Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Story of a Secret State” as Want to Read:
Story of a Secret State
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Story of a Secret State

4.3 of 5 stars 4.30  ·  rating details  ·  294 ratings  ·  66 reviews
In Nazi-occupied Poland, schools, courts and newspapers were operated by the Polish Underground secretly, right under the nose of the Gestapo. The author who was liaison officer between the underground and the exiled Polish government in London, wrote this amazing report right after the liberation.
Paperback, 391 pages
Published November 1st 2001 by Simon Publications (first published 1944)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Story of a Secret State, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Story of a Secret State

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,024)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Kinga
As the resident Pole on Bookmunch I have received this book for reviewing and now I am afraid I won’t do it justice. Going through years of the Polish education system, I didn’t think I wanted or needed to know anything more about World War II, the occupation, the Gestapo or the Holocaust. I was wrong. Jan Karski’s Story of a Secret State should be a compulsory read for everyone. I am not saying this because I am Polish and we like to inform the whole world about our heroic, albeit forgotten dee...more
Lorenzo Berardi
Now, this one was extremely good.
And it's hard to believe how "Story of a Secret State" had to wait for so long before being re-published.

Jan Karski - a nom de plume, pardon d'action - wrote this book with the extreme urgency of a man who has just managed to get through four years of war, starvation, captivity and, on the top of it, a dangerous clandestine patriotic activity.
A brilliant combination, isn't it?

Nevertheless, "Story of a Secret State" is written very well with its author never claim...more
Elizabeth Moffat
This is one of the most intriguing and exciting books about World War II, primarily the Polish resistance, that I have read. The bravery and determination of Karski is outstanding, his tale-telling superb, and it made for quite an emotional read.
Valerie
'Jan Karski' was not the man's original name. It started out as his nom du guerre, and remained as his name for the rest of his life.

Early in this book, Karski mentions that while retreating at the beginning of the war, he stopped over in what was then known as the village of Oswiecm. Later, of course, it developed much greater notoreity as the nearest town to the camp that later was named Auschwitz.

I first learned of Karski because, as a courier from the Polish Underground to the Polish governm...more
Janet
A fascinating account, published in 1944, of Poland in the Second World War. Author Jan Karski was a handsome young gentleman enjoying life, working on his doctorate in demography, the science and statistics of populations, when Hitler invaded Poland. His amazing transformation from wealthy citizen/student to cavalry officer to spy/saboteur is detailed as the Polish Underground was formed to fight the Nazi presence. Unlike the Russians (See the Gulag Archepelago), the Polish did love freedom eno...more
Bob Petry
This is an amazing biography. There is enough action, political intrigue, and horror for 3 or 4 movies. An unbelievable true story of a man secretly and abruptly called to war from his world of elite society parties. Captured by the Russians, he escapes by posing as a working-class private right into a German cattle car enroute to a "camp." Escaping from the Gestapo multiple times, Karski finds himself as courier, spy and propagandist in the Polish underground. At one point he even sold bonds fo...more
Maria
Story of a proud Polish patriot who began working for the Polish Underground and helped establish the Polish Government-in-exile during the German occupation of World War II.

He goes from a life of privilege as a 25 year old officer in the Polish army to a life of hiding, subterfuge and at times, exhausting anxiety borne from love of country.

When captured and tortured by the Gestapo: "I had to persist in my story as if it were a magical incantation that would prevent me from blurting out the dama...more
Rachel Choate
I picked up this book while doing a study of resistance to Hitler. This narrative of the Polish underground is phenomenal. I often had to remind myself that it is nonfiction. I was amazed at the amount of detail he was able to print in the midst of the war. Karski's account of the work he and others did to thwart the Nazi occupiers reads like a espionage novel complete with fake passports, double agents, bumbling villains and prison escapes. His writings about the Warsaw ghetto and his visit to...more
Clara Mazzi
Polonia. Parola a cui non riesco ad associare nè un paesaggio, nè una forma di cultura o di storia importante. Tranne purtroppo che i campi di sterminio e un vivo antisemitismo. Ho deciso di leggere il libro di Karski perchè invece racconta l'autobiografia di questo uomo che si è dedicato con passione alla Resistenza polacca, al combattere i tedeschi e la loro oppressione e ha portato avanti, tutto da solo, la situazione folle degli ebrei davanti ai grandi del mondo. Un libro interessantissimo,...more
Pat Stearman
An amazing and sometimes very uncomfortable look at a subject I thought I knew a bit about, but didn't really! The Underground in Poland in WW2. Surprised at how the Poles had a complete government not only in exile as the French did but also in Poland. Schools - another thing I hadn't thought of - what happens to a society after 5 or 10 years of a war in which the children are not educated at all? What happens when an entire generation has been practically starved?
There is a lot about the poli...more
Paul Doucette
Really enjoyed the book. It's written by a professor, sadly now deceased, of mine at Georgetown. Karski has got to be one of the few people smuggled into and out of the Nazi death camps in Poland. He eventually gained a private interview with FDR, giving the President undeniable proof of what the Nazis were doing in the death camps. Sadly the allies did not act on Karski's information.
Kim
Good book. An autobiographical book by Jan Karski, a Polish resistant fighter during WWII. He worked as a courier in the Resistance and saw firsthand and reported on the situation of Poland's Jews. His autobiography is calm, methodical, and not dramatized. Although he certainly got himself into some pretty life-or-death situations, he recounts the events, what led up to them, and how he responded in a measured and restrained way. This book was originally written in 1944 but has only recently bee...more
Nigel
What a man, what a time to be such a man, and thank God for such men
Jason
I will never tell another polack joke again. The Polish are some of the bravest people on the planet. When Europe was falling in the early 40's the Polish, already defeated in 39', had created a complete government, hidden and ready to rise from the ashes.(The context of the book was written before the end of the war so Karski did not know what would befall Poland via the USSR) The courage of the Polish Jews, facing extinction, make a last attempt to get the world to pay attention to what they b...more
Patrick Neylan
Jan 02, 2013 Patrick Neylan rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Patrick by: Amazon Vine
For all the praise it's received, Story Of A Secret State isn't an action-packed read. Karski was more of an administrator in the Polish underground than a fighter, so anyone looking for stories about raids, sabotage and armed resistance might be a little disappointed. Also, the book is a reprint of what he wrote in 1943-44, so it lacks the perspective that comes from our fuller knowledge of events that only came to light after the war. Most obviously, he only has the haziest notion of how fortu...more
Aspho
The release of Story of a Secret State by Jan Karski has been accompanied by a great deal of press both in the U.K. and in the rest of Europe. Having read a two-page article about this book on the Italian newspaper’s La Repubblica, I decided to request it from Amazon Vine.

Originally released in the 1940s, Story of a Secret State is an account of Jan K’s life as a member of the Polish Underground. I am fairly ignorant about the situation of Poland during the Nazi occupation; I was therefore very...more
Diane
I won this advance copy as a give away from Goodreads.

This is a eyewitness account by one person to what was happening during the Nazi and Russian invasion into Poland. Karski gives us a written detail of the horrors the Polish people went through and how the Nazi's where out to completely remove the Jewish people from the earth.

We meet Karski a young Polish boy who thought he had the world going for him. One day he is flirting at a dance and the next thing he know his world is turned up side do...more
Irving Koppel

Although it reads like a novel,"Story of a Secret State" is the true
account of the adventures of a member of the Polish underground during
World War II. Mr.Karski, who came from a prominent Polish family, had
fought the Germans as a member of the Polish cavalry. Since Poland had
been invaded by the Russians as well as the Germans,he ended up as a prisoner of the former. After his escape from the Russians, he joined
the underground,only to be captured by the nazis. As a result of
a terrible beating...more
Scot McAtee
Although I really liked hearing a story about WWII from a viewpoint I don't think I've ever heard before, it was not quite as shocking as what I expected. Karski was definitely a hero and the kind that I like to read about: an ordinary man in extraordinary circumstances. I think he maybe downplayed his part in several sections of the book to the detriment of the book, but there's no telling where it was before editors, translators and whoever else got their hands on his report.

Readers should be...more
Roderick Hart
These are the memoirs of a Polish officer during World War 11. Captured by the Soviets then exchanged into the custody of the Germans, he escapes from a train taking him to a labour camp or worse and makes his way to Warsaw where he is recruited into the Underground.

At first he works as a courier, conveying information from the Underground to the Polish Government in Exile, then in France. Since this involves travelling through several occupied countries with forged papers it is risky and eventu...more
Paul
I was very lucky to win this book through Goodreads, and I'm always pleased to read and review them, even if it takes me a long time to finish them.

The book is the memoir by Jan Kozielewski, who was a Polish army officer who during World War II, became a member of the Polish Underground, with the code name Jan Karski. Kozielweski/Karski eventually becoming a spokesperson for the Polish people in the United States during the final years of World War II. This book is a reprint of his memoir, orig...more
Iceman
Agosto de 1939, Jan Karski, jovem recem licenciado, recebe uma ordem de mobilização para o exercito polaco. Nada impressionado, pois era opinião que os alemães não fariam nada de mal à Polónia face à ameaça francesa e britânica, Jan Karski responde a essa ordem dirigindo-se para a estação e é aí que se depara com milhares de homens na gare e percebe que algo de grave se está a passar.

A partir desse dia, Jan Karski encetará um percurso sinuoso que o levará a tomar contacto com as atrocidades da g...more
Kendra
I recieved this book as a First Reads Giveaway, and couldn't wait to read it from the first notification that it was being sent. As at least one other reviewer has stated...now that I've read the book, I am afraid that I won't be able to do it justice. This is an eyewitness account of events and conditions in Poland from the time of the German and Russian invasion during World War II, by an extraordinarily brave, patriotic man. Although written as a testament to the plight of the Polish people,...more
Rita
Apr 07, 2012 Rita marked it as to-read
Kinga's review: [book orig. pub 1944 !]
As the resident Pole on Bookmunch I have received this book for reviewing and now I am afraid I won’t do it justice. Going through years of the Polish education system, I didn’t think I wanted or needed to know anything more about World War II, the occupation, the Gestapo or the Holocaust. I was wrong. Jan Karski’s Story of a Secret State should be a compulsory read for everyone. I am not saying this because I am Polish and we like to inform the whole world...more
Gerald Sinstadt
The underground movement in wartime Poland seems to have been like no other: loosely structured for safety but coherent enough to pursue a unified purpose. The objective was to create in secret a state that would mirror a new Poland when - if - the Germans were defeated.

When Jan Karski's book in its original form was written that objective was still a work in progress with no certainty as to its outcome. The narrative has the authentic grip of terrifyingly direct experience. The accounts of clan...more
Paul Culloty
For an individual who had no intention of writing a book before WW2, Story of a Secret State is a fast-paced, engaging account that not only hooks the reader through its narrative, but also leaves a valuable historical legacy. In summary, the author mobilises for war, escapes from German captivity, provides valuable work for the Polish Underground in terms of propaganda and liaising with the Government-in-Exile, before shockingly concluding with the first-ever written account of the Holocaust. I...more
Carey Combe
This is an extraordinary testament to Man's inhumanity to Man, and the even more remarkable courage required to resist it. A simple recitation of the facts would make it compelling but Karski is also a superb writer. Rather than trying to generate drama his style is cool and restrained which I think increases the impact. He never complains and writes plainly and elegantly. The most harrowing part of the book is without doubt the two chapters in which Karski describes the fate of the Jews in Pola...more
Mark
My wife and I just watched "To Be or Not To Be" a 1942 film set in Poland staring Jack Benny and Carole Lombard as members of the Polish Underground resisting the Nazi invasion and occupation. Now the film is a comedy-action-propaganda flick that in general is no longer made, and if it is, not made well. And when "To Be or Not To Be" was released in 1942 the horrors committed by the Nazi's were not known in the West. All through this movie I kept telling my wife about this book, "Story of Secret...more
Ubiquitousbastard
I actually thought, when I wanted to read this book, that it had some groundbreaking revelation. No, it's just a report that happened more than sixty years ago, and has no new information to offer me. I really should have done more background work on this before I decided I wanted to read it, but I have to admit the summary was enough to sway me until I read more about the book.

Honestly, there wasn't anything in this book that I haven't already heard/seen or both. At the time, it may have been a...more
Natxo Cruz
Magnífic relat personal d'un resistent polonés durant l'ocupació nazi, que va més enllà de la seva pròpia experiència en el conflicte per oferir un panorama detallat de les condicions que els alemanys van imposar al primer país que envairen el 1939.
Un llibre que ve a omplir un buit habitual en els manuals d'història, que deixen força de banda el paper de Polònia un cop derrotada (si no és per parlar de l'holocaust jueu i la solució final) i de la resistència polonesa en favor d'altres moviments...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 34 35 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Pamiętnik z Powstania Warszawskiego
  • The Eagle Unbowed: Poland and the Poles in the Second World War
  • Voyage of the Damned
  • Babi Yar: A Document in the Form of a Novel; New, Complete, Uncensored Version
  • Neighbors: The Destruction of the Jewish Community in Jedwabne, Poland
  • The Peasant Prince: and the Age of Revolution
  • Fado
  • The Taste of Ashes: The Afterlife of Totalitarianism in Eastern Europe
  • The White Mouse
  • The Eighth Day of the Week
  • The Meaning of Hitler
  • Hitler, the Germans, and the Final Solution
  • The Nazis: A Warning from History
  • Masters of the Air: America's Bomber Boys Who Fought the Air War Against Nazi Germany
  • The Elephant
  • Rising '44: The Battle for Warsaw
  • Mussolini: His Part In My Downfall  (War Memoirs, #4)
  • Into That Darkness: An Examination of Conscience
219581
Jan Karski (born Jan Kozielewski) was a Polish World War II resistance movement fighter and later professor at Georgetown University. In 1942 and 1943 Karski reported to the Polish government in exile and the Western Allies on the situation in German-occupied Poland, especially the destruction of the Warsaw Ghetto, and the secretive German-Nazi extermination camps.
After the war Karski entered the...more
More about Jan Karski...
Emisariusz. Własnymi słowami. Książka z płytą The Great Powers and Poland 1919-1945: From Versailles to Yalta Polska powinna stać się pomostem między narodami Europy Zachodniej i jej wschodnimi sąsiadami Tajna dyplomacja Churchilla i Roosevelta w sprawie Polski (1940-1945) The Warsaw Ghetto

Share This Book

“My dear girl,' I answered in high spirits, for I felt elated at being active again. 'You are about to witness the birth of an immortal literary masterpiece. In a few moments, I shall begin the composition of an eloquent letter. This letter is going to be received by everyone in the Reich who has a Polish name. Or at least that is what shall try to accomplish. We want to remidn everyone of Polish origin that, although they are nominally German, Polish blood continues to flow in their veins.'
Danuta interrupted my oratory.
'Calm down, Witold. Don't excite yourself so. If you raise your voice much louder you shan't have to send any letters. Everybody in the Third Reich will have heard you, including the Gestapo.”
2 likes
“The photographer was installed in the back of an inconspicurous dry-goods store in the poorer neighbourhood of Warsaw. He seemed to know all about me. His job was to prepare a picture of me which resembled me sufficiently to be claimed as mine, but in which the features were so vague that I could disown it if the need should arise.
He was a bold, spry little man who hardly replied to my few remarks. His deliberate taciturnity was not lost on me and I remained quiet while he concentrated on the task of turning out what proved to be a miniature masterpiece of photographic ambiguity. When it was finished he handed it to me with a pleased smile. I glanced at it and marveled aloud at his skill.
'It's incredible,' I said. 'It makes me feel as though I had met myself before but can't quite remember where.”
1 likes
More quotes…