Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “A Jury of Her Peers: American Women Writers from Anne Bradstreet to Annie Proulx” as Want to Read:
A Jury of Her Peers: American Women Writers from Anne Bradstreet to Annie Proulx
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

A Jury of Her Peers: American Women Writers from Anne Bradstreet to Annie Proulx

4.0 of 5 stars 4.00  ·  rating details  ·  202 ratings  ·  48 reviews
A Jury of Her Peers is an unprecedented literary landmark: the first comprehensive history of American women writers from 1650 to 2000.

In a narrative of immense scope and fascination—brimming with Elaine Showalter’s characteristic wit and incisive opinions—we are introduced to more than 250 female writers. These include not only famous and expected names (Harriet Beecher S
...more
Hardcover, 512 pages
Published February 24th 2009 by Knopf
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Jury of Her Peers, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about A Jury of Her Peers

The Book Thief by Markus ZusakFahrenheit 451 by Ray BradburyMatilda by Roald DahlThe Shadow of the Wind by Carlos Ruiz ZafónThe Thirteenth Tale by Diane Setterfield
Books about Books
271st out of 636 books — 996 voters
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper LeeSecrets of the Realm by Bev StoutLittle Women by Louisa May AlcottGone with the Wind by Margaret MitchellThe Color Purple by Alice Walker
Best Books by American Women
249th out of 281 books — 198 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 938)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jessica
May 18, 2009 Jessica rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: americans; women; writers; readers or potential readers of american women writers; thirty-year-olds
Recommended to Jessica by: dan redican, via salon article link
Shelves: chicklits
This is a really great book. Elaine Showalter claims to have written the first comprehensive overview of American women writers, and as I love and trust Dr. Showalter, I have no reason at all not to believe her.

First of all: Elaine Showalter is married. To a man. Yes, yes, I was disappointed too, but if we can't sweep her off her feet and spirit her away to live in our castle, at least we might enjoy her engaging critical history of important lady authors from the Pilgrims' day until now! Dry yo
...more
Ms. Online
SOMETIMES A PEN IS JUST A PEN
Jennifer Cognard-Black


Review of A Jury of Her Peers: American Women Writers from Anne Bradstreet to Annie Proulx
By Elaine Showalter
Knopf

Authors breed books. Like mothers, they grow and nurture their creations. Yet the word author is derived from the Latin auctor and actually means a male begetter, or father. As authors Sarah Gilbert and Susan Gubar famously claimed in their 1979 book Madwoman in the Attic, a study of Victorian women writers, a “pen is in some sense…
...more
Catherine
One of the more comprehensive books of its kind. I have a more mixed reaction to it than the 4 stars indicates but I think it's an important work and well worth reading. On the plus side, Showalter introduces readers to women writers that I for one have never run across before. There are short biographies and descriptions of their work, which are also useful. The book design is also quite outstanding, and it supports Showalter's style so well that reading this book is a pleasure, despite its siz ...more
Stephanie
This was a very readable discussion of American women's writing from the beginning through the '70s. I really loved most of it, although it helped that I was on an early American women's writing kick just a couple of years ago. Starting around the 1840s, the book generally covers the subject decade by decade, sometimes pegging writers into the most fitting decade and sometimes (more as the book goes on) revisiting them later. There's a good analysis of the writers (up until the middle of the 20t ...more
Russell
It is hard to review a book that really is only a literary history of women in American Literature. All I will say is, I learned a lot. I did find some of the sections that were used to create a history too long. And some of the authors that were focused on, are forgotten for a reason. But I did get introducted to a number of terms and time periods of American Lit. I was not aware of.

My biggest issue was with the moder women. I am a huge fan of a lot of them - Toni Morrison being one of my favor
...more
Karen
Four and a half, really. It took me awhile to finish this but it was worth it. The book is broad in scope and very readable. As with any undertaking of this size, there will be quibbles about specific authors, but it all leads to great conversations about books, so that's what's most important. I've started a TBR list from it to begin next year. I would have liked a bibliography included.
Stephany
I did it! I finished the whole tome last night.

This book was published in 2009 and it's the first anthology of American women writers. Just saying.

Having attended an all-girls high school that did a fair job of highlighting the contributions of women in various subjects, and having obtained a Women's Studies certificate in college, I didn't think that so much in this book would be new to me. Oh, it was - and I gained a huge to-read list of women writers that I've been plowing through since.

I'd n
...more
Mick
My response to this book is complicated. I think it does important work; no book like this has ever been compiled. However, it makes me wonder what, exactly, we're counting on a "literary history" to do. I may find bits (small bits) of this text useful in pointing me toward previously unfamiliar authors whose work might prove fruitful for my dissertation; beyond that, however, I question its usefulness and, more importantly, the effect it has on the body of American women writers that it treats. ...more
Mandy
Fascinating interview with the Economist on their podcast on this, and remarkable that this is the first literary history of women writers.

After reading: Engaging history of American women's writing, came away with a new perspective on the challenges posed by the endeavor over time and a list of authors that I need to read. Reviewers have criticized Showalter for a. being overly harsh re: Gertrude Stein and b. not expressing as much enthusiasm for the later writers. I can't speak to a, but I thi
...more
Kay Robart
Elaine Showalter has compiled an astonishingly complete literary history of the work of American women, beginning in the early 17th Century and covering through the 20th. She has written this book, she explains, because literature by American women has been consistently ignored or omitted from criticism, anthologies, and scholarly works. She points out that even novels and poetry that were very popular and widely read in their own times sank like a stone into oblivion afterwards because the work ...more
Melissa
This one gets easier to read as you get closer to the present - I think it's because the authors are actually recognizable (Morrison, Plath, Jackson, Rich, etc) as opposed to so many of the pre-twentieth century authors (Fanny Fern?). I do appreciate the research and work Showalter went to in finding overarching themes in women's writing at different time periods. The road to acceptance has not been smooth.

I still think longer/any excerpts of the authors' work should have been included. Copyrigh
...more
Jane
I'm about half way through this book and I'm finding it slow going. Showalter discusses so many women that she doesn't talk about any in depth. Still, there is a lot to interest me and I'm determined to get into the 20th century.

I have finished Showalter's A Jury of Her Peers, and found it ambitious and readable. It is heavily footnoted, but I just trusted in the footnotes and didn't read most of them. She discusses the roadblocks in the success of women's writing, which included poverty, ambiva
...more
Korri
This volume is an odd mix. Showalter gives detailed plot summaries and analyses of some authors' work while others are only represented by biographical details and the titles of their publications. I guess in this way Showalter replicates questions about the role of gender in art (i.e. how much does an artist's personal life matter in comparison to what she produces? should one look at a poem or novel aesthetically and/or contextually?) The form of the book directly relates to its subject and mi ...more
Melissa Railey
A Jury of Her Peers is a comprehensive look at the history of American women writers from the founding of America to the modern times. It examines women writers and gives a thorough study of each writer but Elaine Showalter never overdoes it. She seems to know that line between not enough information and too much information. The book is basically a textbook but it makes very good reading. I love reading about the history of women and the marks that women have made on history. The stories of ama ...more
Jenna
Read this entire textbook in my Fall 2014 Women Writers class at ODU. It taught me a TON about the history of women writing in America.
Vivian Valvano
I've come to the conclusion that some books try to render a history of a subject but only render a survey. There is great breadth, but not enough depth here. Showalter is such a noted critic that I expected more. She is obviously very knowledgeable and well read, but in an effort to write something about just about every woman who wrote, from Bradstreet to Proulx, she really does a "gallop" through the ages. And her handling of 20th-century authors by decade instead of by authors' oeuvres is esp ...more
Jayme
I found it hard to believe that a comprehensive criticism of American women's writing didn't exist until now. All of the courses I took in school gave me small sketches into the role of women in the literary narrative of our country, but this very readable book gave me a more complete picture. Obviously, there are many important writers left out. I could name many in this review. But overall, Showalter created a very interesting portrait. I really appreciated her approach-short biographies and c ...more
Martha
Showalter does a great job of placing each writer in her point in history, while also talking about the individual style, strengths, and weaknesses of her writing. She writes about the major themes of each era while making sure to include women who stood outside of those themes. By the end, you not only have a great sense of how women's writing has changed over time, but also a clear picture of how women's writing and the culture and politics of the day impacted each other.

Best of all, you learn
...more
Sarah Holz
Fabulous pull-together of women writing in the United States. Showalter is admirably evenhanded throughout, never shying away from literary criticism for the sake of the Sisterhood of Lady Writers (though in one small lapse it's pretty clear she's no Gertrude Stein fan...not being one especially myself it didn't particularly bother me). It's hard to imagine that anyone would be familiar with every name in the book either, so I found it a gold mine of new selections for my to-read list as well.
Erin (work)
Don't be intimidated by it's size: it's very readable and Showalter is engagingly opinionated. I am completely inspired to return to novel-reading--and it was a fantastic reminder of all the books I actually have read (versus thinking about all the books I haven't . . . . ). Not enough discussion of women poets--and not a book of literary criticism--and it is making a canon--but I recommend it.

**Important: she is really really wrong about Gertrude Stein.
Sarah
Just picked this up over the weekend and am currently dipping into it. I read some Showalter during my Am studies degree and greatly enjoyed her work, a well-informed and articulate scholar whose premise of putting American women's writing centre stage does not prevent her from offering cogent critiques of some of the work. It loses one star for lack of pictures, though, they would have been very useful to put faces to names.
Heather
This book should be required reading for any student of American literature. It highlights the diversity and breadth of American womens' writing, and reintroduces a lot of lost voices. More than anything, A Jury of her Peers makes me want to read, to track down all those women I've missed, and to revist those that I already love. A really great survey of literary traditions that have too often been ignored or trivialized.
Pamster
Okay, wow. Not that I don't have issues (where's Octavia Butler?), but this book is still amazing. It's something that hasn't been done before, and now it exists, and we can all point out our issues with it and have these super important conversations about canon. Awesome, important work. I read Maud Martha (AWESOME) after hearing Showalter do a reading and discussion to promote this book, so she's already improved my life.
Carolyn
I wish this had been out when I was tasked with teaching women's lit! It's a great run-down of notable women writers --perfect for syllabus-building. But it is a little strange to be reading a book that really just describes other books --a terrific way to discover authors, but I found myself wishing that Showalter had done more analysis or offered more insights, even though I know that wasn't her project.
Ed
Only read about 300 pages of this as there were a bunch of holds on it, but it is a great collection of amazing stories of women trying to create and find a place for themselves in this world. More about the writers' lives than the works themselves. QUIBBLE: Where the F is Jane Bowles? I think her story would have added a lot to the 40's chapter.
Deonne Kahler
I picked this up more out of duty to expand my education on the history of women writers than anything else, but ended up really enjoying it. It's academic - thoroughly researched, analytical, comparative - but it's also got spark and heart. This is no dry creaky tome, and was highly readable - all 512 pages of it. Recommended.
Jenny
Great book! It’s fun both for reference, and as a straight read-through. I didn’t agree with Showalter’s opinions all the time – she’s tough on Gertrude Stein – but mostly she’s generous and respectful towards her subjects. I enjoyed this book too much to make lists, so I have to go back and read it again.
Tara
A survey of the writing of American women, told in sequential short biographies. It outlines both the broad sweep of concerns and restrictions facing women writers as well as the specific obstacles and accomplishments of individuals. Engaging and anecdotal, it also serves as a nice reference book.
Heidi
Four stars for having written with it, even though I didn't always agree with the perspective. (Often, points given for appropriate political perspectives rather than for great writing and characterization.)

Depressing that England has so many 'greater' women writers than Americans.
Dee L.
This book was crammed with information, which made it tough to read for extended periods of time, but well worth it. I read through it while I was eating breakfast, getting an oil change, and during lunch breaks. Fascinating, informative, important. A+ book, highly recommended.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 31 32 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • A New Literary History of America
  • The Life and Death of Mary Wollstonecraft
  • The Essential Feminist Reader
  • The Madwoman in the Attic: The Woman Writer and the Nineteenth-Century Literary Imagination
  • From Eve to Dawn: A History of Women in the World, Vol. 1
  • The Cambridge Companion to Gothic Fiction
  • Seduction and Betrayal: Women and Literature
  • From Reverence to Rape: The Treatment of Women in the Movies
  • Passionate Minds: Women Rewriting the World
  • The Spinster And Her Enemies: Feminism And Sexuality 1880-1930
  • Women's Letters: America from the Revolutionary War to the Present
  • Classics for Pleasure
  • The Things That Matter: What Seven Classic Novels Have to Say About the Stages of Life
  • Faith and Betrayal: A Pioneer Woman's Passage in the American West
  • 500 Great Books By Women
  • The Male Body: A New Look at Men in Public and in Private
  • The Salon.com Reader's Guide to Contemporary Authors
  • The Cambridge Companion to Jane Austen
Elaine Showalter (born 21 January 1941) is an American literary critic, feminist, and writer on cultural and social issues. She is one of the founders of feminist literary criticism in United States academia, developing the concept and practice of gynocritics.

She is well known and respected in both academic and popular cultural fields. She has written and edited numerous books and articles focusse
...more
More about Elaine Showalter...
The Female Malady:  Women, Madness and English Culture 1830-1980 A Literature Of Their Own: British Women Novelists From Brontë To Lessing Daughters of Decadence: Women Writers of the Fin-de-Siècle Teaching Literature Hystories: Hysterical Epidemics and Modern Media

Share This Book