14th out of 143 books — 16 voters
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song, The Sixties And After” as Want to Read:
Tell Me Why: The Beatles: Album By Album, Song By Song, The Sixties And After
by Tim Riley (Goodreads Author)
A unique combination of musical analysis and cultural history, Tell Me Why stands alone among Beatles books with its single-minded focus on the most important aspect of the band: its music. Riley offers a new, deeper understanding of the Beatles by closely considering each song and album they recorded in an exploration as rigorous as it is soulful. He tirelessly sifts thro ...more
Paperback, 482 pages
Published May 30th 2002 by Da Capo Press
(first published 1988)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
(showing 1-30 of 923)
Riley achieves what I would have thought impossible - he allows us a fresh listen to the most familiar music of the late twentieth century. Plus he makes it clear how underrated Ringo Starr is. This book (which must be read with recordings of all the songs at the ready) is a must for any serious music fan.
Been meaning to read this one for a couple years, and finally picked it up at my library. In it, Riley analyzes the Beatles published output song by song, chronologically. I would agree with most of the criticisms others have made-- he seems to have a grudge against George, dismissing most of his songwriting contributions until Rubber Soul, and ragging All Things Must Pass. I'm a big George fan, and always thought his off-kilter early tunes made for a nice contrast to the L/McC stuff (and I thin ...more
Riley offers an accessible but musically informed analysis of every album and significant single released by the Beatles. Lots of intriguing and satisfying discussions of melody, innovative uses of harmony and instrumentation, and other aural aspects of the music on record.
I accept the role of professional critics. We've got food critics, movie critics, political commentators, etc. Somebody annointed Siskel and Ebert as movie critics and people like me listen to their recommendations and act or not accordingly. Don't ask me what makes their opinion more valid than my next door neighbors, although my next door neighbors opinion on restaurants and movies and such carries as more weight with me as the professional opinions do, often times. Yet we still assume that cr ...more
I vowed to lay off Beatles books but this was in the library and couldn't resist. It was so much like the later 'Revolution in the Head' - going through song by song, that I didn't read from cover to cover, just picked favourite songs (eg Rain, And Your Bird Can Sing: the guitar solo is flourescent irony.. it glitters with supremacy.) and also read all the stuff on their solo careers (up to late 80s - George still alive). Again too dismissive of George I thought, saying of his wonderful 'All Too ...more
Tell Why: The Beatles: Album by Album, Song by Song, the Sixties and After is a must read for any Beatles fan. Tim Riley goes through, album by album, song by song, and critiques each and every one. What makes this book so good is that Mr. Riley isn't simply some music critic with a journalism degree. He is an actual musician himself, both a pianist and composer. He has a bachelor's degree and a master degree in piano. Mr. Riley then has a good understanding of music theory, which he puts to goo ...more
Aug 01, 2014 Roderick rated it 4 of 5 stars
Okay, he's a real music critic, so therefore he takes himself too seriously at times (I mean, suggesting songs should end a different way, now really?), but it's fun reading about the music, described over my head, in personal, technical and lyrical ways for the Beatles; meanwhile listening to their albums at the same time; and when he loves songs, he goes into great detail about them, even though it was all focused on the Brit albums, which were so carefully crafted by the Fab Four--little did ...more
Outstanding detail and insights about how the Beatles constructed every song and album recorded on the EMI/Parlaphone and Apple labels. An unflinching, fair and honest discussion authored by a man who degreed in Piano and Music Theory. At times technical and intricate in deconstructing the Beatles work, it might overwhelm the non-musician at times - but not enough to detract from the enjoyment Riley gives the reader. Musicians, on the other hand, will greatly apprerciate Riley's attention to det ...more
Song by song (literally) account of the Beatles' recordnigns ,with a focus on discussing them from th epersepctive of music, so there's lots of technical terminology I don't understand. Riley is generally good at providing concrete examples (e.g. by quoting lyrics) to help on figure these thing out, and there's certainly plenty here ot interest the fan as opposed to the musician or scholar, but it's fairly heavy going for someone not well-versed in musical terminology. Still, a book any Beatle f ...more
Loved this book. Great explanation and critique of The Beatles' songs and albums. Mr. Riley does an in-depth job of breaking down the songs, perhaps too in-depth because there were passages that I didn't quite understand (not having a background in music theory). However, overall I found this to be a very entertaining and informative book.
Very good book. Not thrilled with the anti Harrison stance. I think Riley underestimates his songs. Sometimes this book tends to ramble and be repetitive. However it is worth reading and does do something almost every other Beatle book doesn't, deals with the music and not the mania. I recommend it to friends and students all the time.
Nov 10, 2012 Melanie rated it 3 of 5 stars · review of another edition
A frustrating analysis of the Beatles work. On the one hand, Riley is trying to do some actual analysis of their music, on the other, he gets LYRICS wrong and is a bit too in love with the scratch of his critic's pen for his own good. There are some worthwhile insights in there, but there is also a lot of annoyingness.
Slogged through the first half of the book. You'd think it would be hard to make the Beatles music boring but that's what it was. It has picked up a bit as he get's into Sgt. Pepper's. Last third of the book was interesting, although I had a very hard time finishing.
NPR CRITIC, AUTHOR, PIANIST, and SPEAKER TIM RILEY reviews pop and classical music for NPR's HERE AND NOW, and has written for the HUFFINGTON POST, THE WASHINGTON POST, SLATE.COM and SALON.COM. He was trained as a classical pianist at Oberlin and Eastman, and remains among the few critics who writes about both "high" and "low" culture and their overlapping concerns.More about Tim Riley...
Brown University sponsored Rile ...more
Brown University sponsored Rile ...more