7th out of 20 books — 8 voters
Rivers of Empire: Water, Aridity, and the Growth of the American West
When Henry David Thoreau went for his daily walk, he would consult his instincts on which direction to follow. More often than not his inner compass pointed west or southwest. "The future lies that way to me," he explained, "and the earth seems more unexhausted and richer on that side." In his own imaginative way, Thoreau was imitating the countless young pioneers, prospec...more
Paperback, 416 pages
Published June 18th 1992 by Oxford University Press, USA
(first published 1986)
To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
(showing 1-30 of 365)
In his 1985 work Rivers of Empire Donald Worster studied the political and social implications of the increasingly extensive irrigation works projects that transformed the arid inland valleys of California into agricultural meccas. The intricate, centralized control of water that made the desert bloom had not, Worster argued, done the same for democracy. Agriculture could not exist without water, and from the late 19th century on the expense of constructing and maintaining irrigation projects ha...more
Donald Worster recognizes that west of the hundredth meridian, he who has the water rights makes the rules. Or rather, this history of the west posits that the scarcity of water in the arid west made it the most important resource. Therefore, by chronicling how water was controlled and developed by "elites of wealth and technological power," Worster sets out to show how no other factor is more important to the growth and history of the West. Beginning first with a reflection from a ditch in the...more
Water. You can drink it; you can swim in it; you can use it to grow crops and even power entire cities. All of this can be done with the use of something as simple and abundant as water. However, as any first grade student can tell you, without clean water to drink, human beings would die. Without sufficient rainfall, crops would not grow. Water may be everywhere, but that doesn't mean we have a drop to drink. Nothing about water is as simple or as abundant as it might seem.
In Donald Worster’s...more
In Donald Worster’s...more
This book is a tough read. It features quite a few pages on Marx and a German philosopher named Wittfogel who write about what it is that big irrigation projects do to the societies that build them. In the end there is a bit of description of how the Western US could have been settled without Hoover dam and the like. Not a lot of take home value in this environmental history. It did give a good context in which to consider water projects that are under consideration today.
The American West continues to need irrigation resources but as with the Colorado Flood of 2013 water can sometimes overwhelm the people. Wurster is a prolific author and I wish more of his books were in the Corning, Ia library. So many promising writers out there and I've set my goal to read 10 a month and perhaps write one of my own about the freedom people enjoy in the American West and the stark landscape of mountainous arid terrain,
Concentrating less on government corruption and waste than "Cadillac Desert" and more on water allocation as a form of social control, Worster's analysis of Western water projects paints--in my opinion--an even scarier picture of the future of the West than "Cadillac Desert." He points out that in an arid environment like ours, he who holds the keys to cheap water holds great power and control. While I do agree with him on this point, I do not know for sure if this system has created as much pot...more
Dec 10, 2011 Donald Linnemeyer rated it 4 of 5 stars
This is one of those books that are fascinating or its sheer originality. As an American, I've never really thought about water scarcity, at least not about it actually affecting me. But Worster puts the irrigation history of the west at the forefront of America history, and he places us in that story, still to be decided. Throw in some interesting Marxist analysis of western settlement (water scarcity typically leads to powerful, centralized, oppressive government), and you've got a great read.
Fear the Iron Triangle - the alliance between politicians, businesses and the regulatory offices created to maintain standards of safety, sustainablity and democracy. Political and economic systems reliant on this alliance become anti-democratic, anti-environment, and anti-life in thier amoral and unaccountable pursuit of profit and power.
It was really good, even infuriating at times... Although it filled in gaps with stuff I didn't know, if you've read other books on water and dam-building, etc. some of the information is already covered. The conclusion was also pretty far-fetched, but overall a really good book.
The author claims that Mormons only settled the great desert in the western US b/c they were under the threat of excommunication from the "shadow theocracy" in Salt Lake. Couldn't have been that they wanted land to farm where they wouldn't be persecuted.