12th out of 39 books
—
11 voters
Bread Givers
This masterwork of American immigrant literature is set in the 1920s on the Lower East Side of Manhattan and tells the story of Sara Smolinsky, the youngest daughter of an Orthodox rabbi, who rebels against her father's rigid conception of Jewish womanhood. Sarah's struggle towards independence and self-fulfillment resonates with a passion all can share. Beautifully redesi...more
Paperback, 336 pages
Published
August 1st 2003
by Persea
(first published 1925)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
May 30, 2008
Valerie
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Young Women, College Students
Recommended to Valerie by:
History Teacher
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The Bread Givers, immediately transports the reader back in time to the tenements of New York's Lower East Side during the early 1920's and the struggles of young Jewish immigrant, Sara Smolinsky. Caught between her old world values and her deep desire to become an "American", Sara's plight towards independence is heart-wrenching to say the least. As Sara tries to break free from her dominating Rabbi father and Jewish traditions, she is soon faced with similar barriers in the form of greedy land...more
The Long Way to Independence: A Book Review of Bread Givers
Persea,2003,336pp.,$9.99
Anzia Yezierska ISBN:0892552905
Wanting independence and freedom is everyone's wish. Everyone wants to live their own life without anyone controlling it. However, it is not that way for Sara Smolinsky. With her controlling and old world like father, Sara struggles to gain independence. Holding all her anger in as she watches each one of her sister fall into the traps of their father, Sara plans to make a stop. She...more
Persea,2003,336pp.,$9.99
Anzia Yezierska ISBN:0892552905
Wanting independence and freedom is everyone's wish. Everyone wants to live their own life without anyone controlling it. However, it is not that way for Sara Smolinsky. With her controlling and old world like father, Sara struggles to gain independence. Holding all her anger in as she watches each one of her sister fall into the traps of their father, Sara plans to make a stop. She...more
This book was assigned reading as part of a course on immigration policy within the US. The professor recommended it highly and told the class that it was a good read and that we would all find ourselves absorbed in the book once we got into it. Truth was spoken.
Bread Givers is the story of Russian Jew immigrant Sara Smolinsky and her desire and struggle to achieve the pinnacle of what it means to be an American; the opportunity to invest one's self in individual pursuits.
As with any book I re...more
Bread Givers is the story of Russian Jew immigrant Sara Smolinsky and her desire and struggle to achieve the pinnacle of what it means to be an American; the opportunity to invest one's self in individual pursuits.
As with any book I re...more
This book was assigned reading as part of a course on immigration policy within the US. The professor recommended it highly and told the class that it was a good read and that we would all find ourselves absorbed in the book once we got into it. Truth was spoken.
Bread Givers is the story of Russian Jew immigrant Sara Smolinsky and her desire and struggle to achieve the pinnacle of what it means to be an American; the opportunity to invest one's self in individual pursuits.
As with any book I re...more
Bread Givers is the story of Russian Jew immigrant Sara Smolinsky and her desire and struggle to achieve the pinnacle of what it means to be an American; the opportunity to invest one's self in individual pursuits.
As with any book I re...more
Bread Givers, by Anzia Yezierska is a compelling book, not only in its vivid descriptions of life in Manhattan during the 1910s-1920s, but also its look into an Orthodox Jewish family, and its standards. It is a coming of age story, of the youngest of four daughters, told through her narration.
The familial patriarch is Rabbi Smolinksy, and his wife is Shenah, who is in awe of him, despite her nagging manner. His interactions, decisions and doctrine influence his daughters, Fania, Bessie, Mashah,...more
The familial patriarch is Rabbi Smolinksy, and his wife is Shenah, who is in awe of him, despite her nagging manner. His interactions, decisions and doctrine influence his daughters, Fania, Bessie, Mashah,...more
This book has good points and bad points for me. First of all it is historically accurate from what I've read about Jewish Immigrant life from the 1920's. It is a touching story and inspirational for all people who have dreams. This book shows that with hard work and perseverance you can fulfill your dreams and overcome any obstacle. The only things that I did not like about this book were the characters. The father is a very insensitive man towards his daughter’s feelings and seems like he onl...more
Bread Givers is about a family whose father is a scholar and insists that the women of his family support him. This is not unheard of in Jewish life, but it is definitely not part of the mainstream Judaism. It saddened me to see that the mothers and daughters in the family seemed very ignorant of Jewish life. The daughters leave and marry the horrible husbands the father has ordained for them and maintaining a home that has any elements of Judaism doesn't seem to have been important to anyone. E...more
"Wow." That was how I felt after I first finished this novel. I regret selling the book after I bought it for one of my classes. It was the first time I read a book in a long time about immigration. The novel follows the life of a Jewish girl who comes to America. She lives in New York City and struggles with her faith.
Most novels that cover the loss of faith focus on tragic loss. Meanwhile, Sara is unsure about her faith due to tradition. At the start of the book, Sara is only ten years old and...more
Most novels that cover the loss of faith focus on tragic loss. Meanwhile, Sara is unsure about her faith due to tradition. At the start of the book, Sara is only ten years old and...more
I grew up loving "All-of-a-Kind Family", the story of poor Jewish immigrants in the tenements of New York, five girls cherished by their parents and encouraged to grow and have adventures and find their path in life. I'm sure the stories were somewhat idealized for the audience of children they were aimed at, but they provided a benign window on a different world than my Protestant, Midwestern, middle-class one.
This grim tale of the same era, same location, same culture, could hardly be more dif...more
This grim tale of the same era, same location, same culture, could hardly be more dif...more
After reading "Call It Sleep," I kind of dreaded reading yet another difficult, dreary book about immigrants on the Lower East Side of New York in the early 1900s. Wow. Was I unbelievably surprised when I start "Bread Givers." I could not put this book down, even sneaking away from a family event to read a few more pages. What's so unbelievable to me is not only is the subject fascinating, but the books is immensely readable. It was like reading something written today.
Sara is the daughter of a...more
Sara is the daughter of a...more
If you are American, and probably even if you are not, you have heard this story before: determined immigrant leaves the Old World behind to seek their fortune in the New; working their way out of a life of crushing poverty, they encounter the prejudices of those better-established than they are, and struggle to find a balance between honoring the traditions of their family while at the same time becoming acculturated to their new, adopted country. Anzia Yezierska's The Bread Givers presents thi...more
(From a posting for a class)
Breadgivers tells the tale of Sara Smolinsky trying to find her place in the world, similar to how Jim and Antonia must find their place in the world as in My Antonia. Sara doesn't want to be married off, and doesn't want to give all her wages to her strict Jewish father. She views his way of life as the old way, and knows there is something more out there for her. He demands that she serve him, and yet she grows tired of his demands. He uses his religion to try to ma...more
Breadgivers tells the tale of Sara Smolinsky trying to find her place in the world, similar to how Jim and Antonia must find their place in the world as in My Antonia. Sara doesn't want to be married off, and doesn't want to give all her wages to her strict Jewish father. She views his way of life as the old way, and knows there is something more out there for her. He demands that she serve him, and yet she grows tired of his demands. He uses his religion to try to ma...more
Sara Smolinsky, lives a hard life. No one in their family, can find a good-paying job in the family. With a household of 5, and having a small amount of wages being used for the family, Sara strives to make some money for her family. Her father however, is studying the "Torah" and is not looking for work at all. Every single day, he sits at home in his own private room reading the bible. Having to live in a poor family and a father that doesn't work due to his "learning", she decides to live her...more
After being super pissed off through the first 140 pages of the father figure's tyranny, I began to have more patience for Bread Givers.
The most interesting thing was keeping in mind that it was not historical fiction but rather a semi-autobiographical novel published in 1925. So I think the reason that it is widely-read and -taught is that it had been a pioneer in English-language immigrant fiction. Tension between the Old World and the New, between generations--family vs. personal identity, o...more
The most interesting thing was keeping in mind that it was not historical fiction but rather a semi-autobiographical novel published in 1925. So I think the reason that it is widely-read and -taught is that it had been a pioneer in English-language immigrant fiction. Tension between the Old World and the New, between generations--family vs. personal identity, o...more
What I hated:
-The father is an absolute motherfugging piece of dip-shiz. Can he die? Please? He's just such an a-hole and a hypocrite just LET. HIM. DIE. AND. ROT. IN. HELL. -cough- Thank you.
-The mother died instead of the father. WTF IS THIS!?
-All of the characters were stupid and shallow and selfish. I didn't even like Sara that much.
-The whole book was just repetitions on how horrible her life is. She doesn't even really do anything to try and make it better until late in the book.
-All of th...more
-The father is an absolute motherfugging piece of dip-shiz. Can he die? Please? He's just such an a-hole and a hypocrite just LET. HIM. DIE. AND. ROT. IN. HELL. -cough- Thank you.
-The mother died instead of the father. WTF IS THIS!?
-All of the characters were stupid and shallow and selfish. I didn't even like Sara that much.
-The whole book was just repetitions on how horrible her life is. She doesn't even really do anything to try and make it better until late in the book.
-All of th...more
Sara and her family worship the holy Torah, and no matter what, they do what the Torah says. Sara and her family try to follow her father's wishes, but he makes things very complicated. The sisters are married off to men that the father believed were rich and would give good lives to his daughters. Sara does not want to follow in her sister's footsteps and decides to leave home and try to live the life of an independent girl. Her father wants her to make him proud, but she can not take him and h...more
Remarkable book. The style is often melodramatic--and yet the emotions are so thoroughly felt and convincing that the melodrama is transcended. The narrative seems to be written in a naive Yiddish-inflected English... yet that inflection drops imperceptibly away as Sara, the protagonist, educates herself out of the impoverished Jewish Lower East Side life of her early years, goes to college, and becomes a teacher. Each of her sisters, by contrast, becomes trapped by marriage (even the one who ma...more
This was my absolute rave-about-and-recommend-to-everyone favorite book in my early twenties because it explored all the things I cared about most: falling in love, a burning ambition to write, and Judaism. At the time, I said I wanted to be Anzia Yezierska, but in mirror image; whereas she ran away from Yiddishkeit, I was embracing it. I wanted to portray my world and choices just as poignantly as she. That's still my ambition, but now that I'm older, I see many more flaws in Anzia Yezierska, n...more
Vivid storytelling of the lives of an immigrant family, Polish Jews, on Hester Street c.1910. Father, mother and four daughters. This is NOT Little Women though there are some parallels, but that's not what interests me. I see Bread Givers as a study in abuse of power.
The father, Smolinsky, is empowered by his culture; he exploits that power by abusing his wife and daughters. He's a bully, a mean, selfish, shameless, self-pitying, hypocritical bastard. And he's no exaggeration. Sara, the narrat...more
The father, Smolinsky, is empowered by his culture; he exploits that power by abusing his wife and daughters. He's a bully, a mean, selfish, shameless, self-pitying, hypocritical bastard. And he's no exaggeration. Sara, the narrat...more
Three and a half stars. The writing style is quite simple and the plot is often maudlin and predictable. Still, there is something so sincere about this novel about a young Jewish girl trying to eke out an existence in the extreme poverty and squalor many first generation immigrants experienced in the early part of the twentieth century. This novel brought to mind Little Women and Fiddler on the Roof (four daughters to marry off). You are meant to intensely dislike their father who is painted as...more
Great! Awesome! Highly recommended!
Bread Givers was a fast read with themes of family, obligation, and independence that everyone can relate to. I especially liked the book knowing it evolved out of Yezierska's personal experience as a poor Jewish girl at the turn of the century. A story of success and love, Bread Givers didn't come off as a cliche, partly because of the difference in time period and cultural background. I was a little disappointed in the conclusion, but quite enjoyed all parts...more
Bread Givers was a fast read with themes of family, obligation, and independence that everyone can relate to. I especially liked the book knowing it evolved out of Yezierska's personal experience as a poor Jewish girl at the turn of the century. A story of success and love, Bread Givers didn't come off as a cliche, partly because of the difference in time period and cultural background. I was a little disappointed in the conclusion, but quite enjoyed all parts...more
I read this for school. I didn't want to but I only had like a week to read it (which is fast for me). But I liked it ok.
Its a biography/story told from the perspective of the younger daughter of a poor Jewish family who moved to NY during the time after the war when everyone moved there. They were really really poor which the author makes clear and everyone is really weird. The father is distant yet 'religious' the mother is mean all the neighbors and people can't be trusted. It's kind of negat...more
Its a biography/story told from the perspective of the younger daughter of a poor Jewish family who moved to NY during the time after the war when everyone moved there. They were really really poor which the author makes clear and everyone is really weird. The father is distant yet 'religious' the mother is mean all the neighbors and people can't be trusted. It's kind of negat...more
This is the lovely story of Sara, a young Jewish woman, the daughter of an Orthodox rabbi in 1920's New York. Sara declares herself to be free of some of the traditions of the past, such as marrying who your father tells you to marry, and goes off by herself to live an American life. Her struggles for independence and fulfillment are compelling. I first heard of this book when a childhood friend of mine made a documentary film about the author, Anzia Yezierska. The trailer for the film "Sweatsho...more
Best totally unexpected summer read. I picked it up from a used books bin in front of a church on 22nd on Wednesday and finished it late Thursday. I don't feel I read it too fast, though the tale of a young Jewish I migrant fighting back against a Torah-breathing father to make her own way in the USA felt a little cliched, which did make me skim it in parts. This was my error, as the tale is set pre-cliches, since it was published in 1925. The writing is absolutely fearless, especially regarding...more
I wasn't really looking forward to this book, just as I wasn't looking forward to reading.
If I must take a star away, it's because of the portrayal of men in the book. It's a feminist book, though you won't really appreciate it until you've made it 2/3 of the way through the book and realize that none of the men in the book thus far have been anything but jerks, swindlers, sexists, uber-religious conservatives and all around morons.
Characters: Typical for a big-family drama of this sort. There's...more
If I must take a star away, it's because of the portrayal of men in the book. It's a feminist book, though you won't really appreciate it until you've made it 2/3 of the way through the book and realize that none of the men in the book thus far have been anything but jerks, swindlers, sexists, uber-religious conservatives and all around morons.
Characters: Typical for a big-family drama of this sort. There's...more
This is a book my son had to read in college. I decided to try it myself and although it was not the most exciting book I have ever read, it was a good one for me. I was able to feel blessed to be an American living in such good conditions as I do because the description of the poverty, dirt, and hard work was incredible. I identified with the author for being different than her family and peers in her goals. I liked her descriptions of the life she put together for herself, alone. This book wil...more
I really enjoyed this book - an interesting look at jewish immigrants in the 1920's, a somewhat autobiographical story told through novel form. It shows the struggle of the main character in her want to be american and her cultural ties. old vs new. etc. The author touches on immigration,poverty, culture clashes, the women's movement, and more so the jewish woman's movement, and also just...the start of the rise of secular judaism. To me, the 1920's is always an interesting setting to read about...more
Generally, I love this kind of book - historic, female viewpoint, up and out from poverty - something that gives me a bit of perspective not only of how things used to be, but what my own parents faced, and what formed their attitudes and outlook. Considering the age of this book, I know it's a silly thing to gripe about, but there were typos. I'm not talking about the grammar that indicates English as a second language, but just plain typos - the word "in" two times in a row, unnecessarily. The...more
This novel offers an interesting prospective on a Jewish immigrant's life in the heart of New York City, and definitely gave me a more detailed prospective on how difficult it was for first-generation families to be successful in America. Although I'm sure the conditions depicted in this novel were not over-exaggerated, I felt as though the writing was very repetitive and read like a young adult novel. I feel as though this novel would be more widely known and respected had the author chosen to...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Date of Birth: 1885
Date of Death: 1970
Anzia Yezierska, the youngest of nine children, was born into poverty circa 1885 in Russian Poland. Her family immigrated to the Lower East Side of Manhattan around 1892. Immigration officials used the oldest child's name, Mayer, as the last name of the family and switched Anzia's name to Harriet, and so she became Hattie Mayer. After attending elementary scho...more
More about Anzia Yezierska...
Date of Death: 1970
Anzia Yezierska, the youngest of nine children, was born into poverty circa 1885 in Russian Poland. Her family immigrated to the Lower East Side of Manhattan around 1892. Immigration officials used the oldest child's name, Mayer, as the last name of the family and switched Anzia's name to Harriet, and so she became Hattie Mayer. After attending elementary scho...more
Share This Book
3 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...

Loading...





























Mar 09, 2012 07:51am