved in brutal, relentless, close quarter combat...more
Enemy at The Gates is the most compelling, disturbing, and brilliantly written attempt to relate what being involved in brutal, relentless, close quarter combat...more
This is a book that stays with you, making you remember the brutality of war. Whether you were German, you were sorrily sacrificed, or Russian you were driven to be sacrificed. The body counts and politics play off each other to show how decisions made behind the lines affect the men and women at the front. And in Russia the front was everywhere. And the movie of the same name, while very focussed, intense and realistic, it does only have to do with a small portion of the book.
The Enemy at the Gates: is another well researched history of the Battle of Stalingrad where the German Sixth Army was destroyed and marked the beginning of Nazi defeat in World War II. Craig uses interviews and memoirs of participtants to weave the intensity of the fighting and how Soviet troops inside the city fixed the German army's attention to capture the city while Soviet troops built up strength on the flanks that sealed the fate of the Hitler's effort to conquer Russia.
An entirely sobering account of the epochal battle of Stalingrad. The ruthlessness and inhumanity of war is nakedly exposed. Corpses abound – towards the end rotting bodies are stacked up in makeshift German hospitals.
Stalingrad is what can happen to invaders. Although one feels sympathy for the Germans in reading their letters home to their wives and parents – there is no introspection in these letters of the reasons of why they were so far from their homeland. When one seeks to destroy a city...more
Stalingrad is what can happen to invaders. Although one feels sympathy for the Germans in reading their letters home to their wives and parents – there is no introspection in these letters of the reasons of why they were so far from their homeland. When one seeks to destroy a city...more
An outstanding history - thoroughly researched with first person accounts presented in the third person. Presented in anecdotal form which was utterly insightful. In this day of texting and electronic communications, watch for the author's observations about the teletype communications between Schmidt and Schultz, written over forty years ago. Very hard to put down. Balanced in its humanity.
Living in Ukraine has given me an interest to read more about the Eastern Europe history. I feel like I know almost every inch of Stalingrad (Volograd now). I can't believe the audacity of Hitler and how blindly people followed the little corporal. Stalin was not saint either. The book was about as realistic as I would care to read about the horrors of war.
Of the WWII books I have read, this may be my favorite. It sounds odd, but the author humanized the struggle for Stalingrad. The stories of the individuals caught between a rock and a hard place made me understand how the Soviets/Russians call it the Great Patriotic War. I also realized how important the battle for Stalingrad was in winning the European War.
It's been a while since I read it, but as I recall it was a decent look at the history of the Battle for Stalingrad.
Because of the movie of the same name that came out a few years ago, it needs to be said that the story of Soviet sniper Vassili Zaitsev is only a very small part of the story. It's essentially an extended anecdote in the book
Because of the movie of the same name that came out a few years ago, it needs to be said that the story of Soviet sniper Vassili Zaitsev is only a very small part of the story. It's essentially an extended anecdote in the book
I liked this book, generally speaking. I love WWII history books as a rule, and this was interesting because it had perspectives from both the German and the Russian side, as well as occasional Italian. This book could be riveting at times and extremely dry at times. Having an index with all the characters mentioned would have been helpful.
-En el imaginario popular, la batalla más famosa de la Segunda Guerra Mundial y casi de la Historia-.
Género. Historia.
Lo que nos cuenta. Comenzando en el verano de 1942, y echando un poco la vista atrás para situar al lector, narración del durísimo enfrentamiento en Stalingrado y sus alrededores, que describe también las consecuencias posteriores para muchos de los supervivientes y nos traslada finalmente hasta el año 1955, en el que sus ecos todavía resonaban.
¿Quiere saber más del libro, sin s...more
Género. Historia.
Lo que nos cuenta. Comenzando en el verano de 1942, y echando un poco la vista atrás para situar al lector, narración del durísimo enfrentamiento en Stalingrado y sus alrededores, que describe también las consecuencias posteriores para muchos de los supervivientes y nos traslada finalmente hasta el año 1955, en el que sus ecos todavía resonaban.
¿Quiere saber más del libro, sin s...more
An excellent book that identifies the objectives, forces, and staggering magnitude of the elements of the battle for Stalingrad. In one of the most important battles of the the war, victorious Russian forces began to turn the momentum of the Nazi war machine. This reader enjoyed the book so much that it was twice read.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| World War Two Rea...: 2012 - October - "Enemy at the Gates" by William Craig | 155 | 91 | Dec 08, 2012 10:17am |

Loading...











view 2 comments

Mapa sacado de 


















