46th out of 352 books
—
458 voters
Housekeeping vs. the Dirt (Stuff I've Been Reading #2)
by
Nick Hornby
In this latest collection of essays following "Housekeeping vs. the Dirt," critic and author Hornby continues the feverish survey of his swollen bookshelves, offering a funny, intelligent, and unblinkered account of the stuff he's been reading.
Paperback, 200 pages
Published
September 13th 2006
by McSweeney's
(first published September 10th 2006)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,439)
Lisa Vegan
rated it
As with his The Polysyllabic Spree, the first collection of these columns, Hornby is funny and informative. Perhaps too informative as reading about these books is dangerous if one doesn’t want one’s to-read list to get too much longer. Each essay covers one month of books Hornby bought and books Hornby read.
The structure continues to be inspired but I didn’t enjoy this collection as much as the last one because he goes off in tangents and talks somewhat less about books and because,...more
The structure continues to be inspired but I didn’t enjoy this collection as much as the last one because he goes off in tangents and talks somewhat less about books and because,...more
I can't even begin to say how much I liked this book. Almost enough to subscribe to the Believer, at least, if only for Hornby's essays. At the risk of offending lots of critics, his essays do something that so few book reviews ever do: entertain the reader on their own merits, and and AND, so much more importantly, actually inspire you to WANT to read the books he talks about. A uniquely witty and "literary" (I mean that in the good, intelligent way) reader who actually has, like, ...more
Elizabeth
rated it
Is it wrong to laugh loudly on public transportation? Are people are going to look at you funny? If you are a person, like me, who reads during the commute and is embarrassed by public displays of amusement, read this one in the privacy of your own home. I recommend drawing the curtains as well.
I can't claim that this book was great, by any means. It was witty and informative and entertaining, though, and that's just what I was looking for when I decided to read it.
For those not familiar: "Housekeeping..." is a sort of sequel to Hornby's earlier work "The Polysyllabic Spree." Both of these books were originally published in monthly segments in "The Believer."
The premise of these pieces is to track the contant readers' dilemma: whi...more
For those not familiar: "Housekeeping..." is a sort of sequel to Hornby's earlier work "The Polysyllabic Spree." Both of these books were originally published in monthly segments in "The Believer."
The premise of these pieces is to track the contant readers' dilemma: whi...more
I've previously read and enjoyed Nick Hornby's first book of columns from The Believer, The Polysyllabic Spree, so I was looking forward to his new collection Housekeeping vs. The Dirt. I find his reviewing style refreshingly down to earth and persuasive. I think his writing about music is also first rate, see 31 Songs. I walked away from the first book with 10-12 titles that I wanted to read and all of them lived up to my expectations that were created by Hornby. I think we have similar tastes-...more
I love Nick Hornby so much I get all tongue-tied trying to explain why, and end up just enthusing in what's probably kind of an embarrassing way. This books of essays is just as smart and funny and wonderful as The Polysyllabic Spree, both of which are collections of Hornby's reviews from "The Believer" magazine. Aside from being a great read in and of themselves, the essays have also given me some amazing recommendations for further reading, including books I'd never have heard of o...more
Anyone who knows my reading habits knows how much I love reading books about books. It seems about the only way to read real thoughts on real literature instead of reading flippant gibberish found everywhere else. I say this because anyone willing to take the time to write about books usually has something interesting to say other than the humdrum.
Hornby makes a good point in saying we should not judge those who read pop fiction because we don'tknow if maybe that one crap book may be the g...more
Hornby makes a good point in saying we should not judge those who read pop fiction because we don'tknow if maybe that one crap book may be the g...more
This is going to be a joint review of all three of Nick Hornby's collections of Believer columns.
First off, I need to say I'm deeply relieved that Nick Hornby can write nonfiction, and that's it's just Fever Pitch that is miserable. I was a little worried.
Secondly, you should not read these books if you do not want your list of books to read to grow significantly. While is is part of the Believer's schtick that reviews must be positive (the books he doesn't like must on...more
First off, I need to say I'm deeply relieved that Nick Hornby can write nonfiction, and that's it's just Fever Pitch that is miserable. I was a little worried.
Secondly, you should not read these books if you do not want your list of books to read to grow significantly. While is is part of the Believer's schtick that reviews must be positive (the books he doesn't like must on...more
In his second collection of articles from The Believer, Nick Hornby writes his impressions of various books he has read each month. In his preface, Hornby writes about how writing these articles changed his reading - he started reading those books that he, incredibly, wanted to read - and believes that reading itself should not be, as some people think, a grand slog to read those books that one "should" read, but a fun way to spend free time. Only he says it much more elegantly and per...more
I prefer his first book on reading to this one because he selects books more carefully and it represent his personal taste. But this book still has his thoughtful inner voice and did not lose frankness. Presumably I will read his third book that takes a journey into his personal reading habit. Especially, I love when he talks about his frustration with reading less books during soccer season. He doesn't bother to read more for the magazine. Sometimes personal matter comes first. That's life. I w...more
I picked up this book while whiling away a couple of hours in a Borders. It is the kind of reward that browsing often delivers - you follow your interests and intuition from, say, the crafting to the history section, and somewhere along the way you find an unsought gem. When I came across Nick Hornby's Housekeeping vs. The Dirt, I had been looking for his High Fidelity, to read the source material for the movie I had so enjoyed. Housekeeping vs. The Dirt is Hornby’s monthly accounts of his “book...more
I have to admit that I read Hornby's second collection of essays from the Believer magazine for purely tactical reasons. You see, I made one of these "New Year's resolutions" to read more. And since the other one, eat better and run in the morning before work, didn't pan out, I figured I needed to stick with the reading. So, to complete three books for Jan 09, I removed Housekeeping vs The Dirt from my bookshelf because I knew 1) it was short 2) a fast read and 3) it would be good moti...more
I picked this book off the "to read" pile because I thought "hey, it's a quick read - Nick Hornby and 150 pages or so." Like Nick Hornby I do have a large pile of books I want to read and I'm constantly buying them faster than I can get through them. So it was ironic that I chose this book because it's short; it's really a gateway book- book reviews of everything he's read in an 18 month period and of course I now have a long list of more books I want to buy and read! How ...more
Bottom line: You should read this book because you never once have to laugh at the pomposities of the French Academies of the eighteenth century.
Of course, there are many other good reasons to pick this up. I did so because I was over half an hour early for a meeting near St. Clair station, and was grateful to find that Deer Park library was only steps away from the office. This book immediately jumped out at me, because I was shocked to find that there was a Nick Hornby book in exi...more
Of course, there are many other good reasons to pick this up. I did so because I was over half an hour early for a meeting near St. Clair station, and was grateful to find that Deer Park library was only steps away from the office. This book immediately jumped out at me, because I was shocked to find that there was a Nick Hornby book in exi...more
Perfect to read in little bits, this book sat next to my bathtub for the better part of a month. (shhh don't tell the library). I'm going to admit I skipped over some parts, because sometimes reviews of books you haven't read can be boring, and sometimes Hornby's fake ranting in annoying. I really enjoy that the selected books are not just limited to recent releases, but jump all over the place in time, subject matter and context. What kind of books a person buys, which ones they read and which ...more
Imagine having access to Nick Hornby's Goodreads updates? Well this is pretty close, this collection of monthly columns he wrote for some magazine. Each month he lists what he bought and what he read. Its interesting because, well I love NH so I'm curious as to what he reads. He's such a great bloke, no literary snobbishness here, he just likes to read whatever grabs his interest. His reviews are engaging and he always ends up talking about other things or making excuses that he didn't read much...more
Maybe I'm being too harsh. Maybe I should give this three stars. I'm quite fond of Nick Hornby ("About A Boy" is one of my favorite books) but I found myself disappointed. These essays just seemed inconsistent in quality. His train of thought was too messy and all over the place. I'd get excited at the mention of a certain book in his "books read" column only to find it barely touched upon (one line each on Zadie Smith's and Hanan al-Sheikh's books, really?) Then just when I ...more
Not quite as laugh-out-loud funny as The Polysyllabic Spree, these essays still felt like wee gifts to me. Honestly, there is little I would rather do more than read Nick Hornby writing about reading. We don't really have the same taste in books, much of the time, but I still managed to add quite a few of his picks to my to-read list (as if it needed to get any longer!). He even got me to consider picking up Gilead again, which is quite a feat. I love that he includes excerpts from book he's lov...more
Nick Hornby demonstrates that literary criticism is not dead, but that it is also fun to read. His thoughts on what he reads are as fascinating as the books he buys each month to read. And he does read everything from Marilynne Robinson (Housekeeping) to Motley Crue (The Dirt), covering highbrow literary pursuits to the low brow (thus "The Dirt," which Hornby notes "isn't a bad book" but "it's definitive, if you're looking for the definitive book on vile, abusive, misog...more
I would have given it more stars but the language was too much. Not a lot, but when it was there, yikes! Nick Hornsby is a great writer and I have tried to read a couple of his books because I like his movies but I had to put them down due to language. This book is a collection of essays on books he has been reading that are printed in a newspaper. I was hoping that meant the language was cleaner and for the most part it was. He's a brillant and funny but self deprecating writer and just re...more
Michael
rated it
Note on finishing: Loved it. Really am sad that he won't be doing this column for the Believer anymore, because thanks to him I've unearthed the two Marilynne Robinson novels I own and moved them to the top of the pile. (And discovered that I've purchased at least two copies of Housekeeping, though if memory serves, there's another lurking in a box somewhere with a greenish-yellow cover circa early nineties. Damn.
Also worthwhile if only to discover that Hornby, too, finds Iain Banks...more
Also worthwhile if only to discover that Hornby, too, finds Iain Banks...more
I finished Nick Hornby's second collection of essays, Housekeeping vs. the Dirt sometime last summer, and so this brief review will be sorely lackingk in details. Like his first collection, The Polysyllabic Spree, this volume collects essays originally written for The Believer to chronicle what Hornby has read in the month between issues of the magazine.
Hornby's essays are, as always, well-crafted, and tightly woven, even when he protests that they are not so, but what sticks with me...more
Hornby's essays are, as always, well-crafted, and tightly woven, even when he protests that they are not so, but what sticks with me...more
For the most part, this book is just as engaging and entertaining as Hornby's first book of reading essays. But there is one big reason I am not as in love with this one, and have also lost a bit of respect for Nick Hornby. Normally, I have no problem with people preferring one genre over another. Don't like romance novels? Cool, don't read them. Not a fan of science fiction? Whatever, that's your decision. But when Hornby stated that he was trying to expand the type of stuff he reads by trying...more
Housekeeping vs. The Dirt is a collection of Nick Hornby's columns in The Believer. Since I can't afford a subscription to the magazine I periodically read bits online and I buy Hornby's collections when I find them at a used book shop. I read The Polysyllabic Spree awhile back and didn't even realize another book was out there. Oh my goodness, I just realized the pun in the title. They are both book titles Hornby read and reviewed. Sheesh.
His subtitle is "Fourteen Months of Ma...more
His subtitle is "Fourteen Months of Ma...more
I suppose this book should probably receive five stars -- the writing was light, fun, intelligent, and everything I expect from Hornby -- but I suppose I'm marking him down for the number of books that *I* will now read on his recommendation. Not that I would be annoyed by my ever-growing To Read list, but on the contrary, I expected to find more than a handful from this volume, especially since I was already planning to read several of his choices.
Still, the reviews are excellent a...more
Still, the reviews are excellent a...more
The title represents a range, the superb novel by the sublime Marilynne Robinson is Housekeeping, and The Dirt is the oral history of Motely Crue. The range is Hornby’s reading for a year or so and the collection is his second such month-by-month chronicle of that reading for The Believer magazine. The first, The Polysylabbic Spree, was a wonderful diverting pleasure and this one is quite as enjoyable. Funny, clever, insightful, and charming. Some old jokes (the Spree) and some new ones that tir...more
This book and its predecessor, Polysyllabic Spree, seem to be made for posters on this site. These collections of Hornby's columns for the magazine The Believer are his musings on what he has read this month. Supposedly -and Hornby makes it clear he's not necessarily to be trusted on this or any other topic- the magazine stands by one commandment: "THOU SHALT NOT SLAG ANYONE OFF." This means you're getting a fan's notes more than a critic's analysis.
This seems just the for...more
This seems just the for...more
Hornby is as clever and funny as in his first collection of columns, The Polysyllabic Spree, but I liked this one better for one simple reason: I was familiar with more of the books. I need to flip back through to make sure I've picked out all the ones I want to read, and it's going to be a sizable list.
He focuses on the idea that all reading is good reading, and that all books have some merit. I'll cop to being a book snob, but I'm slowly growing out of it (in large part because I...more
He focuses on the idea that all reading is good reading, and that all books have some merit. I'll cop to being a book snob, but I'm slowly growing out of it (in large part because I...more
After I read and enjoyed Polysyllabic Spree I bought The Believer for a few months just so I could read Hornby's column. I hated it. I didn't think they were that funny and I had a hard time remembering from month to month what he talked about so when he referred back to a previous column I was lost. But reading the columns collected into a book I can follow the month-to-month "story" and find the humor. This was as enjoyable as the first book, chatty and highly entertaining.
This is Hornby's second in a series of articles he published for the literary magazine, The Believer. The intro is one of the best parts of the collection. Hornby pleads the case that there are no "bad" books. In the modern world where so many distractions (family, movies, sports, TV) pull at us, there's no need to struggle through a classic or recommended book that you aren't enjoying. Put the thing down, read something else, and never be ashamed of your reading choices. Just read.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Nick Hornby is the author of the novels A Long Way Down, Slam, How to Be Good, High Fidelity, and About a Boy, and the memoir Fever Pitch. He is also the author of Songbook, a finalist for a National Book Critics Circle Award, Shakespeare Wrote for Money, and The Polysyllabic Spree, as well as the editor of the short-story collection Speaking with the Angel. He is a recipient of the American Aca...more
More about Nick Hornby...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“Please stop patronizing those who are reading a book - The Da Vinci Code, maybe- because they are enjoying it. For a start, none of us know what kind of an effort this represents for the individual reader. It could be his or her first full-length adult novel; it might be the book that finally reveals the purpose and joy of reading to someone who has hitherto been mystified by the attraction books exert on others. And anyway, reading for enjoyment is what we should all be doing. I don't mean we should all be reading chick lit or thrillers (although if that's what you want to read, it's fine by me, because here's something no one else will tell you: if you don't read the classics, or the novel that won this year's Booker Prize, then nothing bad will happen to you; more importantly,nothing good will happen to you if you do); I simply mean that turning pages should not be like walking through thick mud. The whole purpose of books is that we read them, and if you find you can't, it might not be your inadequacy that's to blame. "Good" books can be pretty awful sometimes.”
—
107 people liked it
“I would like my personal reading map to resemble a map of the British Empire circa 1900.”
—
28 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...







view all 6 comments




































