The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia
by
Laura Miller (Goodreads Author)
THE MAGICIAN'S BOOK is the story of one reader's long, tumultuous relationship with C.S. Lewis' The Chronicles of Narnia. Enchanted by its fantastic world as a child, prominent critic Laura Miller returns to the series as an adult to uncover the source of these small books' mysterious power by looking at their creator, Clive Staples Lewis. What she discovers is not the fam...more
Hardcover, 320 pages
Published
December 3rd 2008
by Little, Brown and Company
(first published November 25th 2008)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,797)
Aug 04, 2008
Miriam
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Everyone who loves reading, Narnia, fantasy, ok, all of you.
I don't usually read literary criticism but this is totally fascinating. It stems from Miller's personal love of the Chronicles of Narnia and goes on to analyze them, and their place in the cannon, talk about C.S. Lewis' life, his faith, the role of Christianity in the books and in his life, as well as his relationship with Tolkien. She talks about the nature of reading, the difference between reading as a child and as an adult and in my favorite parts, the dichotomy between the little girls who...more
Book reviewer and Salon.com co-founder Laura Miller fell in love with Narnia in the second grade when her teacher handed her a copy of The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe. Several years later, Laura, by then a lapsing Catholic and a junior-high student, read that C.S. Lewis's intent in writing the Chronicles of Narnia had been a recasting of Christian doctrine for children. She felt snookered and angry and did not revisit Narnia for many years. During those years, the Christian aspect of the Nar...more
Like Laura Miller asserts, even in her title, and sticks to very evenly throughout the book, one usually comes with a prejudiced eye to the Chronicles and to Lewis. I am not a skeptic--I am a Christian, and unlike Miller who was enamored of the books as a child, I really didn't come to them completely until I was a senior in college, after lots of spiritual twists and turns, and finally fully accepting that, well, the Church was where I found and celebrated the magic and the mystery of the worl...more
"...The word "spell, as Tolkien mentions in his essay "On Fairy Stories", once meant "both a story told, and a formula of power over living men. Where does this power come from and what is it made of?"
This passage (chapter 26) most accurately summarizes the riddle Laura Miller sets out to answer for herself in The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures In Narnia.
Truthfully, I picked this book out at the library because I just couldn't resist the title. Nonfiction titled The Magician's Book: A...more
This passage (chapter 26) most accurately summarizes the riddle Laura Miller sets out to answer for herself in The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures In Narnia.
Truthfully, I picked this book out at the library because I just couldn't resist the title. Nonfiction titled The Magician's Book: A...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I enjoyed reading this tremendously. I'm no longer a "friend of Narnia" as such, but like Miller, sure was as a child. Perhaps not quite as fanatic (my imaginary land of choice being Wonderland), but I did reread them too and loved the Chronicles very much (and, yes, have my Puffin box set among my favorite childhood books).
Then I remember well teaching The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe for the first time as a young teacher and being shocked, shocked! at the heavy-handed Christian themes. B...more
Then I remember well teaching The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe for the first time as a young teacher and being shocked, shocked! at the heavy-handed Christian themes. B...more
Many books written about C S Lewis are essentially gushing paeans, written by sycophantic acolytes. Written by a non-believer, The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia might be described as a secular appreciation, not only of Narnia, but of Lewis' imagination as a whole, as well as its wellsprings and tributaries. As young reader, Miller fell in love with Narnia, only to become disgusted and appalled when she grew up to learn that her beloved stories had been carefully imbued by the...more
I don't think I've ever read a book of lit crit so quickly or with so much enjoyment. A blurb on the back describes it as "conversational, embracing, and casually erudite" which is exactly right. Laura Miller talks about everything from Beowulf to Led Zeppelin, from Little House on the Prairie to Lolita, all with equally fresh insight. She makes her own prejudice perfectly clear: she is a lapsed Catholic and has no patience whatever with Christianity in any form, and she even describes Graham Gr...more
I bought a Kindle. This is the first book I've attempted to read on it. I can see that a Kindle has advantages over physical books in a couple ways: while traveling as you can compress LOTS of books into a space smaller than one paperback and if you wish a book had slightly larger print you can push a couple buttons and make it so. However, for general reading, when space or font size are not a consideration, a "real" book is still preferable.
I checked this book out of a library. It really was...more
I checked this book out of a library. It really was...more
Mar 03, 2010
Mary Etta
marked it as to-read
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Vicky
Shelves:
unfinished
This sounds interesting. I've been a fan of C S Lewis since our KS days when a teen-age friend gave the Narnia set to our daughter Chris dealing with brain cancer. Later David and Polly loved reading "Screwtape Letters." Between the two and expanding to other writings we've been fans ever since extending to the grandchildren. Loved a stage play at MSU of which I would have loved to have read the script. (Didn't I see that with you, Vicky?)I think it was "Shadowlands." So this sounds like a good...more
I haven���t had a best book of the year since Little, Big, I think, and this is just about a perfect book for me. Literary nonfiction, nonacademic analysis, a lover���s criticism and memoir, a bit of biography without much prying, about children���s books but for adults, and the knowledge that she can love Narnia as an adult without Christian apologetics.
Laura Miller draws an analogy, C.S. Lewis : J.R.R. Tolkien :: Samuel Coleridge : William Wordsworth. She talks about that for a while and then...more
Laura Miller draws an analogy, C.S. Lewis : J.R.R. Tolkien :: Samuel Coleridge : William Wordsworth. She talks about that for a while and then...more
In The Magician's Book, an attractive stew of biography, critical analysis, reader's notes, and fan mail, critic and writer Laura Miller details her lifelong love affair with the seven novels that make up C. S. Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia. She also tackles Lewis's Christian themes and his perceived racism, sexism, and elitism head-on, writing that the author's religious views "worked like a black hole, sucking all the beauty and wonder out of Narnia." Traveling to England to absorb the landscap
...more
Improbably, I ended up finishing this book rather quickly, despite my having a newborn and a toddler at home. In addition, I confess that I have never read any of the Narnia books, but I am unnaturally interested in C.S. Lewis, as his Christian apologetics are of the very rare sort that can make me rationally appreciate Christianity.
I still really enjoyed this book. It is fully of wonderful literary criticism, and managed to wake up my sleep-deprived, thinking brain. I loved many of the discussi...more
I still really enjoyed this book. It is fully of wonderful literary criticism, and managed to wake up my sleep-deprived, thinking brain. I loved many of the discussi...more
As a child in early elementary school, the author, Laura, devoured the series of children’s books by C.S. Lewis called The Chronicles of Narnia. For her, they were the conduit into an entirely new realm of books and reading and, as such, hold a place not only in her literary life but also in her childhood itself. As Laura grew and discovered the barely concealed Christian messages within the books, a sense of betrayal tainted her view of the texts that had so brightly colored her childhood.
In th...more
In th...more
I’m a sucker for literary criticism. I mostly enjoyed the first two thirds of this book, though there were times that it seemed more like Eat, Pray, Love, (a book I utterly despised) than anything the Last Action Hero of Literary Criticism, Harold Bloom would have written. For those who do not know me, I found that . . . off putting.
As a founding member of Salon.com, Miller has had a rare opportunity to talk to authors who have wrestled hard with C. S. Lewis over the years. Neil Gaiman, Philip...more
As a founding member of Salon.com, Miller has had a rare opportunity to talk to authors who have wrestled hard with C. S. Lewis over the years. Neil Gaiman, Philip...more
Narnia is shrouded in darkness. The harsh King Miraz, uncle to the throne’s heir, Prince Caspian, rules the land, and has made certain any memory of “the old days” (as Caspian calls them) is stamped out. But Caspian—having heard tales of Satyrs and Fauns, Nymphs and Dwarfs, Talking Beasts and all manner of magical creatures—longs for more than the drab castle in which he lives. Risking torture and death, Caspian’s new tutor, Doctor Cornelius, sneaks the young prince to the top of the highest tow...more
Narnia was one of my favorite series as a child, and though I've grown up to be fairly non-religious, I still like to go back and reread it every few years. I saw the word Narnia on this book when we got it in and had to check it out. I've read enough about the religious aspects of the book, and the cover claimed this book wasn't going to rehash the religious interpretations of Narnia. But then the author spent a lot of time discussing how she felt betrayed when she read the series as a grown up...more
I fell in love with The Chronicles of Narnia when my friend Melissa told me the story of "The lion, the witch and the wardrobe" and later "the horse and his boy". At our next school book fair, I bought the series for myself and proceeded to read and reread them. I still love fantasy...and pieces of Narnia are part of my family lore/vocabulary and part of my imaginative furniture.
This book is written, beautifully written, by someone who also fell in love with narnia...but then distanced herself f...more
This book is written, beautifully written, by someone who also fell in love with narnia...but then distanced herself f...more
Feb 01, 2011
danielle.
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Fans of Narnia, English Teachers, anyone who has a favorite childhood book
Recommended to danielle. by:
BEA
Shelves:
favorites
I picked up this book at BEA 2009 and it sat on my shelf for almost a year. When I finally did pick it up, I was angry at not having done so sooner. I've never read a literary criticism this compelling, and I'm a former English major and current English teacher, so I've read a lot of them! The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia was equal parts literary criticism and memoir. I could not put this book down and found myself highlighting and writing in the margins like mad. We've all...more
OK, so admittedly I didn't like this book as much as a good novel. Not as much as the novels of many of the authors quoted within the book: Neil Gaiman, Susanna Clarke, Philip Pullman, etc.
And a lot of the book was spent on J.R.R. Tolkien and how he was a dour spoilsport who hates fun and children and his best friend C.S. Lewis.
But it was still a lot of fun reading about Lewis' life when he was writing the books, some of the landscape inspirations in England and Ireland, and what all the people...more
And a lot of the book was spent on J.R.R. Tolkien and how he was a dour spoilsport who hates fun and children and his best friend C.S. Lewis.
But it was still a lot of fun reading about Lewis' life when he was writing the books, some of the landscape inspirations in England and Ireland, and what all the people...more
Reading this book was more fun than I'd thought it would be. Miller loved the Narnia books as a girl, felt betrayed and angry as a teenager when she clued in to the Christian themes, and then returned to them as an adult and found new things to appreciate. The book is divided into three sections, each corresponding to one of those three phases. She nicely pulls together an interesting and thoughtful critical look at the series.
I was embarrassingly old - like, 15 - when I realized that Aslan was...more
I was embarrassingly old - like, 15 - when I realized that Aslan was...more
This isn't a terrible book, but it's really lacking in character. I never felt that the author took a strong stand on anything, and I think she truly felt that describing the experience of reading was enough to sustain a full-length book. In particular, she never fully addresses the major issue, which is that one of the most beloved children's books of all time, which she loved as a child, was in many ways a propaganda piece for a religion she doesn't believe in. She doesn't generate enough ange...more
May 29, 2009
Caleb
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Grown-ups who adored the Chronicles as kids
Shelves:
non-fiction
This was an impulse borrow from the library, and while I'm not generally much of a reader of literary criticism, this book sucked me right in and ended up being one of those "can't put it down" type of reads I'm always hearing people talk about (but hardly ever experience myself).
The sub-title is actually rather misleadign, as the author does talk a bit about how learning of the Christian meanings Lewis weaved into her favorite books of girlhood made her feel betrayed and soured her to the work...more
The sub-title is actually rather misleadign, as the author does talk a bit about how learning of the Christian meanings Lewis weaved into her favorite books of girlhood made her feel betrayed and soured her to the work...more
I like reading books about reading.
The author of "The Magician's Book" was swept away as a child, like many of us were, by the enchantment of that world beyond the wardrobe, and in fact that was her real introduction to the world of books. As a teen, however, (again like many of us) she felt betrayed and repulsed by what she then saw as ham-fisted attempts to proselytize Christianity. "The Magician's Book" is the story of her long journey back to appreciating The Chronicles again, on her own ter...more
The author of "The Magician's Book" was swept away as a child, like many of us were, by the enchantment of that world beyond the wardrobe, and in fact that was her real introduction to the world of books. As a teen, however, (again like many of us) she felt betrayed and repulsed by what she then saw as ham-fisted attempts to proselytize Christianity. "The Magician's Book" is the story of her long journey back to appreciating The Chronicles again, on her own ter...more
I fully expected this to be a much-needed attempt at reclaiming The Chronicles of Narnia from the Christian commentary that has essentially annexed this series as a kind of sacred text and regard it as a great theological statement (I know these types of people myself). I would have been just fine with simply that, but the title here is misleading, which, frankly, I should have expected coming from Miller. Instead of marking territory for a battle, she embarks on a pleasantly meandering, extreme...more
I love to read. I have for as long as I can remember. I would sequester myself off in the woods during the summer, burying my head in a book as I solved cases with Encyclopedia Brown and the Boxcar Children, wondered if maybe my teacher was an alien, and wished my school was as awesome as Wayside. In the winter time I would crawl into one of my parents' cars, trying to find a secluded and warm spot as I journeyed off to other worlds. And despite my love for the stories and worlds of Louis Sachar...more
Jan 29, 2009
MsInterpreted
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
People who enjoy sharing others' reading experiences
Recommended to MsInterpreted by:
Book reviews on Salon, the NY Times
I really adored this book; there were so many points at which I beamed and nodded in recognition, recalling my own experiences reading C.S. Lewis and many of the other authors Miller mentioned.
It was wonderful to read something about the Chronicles and Lewis that took the books seriously without requiring a dogmatic Christian interpretation. Miller's distinction between "children's" books that focus on "obedience and naughtiness" as opposed to "good and evil" was perfect; it so aptly characteriz...more
It was wonderful to read something about the Chronicles and Lewis that took the books seriously without requiring a dogmatic Christian interpretation. Miller's distinction between "children's" books that focus on "obedience and naughtiness" as opposed to "good and evil" was perfect; it so aptly characteriz...more
I think I come pretty much from Miller's generation and background and had a fairly strong connection to the Chronicles of Narnia as a pre-teen reader but never felt any sense of anger or disappointment upon becoming aware of Lewis's religious symbolism - if anything, I probably thought it was kind of cool. So Miller's jumping off point is not one I share. However, despite my enthusiasm for Lewis, Tolkien and comparable fantasy, I have many books ahead of either of their biographies on my list s...more
May 06, 2010
Kate
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommended to Kate by:
gift from Ben & Angela
Shelves:
faith
As I read this book I kept responding to the author aloud (which made it impossible to read in public). It's disappointing that she seems to equate Catholicism with all Christianity, since so many of the ideas and experiences she cites as problems with the Chronicles are not the experiences and beliefs of many, many Christians. For example, even though a High Anglican cathedral may look very much like a Catholic church and the liturgy may feel quite similar, there are some key underlying concept...more
I really liked this book. while reading it, I felt a paralell with the author, who felt a bit cheated by her experience re-reading the Chronicles of Narnia as an adult and finally realizing the inherent Christian symbolism. Like the author, I often felt that Narnia was probably the only "true" make-believe children's story. It had the feeling of a place you could actually visit, a story whose adventures you could also complete. I must have re-read all of the Narnia books over a hundred times bet...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Laura Miller is a journalist and critic. She is a cofounder of Salon.com, where she is currently a staff writer, and is the editor of The Salon.com Readers Guide to Contemporary Authors. A regular contributor to The New York Times Book Review, her work has also appeared in The New Yorker, the Los Angeles Times, Time, and other publications. She lives in New York. Her new book is The Magician's Boo...more
More about Laura Miller...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Buying a book is not about obtaining a possession, but about securing a portal.”
—
47 people liked it
“Do the children who prefer books set in the real, ordinary, workaday world ever read as obsessively as those who would much rather be transported into other worlds entirely?”
—
23 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






























Aug 05, 2008 05:51pm