Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Sin City, Vol. 3: The Big Fat Kill (Sin City, #3)” as Want to Read:
Sin City, Vol. 3: The Big Fat Kill (Sin City, #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Sin City, Vol. 3: The Big Fat Kill (Sin City #3)

4.09  ·  Rating Details ·  12,271 Ratings  ·  231 Reviews
One of "Sin City's" most fascinatingly conflicted characters, Dwight, returns in "The Big Fat Kill", the third volume of Frank Miller's seminal noir comic and the inspiration for one of the segments of the blockbuster "Sin City" film! This third edition is newly redesigned and features a brand-new cover by Miller - some of his first comics art in years! For Dwight, sometim ...more
Paperback, Third Edition, 184 pages
Published October 27th 2010 by Dark Horse (first published 1996)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Sin City, Vol. 3, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Sin City, Vol. 3

Watchmen by Alan MooreSoon I Will Be Invincible by Austin GrossmanThe Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay by Michael ChabonBatman by Frank MillerHero by Perry Moore
Superhero Fiction
63rd out of 563 books — 981 voters
Watchmen by Alan MooreThe Complete Maus by Art SpiegelmanV for Vendetta by Alan MooreThe Sandman, Vol. 1 by Neil GaimanBatman by Frank Miller
Required Reading Graphic Novels
220th out of 825 books — 1,576 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jul 30, 2015 Algernon rated it really liked it
Shelves: comics, 2015

By the third tradeback album, readers should no longer be surprised at the excessive violence, nudity and cussing that define night life in Basin City. The question is not if things are about to go worse, but into what kind of horrible manner will the s--t hit the fan next. The Big Fat Kill starts with a case of domestic violence as a former minor character, the waitress Shellie, is battered in her own apartment by an old flame. By the end of the installment we will witness wholesale slau
The Big Fat Kill: One of the most original Sin City stories
Originally posted at Fantasy Literature
The Big Fat Kill is the third volume in Frank Miller’s SIN CITY series, featuring Dwight McCarthy, Marv, and the ladies of Old Town delivering justice with extreme prejudice to some very deserving goons. It’s another celebration of violent revenge against some pretty reprehensible people, so it goes down fairly easily. It’s also the most creative storyline of the first three volumes, and is featur
Apr 28, 2015 Carmen rated it did not like it
Recommends it for: No One
Recommended to Carmen by: Book Store

Dwight's the MC again, and I don't like him.

Also, I have some questions:

1.) Why didn't Dwight take care of the men BEFORE Shellie got beaten?

2.) Why didn't Shellie tell him Jackie-boy was a cop before? Like, way before?

3.) Why didn't Jackie-boy, when in Old Town, being threated/maimed by the whores, tell them he was a cop? It would have been a simple, quick solution to his problems and it's RIDICULOUS that he didn't mention it. I mean he was drunk, but not THAT drunk, and getting hur
Jun 30, 2012 Melki rated it really liked it
The best of the series so far.

This time the curvy gals of Old Town have gone too far and killed the wrong man.

No. Let's rephrase that. They killed the right man, at the wrong time, and in definitely the wrong place. This guy will be missed.

Soon, cops and the mob will be swarming the place. Deals will be broken.

And let's face it...nobody wants to see that many 38DDs shot full of holes.

Now guess who's gotta clean up the mess before all hell breaks loose?

Will there be enough body bags in Sin City
Nov 25, 2013 Felisberto rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2013

Surpreendentemente fabuloso. É, "Sin City"!!!

Este volume de "Sin City" é qualquer coisa de espectacular. Vi-me mergulhado no gosto pelo perigoso; mortalmente envolvido pelas vicissitudes da vida criminosa.

"Temos que matar até ao último destes cabrões. Até ao último.
Não por vingança.
Não porque eles merecem.
Não porque vai tornar o mundo num local melhor.
Não há nada de justo ou de nobre nisto.
Temos que os matar, porque precisamos deles bem mortos." (in Sin City, pp. 61 & 62)

É assim, em Sin Ci

Further proof that Sin City is the truest movie adaptation of comic book source material. This series might be my favorite in comics. Period.

Michael Benavidez
Oct 06, 2014 Michael Benavidez rated it really liked it
While I do enjoy this volume, it seems less focused on the characters and more on the action filled plot. Where as the last two were focused on the character's state of mind, this one seems merely content to let the action push them forward.
That isn't to say it isn't a good part, the best moments come when there is no action and merely reflection on the events that are taking place.
Jack van Riel
Graphic Novels are hard to rate. This gets maybe 2 stars for the story, 5 for the art.

Brutal pulp noir story filled with with half-naked bad-ass prostitutes with guns, a nihilistic cold-blooded bastard of a hero, mercenaries that kill for pleasure, abusive drunks, swastika-shaped ninja stars that slice off body parts, severed and exploding heads, and lots and lots of shooting and killing.

What is it with highly stylized, uncompromising, visually striking ultraviolence that's so fascinating? Why d
Feb 05, 2014 Vivienne rated it liked it
Sin City is considered among the best noir comics ever created. Based on volume three, I don't know why. The storyline seems to be an excuse for pseudo-porn images of gun-toting prostitutes, and the monochrome art style is hard on the eyes. It was an entertaining short read, but I'd forgotten I'd read it within 24 hours, probably because I had zero emotional engagement with the characters. They were as one-dimensionally violent and underdressed as the cast of a Michael Bay movie. Vol 3 does noth ...more
Oct 27, 2010 Tom rated it it was ok
Shelves: comics
More of the same...I'll probably finish the series just to satisfy my inner completionist, but Frank Miller's style can grow tired after a couple of these. His characters aren't complex or rich enough to make this series something special.
Nicolo Yu
Jan 25, 2014 Nicolo Yu rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: sdcc-2008-hauls
The Sin City movie made me want to check the original graphic novels. I found this lone Sin City hardcover at a dealer table at a discount and I just got to have it. I like the story but I found myself preferring the movie over the book.
Nov 15, 2014 Trey rated it liked it
A few random observations three volumes in:

1) The first page of issue five is an explanation of King Leonidas of Sparta's defense against the Persian army. Is this the first time Miller wrote about this in a comic? I bet researching the info for this page got him excited for 300, which came out about four years later.

2) For someplace supposedly in a desert region, it sure rains a lot in Sin City. It's rained in each volume so far. You know, the kind of rain "that doesn't hit Sin City more than
Oct 14, 2010 abatage rated it really liked it
Shelves: graphic-novels
By now it's easy to know what kind of deal you're getting into with a Sin City book. The art is consistently stark and dramatic, while the story runs the gamut of noir possibilities. Fortunately though, this doesn't seem to matter.

Part of me is glad to see how well the books were translated into film version, as most of the scenes and dialogue are carbon copies. Although, while the film was incredible, it has nothing on the books. There's just something about the way Miller collects panels and d
Aug 12, 2016 Manuel rated it liked it
Shelves: comics
Storia deboluccia rispetto ai due volumi precedenti. Mentre nei primi due episodi Miller si concentrava a lungo sulla psicologia dei personaggi, in questo caso lascia da parte qualunque approfondimento e ci presenta esclusivamente la solita storia di violenza. Divertente, okay, ma oggettivamente di qualità inferiore. Oltretutto è il volume più breve finora, e ci sono un sacco di vignette che occupano una pagina intera senza alcun dialogo e spesso senza neppure chissà che disegni impressionanti. ...more
Jun 18, 2015 ashlee rated it really liked it
this sin city volume is a more in depth look at "old town" and we are introduced to all of the girls. We meet dwight's "valkyrie woman" and "deadly little miho" and they're both equally badass! there is lots of action, great art and vulgar dialogue, everything essential in a great sin city comic :)
Aug 11, 2014 Selwa rated it really liked it
Volume 3, more of the same, which isn't a bad thing. As another reviewer pointed out, this could easily have been added to volume 2, but for me that doesn't detract from the story, the art, the things that make this a fun and fast read. Can't wait to continue with the series!
Feb 13, 2015 John rated it it was amazing
This book was a real showcase for the girls of Oldtown.Gail and Miho really shinned in this one.Plenty of beautiful babes,bad guys,and big guns.What more could a guy ask for.This series is lights out so far.
Aug 12, 2016 Dan rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
The events of this book were a chapter in the first Sin City movie.
Dmitry Yakovenko
Aug 23, 2014 Dmitry Yakovenko rated it really liked it
Shelves: 2014
Третий том "Города Грехов" вышел таким же грязным и порочным, как и первые два. Стоит лишь открыть первую страницу, а ты уже начинаешь чувствовать похоть проституток старого города, алчность продажных копов и жажду легкой наживы обыкновенных преступников. О да, это снова Фрэнк Миллер, Город Грехов и наш старый знакомый Дуайт МакКарти.

Снова Дуйат попадает в огромные неприятности, когда решает защитить свою девушку от ее распоясавшегося бывшего. Однако дело принимает неожиданный поворот, когда в с
Luis Reséndiz
Feb 05, 2015 Luis Reséndiz rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: canasta-básica
este es probablemente el tomo mejor tramado de sin city --de los tres que he leído hasta ahora en mi relectura. plantea su set-up con cuidado (la tregua entre policías y prostitutas de old town, susceptible de romperse con la muerte de un oficial o una prostituta), articula perfecto detalles que más tarde serán significativos, como el grito de shellie o la afición por las detonaciones de uno de los mercenarios. esto va creando la sensación de que todo en la historia tiene un motivo, de que las c ...more
The dark, violent romp of Sin City returns with Dwight McCarthy. When his new girlfriend Shellie is threatened and punched by a drunk ex-boyfriend, Dwight recklessly follows him to Old Town in order to make sure he doesn’t hurt anyone else. In Old Town, “the cops stay out”… which “leaves the girls free to keep the pimps and the mob out.”

Miller hasn’t just created a world of unrelated events in Sin City. Instead, The Big Fat Kill continues a different story with the familiar character of Dwight,
Dec 22, 2014 Jerry rated it it was amazing
I love the book, the story kept me hook. The book is full of action and surprises.
Larry Gagnon
Feb 02, 2013 Larry Gagnon rated it really liked it
The "Sin City" graphic novels by Frank Miller delivers a completely magnificent and engaging story, albeit on the dark side! The art work is so creative. Each page, each illustration captures your imagination and enhances the story further. You feel like you are getting pummeled by an engaging energy, something like not being able to stop eating hot, spicy food. And a last warning, if you don't like gruesome, you might not want to pick this book up.
Jose Miguel
Sep 01, 2016 Jose Miguel rated it it was amazing
By god, is this series ever going to low its quality? The Big Fat Killing is the third installment in the Sin City franchise and I'll be damned, it does just get better in every chapter. It bring some familiar faces, specially Dwight, who was also the main character in the previous book, but also introducing new one's that'll serve a purpose in the plot ahead. Miller's writing is there, and is just as good as you can expect it to be. The art? The perfect representation of a noir strip you can ev ...more
The hero kills because the hooker he loves ends up dead; there's a homosexual bishop protecting his canibal gay-lover; the hero chops off a mans limbs then feeds him to hungry dogs; and it never stops raining. Okay, Frank Miller, we get it - you're gritty. I find all the Sin City books so over-the top bad-ass blood, guts, and sex that I have a hard time not laughing when I read them. Sorry, but its true.
Sep 09, 2014 Adam rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
جلد سوم از مجموعه کمیک نئونوآر "شهر گناه" از فرانک میلر.

چیزی که خیلی جالبه، ارتباط جلدها به هم دیگه است، در عین بی ارتباطی داستان هاشون. مثلاً شخصیتی که توی جلد یک قهرمانه، توی جلد دو یه حضور کوتاه داره و به قهرمان جلد دو، کمک مختصری میکنه. خوشم میاد از این کارش. واقعاً احساس میکنه آدم که همه ی این اتفاقا توی یه شهر به نام باسین سیتی افتاده.
Dec 20, 2014 Diego rated it liked it
Es la segunda historia de Dwight McCarthy y Gail. A mi parecer, el argumento es un poco flojo, pero no dejan de ser entretenido los diálogos y la forma de matar de Miho.

Hay una parte de la historia donde se hace referencia a Leónidas y la batalla de las Termopilas; supongo que Frank Miller ya estaba pensando en llevar al cómic esta historia.
Nov 17, 2011 Mohammed rated it really liked it
A re-read because i like Frank Miller artwork in Sin City series and think its his best period. This story, volume is not the best in the series because the writing is not up to the same class as the art is. Not like The Hard Goodbye story.
Feb 21, 2015 Bobby rated it it was ok
Closer to 2.5 stars, but not enough to go three. Of the first three books in the series, this is the weakest so far. It takes awhile to get the story rolling, and when it does, it's blood and guts fun, but then it gets resolved awfully quick. Dwight is the protagonist, but it's Miho the assassin who is the most interesting of the bunch.

There's nothing wrong with style over plot/substance, especially in a crime tale, but the style was nothing new to Sin City, and not enough to keep the plot from
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • 100 Bullets, Vol. 2: Split Second Chance
  • Preacher, Volume 5: Dixie Fried
  • Hellboy, Vol. 6: Strange Places (Hellboy, #6)
  • The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Vol. 2
  • Akira, Vol. 2
  • Transmetropolitan, Vol. 3: Year of the Bastard (Transmetropolitan, #3)
Frank Miller is an American writer, artist and film director best known for his film noir-style comic book stories. He is one of the most widely-recognized and popular creators in comics, and is one of the most influential comics creators of his generation. His most notable works include Sin City, The Dark Knight Returns, Batman Year One and 300.

Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the
More about Frank Miller...

Other Books in the Series

Sin City (7 books)
  • Sin City, Vol. 1: The Hard Goodbye (Sin City, #1)
  • Sin City, Vol. 2: A Dame to Kill For (Sin City, #2)
  • Sin City, Vol. 4: That Yellow Bastard (Sin City, #4)
  • Sin City, Vol. 5: Family Values (Sin City, #5)
  • Sin City, Vol. 6: Booze, Broads, and Bullets (Sin City, #6)
  • Sin City, Vol. 7: Hell and Back (Sin City, #7)

Share This Book


Stay smart. Stay cool. It's time to prove to you're friends that you're worth a damn.
Sometimes that means dying.
Sometimes it means killing a whole lot of people.”
“She doesn't quite chop his head off.
She makes a Pez dispenser out of him.”
More quotes…