Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Too Late the Phalarope” as Want to Read:
Too Late the Phalarope
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Too Late the Phalarope

3.85 of 5 stars 3.85  ·  rating details  ·  888 ratings  ·  83 reviews
Paton's second novel portrays a police lieutenant's struggle with his conscience when he violates strict South African law concerning relationships between Blacks and whites.
Paperback, 287 pages
Published January 3rd 1996 by Scribner (first published January 1st 1950)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,342)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Justin Lonas
People try to pigeonhole Paton's novels as being about Apartheid and racial tension or simply lump him in with other African writers as a good portrayer of South African life in the 20th century.

I think that Paton deserves to be listed among the all-time greats of English literature. He writes about universally understood concepts like love, parenthood, broken families, etc. Mostly, Paton writes about sin--from temptation to commission to confession to consequences. The fact that his work is lay
...more
Mika
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Diane Gihring
Feb 27, 2011 Diane Gihring rated it 5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: anyone over 14
Recommended to Diane by: Kurt Kruger
Shelves: african-lit
I love this book. It is so powerful, especially to discuss in a class situation. And it is well written.

The story is a classic Greek Tragedy: the tragic hero is one of high standing in society, everyone loves and respects him. He has a tragic flaw-pride-and he makes a mistake in judgment and then he falls and hard! But he is not completely destroyed and actually in this case, I think the end result is all the better for Pieter and his immediate family.

I like how Paton has adopted the Greek Trage
...more
Adam Fleming
I was turned on to this book because I put Paton's Cry The Beloved country on my top ten novels of all time list on Facebook and someone suggested I read it. Found it at one of my favorite used book stores and snatched it up for a buck or two.
Paton is most famous, I think, for Cry The Beloved Country, which was made into a major motion picture starring James Earl Jones. The simplicity of Paton's use of language sparkles, and the earthy imagery his characters pull out doesn't feel contrived but a
...more
Allie
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Fergie
No one speaks to the human soul through the use of language like Alan Paton. His exquisite use of prose is as powerful as it is lyrical. While not as emotionally rich as his masterpiece, "Cry, The Beloved Country", this novel is almost as enduring in its scope of human nature. One begins to really feel what it must have been like to be a white South African in a racially-divided world in post WWII almost as much as one can suppose the issues covered in the book are still faced to varying degrees ...more
Sue
A white police lieutenant violates South Africa's hard rule prohibiting inter-racial relationships and suffers the consequences for his actions. But not only him, his entire extended family as well.
I struggled with this from start to finish. For one thing, every time I sat down to read, I dozed off at some point. It took me quite a while to figure out that the narrator is the lieutenant's aunt. In several places I had a hard time following that part of the plot in terms of the overall story li
...more
John Sharrock
This is my favorite book ever. Paton has such profound insight on the topic of justice. I enjoyed this book even more than Cry the Beloved Country!
Michele
Diving into this book is taking a trip to South Africa. He puts you there so fast and so effectively with his beautiful writing and thoughtful prose.
I think this book has a bit of weak start. The narrators voice isn't strong and I found myself confused as to whether we were talking about Pieter or his parents. Once I got that straightened out the pages really flew by. Also, when you find out the narrator is his weak, fragile aunt he may have done this perfectly.
Didn't anyone else think Alan Pat
...more
Sadiq sagheer
This is a good book but not as perfect as "Cry the Beloved Country" which is perhaps the best book I have ever read. This book is more of Metaphorical if compare with Paton's best " Cry the Beloved Country".like Paton's other novels and work this novel is also based upon Apartheid environment.
Story is based upon the life of Pieter van Vlanderan and his family, Pieter a police sergeant who fall in love with a black girl and break the Immorality Act of South Africa for which he was later punished
...more
Tasha Chinnock
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Hannah
"Yet it comes to me that it is not the judgment of God but that of men which is a stranger to compassion; for the Lord said, go thou and sin no more."

The feeling of finishing a book that tips you into a better world and a better self and a greater heartbreak.

I had to give this book some space before I wrote about it. Paton has long been one of my favorite authors, solely on the strength of his book Cry, the Beloved Country. While some girls were having normal childhoods and writing A Walk to R
...more
Cori
I've had to mull this one over for a few days to decide how I really feel about it. It was definitely not as impactful as "Cry, the Beloved Country." But a powerful story on its own. Here's what I liked:

*Paton's writing - I think some people would find it a bit detached and repetitive. It connects with me, though, and makes sense, approaching a senseless societal situation like apartheid with understated emotion. You certainly feel what's being portrayed without it being overly in your face.

*I l
...more
Ian
This second novel by Alan Paton, who acheived instant fame for Cry, The Beloved Country, is another work that highlights injustice in aparthied South Africa. Pieter van Vlaanderen, a police lieutenant, revered in his community as much for his moral rectitude as for his rugby skills, harbors a secret and shameful lust for the black girl Stephanie, against which he struggles but finally gives in to, in violation of the 1927 Immorality Act criminalizing sexual intercourse between natives and Europe ...more
Erin
I found this book to be intriguing as well as sad. Alan Paton's style of of writing lends itself to the story. The characters, circumstances, and setting were perfectly written. I am saddened by his view of God and the hopelessness throughout the book. The small ray of hope at the end, however, does give me some satisfaction. Overall, I enjoyed this book.
AnnaVan
recommended to me from my nephew. he had to read it for his research writing class at moody in chicago. it's a book i never would have picked up on my own. it took me a while to get into it, but once i did (after about 50 pages), it flew. a wonderful, thought-provoking read.
Gabriel Oak
A harrowing, HARROWING portrait of religious guilt and repressive family and social life. Paton's insights into the ways that apartheid forced individuals into untenable moral situations are incredibly perceptive, as are his ruminations on Christianity in general. This is not as accomplished or sweeping a book as Cry, the Beloved Country, but certainly merits careful reading and thought in its own right.
Christine
Passage From Book:

I knew a man that counted the days, each day, everyday, tearing them off on the little block that stood on his desk. He was always looking at his watch, and saying it’s one o’clock or it’s four o’clock or it’s nine o’clock, as though it were something for satisfaction. When April went, he would say, April’s gone, and wait for May to go too. I never saw him on New Year’s Day, but I suppose he would have said, the old year’s gone; he was waiting for death, though he didn’t know
...more
Catherine
I read this for a class in college and re-read it now. what a profound book. About South Africa, apartheid, shame, temptation, individual and family brokenness, justice, and mercy. Very well done.
Shauna
I can't decide what I think of this book...definitely a very well written book, I read the whole thing in a few hours, but I'm not sure how I feel about the story itself. Set in post WWII South Africa the main issue is of course race; there are "Immorality Laws" forbidding relationships between blacks and whites. Breaking these laws not only lead to prison, but disgrace for the entire family. It's no surprise what happens in the story along those lines, but there are also family relationship iss ...more
Abrya
This novel was a well written novel. I enjoyed the story overall and i liked the insight of South Africa. Alan Paton's "Cry the Beloved Country" showed South Africa from a native African's point of view. This novel, however, is from a white European's point of view.The novel touches base on the racism and mistreatment of blacks and the way things where run in the past. The author did very well at using his words to elicit emotions and sympathy from the reader. I personally enjoyed the book and i ...more
Candice
After reading, and loving, Cry the Beloved Country, I was looking forward to reading this. I didn't like the way it was written at all. The story was good, but the way of writing did not appeal to me at all. The characters were not well-developed, and I just could not get into the story. From the description, I knew that a white man was going to get into trouble for consorting with a black woman in South Africa in the time of apartheid. The consequences for him an his family are terrible. I just ...more
Chandra Power
I clicked the five stars and then sat here thinking I really don't know if I can say that I loved this book. Or even that I liked it. But I certainly didn't dislike it or hate it. It's one of those books that makes your heart ache for just about everyone. Set in South Africa during Apartheid, the novel is about racism and colonialism, fathers and sons, husbands and wives, aunts and nephews. It's about love and honor and betrayal and deceit and stupid laws. It's troubling me and I know it will be ...more
Elizabeth Young
This is my touchstone book. I check out every book store to see if they have a copy of it. I love everything by Alan Paton but I think this tells more about the repressive nature not only of apartheid but the society that produced it. It is a very personal experience. I lived this man,s fear and loneliness and intense personal struggle with his demons. It is told through the loving and sensitive eyes of his aunt, herself an outsider, and that gives it such a wonderful depth of emotion.
Pammy
I chose this book because of the affect Paton's CRY THE BELOVED COUNTRY had upon my teen-age years.
All these many years later, I still was astounded to read of a place and time where an affair between an Afrikaner man and a black woman has greater racial and cultural consequences than the resultant broken marriage and family woes.
Apartheid is a theme in this story, but not the main one: passion, guilt, love and remorse play out, interestingly, without any graphic sexuality.
wes Goertzen
Oct 13, 2008 wes Goertzen rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommended to wes by: sheree goertzen
Shelves: readingpleasure
my cousin recommened and gave me the book a long time ago. Too long ago really. I finally sat down to read it when heather was stateside. I thought hte book was really good. I kinda can related with the insanity or dark side of Pieter. I mean its a part of us. Paton's exploration reminded a bit of The Brothers Karamazov but i'm not sure exactly why...maybe just the depth and humanness (darkness and all) of the characters. Very good book, though not really a page turner.
Virgilio Machado
A Lei de Ferro usa as vidas de pessoas comuns para ilustrar a desumanidade da segregação racial Sul Africana. A segregação racial é odiosa em teoria e impossível de aplicar. Para o provar, Paton conta a história de Pieter, um polícia branco, que tem um caso com uma mulher nativa. É traído e denunciado e, por isso, envergonha-se a si próprio e à sua família.

http://www.precomania.com/search_getp...
Tanya W
This gripping novel explores the terrible family and social consequences of choices made in a culture that is very unforgiving of intimate relationships between whites and blacks. It also draws the reader’s compassion for the offending adulterer who unsuccessfully tries to let his wife know of his unfulfilled sexual needs.

What a tragic story, I hope the culture has become more accepting of interracial relationships.
Mandy
An informative look at South African culture of the period. It's sometimes difficult to follow the plot, but the emotions of the characters are vivid and stunning. By the time the story reached its unfortunate conclusion, I was sympathetic to the plight of the characters negatively affected by the outcome of the story. Well done, Mr. Paton. I can see why this book is a well-remembered classic.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 44 45 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
I saw you 1 2 Sep 23, 2014 07:46PM  
The title 1 2 Sep 23, 2014 07:45PM  
  • The Story of an African Farm
  • July's People
  • The Lost World of the Kalahari
  • African Stories
  • Imaginings of Sand
  • The Good Doctor
  • The Complete Poems
  • Die Swerfjare van Poppie Nongena
  • UFOs and the National Security State 2: The Cover-up Exposed 1973-91
  • The House of Breath
  • Overloaded Ark
  • Send Me
  • Marx and Satan
  • The Heart of Redness
  • The Stone Virgins
  • Homecoming: Earth (Omnibus) (Homecoming Saga, #4-5)
  • The Pict
  • Two Years Before the Mast and Twenty-Four Years After (Harvard Classics, #23)
3527
Alan Stewart Paton was born and educated in Pietermaritzburg, KwaZulu-Natal. He started his career by teaching at a school in Ixopo where he met and married his first wife. The dramatic career change to director of a reformatory for black youths at Diepkloof, near Johannesburg, had a profound effect on his thinking. The publication of Cry, The Beloved Country (1948) made him one of South Africa's ...more
More about Alan Paton...
Cry, the Beloved Country Ah But Your Land Is Beautiful Tales From a Troubled Land Debbie Go Home Instrument of Thy peace: The Prayer of St. Francis

Share This Book

“But perhaps when you were too obedient, and did not do openly what others did, and were quiet in church and hard-working at school, then some unknown rebellion brewed in you, doing harm to you, though how I do not understand.” 6 likes
“But to punish and not to restore, that is the greatest of all offences.” 4 likes
More quotes…