Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Lucky Breaks (The Hard Pan Trilogy, #2)” as Want to Read:
Lucky Breaks (The Hard Pan Trilogy, #2)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Lucky Breaks (The Hard Pan Trilogy #2)

3.75 of 5 stars 3.75  ·  rating details  ·  709 ratings  ·  179 reviews
"Eleven is much more intrepid than only ten."

On the eve of her eleventh birthday, Lucky wants to let loose and become intrepid; she's ready for life to change. But Hard Pan (population 43) drones on like it always has: Lincoln all tied up in knotty matters, Miles newly diagnosed as a genius but as needy as ever, Brigitte running her Café and trying to figure out what it
Hardcover, 192 pages
Published March 10th 2009 by Atheneum Books for Young Readers (first published January 1st 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Lucky Breaks, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Lucky Breaks

Catching Fire by Suzanne CollinsWhen You Reach Me by Rebecca SteadThe Evolution of Calpurnia Tate by Jacqueline KellyWhere the Mountain Meets the Moon by Grace LinThe Magician's Elephant by Kate DiCamillo
Newbery 2010
56th out of 103 books — 537 voters
The Hunger Games by Suzanne CollinsLittle Brother by Cory DoctorowThe Host by Stephenie MeyerGraceling by Kristin CashorePaper Towns by John Green
ALD 2009 YA Booklist - Fiction
36th out of 65 books — 47 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,152)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
[Insert usual why-can't-a-book-be-a-standalone-book-anymore rant here. Also: there will be a third, or at least that's the implication in Patron's acknowledgments at the end. ]

As her eleventh birthday draws near, Lucky finds herself wanting just one thing: a girlfriend. Lincoln's been her best friend for years, but lately Lucky's looking at him more critically: he's always so calm and rational, and so caught up in his knot-tying, and the secret project he's working on for the knotting competitio
In her first companion novel to the Newbery Medal-winning The Higher Power of Lucky, author Susan Patron has managed to do something rare and quite beautiful: evoke all of the charm stitched into the seams of the original while tackling issues old and new that force Lucky to stretch her heart and mind to their fullest capacity.

Susan Patron is an excellent, wonderfully sensitive writer, capturing with grace and nuanced skill the moods and conversations of the kids that populate Lucky Breaks. Sh
Brooke Shirts
Another return to Lucky Trimble and the eccentric inhabitants of Hard Pan, California. Like its predecessor, The Higher Power of Lucky, it moves at a leisurely pace, low on plot and high on minute observations of inner turmoil. Lucky gets a new best friend, and worries that her other best friend, Lincoln, is growing apart from her. The solution? Sabotage.

Yeah. I was there to read about it, and I still can't quite figure out why Lucky does the things she does. This is a book about the desire to b
The Library Lady
I noticed she made sure to get the word "scrotum" in again. Hee, hee, hee....

Update: In fact, she got it in twice!
I enjoyed this, but I found the pacing a bit off--it needed something more before the final chapter. I know this is now part of a planned trilogy and it feels a little as if she was hurrying to finish this one and move on to the third book.

BTW, I don't find Lucky's thoughts or language unusually advanced for her age--she sounds a lot like my own thoughtful almost 10 year old. Besides
"The beauty of Patron’s 'Lucky' books thus far, is while connections and meaning can be found in the stories, they are still really character-driven and encapsulated ideas are held in balance. Lucky is eleven and this is what is going on in her world. Character-driven plots are ever dangerous, of course, because if the reader finds none of the characters or their struggles endearing… Yet, many have responded to these novels, feel invested in one or more of the characters. Patron has written some ...more
What do you do when you are about to be eleven, you live in small town, and all you want to be is intrepid? In author Susan Patron’s follow-up to The Higher Power of Lucky, we meet again with the day-dreaming girl named Lucky, one of the forty-three individuals who inhabit the small California town of Hard Pan. Like most children, ten-year-old Lucky believes that her life will be more exciting when she turns one year older. But when exciting things don’t happen as quickly on their own for Lucky ...more
Eh. I just do not see what the Newbery committee sees.

I like Lucky. I like the relationship between Lucky and Paloma, and of course, Brigitte is always solid. But the star of this book, to me, was Lincoln. He was kind, loyal, trustworthy, mature, and incredibly patient with Lucky, who was downright mean to him.

Oh--and the burro. He rocked.

My major problem with this book is a picky thing, something that drove me nuts. It was Patron's continual referencing to Lucky's glands: The meanness gland in
Does every outstanding children's book have to have a sequel or be written into a series? I was a little disappointed that Patron went this route. There is nothing wrong with Lucky Breaks, but I can't help but compare it to Higher Power of Lucky. In comparison, this volume seems a little formulaic and lackluster. Lucky gets into some hijinks, the word scrotum is uttered, and then all is well in the land of Hard Pan. The End.
Will I keep reading Lucky books? Probably. But only to find out what hap
As is so often the case, I'd rather leave characters I liked just as I left them. Continuing the story of Lucky, Lincoln, Brigitte, and Miles feels forced here, as does the continuing referral to the bitten dog.

Lucky decides it's time for a new best friend when Lincoln's knot tying just might win him a trip away from her to spend a year in England. New character Paloma is likeable enough, but the story lacked the character development and sincerity of the first book. I suspect these characters
It was amazing!
Theresa Milstein
Lucky is a year older, but not a year wiser. She becomes outright mean. Instead of character growth, she regressed. In the previous book, her running away felt authentic. This time, her meltdown was self-inflicted and selfish. When people come for the rescue, she scorns. It's difficult to know why people befriend her when she's so selfish. Pretty words too late don't erase bad behavior.

Though there's charm and some acute observations, this fell flat for me.
Sheela Word
Wonderful sequel to the "The Higher Power of Lucky." Lucky makes a new friend...a girl...but what can she do to keep Lincoln and Miles out of the picture? The emotional stakes are not as high as in the first book (Brigitte is here to stay), but Lucky manages to create some serious trouble for herself. I love "Hard Pan," as improbable as it is, and I love a girl protagonist who models herself after Charles Darwin. My daughter, age 10, adores this series too.
On the eve of her eleventh birthday, Lucky wants to let loose and become intrepid; she's ready for life to change. But Hard Pan (population 43) drones on like it always has: Lincoln all tied up in knotty matters, Miles newly diagnosed as a genius but as needy as ever, Brigitte running her Café and trying to figure out what it means to be American.

Enter Paloma, tagging along on a visit to Hard Pan with a pack of hungry geologists. She's smart and pretty and fun -- definitely best-friend material.
This doesn't live up to the first. It reminded me of books I read in grade school, though, which was good.
2 1/2 stars

As posted on Outside of a Dog:

I’ll admit to not being much of a fan of Susan Patron’s Newbery winning The Higher Power of Lucky. It wasn’t that I disliked the book, but simply looked at it after its win and said, “What’s special? What’s distinguished?” As a librarian, I see the book sit on the shelf mostly, occasionally checked out by teachers or college students. For these reasons, I wasn’t in a hurry to pick up the sequel, Lucky Breaks. But a recent challenge I set myself found me p
This past weekend, I finished Lucky Breaks in ARC form and my happiness glands and sadness glands are both still pumping. Sequels are generally to be approached with trepidation but not in this case. Susan Patron has delivered a story that I think sings even more beautifully than The Higher Power of Lucky. Don't get me wrong: I adored that book (so much so, in fact, that I didn't even register "the word" on page 1 in first reading). Susan tells the stories of the hardscrabble folks of Hardpan wi ...more
Madigan McGillicuddy
In this wonderful sequel to The Higher Power of Lucky, we return to the dusty micro-town of Hard Pan, California. Lucky's meandering thoughts and careful appreciation of little details is explored in a quirky and whimsical fashion. She sees eleven as being intrepid and cherishes the "secret 11" in the straps of her new training bra. At eleven years of age, she is clearly looking forward to growing up, wearing make-up and other such things that are just ahead of her... yet she is still happy to n ...more
Review of all three books in the 'Hard Pan Trilogy'

Lucky Trimble lives in Hard Pan, California, in a canned-ham bedroom attached to a trailer. She lives with Brigitte, who is not her mother but her biological father's French ex-wife. Brigitte came to Hard Pan all the way from France because Lucky's father asked her to, after Lucky's mother went out into the desert after a storm and was struck dead by lightening.

So for now Lucky lives with Brigitte, who calls her 'petite puce' which sounds l
A heartwarming story, centered on the character of Lucky, who's about to turn 11. She and the younger Miles are going to have a big birthday celebration with all the residents of their desert town of Hard Pan (population 43). The town may be small, but it's full of Old Desert Rat Characters, and lots of love. Lucky's still trying to figure out who she is and how she feels about life. When the 'ologists arrive to do their scientific work, and they bring along a girl of Lucky's age, she realizes s ...more
Jennifer Wardrip
Reviewed by Sally Kruger aka "Readingjunky" for

LUCKY BREAKS is the second book in Susan Patron's THE HIGHER POWER OF LUCKY trilogy. It continues the story of Lucky, who lives in the middle of the desert in a tiny town called Hard Pan.

Lucky is about to turn eleven, and she can hardly wait. She is sure that being eleven will cause her life to be much more exciting than being ten. After all, being eleven is at "the door of becoming a teenager."

Not a whole lot has changed in Lucky's
Jason Pettus
(I now maintain a blog just for my kid-lit reviews. Find it at .)

A friend has convinced me to try my hand this year for the first time at writing children's literature; but I don't actually know anything about children's literature, so am starting the process among other ways by first reading a stack of existing books that have been recommended to me. This is the 2009 sequel to Susan Patron's The Higher Power of Lucky, winner of the 2006 Newbery Award (and which
Lucky returns after her success in The Higher Power of Lucky, with her most appealing character traits. Her life in Hard Pan, CA, a miniscule settlement in the Mojave Desert, proves to be a rich and enjoyable locale for taking in her almost-eleven-year-old mind-set. She chooses Darwin as a role model, and sets about being intrepid without always being appropriately thoughtful about where this pursuit might lead. Her two local friends, contemporary knot-tyer Lincoln and gifted five year Miles are ...more
Lincolnwood Public LIbrary
I love quirky characters and novels that have a strong sense of place and Susan Patron's books featuring Lucky Trimble have both. I adore Lucky. She's plucky, spunky and far from perfect(her pride and jealousy in this particular book are spot on.)
The town of Hard Pan is fascinating, and the 43 people who live their form a family of their own. It is a place that falls on the lower end of the socioeconomic scale and yet that fact is never even presented as a problem, an issue, or a negative. In H
I love quirky characters and novels that have a strong sense of place and Susan Patron's books featuring Lucky Trimble have both. I adore Lucky. She's plucky, spunky and far from perfect(her pride and jealousy in this particular book are spot on.)
The town of Hard Pan is fascinating, and the 43 people who live their form a family of their own. It is a place that falls on the lower end of the socioeconomic scale and yet that fact is never even presented as a problem, an issue, or a negative. In H
Kathie Jackson
Susan Patron does it again! In her second installment of this trilogy, Lucky is about to turn 11 in her hometown of Hard Pan, Calif., pop. 43. All our favorite characters return: Lucky's friend Milo the 5-year old genius; Lincoln the child knot-tying prodigy; Lucky's foster mother Brigitte; HMS Beagle, Lucky's mutt named after the ship of her idol Charles Darwin; and family friend Short Sammy who made his home from an abandoned water tank. Things get exciting when a group of "ologists" visit Har ...more
Elaine Bearden
Sequel to The Higher Power of Lucky. For grades 3-6. Patron has a great sense of the emotions that are part of growing up, and includes those kind of details in her writing. I think the first book in the series is stronger. I felt like this plot sometimes dragged along. (Perhaps since it is the second book in a trilogy, like Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins.) I also thought the author used a lot of details from our now-lives (ie: google, etc.) - words that will quickly date the story, which make ...more
Sandra Stiles
Lucky Trimble believes that at age 11 she is so much more grown up. Her word for it is intrepid. This prompts her to do things she would not have done at age 10. She is surrounded by an eclectic group of kids. Lincoln is becoming known for his knot tying ability, and miles is a six year old genius. The lady who is Lucky’s guardian runs a French Restaurant. Then there is Lucky. If she just had a best girl friend everything would be alright. Enter Paloma. Lucky invites Paloma to spend the weekend ...more
I enjoyed this book the most of the trilogy. I like the variety of characters, new and old, human and animal. Lucky makes a new friend and comes to understand her old friends better. There is some excitement when the kids go looking for treasure at the bottom of a well. I think it could stand alone. It would be fun to booktalk from the standpoint of the unusual setting, humor and bit of adventure.
It can't be easy to write a sequel to a Newbery Medal winner, with all those high expectations to meet, but Susan Patron has done a beautiful job with LUCKY BREAKS, her follow-up to THE HIGHER POWER OF LUCKY, and I find myself getting to know and love Lucky all over again.

This book comes with the same pitch-perfect, lyrical language as the first, with some new twists. Lucky is eleven now, and she's beginning to ask more questions about life, about her relationship with Lincoln, about that box in
Listened to this at my children's request during a long car ride. We liked it a fair amount, even if not quite as much as the first book. Characters who make mean choices that they then agonize over always resonate with me. We'll undoubtedly listen to the third book during our next car trip.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 38 39 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Fartiste
  • What Happened on Fox Street
  • Penny Dreadful
  • Ellie McDoodle: Have Pen, Will Travel
  • Crunch
  • Alvin Ho: Allergic to Dead Bodies, Funerals, and Other Fatal Circumstances (Alvin Ho, #4)
  • The Vanishing Violin (The Red Blazer Girls, #2)
  • The Case of the Gypsy Good-bye (Enola Holmes Mysteries, #6)
  • Dogs and Cats
  • The Last Newspaper Boy in America
  • Alchemy and Meggy Swann
  • Melonhead
  • Heart of a Shepherd
  • The Secret of Zoom
  • Dessert First
  • Bird
  • My One Hundred Adventures (My One Hundred Adventures #1)
  • Younguncle Comes to Town
Susan Patron specialized in Children's Services for 35 years at the Los Angeles Public Library before retiring in 2007, the same year her novel The Higher Power of Lucky was awarded the John Newbery Medal. As the library's Juvenile Materials Collection Development Manager, she trained and mentored children's librarians in 72 branches. Patron has served on many book award committees, including the ...more
More about Susan Patron...

Other Books in the Series

The Hard Pan Trilogy (3 books)
  • The Higher Power of Lucky (The Hard Pan Trilogy, #1)
  • Lucky for Good (The Hard Pan Trilogy, #3)

Share This Book

“When you are sad, your heart pumps the tragedy all through your body and fills your mind with the story of your suffering, and you tell that story to yourself over and over.” 8 likes
“The whole world is full of danger. But also it is full of beauty and courage and many wonders.” 4 likes
More quotes…