89th out of 237 books
—
78 voters
Gertrude
With Gertrude, Herman Hesse continues his lifelong exploration of the irreconcilable elements of human existence. In this fictional memoir, the renowned composer Kuhn recounts his tangled relationships with two artists--his friend Heinrich Muoth, a brooding, self-destructive opera singer, and the gentle, self-assured Gertrude Imthor. Kuhn is drawn to Gertrude upon their fi...more
Paperback, 256 pages
Published
August 1st 2005
by Picador
(first published 1910)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Hermann Hesse's Gertrude and Knut Hamsun's Victoria share a common bond about man's attempt to fight fate, fate's conspiracy against man in his search for inner peace and lasting love. Kuhn, the student, aspiring composer and central character, seeks direction and purpose, understanding, and eventually, solace, through his life struggles, which lead him towards the path of unrequited love, an attempt at suicide, success and fame, death of close friends, and finally to peaceful resignation.
Gertru...more
Gertru...more
Tiene un estilo formal que puede sonar cursi o afectado. Quizá porque fue escrita a principios del siglo pasado. Leí la versión española de Emilio Ávila de la Torre. Me gustó porque me parece que describe muy bien el alma pesarosa de los artistas o mentes creadoras que tienen mucha sensibilidad. Es la historia de un músico, así que cualquier músico compositor podría sentirse conectado con el personaje principal. Pero creo que la forma en que describe el proceso creativo se podría bien aplicar a...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Dacă există ceva creat de om care să poată ajuta trăirea și purtarea existenței, acest ceva cu siguranță are în plămădeală muzică și scriere.
Pentru mine, acest ceva este Hesse, cărțile lui și spiritul lui, impregnat în scriere și îndreptat, direcționat, dedicat cititorului. Tot ce-a creat (și din ce-am citit) e despre natura umană și o încercare de a o înțelege fără a o judeca prea aspru. Fără a-i impune îmbunătățire.
Doar că acel uman prezent în lucrările sale are o puritate aproape inumană az...more
Pentru mine, acest ceva este Hesse, cărțile lui și spiritul lui, impregnat în scriere și îndreptat, direcționat, dedicat cititorului. Tot ce-a creat (și din ce-am citit) e despre natura umană și o încercare de a o înțelege fără a o judeca prea aspru. Fără a-i impune îmbunătățire.
Doar că acel uman prezent în lucrările sale are o puritate aproape inumană az...more
Another novel about unrequited love. The book shows the influence of Nietzsche and the split between Dionysian passion and the intellectual and cerebral virtues of the Apollonian aspect. This duality reminded me a little of Death In Venice by Thomas Mann, which I have also read this month.
The main protagonist Kuhn, is a fairly successful composer who is looking back. Kuhn reminded me a little of Philip Carey in Maugham's Of Human Bondage (which I have also read recently), because of his physica...more
The main protagonist Kuhn, is a fairly successful composer who is looking back. Kuhn reminded me a little of Philip Carey in Maugham's Of Human Bondage (which I have also read recently), because of his physica...more
رواية رائعة ، بشكل عام أعشق الروايات الدراميةالتي سوف تجد نفسك فيها بشكل أو بآخر .
ذكرتني بفلم
Revolutionary Road
اقتباس "
فالقدر ليس رحيما، والحياة متقلبة وفظيعة، ولا خير ولا في عقل في الطبيعة، ولكن الخير والعقل موجودان فينا، نحن البشر، الذين يتلاعب بنا القدر، وفي إمكاننا أن نكون أقوى من الطبيعة ومن القدر، ولو حتى لبضع ساعات. ويمكننا أن نتقارب وقت الحاجة، وان نتبادل الفهم والحب، ونعيش ليواسي أحدنا الآخر.
وأحياناً عندما يرين الصمت في الأعماق السحيقة، في وسعنا أن نقوم بما هو أكثر. نستطيع عندئذ أن ن...more
ذكرتني بفلم
Revolutionary Road
اقتباس "
فالقدر ليس رحيما، والحياة متقلبة وفظيعة، ولا خير ولا في عقل في الطبيعة، ولكن الخير والعقل موجودان فينا، نحن البشر، الذين يتلاعب بنا القدر، وفي إمكاننا أن نكون أقوى من الطبيعة ومن القدر، ولو حتى لبضع ساعات. ويمكننا أن نتقارب وقت الحاجة، وان نتبادل الفهم والحب، ونعيش ليواسي أحدنا الآخر.
وأحياناً عندما يرين الصمت في الأعماق السحيقة، في وسعنا أن نقوم بما هو أكثر. نستطيع عندئذ أن ن...more
Very nice book! About love that's not meant to be, about passion for music and about friendship. It's a very easy read, taking notice of the fact that the story was written about a century ago. If you like Hesse's work you should absolutely read this.
Hesse can wrap words around subtleties i thought people could only slightly sense the truth of.
Hesse can wrap words around subtleties i thought people could only slightly sense the truth of.
"Düşünme denen şeyin çilesini çekmeyenler, sabahleyin yataktan kalkmayı kıvançla karşılar, yiyip, içecek olmalarına sevinir, yeterli görür bunları, durumun başka türlü olmasını istemez. ne var ki, bu doğallığı elden çıkaranlar günün akışı içinde hırsla, gözlerini açarak gerçek hayatı yaşayacak anları kollarlar; öyle anlar ki çakıvermeleri mutlu kılar insanı, bütün yaşamın anlam ve amacına ilişkin tüm düşüncelerle zaman duygusunu silip atar. Bu gibi anlar yaratıcı anlar diye nitelenebilir, çünkü...more
Karşımıza Gertrud’da bir müzik insanı olarak çıkan Kuhn ile satıra dökülmüş kelimeler arasında gördüğümüz Hermann Hesse, hemen her kitabında olduğu gibi yine bir sanatçının gözünden bir hikaye anlatıyor aslında. Kitap boyunca yazılmaya başlanması sürecinden tutun da hazırlık sürecine kadar takip edilebilen bir operanın hikayesini de Gertrud’da olan bitene paralel olarak görüşümüz bundan olsa gerek. Ve bu da benim gözümde Hesse’yi, karşıma bazen ressam bazen de müzisyen olarak, ama sürekli bir sa...more
There's something I really like about Hesse's work. Maybe someday I'll work to develop into a thinker, and have more to say about it all. But for now, snippets:
p. 9: At the same time I also had periods of daydreaming when I improvised on the violin and enjoyed the intoxication of fleeting impressions and exalted moods. I soon knew that this was not creativeness but just playing and running riot, against which I had to guard. I realized that it was one thing to indulge in daydreaming and intoxica...more
p. 9: At the same time I also had periods of daydreaming when I improvised on the violin and enjoyed the intoxication of fleeting impressions and exalted moods. I soon knew that this was not creativeness but just playing and running riot, against which I had to guard. I realized that it was one thing to indulge in daydreaming and intoxica...more
Not the easiest book to get through. It's pretty dark and sad. But definitely some of the most beautiful writing I've read. This is probably one of my favorite quote of all time:
"Fate was not kind, life was capricious and terrible, and there was no good reason in nature. But there is good and reason in us, in human beings, with whom fortune plays, and we can be stronger than nature and fate, if only for a few hours. And we can draw close to one another in times of need, understand and love one a...more
"Fate was not kind, life was capricious and terrible, and there was no good reason in nature. But there is good and reason in us, in human beings, with whom fortune plays, and we can be stronger than nature and fate, if only for a few hours. And we can draw close to one another in times of need, understand and love one a...more
It is very interesting to read Hermann Hesse extensively and see his development as a thinker and writer. Gertrude has many of Hesse’s central ideas stated in their early and not fully developed forms. It’s almost like seeing a young mind at work, as his works progress his philosophies become more crystallized and his writing becomes more captivating. Gertrude is like a rough draft of many of the ideas central to Hesse’s works. While it is interesting and has its moments, the book doesn’t quite...more
Sounds like an existential law firm for the humanities: “Student, Painter and Musician Esq.” (The subject of Hesses’ first three novels.) This novel deals with the composer Herr Kuhn and his tangled relationship with the worldly singer Heinrich Mouth and the woman they love and share(!) Gerturde. Hesse begins his lifelong quest for exploring the conflict between the good (piety) and evil (worldliness). The subject of his later masterwork “Narcissus and Goldman.” Similar to Goethe in its existent...more
Excellent, thoughtful novel concerning a lonely artist who finds happiness in loving an attractive woman. His friend also falls in love with her and they get married. Soon his friend's bad side shows itself and the marriage dissolves as he commits suicide. The narrator almost did the same thing when he found out about the relationship. Hesse tells us that our life is meaningless unless we devote it to others. Youth is happy, but egotistical while in old age we aren't so self-involved but long fo...more
The themes of love, passion, music, solitude, finding your path in life, family, friendship all speak deeply to me. There are so many wise quotes throughout that seemed aimed at me. A sullen story but it felt like it gives me hope. Its ideas on wisdom and truth were very apropos to what I want to become. The idea that idleness can have worth if you make it so. Youth and old age, how you view things as your perspective grows and changes. Suicide and what leads people to that point. Believing and...more
الآن شعرت قليلًا بسبب التقدير الذي يحمله تاركوفسكي لهيرمان هسه..
هيرمان هسه يحتاج لحالةٍ من الهدوء لقراءته هذا ما أحسست به,,تحتاج للهدوء لكي تتمكن من الاستمتاع بالهدوء المطلق الذي يسيطر على طريقته في السرد,على هدوء الأحداث في الرواية الهدوء الذي تفرضه أجواء الرواية التي تدور في محيط أرستقراطي في ألمانيا..
كل شيء بطيء ولكن في مرحلة معينة أثناء القراءة يجبرك على الامساك بالكتاب حتى النهاية..
الرواية لا تحمل أي نوع من الأمل الأحمق بالحياة كما يفعل باولو كويلو وكذلك لا تراجيديا هنا بل حياة فقط والاحسا...more
هيرمان هسه يحتاج لحالةٍ من الهدوء لقراءته هذا ما أحسست به,,تحتاج للهدوء لكي تتمكن من الاستمتاع بالهدوء المطلق الذي يسيطر على طريقته في السرد,على هدوء الأحداث في الرواية الهدوء الذي تفرضه أجواء الرواية التي تدور في محيط أرستقراطي في ألمانيا..
كل شيء بطيء ولكن في مرحلة معينة أثناء القراءة يجبرك على الامساك بالكتاب حتى النهاية..
الرواية لا تحمل أي نوع من الأمل الأحمق بالحياة كما يفعل باولو كويلو وكذلك لا تراجيديا هنا بل حياة فقط والاحسا...more
Although slightly melodramatic and obvious, Hesse had some very touching paragraphs and ideas about selflessness, music and love. The characters were vivid and made real, yet there was a silent delicacy to their fancies. Some moral melodrama could've been left out, even though it wasn't anywhere near enough to bother me. I wouldn't classify it as a masterpiece, but I happened to read it in a very vulnerable time and it helped me solve some very deep routed thought processes and conflicts in myse...more
Sep 24, 2012
Happy When
added it
Another classic by Hesse.
May 13, 2011
Erik Graff
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Hesse fans
Recommended to Erik by:
no one
Shelves:
literature
I see by the reviews that this novel, Hesse's third, is sometimes seen as a gloss on Nietzsche's Apollonian/Dionysian schema in his The Birth of Tragedy. Unless forewarned, I tend to read novels like I watch movies--like a child, disbelief and critical apparati suspended. After picking this volume up at Stuart Brent Books on Chicago's Michigan Avenue, I devoured it quickly during quiet times at work around the corner on Ontario and saw no great depths or wide horizons of implication in it.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Hermann Hesse was a German-Swiss poet, novelist, and painter. In 1946, he received the Nobel Prize in Literature. His best known works include Steppenwolf, Siddhartha, and The Glass Bead Game (also known as Magister Ludi) which explore an individual's search for spirituality outside society.
Hesse was born in the Black Forest town of Calw to a Christian missionary family. Both of his parents served...more
More about Hermann Hesse...
Hesse was born in the Black Forest town of Calw to a Christian missionary family. Both of his parents served...more
Share This Book
5 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Era linistitor sa stiu ca seara nu voi mai trai.”
—
3 people liked it
“Aun cuando mi destino externo se haya desenvuelto como sucede para todos, inevitablemente y según lo decretado por los dioses, mi vida íntima es obra propiamente mía, con sus gozos y amarguras, y soy yo, en lo personal, el responsable de la misma.”
—
2 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






































Oct 12, 2011 07:46pm