66th out of 125 books
—
124 voters
Reasons to Live
by
Amy Hempel
The author of "At the Gates of the Animal Kingdom" presents a "tough-minded, original, an fully felt" (Sheila Ballantyne) collection of stories that "approach the usual cliches of real life and fiction at an unexpectedly oblique angle. And they do so with amazing force" ("Wall Street Journal"). *Lightning Print On Demand Title
Paperback, 144 pages
Published
July 20th 1995
by Harper Perennial
(first published 1985)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,907)
If you’ve been keeping track of my reviews thus far, you know I don’t rate very highly, but Amy Hempel’s Reasons to Live is the standard to which all other fiction books must rise. Long before Chuck Palahniuk’s frenzied fan base or the New York Times 2006 Book of the Year Award drove her collected stories to mass acclaim, I was graced to read Hempel’s widely anthologized “In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson is Buried” in late 1998. It’s a story about a woman visiting her terminally ill friend in hos...more
Amy Hempel's single biggest strength is combining apparent simplicity with deep reserves of meaning; her stories tend to be short, full of small sentences, and intentionally opaque, so much so that some people have taken to lumping her into the Carver/Wolf American Minimalism sort of school. I think this is a terrible mistake. Carver and Wolf are capital R realists; the spaces between the words - the part of the iceberg hidden underwater, as they told you in English class - tend to contain som...more
okay, jesus. how do you even start to tackle the subject of amy hempel? i'll make a list of things that make this book better than anything that will ever make it into the top ten of the bestseller lists:
[1] minimalist (or "miniaturist," if you ask hempel) writing style that is unique and moves at a rapid clip
[2] emotional displacement
[3] subtlety.
that last one is particularly important, since i think one of the more difficult challenges any writ...more
[1] minimalist (or "miniaturist," if you ask hempel) writing style that is unique and moves at a rapid clip
[2] emotional displacement
[3] subtlety.
that last one is particularly important, since i think one of the more difficult challenges any writ...more
As with Carver, Hempel is only a minimalist when read shallowly and with certain misperceptions in mind about what detail consists of, and, most probably, already bent on affixing reductive labels on writers rather that appreciating their essence. It doesn't surprise me that she is more popular now than when this collection first came out: The quirky juxtapositions, the stand-up comic lines, and the staggering emotions under the surface that are suppressed in words but not affect, all seem so no...more
The pieces in this collection are often so short that they veer towards gestural sketches. Rarely do we know things about Hempel's characters such as name, age, and sometimes even gender beyond a reasonable guess. However, the writing is so taut that these stories hum with energy and often build to a blow-like ending, painful and revelatory. While a few lines of dialogue come across as preciously precocious, these stories dazzle with their humor as well. Particular favorites were "In th...more
The Great: "Tonight is a Favor to Holly"; "Nashville Gone to Ashes"; "In the Cemetery"; "Beg, Sl Tog, Inc, Cont, Rep"; "Pool Night"; "Three Popes"
The Pretty Darn Good: "When It's Human"; "Today Will Be a Quiet Day"
The Forgettable: the rest
I'm not entirely sure what this tells you about a short fiction collection comprised of fifteen stories ranging from one-page to no more than twelve...more
The Pretty Darn Good: "When It's Human"; "Today Will Be a Quiet Day"
The Forgettable: the rest
I'm not entirely sure what this tells you about a short fiction collection comprised of fifteen stories ranging from one-page to no more than twelve...more
I feel like an idiot for not appreciating Amy Hempel's Reasons to Live as much as expected to. But I really thought a few of the stories in this collection were great. Especially Nashville Gone to Ashes and Beg, Sl Tog, Inc, Cont, Rep. Hempel's writing is feminine in a way that's it's not flowery, or (extremely) passive, but of feminine things like knitting, laundry and being a wife.
I have to admit that stories with a few unpredictable twists of structure, which are of no consequence ...more
I have to admit that stories with a few unpredictable twists of structure, which are of no consequence ...more
I love Amy Hempel. I love her spare vignettes - her slice-of-life moments in prose. I love her darkness, her slight hope. In reasons to live, she gives us just that as well as reasons not to.
Fantastic Micro-fiction -- fantastic moments in otherwise unpresented lives.
(The only thing that nearly prevented me from giving a 4 star rating was the use of the - ludicrous and wrong - phrase "mute point" in one of the stories. I would like to think it was the chara...more
Fantastic Micro-fiction -- fantastic moments in otherwise unpresented lives.
(The only thing that nearly prevented me from giving a 4 star rating was the use of the - ludicrous and wrong - phrase "mute point" in one of the stories. I would like to think it was the chara...more
Death and tragedy haunt the short, short stories in Amy Hempel’s first story collection Reasons to Live (1985) like empty chairs at the table. And there is no steak, no potatoes, nor substantial courses atop Hempel’s literary table. Instead the reader is treated to tapas -- bite-size delicacies of exquisite flavors -- a literary lunch that only a truly talented minimalist (or miniaturist) writer could cook up successfully. And underneath the table: a dog or two lay near the diners’ feet,...more
Amy Hempel's short fiction collection titled reasons to live are stories of tragedies that happen. As you might say "life happens". This collection was published in 1985, maybe she would title it "life happens" if she was picking a name today. I liked many of the stories but other readers have disliked the fact that the characters are without name and very minimal detail. I think this makes it easier to insert self. Many of the stories seem to struggle with loss or a tragedy....more
A very good book of short stories. The shorter pieces are spare and elliptical--sort of like Raymond Carver, but without the power. But the better longer pieces--"Nashville Gone to Ashes," "In The Cemetery Where Al Jolson is Buried," "Today Will Be a Quiet Day" are very fine. In their classical, restrained, deeply human way they remind me of Tillie Olsen at her best--and that is high praise indeed.
this book does not = one of them
(okok, too easy. a bit pat. Was she not asking for it, though, with a title like this for a collection of stories? Is that not a bit presumptuous?
(okok, too easy. a bit pat. Was she not asking for it, though, with a title like this for a collection of stories? Is that not a bit presumptuous?
This was great. What I liked most about these stories is how you start reading them and you have no idea what is going on. You just dive in--or fall backwards--and trust that where Hempel takes you is a good place, that she will catch you before you drop to the floor. I kept having to go back as I read, to make sense of what I'd just read, I guess, but that seems so like life to me, what it would actually be like if I were suddenly to eavesdrop on the characters in these stories with all their i...more
going back. settling down. taking one moment to catch my breath. sitting beneath a weak light at a ten to midnight last night. the dogs asleep. the third of january. my childhood one thousand miles away. my mother one thousand miles away. asleep. hopefully. asleep. and a bedroom away a box of fading photographs the documents of her goodness. her smile. her love. and opening this again. with a beer on the table. it strikes me again. stage 3C. she is recovering and my father is all head in his han...more
Just discovered Amy Hempel. Where has she been all my life? As a kid everything was exciting, new and different; as a grown-up everthing begins to look and sound the same. Feel like a kid again discovering a writer who is life-changing. Short, succinct, minimalist, literary goddess - Hempel is exactly the writer I wish I was but never will be. Half poetry, half-memoir, half-fiction. Read her and your life will be changed forever.
I read In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson is Buried at some point in college or graduate school and thought it was great, but for some reason I didn't buy and finish this collection. This is the kind of book that makes me want to be a short story writer forever, no novels, no poetry, just these perfect stories. Plus, the narrators all like dogs.
Hempel's writing is quirky, but I don't know if that does it justice. It's somewhat fragmented and dense while also being funny and warm (the fragmented-but-warm trick seems especially hard to pull off). I don't know if one reading of these stories does them justice...glad I read the collection, and I imagine I will return to Hempel at some point.
Amy Hempel is why I want to write. She makes an art out of this botched and awkward language known as English. And even the most juvenile speaker of our language can appreciate the poetry of her style. The woman must spend hours scrutinizing every single word that she puts in a sentence. And for good reason. Her writing is simply flawless. She is a master in creating atmosphere. She paints moments in time better than a dream can.
I'll forever aspire to create images like Amy Hempel can...more
I'll forever aspire to create images like Amy Hempel can...more
I just can't get into short story collections like I can a good book. Some of these stories were weird in the way short stories are (if you read short stories a lot, you'll know what I mean) and some were actually pretty good. Not a bad read, considering it was only around 140 pages. More than that, and it would've gotten fewer stars.
I picked this up as a recommendation from Palahniuk. Her writing really epitomizes how much potentcy can be derived from minimalist short stories. It's hard to point at any point in the tales and say 'that's superfluous'. A great example of taking the essence of an MLA handbook and making it into an art form.
For me this averaged out to a four star rating--the collection has quite a few stories that are only a couple pages long and a couple slightly longer short stories, and I found I connected with and felt most satisfied by these longer ones, especially the excellent "In the cemetery where Al Jolson is buried."
I have a friend who attends Bennington where this author is a professor. As I've written more and more short stories my friend encouraged me to read this book.
It's excellent.
Her sentences and her ability to turn a phrase are amazing. I'll be reading more of her work, for sure.
Recommended for anyone trying to write stronger, more succinct prose!
It's excellent.
Her sentences and her ability to turn a phrase are amazing. I'll be reading more of her work, for sure.
Recommended for anyone trying to write stronger, more succinct prose!
More minimalist than I usually like, but clever and incisive writing. The characters are somewhat angular, if that makes sense, rather than soft. I prefer stories with deeper, more feeling-oriented characters and plots, but I can appreciate the skill and smarts of Amy Hempel's style.
Sometimes I don't like very short stories because they seem incomplete, or they seem like they could be better if the author hadn't shirked density/depth, or they seem like the author is using brevity to make some kind of statement when in actuality the only statement they're making is "I don't have the time to really develop this story." This book is an exception to that-- the writing is beautiful throughout, the characters fully realized within sentences and I can't imagine how long...more
If you have never heard of Amy Hempel, pick up this book and read In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson is Buried. This was her first short story. And if this story doesn't just kill you, then you shouldn't be following my recommendations.
"In the cemetary where Al Jolson is buried" is my favorite story from this collection. I actually encouraged Deb to steal this from Laura's bookshelves at Samm's Birthday party. I'll have to find out how she likes it.
Amy Hempel is a good writer. I am torn between wanting to be as good, and disdaining anything I write which at all resembles her work. I think this is because her stories force me to face things about myself and other humans, and it's not at all pretty.
Hmmm, sounds real, doesn't it? Therein lies her gift.
Hmmm, sounds real, doesn't it? Therein lies her gift.
If you only read this for "In the Cemetery Where Al Jolson Is Buried," just do it--one of the best short stories written, ever, and I dare you to not feel a gut wrench at the end.
But don't neglect the rest. The way Hempel pares things back can be difficult on first immersion if you're not accustomed to a particular kind of minimalism, but she's the kind of writer who can pare back and leave the juice. I'd actually choose "lush" as a way to describe the prose in ...more
But don't neglect the rest. The way Hempel pares things back can be difficult on first immersion if you're not accustomed to a particular kind of minimalism, but she's the kind of writer who can pare back and leave the juice. I'd actually choose "lush" as a way to describe the prose in ...more
One of my favorite books. These stories will absolutely grab at your heart and make you realize there are actually things that can make you FEEL, and in a positive way. I absolutely love this book.
Recommended by Dr. Bondurant. Startling and original and funny and deep. This book displays high standards of craftsmanship while being entertaining and accessible-- a neat trick.
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A man's writer? | 6 | 18 | Jan 07, 2012 01:28pm |
Amy Hempel is an American short story writer, journalist, and university professor at Brooklyn College. Hempel was a former student of Gordon Lish, who eventually helped her publish her first collection of short stories. Hempel has been published in Harper's, Vanity Fair, GQ, and Bomb. She is the recipient of a Guggenheim Fellowship, as well as the Ambassador Book Award in 2007, the Rea Award f...more
More about Amy Hempel...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“He wondered how we know that what happens to us isn't good.”
—
12 people liked it
“She introduces me to a nurse as the Best Friend. The impersonal article is more intimate. It tells me that they are intimate, the nurse and my friend.
'I was telling her we used to drink Canada Dry ginger ale and pretend were were in Canada'
'That's how dumb we were,' I say.
'You could be sisters,' the nurse says.
So how come, I'll bet they are wondering, it took me so long to get to such a glorious place? But do they ask?
They do not ask.
Two months, and how long is the drive?
The best I can explain it is this - I have a friend who worked one summer in a mortuary. He used to tell me stories. The one that really got to me was not eh grisliest, but it's the one that did. A man wrecked his care on 101 going south. He did not lose consciousness. But his arm was taken down to the bone - and when he looked at it - it scared him to death.
I mean, he died.
So I hadn't dared to look any closer. But now I'm doing it - and hoping that I will live through it.”
—
6 people liked it
More quotes…
'I was telling her we used to drink Canada Dry ginger ale and pretend were were in Canada'
'That's how dumb we were,' I say.
'You could be sisters,' the nurse says.
So how come, I'll bet they are wondering, it took me so long to get to such a glorious place? But do they ask?
They do not ask.
Two months, and how long is the drive?
The best I can explain it is this - I have a friend who worked one summer in a mortuary. He used to tell me stories. The one that really got to me was not eh grisliest, but it's the one that did. A man wrecked his care on 101 going south. He did not lose consciousness. But his arm was taken down to the bone - and when he looked at it - it scared him to death.
I mean, he died.
So I hadn't dared to look any closer. But now I'm doing it - and hoping that I will live through it.”

Loading...






















view all 4 comments


































