Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Rule Against Murder (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #4)” as Want to Read:
A Rule Against Murder (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #4)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

A Rule Against Murder (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #4)

4.21 of 5 stars 4.21  ·  rating details  ·  16,438 ratings  ·  1,362 reviews
It is the height of summer, and Armand and Reine-Marie Gamache are celebrating their wedding anniversary at Manoir Bellechasse, an isolated, luxurious inn not far from the village of Three Pines. But they're not alone. The Finney family -- rich, cultured, and respectable -- has also arrived for a celebration of their own.
The beautiful Manoir Bellechasse might be surrounded
Hardcover, 322 pages
Published January 20th 2009 by Minotaur Books (first published 2008)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Rule Against Murder, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Rule Against Murder

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Mona Temchin
Another Enjoyable Chief Inspector Gamache Mystery

Book Four of Louise Penny's Chief Inspector Gamache series, "A Rule Against Murder", unlike the previous books, is not set in the picturesque Quebecois village of Three Pines (although the protagonists do pay Three Pines a visit).

Instead, most of the action occurs at the Manoir Bellechasse, a luxurious and remote Quebec Inn (patterned on the real Hovey Manor).

Chief Inspector Armand Gamache of the homicide division of the Montreal Surete and his wi
You know?
These are really growing on me.
Thanks, Mom!

So, here's a stupid conversation I had with my mom last week while we were sitting in the waiting room between doctor's appointments.
Me: "Oh, hey, I'm listening to the next Louise Penny book."
Mom (perks up): "Which one?"
Me: "It's either the fourth or the fifth. It's the one that takes place in the lodge out in the wilderness and there are snotty rich people there while Gamache and his wife, Rene Marie, are celebrating their anniversary."
Her: ".
Aug 29, 2015 Anirudh rated it 2 of 5 stars
Recommended to Anirudh by: Neena
I began reading this book with high expectations. It had received a lot of praise and high ratings. So naturally I was eager to unravel its mysteries. But unfortunately, it was a letdown. I am not sure whether the author was trying to write a crime thriller or a family drama. I would not call this a thriller, as there is no thrill. None what so ever. There were a few good points and a lot of bad points which made me give this book 2 stars. SPOILER ALERTS!!


1. Setting. The protago
Chief Inspector Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie, are celebrating their thirty-five-year wedding anniversary by staying at Manoir Bellechasse for a few days. The rich, cultured, respectable Finney family, an old- or no money family, living in a meritocracy, graces their presence in this remote auberge. One of the family's members desrcibes the family as “seven mad Morrows in a verchère”. The matriarch was now a Finney, but was actually still a Marrow in many ways. So much so, that she wanted a s ...more
Richard Reviles Censorship Always in All Ways
I'm mad at Louise Penny because of book #5 in the Three Pines/Chief Inspector Gamache mysteries, and I want to take it out on her now, but in fairness I just can't. I loved this book as much as I expected to. I thought that moving the action out of Three Pines would make me grumpy, but instead it made me feel, more than ever, that I want to live in Three Pines because Manoir Bellechasse is close for those times I need to get away from the hectic hustle and bustle of Three Pines (snort).

The Gamac
Ivonne Rovira
I've been hooked on Louise Penny's Chief Inspector Armand Gamache series since I read her debut novel, Still Life. Yet, as great as the novels have been, A Rule Against Murder still somehow manages to top all of the previous ones.

As ever, Penny plots out an interesting murder mystery that keeps you guessing until the end. However, what truly will delight the reader are the secrets revealed about Peter Morrow's well-to-do family and one about Armand Gamache himself. The theme of when to remember
Nov 26, 2011 Patti rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Patti by: Robin Agnew gave me an ARC--thank you!
I just want to hang out with Armand Gamache. He is such a calm, practical person to be around, and you just know that he'll figure out who did what and why. In this entry into the series, Armand and his wife, Reine-Marie, are spending their anniversary at their favorite lodge, not far from Three Pines. While they there, a family reunion is going on also, with a family that seems such in name only--they are related to each other, but there is no affection displayed or even seemingly felt among th ...more
I have listened to this series and Inspector Gamache is the perfect companion for my commute. This one took the reader away from Three Pines and I enjoyed the many glimpses into Gamaches life and even his demons. Each one is getting just a bit better as these characters have become more familiar to me, almost like good, comfortable old friends.

The murder in this one left me guessing right up until the reveal....and no guess was correct. Not the who or how. I love when the light bulb comes on a
Moira Fogarty
See, the problem with setting this mystery at Manoir Bellechasse, a vacation resort in the wilderness, is that I go to Three Pines for a mental vacation already. Taking me on vacation from my vacation spot just annoys the heck out of me. I don't want a big house with a fancy chef and bugs full of annoying guests! I want a cozy village with a B&B and regular townfolk. I wished I was at the Clogging Competition instead of hanging out with the totally irredeemably godawful Finney clan. I did no ...more
Patricia Fraser
The second of Louise Penny's Gamache series I've read...each is a stand alone, but there may be merit in reading them in order as the character development is wonderful. Her writing is intelligent and frequently laugh-out-loud funny. I find her descriptions of small events make me appreciate simple things.

Not all her sentences are lengthy, but the following quote is one I wish I'd been thoughtful enough to write. She's speaking of someone escaping from an argumentative, caustic crowd of relation
Claire H
Brilliant. I have finally found a replacement for P.D. James - someone who writes mysteries that are as rich and deep and literate, as gifted at viewing human character, and as high-calibre with building the whodunit, but without the thread of haunting despair that runs through all James novels, particularly her Dalgliesh mysteries. Both writers plunge the reader immediately into a richly layered world, and both explore the surprises, the dusty and ugly corners, the twisty labyrinth of the human ...more
Mary Ellen
I'd really like to give this book 2 1/2 stars. I ended up giving it 3 because I enjoyed the main character, Armand Gamache, very much, and his wife, Reine-Marie, almost as much. (I think I'd like her better if her name weren't Queen Mary...) Gamache reminds me of a French-Canadian Guido Brunetti (for those who don't know him, check out Donna Leon). Or maybe Guido is a Venetian Armand Gamache. Anyway, they are both dedicated, experienced, prudent, happy at home, and eaters and lovers of lots of g ...more
Kathy Davie
Fourth in the Chief Inspector Armand Gamache cozy mystery series set outside Montreal, Canada, and revolving around the inspector.

A Rule Against Murder won the Arthur Ellis Award Finalist for Best Novel in 2009.

My Take
A very intense story about Peter's family. And all those wasted years. The things family does to you that you carry with you all your life. The events that affect how you see the world. What's truly terrifying in this is how unloving they are as they participate in the metaphorical
Feb 26, 2014 Ms.pegasus rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: readers already familiar with the series
Recommended to Ms.pegasus by: browing at my local bookstore
Shelves: fiction, mystery
The Manoir Bellechasse was carved out of the Quebec forest in a past Canadian Gilded Age. Yet it retains its earthy roots. Nearby is tranquil Lac Massawippi, ringed by ancient forests. Chef Véronique harvests honey and beeswax from hives surrounded by blooms of honeysuckle, lilies, and roses. Artisanal cheeses and spirits from a nearby Benedictine abbey stock the larder. At night the stone terrasse embraces a brilliant star-studded sky. This idyllic lodge was cut from logs by coureur de bois ('m ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
- THE MURDER STONE (aka A Rule Against Murder) (Pol Proc-Ins. Gramache-Canada-Cont) – VG+
Penny, Louise – 4th in series
Headline, 2008, UK Hardcover – ISBN: 9780755341009

First Sentence: More than a century ago the Robber Barons discovered Lac Massawippi.

Inspector Armund Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie have come to Manoir Bellechasse where they’ve come for more than 30 years to celebrate their wedding anniversary. They find the rest of the rooms in the small hotel reserved by members of the Finney
this was a bit disappointing to me. first i find out that beauvoir is married!!! it was not mentioned in the first 3 books that i recall and i did send a note to the author. his wife is enid. i missed nichols terribly. i love that character. she is barbara havers! i need her sarcasm and humor. beauvoir also needs that competition for gamache's favor. the sex of the child named bean was never revealed. i wanted to know. this book took me a very long time to read from start to finish. i loved the ...more
Each one in the series gets a little bit better as characters become more fleshed out. There were at least three laugh out loud moments, I think all comments by Gamache. I still want to know about Bean-- boy or girl?
Another wonderfully inventive and humane mystery from Louise Penny! Policeman Armand Gamache and his wife are once again at the luxurious auberge Manoir Bellechasse to celebrate their anniversary. The only other guests are the Finney family, a dysfunctional brood having a family reunion. Armand is astonished when his friends from Three Pines, a lovely village not far from the manor, appear as part of the family. Artists Peter and Clara are at odds with his family, but Peter cannot resist seeing ...more
This "Three Pines Mystery" is the first in the series in which the murder happens somewhere other than the village of Three Pines. A vacation lodge at which Inspector Armand Gamache and his wife are celebrating their anniversary is the setting. Peter and Clara Morrow, from Three Pines, and Peter's family are among the suspects as are all the members of the staff of the lodge. Penny's superb writing and strong characterizations keep the pages turning. We learn about Peter's past and Inspector Gam ...more
Imagine you and a loved one are spending time in one of the most beautiful places, deep in the Quebec wilderness. Full of wild beauty, and breathtaking views....And then imagine being there with the most dysfunctional family you can ever meet. Oh yes, they have a perfect exterior but once you start peeling the layers they are pitifully broken.

And that's how I truly saw them. Each one of the (adult) children believed that they were unloved as children and they took out their hurt on each other.
After a few years of hearing nothing but wonderful things about Louise Penny, I started--yes, I know, uncharacteristically--with this, the fourth book in the series...only because it's the one that presented itself to me. I now want to begin at the beginning and read through to the end; happily, I loved it every bit as much as I expected.

Not only are the main characters well drawn, but Penny's spare descriptions bring to life the minor ones amazingly well. This particular story deals with a remo
Toni Osborne
Published in the USA under the title “A Rule against Murder”

This is an intricate mystery that gives us a new spin in the life and character of Inspector Gamache. Here we see a more personal side of him and his relationship with his wife Reine-Marie.

This old fashion story opens at the Manoir Bellechase, an isolated lodge by Lake Massawippi where the Inspector and Reine-Marie have enjoyed celebrating their wedding anniversary in the past. This year, they find themselves sharing this luxurious inn
Tanja Berg
"We are all blessed and we're all blighted. Every day each of us does our sums. The question is, what do we count?" The prime suspects in this murder mystery is the family of Morrows. After all, it is the sister Julia in a sibling quartet who has been murdered. The Morrows are affluent, most of them, and there is no doubt at all what their sums are. Rarely have I even in literature encountered such a spiteful bunch of people.

Chief Inspector Gamache and his wife are on holiday in an isolated inn
Caroline Taggart
A vaguely unsatisfactory whodunit in terms of plot and character, redeemed by some glorious writing. The action takes place at an out-of-the-way hotel in wildest Quebec, where the province’s head of homicide, Chief Inspector Gamache, is holidaying with his wife. Their fellow guests are a singularly unpleasant family of dysfunctional misfits called the Morrows. (Their utter unpleasantness was, for me, one of the least convincing parts of the book.) One of them is in due course murdered –you can o ...more
This is the third Gamache mystery I've read, with increasing ambivalence. Once again I was intrigued all the way through, wondering how Louise Penny could possibly resolve the crime's seemingly impossible contradictions & complications; & once again -- she didn't! I came away feeling cheated: some of her solutions are just preposterous, so implausible that in the end the whole plot more or less collapsed. Her characters are diverse, mostly realistic, quirky, often fascinating; her settin ...more
As a great admirer of Ms Penny's novels, this one has left me with a less than enthusiastic review. While her characters are always fun, I found this particular outing to be a bit long winded and somewhat lacking in the wit and sarcasm we have come to love in her Three Pines characters.

It was an ok novel, but surely not up to the caliber of the rest of her novels sad to say.
I'm giving this book three stars because I love Louise Penny's writing and Ralph Cosham's narration is as brilliant as always (really five stars.) But Penny is beginning to trouble me with her less than satisfactory solutions to the mystery. It's not that I didn't enjoy the book, I did. But after I finished I kept thinking But that doesn't make sense. But first the good stuff:
This story does not take place in Three Pines, as the other books have, although the little Quebec village does put in a
Jennifer D
louise penny books are little gems of comfort - which always seems so weird, since she's writing murder-mystery stories. but there you go. she has managed to create such charming and endearing character and settings that it doesn't matter if you figure out 'who done it?' early on. you just want to go along on the ride and enjoy each moment. and i really enjoyed this book - the 4th in penny's 'chief inspector gamache' series. it takes place away from the village of 'three pines', so not all of th ...more
I love Three Pines. Although this book played at a place slightly away from it, in the wilderness as Inspector Gamache calls it. The peace was shattered through the murder but still this place and story I will remember.

Who doesn't know that sometimes the family does not agree with each other's lifes or partners but the Morrows were a bit extreme. I would've never guessed that Peter's part of that family. Although I don't particular like him, he seemed rather disturbed and beside himself this ti
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • All Shall Be Well (Duncan Kincaid & Gemma James, #2)
  • Out of the Deep I Cry (Rev. Clare Fergusson & Russ Van Alstyne Mysteries, #3)
  • The Mapping of Love and Death (Maisie Dobbs #7)
  • The Dead in Their Vaulted Arches (Flavia de Luce, #6)
  • White Nights (Shetland, #2)
  • A Matter of Justice (Inspector Ian Rutledge, #11)
Many of Louise Penny's books are published under different titles by UK/Canada and US publishers.
She lives with her husband, Michael, and a golden retriever named Trudy, in a small village south of Montreal.

Her first Armand Gamache novel, "Still Life" won the New Blood Dagger, Arthur Ellis, Barry, Anthony and Dilys Awards.

* Agatha Award: Best Novel
o 2007 – A Fatal Grace – Winner
o 2008 –
More about Louise Penny...

Other Books in the Series

Chief Inspector Armand Gamache (1 - 10 of 12 books)
  • Still Life (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #1)
  • A Fatal Grace (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #2)
  • The Cruelest Month (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #3)
  • The Brutal Telling (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #5)
  • Bury Your Dead (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #6)
  • A Trick of the Light (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #7)
  • The Beautiful Mystery (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #8)
  • How the Light Gets In (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #9)
  • The Long Way Home (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #10)
  • The Nature of the Beast (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #11)
Still Life (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #1) A Fatal Grace (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #2) How the Light Gets In (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #9) Bury Your Dead (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #6) A Trick of the Light (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, #7)

Share This Book

“But you want murderous feelings? Hang around librarians," confided Gamache. "All that silence. Gives them ideas.” 66 likes
“We're all blessed and we're all blighted, Chief Inspector," said Finney. "Everyday each of us does our sums. The question is, what do we count?” 22 likes
More quotes…