M226 Consol Philosophy
M226 Consol Philosophy
by
Boethius
Boethius composed De Consolation Philosophiae in the sixth century A.D. while awaiting death by torture, condemned on a charge of plotting against Gothic rule, which he protested as manifestly unjust. Though a Christian, Boethius details the true end of life as the soul's knowledge of God, and consoles himself with the tenets of Greek philosophy, not with Christian precept...more
Hardcover
Published
March 12th 1943
by Modern Library
(first published 524)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Feb 15, 2012
Mark Adderley
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
medieval-literature,
philosophy
Why does a good God allow bad things to happen to good people? And why does He allow bad people to get away with doing bad things?
In 524, Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius was executed, most likely by strangulation, on a charge of treason. Whilst languishing in prison, he wrote a book that was to become one of the most influential philosophical tracts of the next thousand years, The Consolation of Philosophy.
Boethius is himself the narrator of the book. He speculates on being visited, in his pl...more
In 524, Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius was executed, most likely by strangulation, on a charge of treason. Whilst languishing in prison, he wrote a book that was to become one of the most influential philosophical tracts of the next thousand years, The Consolation of Philosophy.
Boethius is himself the narrator of the book. He speculates on being visited, in his pl...more
Sep 16, 2008
Ron
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
students of the Dark Ages
Shelves:
religion-philosophy,
christian_life
One of the most influential books of the Middle Ages, bridging the passing of classical culture and rise of Medieval Europe.
Invaluable aid to understanding the worldview of Medieval man. For a scholarly analysis of what and how, refer to C. S. Lewis's The Discarded Image ISBN 0521477352.
Paradoxically, another complementary text is Thomas Cahill's How the Irish Saved Civilization, (ISBN 0385418493) covering the same period when Boethius' influence was greatest (though Cahill offers Augustine as...more
Invaluable aid to understanding the worldview of Medieval man. For a scholarly analysis of what and how, refer to C. S. Lewis's The Discarded Image ISBN 0521477352.
Paradoxically, another complementary text is Thomas Cahill's How the Irish Saved Civilization, (ISBN 0385418493) covering the same period when Boethius' influence was greatest (though Cahill offers Augustine as...more
Confused at how to rate this one.
As a work of late Antiquity literature it is a masterpiece (beautifully translated by Mr. Slavitt) and I am happy to have read it, specially the first three books, which deal with human happiness and how to achieve it. Readers of self-help books (self-help, pffft!) would be better off reading this than the vacuous, laughable books of our time.
As a theological work, it is less than convincing. Books IV and V remind me of Augustine's 'The City Of God', circular re...more
As a work of late Antiquity literature it is a masterpiece (beautifully translated by Mr. Slavitt) and I am happy to have read it, specially the first three books, which deal with human happiness and how to achieve it. Readers of self-help books (self-help, pffft!) would be better off reading this than the vacuous, laughable books of our time.
As a theological work, it is less than convincing. Books IV and V remind me of Augustine's 'The City Of God', circular re...more
Written by Boethius while under arrest for allegedly plotting against the Ostrogothic King.
Boethius writes out conversations, interspersed with poems, between himself and a Christian personification of Philosophy who encourages him to reject concerns with the world and concentrate on the eternal instead. While cursing his evil fortune, Philosophy appears and upbraids Boethius for abandoning her and devoting himself to worldly concerns instead of learning and Christianity. As the dialogues progre...more
Boethius writes out conversations, interspersed with poems, between himself and a Christian personification of Philosophy who encourages him to reject concerns with the world and concentrate on the eternal instead. While cursing his evil fortune, Philosophy appears and upbraids Boethius for abandoning her and devoting himself to worldly concerns instead of learning and Christianity. As the dialogues progre...more
The Lady Philosophy appeared to Boethius in a vision while Boethius was in prison for political crimes. This book, while highly entertaining, set the stage for medieval philosophy. Among others, St Thomas Aquinas would be in constant conversation with Boethius.
The first section contains a fiery retort by Boethius concerning his imprisonment.
Eventually he and Lady Philosophy get into a discussion concerning true happiness (which St Thomas would essentially copy several centuries later). They de...more
The first section contains a fiery retort by Boethius concerning his imprisonment.
Eventually he and Lady Philosophy get into a discussion concerning true happiness (which St Thomas would essentially copy several centuries later). They de...more
For a philosophical treatise, I rather enjoyed the Consolation. I'm not religious, and I'm hardly spiritual, but this book provided an interesting way of looking at both of those things. It's alarming and inspiring as well to see such an advanced mind at so early a period in history. Boethius was a later Socrates. He had been diluted by in the ignorance of his day, but he was imprisoned wrongly and reflected on it in meaningful ways.
For someone interested in exploring religious or spiritual idea...more
For someone interested in exploring religious or spiritual idea...more
This is an interesting book. I like the combination of prose and poetry. I do not regret the fact I read it, but I can't give this a good recommendation.
The argumentation is pretty absurd though in many areas, enough so that it is hard to take much of the book seriously. I mean, in Book 4, it is argued that wicked men are necessarily powerless and unhappy, and that the reason why people of common sense would deny such a claim is due to their lack of grasp of the true nature of things. The proble...more
The argumentation is pretty absurd though in many areas, enough so that it is hard to take much of the book seriously. I mean, in Book 4, it is argued that wicked men are necessarily powerless and unhappy, and that the reason why people of common sense would deny such a claim is due to their lack of grasp of the true nature of things. The proble...more
Are you interested in the nature of time, or parallel universes? Do you find yourself wondering about the unknowable nature of the cosmos? If so then this medieval treatise on philosophy, life and the nature of God is just the book for you. No, seriously, I’m not joking … you’ll see. But for now let us begin at the beginning. It is AD524 and the Roman philosopher and civil servant Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius is under house arrest on charges of treason. The charges are almost certainly mor...more
I had to read this book for both PHL100Y1Y, Introduction to Philosophy, and ENG150Y1Y, The Literary Tradition.
I still don't understand it. I mean, sure, I get the premise, but I feel like the arguments don't work as a system in my mind; all I can remember is that he didn't realise true happiness, and that the evil are weak, and to trust in God, which made Lady Philosophy look more like Lady Religion.
Of course, it made me question whether "us mortals can never understand the universe" is actually...more
I still don't understand it. I mean, sure, I get the premise, but I feel like the arguments don't work as a system in my mind; all I can remember is that he didn't realise true happiness, and that the evil are weak, and to trust in God, which made Lady Philosophy look more like Lady Religion.
Of course, it made me question whether "us mortals can never understand the universe" is actually...more
Nov 06, 2011
Chad Warner
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Chad by:
The Tolkien Professor
Shelves:
non-fiction,
christian
In this work from 524 AD, Lady Philosophy (philosophy personified) leads the imprisoned author, Boethius, through discussions about fortune, happiness, justice, predestination, and free will. Through logical reasoning, they make deductions that build throughout their conversation. They often refer to the philosophies of Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. Lady Philosophy and Boethius believe in a monotheistic God similar to that of Christianity, although there’s no explicit mention of Christianity.
T...more
T...more
Boethius is the great murder mystery of Late Antiquity -- accomplished scholar and bureaucrat at the court of Theodoric, the Ostrogothic king of Italy. We know who killed him (or at least ordered it -- Theodoric-- and, although there are various versions of how he died, we know it was in prison at the hand's of the king's men. But we don't know motive--there are some vague references to accusations about association with a less-than-loyal fellow Senator--but the evidence, if it ever existed, had...more
How absolutely delightful: an honest use for Philosophy. Never again will I agree with Edward de Vere that there was never yet philosopher that could endure the toothache patiently: here is a man who endured a dungeon and finally an unjust death. Here is yet another example of the proof that "Wisdom infinite must form the best" world; if it took the torment of Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius to create his magnum opus, which of us would deny that, if he must die, as he must, this method of his...more
A work considered a combination of Menippean satire and apocalyptic dialogue, the Consolation of Philosophy is a philosophical work similar in structure to a classical Greek dialogue (such as the Dialogues of Plato) but with a more personal, religious, and mystical significance. Boethius wrote the Consolation of Philosophy while in prison awaiting his execution, and, while it is controlled in style and emotion, the personal nature of the philosophical quest is evident. The work is comprised of f...more
I’ve meant to read this for a very long time, probably since I found out that the title of The Consolations of Philosophy, another book I quite enjoyed, was borrowed from this one. In case you don’t know the background, I’ll be quick. The writer was leading a perfectly satisfactory life (in fact, even better than satisfactory) when one day everything went seriously yuck (in case you need a theme song to understand this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZyAJWh... – you can’t say I don’t try to provi...more
Sep 13, 2009
Jim Coughenour
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
poetryforliving,
thinkingcap
"It is a sad business, and I am prompted to sing."
Boethius, an imperial official in the waning days of Rome, wrote this book to console himself when he was a political prisoner under Theodoric the Ostrogoth – so it isn't exactly a book you'd expect to be brimming with relevance. However, for readers living through their own middle ages, it definitely proffers a kind of curious comfort. Boethius begins with a poem recounting how in his "salad days" he was rich and "whimsical Fortune smiled for a...more
Boethius, an imperial official in the waning days of Rome, wrote this book to console himself when he was a political prisoner under Theodoric the Ostrogoth – so it isn't exactly a book you'd expect to be brimming with relevance. However, for readers living through their own middle ages, it definitely proffers a kind of curious comfort. Boethius begins with a poem recounting how in his "salad days" he was rich and "whimsical Fortune smiled for a...more
The One and the Good
_Here you find the unequivocal declaration that not riches, not high position, not fame, not physical pleasure are worth pursuing in-and-of themselves. Such things are of value only if they are obtained in the pursuit of the highest Good. This highest Good is demonstrated to be God. Moreover, Boethius points out that when evil men succeed in obtaining such goals over the righteous, then they cease to truly be men- they are beasts and subhuman. This is a refreshing reminder i...more
_Here you find the unequivocal declaration that not riches, not high position, not fame, not physical pleasure are worth pursuing in-and-of themselves. Such things are of value only if they are obtained in the pursuit of the highest Good. This highest Good is demonstrated to be God. Moreover, Boethius points out that when evil men succeed in obtaining such goals over the righteous, then they cease to truly be men- they are beasts and subhuman. This is a refreshing reminder i...more
Dec 20, 2012
Kendra
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Kendra by:
Martha
Boethius. There's nothing more terrifying to me than a book of philosophy written by a philosopher who pretends he's actually talking to Philosophy, personified, while in prison. I really, reallydislike books of philosophy--and I'm not quite sure how I can get away with this dislike, seeing as how it's pretty much impossible to get through life without constructing one's own. Chalk it up to a childish preference for learning about the external world by climbing trees over sitting in a darkened...more
I enjoyed reading this book, particularly given the circumstances under which it was written. I read it while researching the question of God's relationship to time since Boethius attempts to place God outside of time in order to reconcile divine foreknowledge and human freedom. I found his thoughts and arguments interested from a historical perspective on the topic. However, his arguments do not follow given modern understandings of necessity and possibility. There are other ways to reconcile G...more
Philosophy comes to Boethius personified as a woman reprimanding him for his despair. Though reminiscent of Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius, the stoicism espoused is ultimately rooted in a faith that life is not subject to chance and a God that ”watches over His creation.” pg. 50.
Though concise and compelling, The Consolation of Philosophy is merely a shadow of the Greek philosophic tradition from which it is inspired. The imitation of Platonic dialogues is simply that. An imitation. Boethius sta...more
Though concise and compelling, The Consolation of Philosophy is merely a shadow of the Greek philosophic tradition from which it is inspired. The imitation of Platonic dialogues is simply that. An imitation. Boethius sta...more
This was another book that’s been on my mental “rather old things which peak my curiosity” shelf, and it was well worth finally getting around to. I ran across this originally in the form a passage from King Alfred’s translation of Boethius into Old English (in my trusty Cambridge Old English Reader, which I hope to be finishing and reviewing here sometime soon) – the translation was horrible and nonsensical and involved a lot of gibberish about a wagonwheel, but the editors’ introduction went o...more
i read this book in college and in tandem with chaucer's canterbury tales. this is a compelling book written by an imprisoned, sixth-century, roman philosopher during his imprisonment. the consolation of philosophy is a dialogue between boethius and the muses, an attempt to console himself before being put to death. ostrogothic king theodoric the great who had appointed boethius to be head of government and court services, accused boethius of treason for allegedly conspiring with justin I of the...more
This is one of the best experiences available to any reader with a proclivity towards introspection and philosophical reasoning. It is a powerful work of thought-inducing logic. Its victory is its expert balance of two seemingly contradictory goals: it is simultaneously concise and all-encompassing, wasting no words on superfluous descriptions or verbose redundancies while still managing to present well-reasoned explanations of such varied but connected topics as free will, happiness, the nature...more
I listened to this as an audiobook. (from librivox.org - free, volunteer driven, public domain audiobooks)
The book itself: I rather enjoyed this text. Boethius' use of Platonic dialogue as the vehicle for is philosophical points, intermixed with solid classical poetry (that served to reinforce/illuminate points just made) was refreshing and interesting.
That he is exploring themes of justice and free will make the book still relevant philosophically. Also, he spends much time on the good way to...more
The book itself: I rather enjoyed this text. Boethius' use of Platonic dialogue as the vehicle for is philosophical points, intermixed with solid classical poetry (that served to reinforce/illuminate points just made) was refreshing and interesting.
That he is exploring themes of justice and free will make the book still relevant philosophically. Also, he spends much time on the good way to...more
Boethius tried to show why good is always the better choice and evil always the worse choice. He tried doing this purely with philosophy and eliminating religion. Unfortunately, pretty much every argument used stems from the premise that God definitely exists. This is stated at the beginning, and every argument following builds upon that premise.
So Boethius' attempt, in this regard, is a complete and utter failure. Despite his efforts to make it otherwise, this winds up being The Consolation of...more
So Boethius' attempt, in this regard, is a complete and utter failure. Despite his efforts to make it otherwise, this winds up being The Consolation of...more
This book is everything that philosophy should be. Rational and poetic, pious and questioning, faithful to God and reason amongst its doubts.
Boethius gives an updated account of Job's conundrum and provides a graceful and articulate defense of the Romano-Christian philosophy and theology, along with the virtue ethics and politics of the sagest of ancients in the very days before Europe plunged into its years of barbarism, starting with the end of Boethius' life itself. It is philosophy in its t...more
Boethius gives an updated account of Job's conundrum and provides a graceful and articulate defense of the Romano-Christian philosophy and theology, along with the virtue ethics and politics of the sagest of ancients in the very days before Europe plunged into its years of barbarism, starting with the end of Boethius' life itself. It is philosophy in its t...more
I purchased this book while in High School in the 60's for $1.50 with a copyright of 1962..I still have it in excellent condition SANS any pages pulled apart,etc.That SHOULD say how much I adore this writing.
Boethius writes this book from prison in a conversation style between himself and Lady Philosophy.She consoles him by discussing the transitory nature of FAME & Wealth & the ultimate "superiority of things of the mind,which she calls the "one true good".She contends that HAPPINESS co...more
Boethius writes this book from prison in a conversation style between himself and Lady Philosophy.She consoles him by discussing the transitory nature of FAME & Wealth & the ultimate "superiority of things of the mind,which she calls the "one true good".She contends that HAPPINESS co...more
Jan 13, 2008
Mat
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
ailing cows, among others
i know, i know. I really shouldn't like this book so much but it was my absolute favorite in college. my best friend and i would take it down to the calves, screaming with grief because they had just been weaned, and read it to them in hopes it would help them see past their pain. I think it worked some of the time! That's how good this book is.
He is perhaps best known to the modern reader, as the Philosopher that Ignatius O'Riley champions in John Kennedy Toole's "Confederacy of Dunces"
Often styled as "the last of the Romans", regarded by tradition as a Christian martyr, born at Rome in 480; died at Pavia in 524 or 525. Descended from a consular family, he was left an orphan at an early age and was educated by the pious and noble-minded Symmachus, whose daughter, Rusticana, he married. As early as 507 he was known as a learned man, an...more
Often styled as "the last of the Romans", regarded by tradition as a Christian martyr, born at Rome in 480; died at Pavia in 524 or 525. Descended from a consular family, he was left an orphan at an early age and was educated by the pious and noble-minded Symmachus, whose daughter, Rusticana, he married. As early as 507 he was known as a learned man, an...more
Amazing book! Much like Paradise Lost. Long quiet evenings are made for something like this wonderful journey. Pretty highbrow stuff, not for the weak of spirit. Owing heavily to the styles of Plato and Socrates, Boethius's Consolation of Philosophy is a deep investigation into the nature of wisdom and the physical world. Making use of fiction, dialogue, and other Platonic conventions, Boethius s envisioned discussions with Philosophy personified take the reader on a journey of philosophical inq...more
Boethius was a Christian and Neoplatonist philosopher, and also a high functionary in the court of Theoderic, the Ostrogothic king of Italy in the sixth century. He was imprisoned on suspicion of conspiracy (apparently under easy conditions) and wrote this book while in prison. It is a dialogue in prose and verse between Boethius, lamenting his poor turn of fortune, and personified Philosophy, who tries to convince him that there is really no such thing as evil, that wicked men are really powerl...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| On the Southern L...: Boethius and the Consolation of Philosophy | 1 | 11 | Mar 06, 2012 04:03pm |
Anicius Manlius Severinus Boëthius, commonly called Boethius (ca. 480–524 or 525 AD) was a philosopher of the early 6th century. He was born in Rome to an ancient and prominent family which included emperors Petronius Maximus and Olybrius and many consuls. His father, Flavius Manlius Boethius, was consul in 487 after Odoacer deposed the last Western Roman Emperor. Boethius, of the noble Anicia fam...more
More about Boethius...
Share This Book
3 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Who would give a law to lovers? Love is unto itself a higher law.”
—
37 people liked it
“Nunc fluens facit tempus,
nunc stans facit aeternitatum.
(The now that passes produces time, the now that remains produces eternity.)”
—
13 people liked it
More quotes…
nunc stans facit aeternitatum.
(The now that passes produces time, the now that remains produces eternity.)”
Loading...




















May 17, 2010 05:49am
Feb 11, 2013 12:22pm
Feb 11, 2013 07:25pm