4th out of 10 books
—
14 voters
Rosalind Franklin: The Dark Lady of DNA
In 1962, Maurice Wilkins, Francis Crick, and James Watson received the Nobel Prize, but it was Rosalind Franklin's data and photographs of DNA that led to their discovery.
Brenda Maddox tells a powerful story of a remarkably single-minded, forthright, and tempestuous young woman who, at the age of fifteen, decided she was going to be a scientist, but who was airbrushed out...more
Brenda Maddox tells a powerful story of a remarkably single-minded, forthright, and tempestuous young woman who, at the age of fifteen, decided she was going to be a scientist, but who was airbrushed out...more
Paperback, 416 pages
Published
September 30th 2003
by Harper Perennial
(first published June 17th 2002)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,360)
A balanced and complete review of the life of a woman who has been ignored, maligned, or offered sycophant worship for her role in the early nucleic acid research. Only a few of her closest coworkers seem to have known enough about her to offer clear insight and to have kept to that image in subsequent years until this biography.
The message of the book is that she was mistreated and it is fair that Rosalind Franklin be adequately acknowledged for her contributions. All of her work not just the...more
The message of the book is that she was mistreated and it is fair that Rosalind Franklin be adequately acknowledged for her contributions. All of her work not just the...more
Jul 05, 2008
Anne Thessen
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
those who enjoy biographies, science or women's studies
Recommended to Anne by:
Ricky
I don't normally like biographies, but I enjoyed this book. Perhaps because I can relate to Rosalind Franklin. There was one part in the book where the author mentions that Franklin was unable to talk about her life's passion (science) with her loved ones. That struck a chord with me since I am also a scientist and I'm very used to people not really caring about what I do for a living. Most people will ask, but I know after a certain point their eyes will glaze over and they'll stop caring. If I...more
The Dark Lady of DNA is an oustanding non-fiction piece of literature. It is all about the life of Rosaling Franklin, and her part in the discovery of DNA. She had originally discovered DNA, but due to her lack of timing, she wasnt able to publish her data, therefore, thats Watson and Crick found her information, studied more upon it, and in the end got the most credit for the discovery of DNA. This is a great book for those of you who love science. I personally love reading about these scientif...more
Je ne vais pas tourner autour du pot pendant des heures, mon impression peut se résumer à ceci : je n'ai pas aimé et ce, pour plusieurs raisons.
Lorsque j'ai postulé pour lire ce livre lors de la dernière édition de Masse Critique, je pensais recevoir un ouvrage mettant en scène le personnage de Rosalind Franklin. Autrement dit, que sa vie serait racontée, qu'il y aurait des dialogues,... Du coup, je m'attendais à quelque chose d'intéressant, de vivant, de prenant, de révoltant ou que sais-je enc...more
Lorsque j'ai postulé pour lire ce livre lors de la dernière édition de Masse Critique, je pensais recevoir un ouvrage mettant en scène le personnage de Rosalind Franklin. Autrement dit, que sa vie serait racontée, qu'il y aurait des dialogues,... Du coup, je m'attendais à quelque chose d'intéressant, de vivant, de prenant, de révoltant ou que sais-je enc...more
In the book "The Double Helix", Rosalind Franklin was presented as unpleasant, unattractive woman who was not fit to be doing science and was a road block in Watson's way to the double helix. There has been since the publication of the book a backlash to Watson's portrayal that has presented her as a martyr or a saint, unsung for her pivotal role in the discovery of the double helix. The truth is probably somewhere in the middle. Brenda Maddox presents a comprehensive, analytical, balanced, and...more
Scientist at a time when science was clearly a masculine and sexist world, dedicated to her work and career when women were more expected to be docile housewives, a free spirit, proud and independant (and paying dearly for that!) Rosalind Franklin was remarkable for more than a reason. Yet, her name will be forever associated with a stain: the controversies surrounding the discovery of the structure of DNA.
A stain because, if it was thanks to HER notes, HER work, HER X-Ray pictures consulted WIT...more
A stain because, if it was thanks to HER notes, HER work, HER X-Ray pictures consulted WIT...more
Great biography on scientist Rosalind Franklin, whose x-ray crystallography data led Watson and Crick (used without her knowledge or permission) to their DNA discovery etc etc. Maddox details Franklin's life - her upbringing (upper-middle class Jewish in London), her education, her scientific works (studying coal in Paris, DNA at Kings College, and mainly tobacco mosaic virus at Birkbeck, and polio virus), her struggles with funding, and the relationships she had with her fellow researchers, fam...more
First off, James Watson is an asshole and everyone knows it. Also he's apparently racist, fat phobic, in favor of eugenics- in addition to being misogynistic (at least according to statements made by him posted on his wikipedia entry).
But, hang on this book was about an incredible lady named Franklin Rosalind! And wow oh wow, she is incredible! Though she could have worked more closer with her senior researcher named Wilkins (and doing so might have prevented him from literally running into the...more
But, hang on this book was about an incredible lady named Franklin Rosalind! And wow oh wow, she is incredible! Though she could have worked more closer with her senior researcher named Wilkins (and doing so might have prevented him from literally running into the...more
At times I didn't want to pick this book up but there were also times when I couldn't put it down. The story of Rosalind Franklin is so interesting but I could have done without all the long descriptions of coal and phosphates. I wanted more about her and less about what she was working on. But then again it is what she was working on the made her indispensable to science. It is amazing that all those cliquish male scientists didn't credit her for her discoveries, contributions and intelligence....more
Rosalind Franklin is most remembered now as the unsung fourth contributor who found the evidence for Watson and Crick’s double-helix paper in the early 1950s. A brilliant experimentalist, Franklin actually made advances in three significant areas in her short life (she died of cancer at the age of 37): the understanding of coal, the shape of the DNA molecule, and the way RNA functions inside viruses.
A few notes about Maddox’s book and this remarkable scientist:
Franklin’s specialty was x-ray pho...more
A few notes about Maddox’s book and this remarkable scientist:
Franklin’s specialty was x-ray pho...more
Sep 11, 2008
Books Ring Mah Bell
rated it
2 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
science nerds
Shelves:
memo-auto-bio,
science-med-psych
She got robbed.
In 1962, Maurice Wilkins, Francis Crick, and James Watson were awarded the Nobel Prize for their elucidation of DNA's structure. It has been pretty well established that they could not have discovered that structure (at least at the time they did so) without the unpublished data of Rosalind Franklin, one of Wilkins' colleagues at King's College, London. The data and a critical photograph (the now-famous "Photograph 51") was obtained and used in a somewhat questionable manner, and most of the men...more
Another book wading into the (auto)biographical minefield that is the discovery of the structure of DNA. (And by minefield I'm thinking more after everything's been blown up already and everything is one ugly tangled mess of mud and holes and bitterness.) On the other hand, this is a pretty good one, carefully researched and generally even-handed, focused more on putting forward a complete picture of Rosalind Franklin's life and personality rather than getting too caught up in the debate about w...more
I found the childhood and family-of-origin material here boring, which is obviously a matter of taste. I'm not sure a full biography was warranted. Clearly the main hook is the story of the subject's role in the Watson/Crick discovery of the structure of DNA.
I have some interest in the sociology and history of science, and I used to edit an academic journal, so I was fully prepared to be fascinated by the story of rushing to publication, properly or improperly crediting one's peers, sexism in sc...more
I have some interest in the sociology and history of science, and I used to edit an academic journal, so I was fully prepared to be fascinated by the story of rushing to publication, properly or improperly crediting one's peers, sexism in sc...more
This is a biography of one of the scientists whose work contributed partly to the discovery of the structure of DNA, although her work was used without her knowledge or consent. She was the infamous "Rosy" in James Watson's "The Double Helix." This biography gives a more complete and balanced picture of her childhood and early education, and her successful career before, during, and after the "Double Helix" era.
After reading Watson's book and the way he belittled her throughout (although he did...more
After reading Watson's book and the way he belittled her throughout (although he did...more
Apr 25, 2012
Folliesgirl14
marked it as to-read
My teacher actually mentioned her in biology class. Later, when reviewing for a test, he asked the class which scientist(s) automatically come to mind when we think of DNA, everyone said (and probably thought) "Watson and Crick!" while I thought "Rosalind Franklin!"
I don't know what it is about scientists, but I just find them so fascinating...even though I've never had a great love of science as a subject. I'm glad Rosalind is beginning to get recognition for her contributions to DNA research.
I don't know what it is about scientists, but I just find them so fascinating...even though I've never had a great love of science as a subject. I'm glad Rosalind is beginning to get recognition for her contributions to DNA research.
It's hard to believe that it hasn't even been 60-years since the discovery of DNA as a double helix! A must-read for any scientist. I don't even know where to begin with this biography because it as so interesting and well-written unlike some that tend to be so dry (I couldn't put it down). The author did an amazing job with this story presenting facts and leaving characterization to the reader. She really set the stage with blending historical fact around the cultural and societal events that w...more
This book made me so mad! Because a woman did the work and a dishonest man, Watson, went into her lab, took a look at her photographs...and was able to use her information along with his and Crick's to come up with their paper about DNA. But they never once acknowledged using her work though every one knew they did. She died of cancer before long, and sInce then England has tried to make up for the slight. Watson is still an ass...
This was a really well-written and interesting biography. I knew that Rosalind Franklin's work was crucial in the determination of DNA's structure and that she hasn't received all the credit she deserved, but I was really impressed by all her other scientific accomplishments.
The thing that surprised me most is that she actually seems to have had very cordial relationships with both Watson and Crick (especially Crick). It makes me wonder why Watson was so unfair to her in his book. Of course, on...more
The thing that surprised me most is that she actually seems to have had very cordial relationships with both Watson and Crick (especially Crick). It makes me wonder why Watson was so unfair to her in his book. Of course, on...more
Sep 05, 2012
Alison
added it
A surprisingly good read for a biography of a scientist (and me not being a science person at all). Rosalind Franklin took a famous photo, Photo 51, that when seen (surreptitiously) by Crick, convinced him that DNA was indeed a double helix. She was working on the same problem at the time, and had no idea how pivotal her photo was to their discovery.
Before starting this book, I knew James Watson was a kook, but I didn't realize he was also a crook. This book sets the record straight about a passionate scientist who happened to be woman. Through her own words and the recollections of the people who knew her best, you get the complete picture of this complicated, intelligent and vibrant person who played the key role in one of the most important discoveries of the last century. The inaccuracies about her scientific approach, intelligence and...more
It's been quite awhile now since I've read this book, but today it came back into my mind as I was thinking about significant women in history. This really is a remarkable story about a woman who was not given her due in one of the most important scientific discoveries of the 20th century.
This book was very readable to the layperson. I don't know if Rosalind Franklin and her male colleagues were treated fairly or not in this book because I'm not a scientist and haven't studied these events and p...more
This book was very readable to the layperson. I don't know if Rosalind Franklin and her male colleagues were treated fairly or not in this book because I'm not a scientist and haven't studied these events and p...more
This cartoon by Kate Beaton sums up the book perfectly.
Rosalind Franklin was a brilliant scientist whose findings were used by male scientists who later maligned her publicly for being, in their opinion, an old dowdy bitchface who didn't know anything anyway.
I have to revise my earlier judgement about the book. It starts really slow but picks up pace after the first ~30%. For my taste the boring parts focus too much on Franklin's extended family, going back at least two generations if I'm not completely wrong. While I do get the notion that your family shapes who you are or will become later in life this didn't interest me too much and the most important thing you learn from all this family talk: No, neither her father nor the rest of her family did...more
I was familiar with the basics of her story, but recently I was encouraged to find out more because of this quote:
Her photographs of DNA were called "among the most beautiful X-ray photographs of any substance ever taken,"
and this fabulous cartoon by Kate Beaton
Her photographs of DNA were called "among the most beautiful X-ray photographs of any substance ever taken,"
and this fabulous cartoon by Kate Beaton
Jan 09, 2010
Stormy
added it
This was a most determined woman who didn't ever give up her quest for knowledge in science. She also like to drive fast in a time when most women didn't even drive.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Brenda Maddox is an American author, journalist, and biographer.
-Wikipedia
More about Brenda Maddox...
-Wikipedia
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...































Sep 11, 2008 10:29am