Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “My Father's Secret War: A Memoir” as Want to Read:
My Father's Secret War: A Memoir
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

My Father's Secret War: A Memoir

by
3.31 of 5 stars 3.31  ·  rating details  ·  516 ratings  ·  108 reviews
In this moving and compelling memoir about parent and child, father and daughter, Pulitzer Prize-winning writer Lucinda Franks discovers that the remote, nearly impassive man she grew up with had in fact been a daring spy behind enemy lines in World War II. Sworn to secrecy, he began revealing details of his wartime activities only in the last years of his life as he becam ...more
Hardcover, 311 pages
Published March 14th 2007 by Miramax Books (first published 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about My Father's Secret War, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about My Father's Secret War

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 886)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Rick
Not quite what I expected. I thought the story would reveal more about the story behind the box of WWII trinkets that a daughter finds in her fathers old age that led her to find out if he was a spy. She did find out clues here and there but most of the book revealed little about the missions or her fathers background but was more of a memior about her relationship with her father and her own demons. The irony is Lucinda Frank's who is apprently wealthy (married to NY's DA) has a farm house and ...more
Heidi
I must admit that I didn't make it through. The writing was amazing (the author has won a Pulitzer) but the story seemed to cycle through the same sequence over and over- memories of childhood or moments from current life, the author's interrogation of her father about his secret war time activities, then speculation about said activities.
I did want to persevere, because I think that there was some really amazing material related to her father's top secret career, but every time I went to pick i
...more
Jessica
"Badgering". That's the word that comes to mind when I think about this book.

I had originally thought it was going to be about the author's father, and what he may or may not have been doing during World War II, but instead it read such that the author was primary, and the father seemed an afterthought.

While I understand what she was trying to find out about her father - possibly a reason why he was so distant while she was growing up, or a cause to the alcoholism - the way she went about it s
...more
Lil
I wanted to like this book - I fell for the "Pulitzer Prize winning author" tagline - but it was too much like A Penny Always Has Two Sides: A Memoir of Growing Up in Wartime Germany: the majority of the book was about the author's knotty relationship with her parent and her attempts to assuage her guilt. Lucinda Franks is a better writer than Steffie Steinke, but I still ended up skimming huge amounts of description - it just gets too ponderous and really bogs down the pacing, which in many pla ...more
Talulah Mankiller
Lucinda Franks grew up in one of those hellish, emotionally stunted postwar families that baby boomers are always writing about. Mommy and daddy didn’t love each other anymore but stuck together “for the kids”; daddy was a functioning alcoholic and mommy was extremely obese, which Franks seems to think are like, matching disorders. Anyway. There was a lot of screaming and yelling and shouting and withholding of affection on mom’s part, not to mention some outright verbal abuse; daddy just wasn’t ...more
Sarah
Jul 19, 2009 Sarah rated it 1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Egotists
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Lori Anderson
Aw, man. I really wanted to like this book, particularly since it was a Pulitzer Prize winning book.

If you've followed any of my reviews, you know I love to read WWII history and memoirs. This book had the makings of a good one, but it was sloooooow. I found myself drifting and dozing off and skimming. Franks could have left out a solid third of the book and tightened it up and it would have been a lot better.

Sorry, not recommended.



Lori Anderson

Blog
Shop
Facebook
Steve
Jul 09, 2015 Steve added it
Shelves: bookreporter
Imagine, for a moment.

You are a young child. Your father is the greatest hero you could hope for. He is a protector and a devoted man. You feel safe with him.

You are getting older. Your father is not how you saw him when you were a child. He is sad, drinks to excess, and tells you he loves a woman other than your mother and wants to leave. He is no longer a hero to you.

He takes long business trips, but your mother can never locate him where he says he's going. Phone calls to the house have no on
...more
Elizabeth Maurer
I hated this book. I have never been so happy to finish a book, so I could put it aside and never look at it again. At first the book made me angry but now I am just exhausted. I mean I guess I should give the author props for the way she portrayed herself "warts and all", but to me she came across as unlikable and frustrating that I couldn't get past some of the things she did/said.

1. The books title is very misleading. The title and the dust jacket makes it seem as if the story will be about T
...more
Stephanie
Boring.
I kept waiting for the "a-ha" moment, the startling climax, which never came. I can't believe how this woman badgered her poor, Alzheimer's-ridden father for a good story (which wasn't good, after all). Oh, yeah, and by the way, no one cares about your name-dropping and life of privilege, Ms. Franks.
Tammy
The title of this book is misleading. I thought I would read about a daughter's discovery that her father had been a war hero and while I found some of that, the bulk of the material was her disappointment in her parents. The author got to know her father through 50 yr old letter and friend's stories as she cared for him at the end of his life. I felt terribly sorry for her father through the entire book. The daughter appeared smug and rude from a very young age and didn't share it with her read ...more
Martha Bogart
Great book and great story. Excellent read. Terrible tragedy about how the horrors of war can change a person.
Lola
Lucinda Franks father was distant, a person she didn't know. Since I enjoy
memoirs & people' relationships, I chose to read this book. Much of the book is about her search for her father's military records, his friends, & the girlfriend she learned about who he was seeing while married to Franks' mother.
His life was a secret to his wife & children. Consequently, their relationships were strained, unfamiliar, & leading to anger & frustration.
If you enjoy reading about life duri
...more
Cameron
On the face of it, this is a fairly straightforward story of a daughter discovering the details of her father's wartime experiences as he enters the last years of his life. But there is a very complex interplay here of a psychologically traumatized soldier and his struggle to raise a family, of a daughter caught between a distant, distressed father and a chronically grieving mother, and finally, of a woman caring for her dying father. What makes this truly fascinating is that Lucinda Franks is a ...more
Joanne
I thought this was a fairly good book of redemption. It was set in the backdrop of WWII and the daughter's quest to find out about her father's activities as a secret agent during the war. The author was able to discover the true nature and persona of her father, with which she was able to finally have a true relationship with him. One thing however was the definite lack of motherly acceptance on the part of Lucinda. She had for years harbored bad feelings for both her parents. She was able to d ...more
thewanderingjew
This book was disappointing. Touted as a memoir about her father, a man who had a secret life as a spy, it really became a book about her. The reader for this audio was poor. She over emoted and was not able to do voices well. Her impersonation of every male character was the same and not believable as a male voice. The dialogue was often trite and it felt as if the author was sometimes a spoiled child trying too hard to wax poetic and the reader was trying to hard to express herself.
Lucinda Fra
...more
Margie
Both more and less than what I expected when I picked this book up off the library shelf, nevertheless I found it to be a compelling read.

Initially I thought to find a recounting of the heroic adventures of a WWII spy. Instead, I discovered the author's introspective recounting of her troubled relationship with a distant and hard-to-understand parent.

The pages of this story relate the author's struggles to come to terms with her father and the role he played in her life, a role she often felt w
...more
Mia Tryst
The book begins with the all-but-destroyed figure of the father, who is lonely, living in abject conditions, broken down and apparently given up on life. The daughter loves her father, but he has become a burden. There is resentment in having to care for an elder person who seemingly gave up on his family years ago. Slowly, we discover an incredible man who, aside from being a war hero, was a dedicated father, a patriot...a man, who at some point pushed away his family because he felt rejected a ...more
Tara
The first word that comes to mind after finishing this book is complicated.

This book is more than anything else one woman's quest for self-discovery through a better understanding of her family, particularly her father.

The complications came as I was unsure how to interpret so many parts of her journey. Was she selfish and perhaps even cold of heart as she badgered her elderly father for answers to his past? Or, is she a daughter simply wanting to know her father better and, in turn, know hersel
...more
Judy
As Franks' father begins to slip into dementia, she discovers some Nazi uniform parts among his things, starting her on an investigative journey into what her father REALLY did during World War II. At first, he is completely resistant to her queries, saying that he pledged never to speak of his activities, but as his mind begins to slip, he begins to divulge more information. Even after his death, Franks continues her quest to learn all she can about her father's secret service activities. As sh ...more
Marguerite
This memoir begins as a mystery, a story about a loved one's double life as a World War II spy. It then turns into a portrait of a dysfunctional family, with a mysterious subtext. But as Lucinda Franks digs into her father's past, she does find secret lives: parents who loved each other passionately, military missions still too secret to talk about, immersion in major world events. Franks can't tie things up neatly, but her journey might be more interesting for that. And, she and her father are ...more
Robin Templin
Very good. Several layers to this story. Coping with a history with her detached father, caring for her father who is mentally fading, and trying to find out what really happened to him during the war. This book says a lot about the generation of men in WWII, and how their experiences impacted entire families back home.
Robin Ahearn
the author talks too much about her life. if i wanted to read about her life more i wouldn't be disappointed. but I'm more interested in the story behind her story... that the title implies the book is about.

it did make me cry though when talking about her father at the end of his life.
Charlie
My father's Secret War was really about the Author's Secret war with her father. Like some of the other Reviewer's the book just didn't muster up to what I thought would be a WW11 memoir instead it became a Family memoir.
Giving a rating of 3 is the best I can do for this book.
Donna
Lucinda grew up in a family with parents who were unloving and aloof towards each other, and oftentimes toward her and her sister. As an adult, she explores her relationship with her father (her mother died) and suspects that her father was a secret agent during WWII. As an investigative reporter , she pieces together his history and thus her own. She finds out the horrors and pain that her father experienced during the war that caused him to retreat to the basement as his sanctuary while she gr ...more
K.K.
As I am doing research into the WWII era and preparing to write my own novel based in that time, I really enjoyed reading the insights that this book had to offer.

This is a memoir. Though some parts are a little slow because the author is trying to cram in a lot of info (so she has to do this through coversations that seem a bit tedious), overall the book was fantastic. I actually cried. Sitting on my bed. Real tears. You get the gist.

I think that memoirs are an important genre though probably
...more
Melinda
Disappointing and boring. One of the rare books I didn't finish. It was due back at the library and I just thought there are so many other books to read or listen to and why waste any more time on this one. Sorry.
Laura
This story is 60% family/relationship, 40% World War II history. It's a true story about a young man who spied for the Allies and was sworn to secrecy. The things he did haunted him to his grave. They effected him so strongly that his family life slowly turned into a shipwreck.

The author, a New York Times journalist, paints her father's story jumping into his past and relaying her own to connect the dots. Definitely a very unique look at WWII and its effect on those involved, secretly or not.

Man
...more
Ashley
At times this book was hard to read. The complicated relationship between daughter and father. The transition between the daughter as child to adult and then her father as the adult to dependent child. A distant ailing father suffering from dementia and lung cancer and a cold hearted daughter, find each other in the end of his life. Lucinda Franks, is very open with her family's relationship, secrets, and pain. It was sad and yet in the end, there was a inner peace that was found within the fami ...more
Joni
Jan 23, 2010 Joni rated it 5 of 5 stars
Shelves: ww2
Biography - Her dad really was a US spy, impersonating Nazis to steal and thwart secret Nazi plans.
In this moving and compelling memoir about parent and child, father and daughter, Pulitzer Prize-winning writer Lucinda Franks discovers that the remote, nearly impassive man she grew up with had in fact been a daring spy behind enemy lines in World War II. His exploits revealed a man of remarkable bravado---posing as a Nazi guard, slipping behind enemy lines to blow up ammunition dumps, and being
...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 29 30 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
A story of a family and the effects of WW2 4 12 Feb 10, 2015 05:25AM  
  • My Father's Country: Story of a German Family
  • Flory: Survival in the Valley of Death
  • Outwitting the Gestapo
  • The General: Charles De Gaulle And The France He Saved
  • The Mirador: Dreamed Memories of Irene Nemirovsky by Her Daughter
  • MASH: An Army Surgeon in Korea
  • The Most Dangerous Man in America: The Making of Douglas MacArthur
  • The Pages In Between: A Holocaust Legacy of Two Families, One Home
  • Benevolence and Betrayal: Five Italian Jewish Families Under Fascism
  • The Occupied Garden: Recovering the Story of a Family in the Wartorn Netherlands
  • The Inextinguishable Symphony: A True Story of Music and Love in Nazi Germany
  • The Great Escape: Nine Jews Who Fled Hitler and Changed the World
  • Something for Joey
  • Castles Burning: A Child's Life in War
  • Underground America: Narratives of Undocumented Lives (Voice of Witness)
  • The Poet of Baghdad: A True Story of Love and Defiance
  • The Abandonment of the Jews: America and the Holocaust 1941-1945
  • The Gallery
183159
My new book, which will be released in August, is called 'Timeless: Love, Morgenthau, and Me.' It's an intimate memoir about my husband, Robert Morgenthau, NY's former DA for 35 years, and me; the successes, trials, adventures, both traumatic and hilarious, of our marriage. It also gives inside information about my husband's most famous cases - The Central Park Jogger, Astor Elder Abuse, BCCI, Ty ...more
More about Lucinda Franks...
Timeless: Love, Morgenthau, and Me Wild Apples Waiting Out A War: The Exile of Private John Picciano Timeless: Love, Morganthau, and Me

Share This Book