15th out of 34 books
—
43 voters
Anne Boleyn: A New Life of England's Tragic Queen
by
Joanna Denny
No English queen has enjoyed such notoriety as Anne Boleyn, and none has been so persistently vilified. Even after her execution in May 1536, on trumped-up charges of adultery, her reputation has been pursued beyond the grave, subjected to all manner of accusation. The unsavory account of her life that has come down through history is one shaped by her enemies. Joanna Denn...more
Hardcover, 384 pages
Published
March 6th 2006
by Da Capo Press
(first published 2004)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,002)
Apr 11, 2009
Chris
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
history-tudors,
history-english
This is a readable book, and a quick read at that. If you are looking for a good biography of Anne Boleyn, however, this isn' t it. The first thing that any reader should know is that Denny has a very anti-Catholic bias. Every Catholic in this book is evil. Every non-Catholic is a wonderful person.
It's not so much Denny's bias that is disturbing (look at the Church at that time), it's her opinions that she passes off as facts. Denny will state that "Anne was appalled" or "thought" something, b...more
It's not so much Denny's bias that is disturbing (look at the Church at that time), it's her opinions that she passes off as facts. Denny will state that "Anne was appalled" or "thought" something, b...more
Jul 17, 2008
Elaina OKeefe
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
pepole who like bios, women's studies, English history
This is a revisioninst biography of Anne Boleyn that attempts to debunk the common myths about the tragic English queen. Although most of her arguments rely on the fact that many common beliefs about her (that she was a witch, that she seduced Henry 8 though sexual means, that she had 6 fingers) were written by her enemies, her assertions often ring true. The author paints a vivid, believable, and much more balanced portrait of Ann Bolelyn...and even if some of her assertions are just wishful th...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I probably enjoyed this biography for the same reason many others did not: Denny's very obvious anti-Catholic bias and almost saintlike portrayal of Anne Boleyn. Most authors (at least until the past decade or two) either tend to pity or revile Anne, so it was interesting to have someone argue that she was a strong political player whose Protestant beliefs did actually give her a moral edge. While Denny's evidence of this tends to be based more on speculation, the fact is that most of what we kn...more
From reading this biography, I know almost as much about Anne Boleyn as I do about author Joanna Denny's hatred of Catholicism. Denny does raise some interesting discussion points about the source of Catherine of Aragon's fertility problems and the origin of Henry VIII's desire to annul his marriage to his first wife. However, what sticks in my mind is her vitriolic, venomous portrayal of everyone who was not a Boleyn supporter. I was especially disturbed and unconvinced by her version of Cather...more
Sep 21, 2012
Monique
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
studied,
non-fiction
I found this book to be an easy and enjoyable read. For a historical biography it was markedly conversational and carries along at a relaxed pace. However, when it comes to historical accuracy I have my doubts. Denny carries an obvious anti-Catholic bias and almost refuses to hear any negativity towards Anne
Denny paints a sympathetic picture of Anne, as a highly intelligent and educated woman, and completely discounts theories defiling her character. Her views of Anne, paint a portrait of a brig...more
Denny paints a sympathetic picture of Anne, as a highly intelligent and educated woman, and completely discounts theories defiling her character. Her views of Anne, paint a portrait of a brig...more
I'm a bit shocked that this book has such a high rating on Goodreads. It's one of the worst biographies I've ever read. I have always admired Anne Boleyn as a historical figure, but even I can admit that this book is terribly biased in favor of Anne. It has a clear pro-Protestant, anti-Catholic agenda which Denny promotes throughout, which ultimately results in her worshipping Anne and criticizing Katherine of Aragon at every chance. I wouldn't be surprised if Denny had had a shrine in her house...more
This history is a riveting read, perhaps not great history, but a good read. Written by a novelist, one whose ancestors worked for Henry VIII, it is a hagiography of Anne Boleyn. If she were still alive, the author would be disgusted with the use of the term, since she was an ardent Protestant for whom Anne Boleyn was a martyr to the cause against the evils of “papism”. Boleyn’s main opposition was in the form of the Catholic Katherine of Aragon, treated here as queen bitch. The heavy-handed bia...more
I have read a great deal about both Elizabeth I and her mother, the infamous Anne Boleyn. Most books focus on how evil and manipulative that Anne Boleyn was. However, many of these books pull information from somewhat biased sources.
This book presents Anne not as this evil woman who changed all of England for her whim, but as a victim. Joanna Denny does a good job of presenting her view but her view is also somewhat biased.
Reading this book does provide the reader with a new view into who Anne B...more
This book presents Anne not as this evil woman who changed all of England for her whim, but as a victim. Joanna Denny does a good job of presenting her view but her view is also somewhat biased.
Reading this book does provide the reader with a new view into who Anne B...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
My main reason for reviewing this book is to warn anyone who is planning to use it for a classroom assignment. Be careful -- this book is full of factual errors. For example, right after page 246 the portrait of Mary is misdated -- the portrait itself clearly identifies both the sitter and her age at the time the portrait was painted! Instead use the Ives bio. of Anne Boleyn. I attempted to check some other citations and was not able to do so. Ives offers better scholarship, his writing is clear...more
Although this book is bad, I don't regret I bought it - at least I saw with my own eyes that some authors are biased in Anne Boleyn's favor to the limits of absurd.
Denny's peculiar biography is full of praise for Anne Boleyn - Anne comes across as religious, chaste and oh-so-wonderful young woman who was caught into the eye of political and religious turmoil.
Denny's Anne is flawless - every source that depicts her in an unsympathetic light is quickly dismissed by author as unreliable or biased....more
Denny's peculiar biography is full of praise for Anne Boleyn - Anne comes across as religious, chaste and oh-so-wonderful young woman who was caught into the eye of political and religious turmoil.
Denny's Anne is flawless - every source that depicts her in an unsympathetic light is quickly dismissed by author as unreliable or biased....more
This is classified as a biography but actually reads more like historical fiction. My middle-school daughter made the mistake of trying to use this book as a primary reference for a term paper this year. The structure of the biography, the sparsity of reference dates, and Denny's penchant for stating a "fact" about Anne Boleyn then recanting it several pages later, made it a miserable reference book. So much so, that I had to step in and read the book too in order to help her sort it all out. Ho...more
All my life I've felt that Anne Boleyn was undeserved of her fate, that history had somehow cheated her. I've read many books on the Tudors and the wives of Henry VIII and none have ever appealed to me as much as Anne Boleyn. This book is a pretty good read if not a totally scholarly work. It is a good introduction to an historic figure who has been much maligned since her trial and execution for treason. This biography portrays her not as the scheming and power-hungry pawn and adulteress but as...more
I was so disappointed in this biography. I am a huge Anne Boleyn fan but this was so biased towards her it was almost annoying. The author needed to include more footnotes or other type of credit to her sources as I found it hard to believe she knew how Anne or Katherine of Aragon or Henry VIII was actually feeling; yet she stated these "feelings" as though they were fact. She repeated information and what seemed like entire paragraphs through the book which was annoying. This book felt and read...more
Joanna Denny puts forward arguments that don't have any basis in fact: for example, that Anne Boleyn was a popular Queen and the people loved her. There is no evidence for this claim whatsoever; in fact, all the evidence points against the claim. However, her writing is lively and she makes Anne's life exciting, unlike Antonia Fraser, who is much more scholarly. Denny's writing is concise and, largley, she sticks to the facts, making it clear where there is conjecture. This style is good for sch...more
Denny has been widely attacked - or alternatively praised - for her version of Anne Boleyn and the nature of her life. This book is definitely more opinionated and controversial than her follow-up, "Katherine Howard", published in 2005.
I think this book can be commended in paying great attention to Anne's religious beliefs, something often ignored or criticised by historians - Antonia Fraser, for instance, believes Anne wasn't a genuine religious radical, and only showed an interest in religion...more
I think this book can be commended in paying great attention to Anne's religious beliefs, something often ignored or criticised by historians - Antonia Fraser, for instance, believes Anne wasn't a genuine religious radical, and only showed an interest in religion...more
I have to admit that when I first picked up this book I was a little sceptical. I have heard many things about Denny’s book on Anne Boleyn, some positive and some negative. I was not sure what to think but was determined to go into this book with an open and positive mind. I wanted to take the book for what it was and see what Denny had to say about the life of Anne Boleyn. Unfortunately when I came to the end of the book I found myself feeling quite disappointed.
Overall when reading this book...more
Overall when reading this book...more
Intelligent, articulate women are viewed as a threat in patriarchal cultures. Add organized religion to the mix and the physical well-being of female members of that culture are very much at risk.
Joanna Denny exposes the dark underbelly of the Catholic church in this book about Anne Boleyn--the second wife of King Henry VIII in England during the 16th century. Catholicism held sway over the civilized world for over a thousand years. When Martin Luther attempted to reveal the "sins" of this reli...more
Joanna Denny exposes the dark underbelly of the Catholic church in this book about Anne Boleyn--the second wife of King Henry VIII in England during the 16th century. Catholicism held sway over the civilized world for over a thousand years. When Martin Luther attempted to reveal the "sins" of this reli...more
At last, a truly sympathetic look at the much-maligned Anne Boleyn -- one of the most fascinating figures in the history of English royalty. The book consistently and thoughtfully debunks the many myths surrounding England's beheaded queen, making this a fascinating read. So far, the only problem is that author Denny can be naive in her supposition, or jumps to conclusions that might sound accurate, but are something of a leap. (She seems very eager to prove her point without necessarily having...more
Mar 04, 2008
Joanna
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
eh...
Shelves:
the-tudors,
historical-nonfiction
As I read this book, it was very difficult to refrain from comparing it to Warnicke's biography of Anne Boleyn, which is still very fresh in my memory. Joanna Denny's biography is less scholarly, and poorly edited. In her favor, though, Denny has written a popular history that is easy to comprehend and doesn't require as much prior knowledge of Tudor politics as Warnicke's. Some scholars disdain popular history, but I firmly support any book that makes history accessible to the widest audience p...more
First of all let me say that I love reading anything about Tudor England and I thought I could gain a new perspective on Anne Boleyn by reading this book. Wrong!! Joanna Denny tries to portray Anne as a Saint who was wronged and who tried to do nothing but good for England. I think anyone who really knows Tudor England would tell you that she's anything but a Saint. So all-in-all I guess I did gain a new perspective on Anne Boleyn and I'd have to say she seems lower to me now than before.
Joanna debunks hundreds of years of character assassination from biased anti-Protestant, anti-reformation sources to paint a picture of Anne that is highly sympathetic. This is not the grasping, ruthless woman we've seen in The Other Boleyn Girl and the Tudors, but rather a highly ethical, principled woman dealing with the insanity of a vain tyrant the only way she knew how. Excellent book.
Although it took me many months to read this book, I learned a great deal and enjoyed learning it. Denny presented many facts and documents to support her theories. Sometimes, though, she put Boleyn in too heroic of light. But all historical literature should always be taken as not absolute truth. She also seemed to focus more on King Henry and his advisors, as well as Boleyn's enemies, more than Boleyn herself. This may be because most documents regarding Boleyn were destroyed.
I took alot away...more
I took alot away...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“The past is a reality that exists just beyond our reach.”
—
7 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...

































Mar 08, 2010 10:27am
Apr 09, 2013 09:26pm