239th out of 2,947 books
—
12,433 voters
Job: A Comedy of Justice
After he firewalked in Polynesia, the world wasn't the same for Alexander Hergensheimer, now called Alec Graham. As natural accidents occurred without cease, Alex knew Armageddon and the Day of Judgement were near. Somehow he had to bring his beloved heathen, Margrethe, to a state of grace, and, while he was at it, save the rest of the world ....
Paperback, 448 pages
Published
October 12th 1985
by Del Rey
(first published 1984)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I really tried to like this book, but I just didn't get it. The characters were flat and the scenarios they found themselves in seemed so episodic and inconsequential that, by about halfway through the book, I grew bored and apathetic. It was recommended to me by someone whose taste I admire, but the book wasn't for me.
A modern-day (well, set in 1994, written in 1984) retelling of the story of Job from the Biblical Old Testament, with quite the sci-fi twist. Alexander Hergensheimer is a pious church fundraiser who is experiencing something very weird. He participated in a native fire walking during a cruise ship vacation and regains consciousness in a world not his own. It looks very much like Earth, but everything is different: culture, values, technology, even his name! He falls for his stewardess and therea...more
Heinlein's take on the biblical story of Job is a little less biblically based and a lot more fantastically oriented. That said, it is quite an interesting story, with a double share of twists and turns, and throughout it all you're rather unsure exactly where Heinlein is going.
The more religious minded might be rather offended at Heinlein's theological inversion of good and bad. I think this would be a tragedy, because the wide range of religions interwoven here it seems quite obvious this is n...more
The more religious minded might be rather offended at Heinlein's theological inversion of good and bad. I think this would be a tragedy, because the wide range of religions interwoven here it seems quite obvious this is n...more
An odd novel; Heinlein, the doyen of doyens of golden-age SF, writes what is essentially a theological novel, although buried in there is a many-worlds, universe-hopping SFnal tale. If it's not all just a hallucination anyway.
It's very odd to read a new-to-me Heinlein now, in the C21, some thirty to thirty-five years after I devoured all the Heinlein I could get. This contains some vintage themes and in some ways feels like it was a dry run for /Stranger in a Strange Land/ - it is, essentially,...more
It's very odd to read a new-to-me Heinlein now, in the C21, some thirty to thirty-five years after I devoured all the Heinlein I could get. This contains some vintage themes and in some ways feels like it was a dry run for /Stranger in a Strange Land/ - it is, essentially,...more
The key to understanding this book lies in the subtitle, "A Comedy of Justice." It exactly mirrors the subtitle of James Branch Cabell's breakthrough best seller, "Jurgen." And the plot is similar. Dig deeper, and you will discover that Cabell was Heinlein's favorite author, and that all of Heinlein's later works, from "Stranger in a Strange Land" onward, were attempts to mimic Cabell"s 18-volume "Biography of the Life of Manuel," of which "Jurgen: A Comedy of Justice" was not the best, merely t...more
In someways I think my journey to this book will always outlast the book itself.
When I was seventeen I told my boss I would read this book, that had been so influential to his young catholic school life. It was one of only two gallon sized bags worth of objects prized from my worst car wreck in my early twenties. It has been the lasting joke of a decade. Whether I had finally read it.
And this late winter, in the year I will turn 29, he sent me a second copy. It is pristine, and not as tender w...more
When I was seventeen I told my boss I would read this book, that had been so influential to his young catholic school life. It was one of only two gallon sized bags worth of objects prized from my worst car wreck in my early twenties. It has been the lasting joke of a decade. Whether I had finally read it.
And this late winter, in the year I will turn 29, he sent me a second copy. It is pristine, and not as tender w...more
Usually classified as sci-fi due to the frequent moves from one alternate world to another. But is a terribly sharp satire on the fundamentalist religionists. Main character Alec is a preacher/fundraiser for a fundamentalist church called the Churches United for Decency (C.U.D.). Along the way his moral standards are tried mightily by earths where scanty clothing is the norm, not to mention the fact that his alter ego is carrying on an affair with his lovely female steward. Any money he accumula...more
Nov 18, 2011
Michele Brenton
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
open minded people with a sense of wonder and imagination.
Shelves:
science-fiction-and-fantasy
Yet another of my perennial favourites. I regularly pick this one up and re-read it.
Each time I find something new to enjoy.
One of the things I'm enjoying this time is the character of Margarethe as I have got to know some people of her nationality and now the dialogue involving her has suddenly become more amusing.
This is a work that leads to a great deal of pondering on the part of the reader as Heinlein's main character Alex Hergensheimer is a philosopher extraordinaire and a Christian minist...more
Each time I find something new to enjoy.
One of the things I'm enjoying this time is the character of Margarethe as I have got to know some people of her nationality and now the dialogue involving her has suddenly become more amusing.
This is a work that leads to a great deal of pondering on the part of the reader as Heinlein's main character Alex Hergensheimer is a philosopher extraordinaire and a Christian minist...more
To start, it is the year 1994, and in Alexander Hergensheimer's world, there are no airplanes, television, computers or traffic lights. Their only form of aeronautic transportation comes in the form of dirigibles. The world is incredibly moralistic, with abortion now termed a capital offense. A "federal law making the manufacture, sale, possession, importation, transportation, and/or use of any contraceptive drug or device a felony carrying a mandatory prison sentence of not less than a year and...more
REALLY disappointing. I'd heard good reviews of this book and I like religious ideas in fiction. So, I was hopeful.
The SF content wasn't impressive. Alternate universe hopping-only not very interesting hops. The visits to heaven and hell were a little interesting.
The religious content was REALLY weak. Basically, yeah, Job was treated like crap by God(indirectly, by having the Devil do the work). The original story was FAR better done. One interesting thing, because of the perspective. I don't kn...more
The SF content wasn't impressive. Alternate universe hopping-only not very interesting hops. The visits to heaven and hell were a little interesting.
The religious content was REALLY weak. Basically, yeah, Job was treated like crap by God(indirectly, by having the Devil do the work). The original story was FAR better done. One interesting thing, because of the perspective. I don't kn...more
This was... a weird book. It starts off strong with lots of comedic value and crazy shenanigans, so it managed to capture me right away and I thought it was fantastic. I also liked the style of writing, e.g. you never quite knew if everything was in the character's imagination or if the Rapture was real, until the last few chapters. I also liked the fact that the main character was questioning a lot of things throughout the book.
That being said, Heinlein's sexism comes through pretty strong, whi...more
That being said, Heinlein's sexism comes through pretty strong, whi...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Warning!!! The following review contains some spoilers.
In 1967, a military doctor in Soviet Union wrote a story about a man and the love of his life. The story was not about just those two, but also about Jesus, Satan, and all kinds of mystical events and fantastical characters. I am talking about The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov. Seventeen years later, a retired naval officer, physicist and mathematician in the United States of America wrote a book that is the mirror image of Bulgak...more
In 1967, a military doctor in Soviet Union wrote a story about a man and the love of his life. The story was not about just those two, but also about Jesus, Satan, and all kinds of mystical events and fantastical characters. I am talking about The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov. Seventeen years later, a retired naval officer, physicist and mathematician in the United States of America wrote a book that is the mirror image of Bulgak...more
An odd duck.
I loved this book back when I bought it (the early 80's), but this reread has me pondering. At the time, I think I enjoyed the transgressive nature of the book (a Heinlein take on fundamentalist Christianity), but this reading left me wanting a deeper examination.
While the plot lifts loosely from the plot of the book of Job, the book as a whole does not refer to the dialogues of Job. And really, the bulk of Job is the discussion between Job, his friends, and (finally) God. The plot...more
I loved this book back when I bought it (the early 80's), but this reread has me pondering. At the time, I think I enjoyed the transgressive nature of the book (a Heinlein take on fundamentalist Christianity), but this reading left me wanting a deeper examination.
While the plot lifts loosely from the plot of the book of Job, the book as a whole does not refer to the dialogues of Job. And really, the bulk of Job is the discussion between Job, his friends, and (finally) God. The plot...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Most recent re-read, and, each time, I enjoy this book more. Yeah, it's full of standard Heinleinian philosophizing, yeah it suffers from a multitude of (literal) deus ex machina ... but Alec Graham is a fun character, a diamond in the rough, culturally prejudiced while remaining pure at heart and fiercely dedicated to love: an appropriate saint.
Having read more Twain since my original review, I also see far more parallels to Twain's works ("Letters from Earth" in particular).
The book is, in sh...more
Having read more Twain since my original review, I also see far more parallels to Twain's works ("Letters from Earth" in particular).
The book is, in sh...more
This book is like distilled Heinlein. Women who are generally intelligent sex objects and the men who love them, slightly awkward but nonetheless charming dialogue, and a healthy smattering of really thought provoking lines.
Not a spoiler: "On reflection I realized that I was in exactly the same predicament as every other human being alive. We don't know who we are, or where we came from, or why we are here. My dilemma was merely fresher, not different.
"One thing (possibly the only thing) I lear...more
Not a spoiler: "On reflection I realized that I was in exactly the same predicament as every other human being alive. We don't know who we are, or where we came from, or why we are here. My dilemma was merely fresher, not different.
"One thing (possibly the only thing) I lear...more
9/28/2003 - 8/10
Job touched on a lot of the same themes as Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land - free love, hypocrisy of religion and juvenile portrayals of women as smart and able yet extremely subservient. Job had some interesting (heretical, yet funny) views about God and Satan, and Heaven and Hell with some interesting religious questions to think about. 'Job', in this case, is a conservative evangelical who is tossed about between some interesting alternate realities. The story was kind o...more
Job touched on a lot of the same themes as Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land - free love, hypocrisy of religion and juvenile portrayals of women as smart and able yet extremely subservient. Job had some interesting (heretical, yet funny) views about God and Satan, and Heaven and Hell with some interesting religious questions to think about. 'Job', in this case, is a conservative evangelical who is tossed about between some interesting alternate realities. The story was kind o...more
With all the Heinlein bashing going on over the past two decades, it is easy to forget how much I enjoyed and appreciated this novel as a college freshmen in 1988-- just a few months after Heinlein died I read this odd journey through various realities and 'religions' that was nevertheless a breath of fresh air for me at the time. I was surrounded by fundamentalists (in the heart of Michele Bachmann territory) and secretly gay which meant I was literally living in Hell at the time with only book...more
Posted on my blog:
Like many Heinlein novels, this one is pretty weird in spots. It also challenges a lot of religious beliefs, and also atheists…. I also think that this book was fairly run of the mill until the very very end and I’m sad that Heinlein waited until the end to make the book so awesome. However, if you are a person who liked the place His Dark Materials ended up, you will probably like the end of Job as well and I would recommend reading it just for the fun thought experiment.
Title...more
Like many Heinlein novels, this one is pretty weird in spots. It also challenges a lot of religious beliefs, and also atheists…. I also think that this book was fairly run of the mill until the very very end and I’m sad that Heinlein waited until the end to make the book so awesome. However, if you are a person who liked the place His Dark Materials ended up, you will probably like the end of Job as well and I would recommend reading it just for the fun thought experiment.
Title...more
Based loosely on the Job in the bible the protagonist suffers parallel world type tribulations. For some reason the parallel worlds all seemed to branch from the 1890s.
The "good" women are compliant sex goddesses; intelligent but not uppity. The sole evil woman was spoke her mind. Ladies, there's a lesson for you. The dialog with the good women was reminiscent of his "Time for Love" collection of stories about Lazarus Long. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Eno...
I enjoyed his extrapolations on...more
The "good" women are compliant sex goddesses; intelligent but not uppity. The sole evil woman was spoke her mind. Ladies, there's a lesson for you. The dialog with the good women was reminiscent of his "Time for Love" collection of stories about Lazarus Long. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Eno...
I enjoyed his extrapolations on...more
This book is awful. I never liked Heinlein, but I found this on Junk Day and decided to give it a try. My god, does it suck. The prose is around a third-grade level and the plot couldn't be any less interesting. The thing that totally ruined it for me was that, if he's supposed to be Job, why is he given the girl of his dreams to accompany him on his interdimensional jaunts? And if washing dishes in Mexico is your idea of Hell, you are an extremely sheltered human being. I didn't even finish thi...more
I had been meaning to read this for years! As always RAH will make you think as you read. His take (or skewering )of fundamentalist religious dogma, and what happens to the main character Alec/Alexander as he progresses through Heinlein's version of the trials of Job is quite amazing.
Alec passes through various incarnations of Earth from his own 1994 with no jets, television or traffic lights, to the final incarnation where he is taken by the Rapture. Alas his beloved Marga is lost. At that poi...more
Alec passes through various incarnations of Earth from his own 1994 with no jets, television or traffic lights, to the final incarnation where he is taken by the Rapture. Alas his beloved Marga is lost. At that poi...more
A little bit like "Sliders." A man goes through a fire-walk only do discover he's been transported into a parallel universe. He meets the love of his life, and they end up being transported through multiple universes together. But he's afraid that, because she isn't a believer, that she won't be in heaven with him after they die. Eventually, they do die, and when he finds his love not in heaven with him, he doesn't hesitate to go to the edge of heaven's clouds and jump off, plummeting into the p...more
If you're familiar with Heinlein, this book should be familiar territory. His writing style in later years is rather distinctive, especially his (or the character's) views of women, sex, and so on. Nonetheless, this is a good book which discusses religion and picks some of it apart. The ending of the book explains things quite nicely, and Hell is a rather lovely place. Satan is a pretty nice guy... not surprising given that this is a Heinlein book. Overall recommend if you're already experienced...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Nov 25, 2012
Rodan
added it
Fundamentalist Christian Soldier, Alexander Hergensheimer walks through fire and vanishes. He woke to find himself trapped in the past, facing mirror images that were not his own and driven by an unknown force to change history for the better. His only guide on this journey is Margrethe, an adulterous woman from his own time, who appears in the form of a hologram that only Alec can see and hear. And so Mr. Hergensheimer finds himself leaping from life to life, striving to put right what once wen...more
When I was ten or eleven, my best pal's mother, noticing my inclinations toward reading, gave me this book, though I doubt the stupid and subliterate battle-ax actually read it. Back then, I would have given it three stars had the internet and goodreads and all that existed. I still have the book, of course, and a nostalgic reread of the first fifteen pages moved it down to two stars. It probably would have taken less than ten additional pages to demote it even further. Some things are best left...more
This was a rather odd intertwining of old-time Christian religion and the science fiction of parallel universes. Based on Heinlein's reputation, I initially approached it as science fiction and found myself getting as frustrated as the main characters in trying to distinguish reality. But then, either because I recalled the subtitle and started reading it as comedy, or because it simply got funnier, I began to enjoy it more about halfway through for its comedic playfulness. And then I was surpri...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Job, Eh? | 12 | 91 | Sep 21, 2012 08:08pm |
Robert Anson Heinlein was an American novelist and science fiction writer. Often called "the dean of science fiction writers", he is one of the most popular, influential, and controversial authors of "hard science fiction".
He set a high standard for science and engineering plausibility and helped to raise the genre's standards of literary quality. He was the first SF writer to break into mainstre...more
More about Robert A. Heinlein...
He set a high standard for science and engineering plausibility and helped to raise the genre's standards of literary quality. He was the first SF writer to break into mainstre...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“God created men to test the souls of women.”
—
57 people liked it
“My only regret involved the sad knowledge that I could not handle the amount of alcohol I would have enjoyed. “Easy is the descent into Hell.”
—
6 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view 1 comment
















