114th out of 565 books
—
840 voters
How the States Got Their Shapes
by
Mark Stein
Why does Oklahoma have that panhandle? Did someone make a mistake?
We are so familiar with the map of the United States that our state borders seem as much a part of nature as mountains and rivers. Even the oddities--the entire state of Maryland(!)--have become so engrained that our map might as well be a giant jigsaw puzzle designed by Divine Providence. But that's where t...more
We are so familiar with the map of the United States that our state borders seem as much a part of nature as mountains and rivers. Even the oddities--the entire state of Maryland(!)--have become so engrained that our map might as well be a giant jigsaw puzzle designed by Divine Providence. But that's where t...more
Hardcover, 332 pages
Published
May 27th 2008
by Smithsonian
(first published 2008)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,474)
read half of it in one sitting. I'm so not cool. Toward the end though, it got pretty repetitive. The strategy of covering every border one state at a time is good in theory, but if read from cover to cover, could be done in about 25 pages. Things I learned from the book:
1. There was a whole lot of bad surveying going on.
2. Panhandles are the most telling of the political atmosphere back then. Oklahoma has a panhandle because Texas wanted to be a slave state. Florida has a panhandle because it w...more
1. There was a whole lot of bad surveying going on.
2. Panhandles are the most telling of the political atmosphere back then. Oklahoma has a panhandle because Texas wanted to be a slave state. Florida has a panhandle because it w...more
This book is divided into 50 short chapters, each detailing how a U.S. state acquired its shape. Easy to understand.
This book at first fascinated me. I love history, and I love maps even more. I can just sit and look at a map for hours, running my mind over the lay of the land. So, I was hooked. How did West Virginia get that little finger of land that reaches toward Pittsburgh? Why aren't Vermont and New Hampshire just one regular-sized state? Why did Wyoming take a bite out of Utah, and not th...more
This book at first fascinated me. I love history, and I love maps even more. I can just sit and look at a map for hours, running my mind over the lay of the land. So, I was hooked. How did West Virginia get that little finger of land that reaches toward Pittsburgh? Why aren't Vermont and New Hampshire just one regular-sized state? Why did Wyoming take a bite out of Utah, and not th...more
Here's an intriguing book of trivia--a tome of a very specific historical niche. Have you ever looked at a state map and wondered why the border runs like it does? No? Er, well, trust me, there are weirdoes like me who love maps and sit and gaze upon all the little quirks and details. And there are some, like me, who have wondered why the heck Michigan has an upper peninsula or why Utah has that notch. Such secrets are revealed in this book, as the logic (or politics) behind each twist and turn...more
Apr 08, 2009
Robin
added it
I have found your Father's Day gift.
You can thank me later. On the other hand, if he becomes completely annoying over dinner and long car rides, I accept none of the blame.
You can thank me later. On the other hand, if he becomes completely annoying over dinner and long car rides, I accept none of the blame.
The title IS a summary of the book, which is an ideal read if you're a history and geography geek like me. It's 304-pages of maps, historical notes, and outright warfare between states. I've always wondered why many East Coast states remained small; yes, they may have been colonies originally, but why not combine eventually? That question and many others are addressed. Sometimes it can get confusing because of the sheer amount of terms, but Stein set aside a special section at the front called D...more
My wife and I read several portions of How the States Got Their Shapes by Mark Stein while we drove to and from Kansas over the Christmas Holidays. The book is a state-by-state description of how the 50 states, plus DC, obtained their current boundaries. The book can be rather repetitive, if you read it straight through (after all, the states all share borders, and if each chapter of the book tells the story of every boundary of one state, there has to be repitition, with the exception of maybe...more
Ok, if you're into interesting facts, ramdom ways to make conversation (that may not go anywhere), or just want to surprise yourself with your own level of ignorance about the actual shape of states (including the one you live in) then this is the book for you.
If, however, despite all that is written above you find repetitveness, poor organization, and failed attempts at grandiose statements and/or humor, perhaps you should pass. This was a pretty poorly written book. It was organized alphabeti...more
If, however, despite all that is written above you find repetitveness, poor organization, and failed attempts at grandiose statements and/or humor, perhaps you should pass. This was a pretty poorly written book. It was organized alphabeti...more
How the States Got Their Shapes
by Mark Stein
304 pages
This book tells us how the states got their borders. Sometimes, States fought for land. Other times, rivers were good borders. There were also states that were made from other states. But there are still some questions about the states. Why does Michigan have the peninsula that should have been Wisconsin’s? And why are some states like Texas and California so big. Shouldn’t every state be equal? The reason why California and Texas are so bi...more
by Mark Stein
304 pages
This book tells us how the states got their borders. Sometimes, States fought for land. Other times, rivers were good borders. There were also states that were made from other states. But there are still some questions about the states. Why does Michigan have the peninsula that should have been Wisconsin’s? And why are some states like Texas and California so big. Shouldn’t every state be equal? The reason why California and Texas are so bi...more
I picked up this book on a whim; the title intrigued me. I like learning how things function and why they are the way they are. One of my all-time favorite books is "A Short History of Nearly Everything" by Bill Bryson. I figured this book would be written in the same manner. Then there's the dust cover, full of reviews with quotes including words like, "fascinating", "engaging", "comedy", and "wonderfully entertaining". And then take into account that Mark Stein is a playwright and screenwriter...more
The information within the book - and for the most part the style in which it is written - is very good. The primary fault is the organization. There are two introductory sections, one laying out the point of the book and the other giving some important information that will be referenced in almost every state history. Then the book goes through each state's border history. The states are listed alphabetically which is handy if you only want to look up a few. If you only want to look up, for exa...more
This useless brick is, unfortunately, one of several self-inflicted literary infections I got by whipping out my Amazon.com iPhone App two hours deep into a happy hour. GOOD friends don't let friends do that. I need better friends, it would seem.
This book is about as compelling and forgettable as those "Brain Quest" trivia cards, and poorly written. I gritted my teeth through the first several chapters that Professor Stein begins with "How come...?" Why not "why?" Or better still, why not acknow...more
This book is about as compelling and forgettable as those "Brain Quest" trivia cards, and poorly written. I gritted my teeth through the first several chapters that Professor Stein begins with "How come...?" Why not "why?" Or better still, why not acknow...more
This is a very fascinating book for anyone interested in the subject at hand, namely, the states and how their borders became what they are. In fact, this would easily be a four star book at least, if not five, for its thoroughness on the subject, except for one issue that I need to agree with reviews I've read on. The book is very repetitive. The layout being what it is, going through all the states (and the District of Columbia) alphabetically, and dealing with each of their borders individual...more
http://nwhyte.livejournal.com/1880268...
A popular history of the building blocks of US political geography (NB the author is not the wingnut Mark Steyn). I learned a number of things from it, including the importance of the 1790 Nootka convention and why Hawaii has more interesting borders than one might have thought. I had not really taken in that the block shapes of Colorado and Wyoming reflected a general aspiration to create states covering seven degrees of longitude and four of latitude (th...more
A popular history of the building blocks of US political geography (NB the author is not the wingnut Mark Steyn). I learned a number of things from it, including the importance of the 1790 Nootka convention and why Hawaii has more interesting borders than one might have thought. I had not really taken in that the block shapes of Colorado and Wyoming reflected a general aspiration to create states covering seven degrees of longitude and four of latitude (th...more
This book is an odd bird. It's a fairly straightforward book on American geography published by the Smithsonian that is written by a playwright, whose bio on the back notes most prominently his authorship of the 1992 film "Housesitter" with Goldia Hawn and Steve Martin, that somehow became a New York Times bestseller and even a History Channel series. The now former playwright, recognizing where is bread is buttered, recently came out with a sequel, "How the States Got Their Shapes Too." It's be...more
Did you know that Connecticut once went to war with Pennsylvania over land? Did you know we almost had a state called Jefferson out west? Stein does a great job of presenting all the quirks of history and politics that defined the borders of each of the states and the District of Columbia.
The book is presented in a series of 52 chapters with one for each state and the district as well as an introductory chapter that highlights some major events and agreements that defined the borders of a large...more
The book is presented in a series of 52 chapters with one for each state and the district as well as an introductory chapter that highlights some major events and agreements that defined the borders of a large...more
In conjunction with Lost States: True Stories of Texlahoma, Transylvania, and Other States That Never Made It, I also heartily recommend How the States Got Their Shapes by Mark Stein. It details the crazy journeys our wonderful 50 states took in order to end-up in the shapes that we know and love today. For example, did you know that Washington (before it got the D.C. moniker) was supposed to be a square city, made up of equal parcels of land donated by both Maryland and Virginia? Well, the cit...more
Fascinating book. I will never look at a state map ever again. It's a little repetitious because the states, after all, border each other so you get some of the same information over and over again. Still, in case you ever wondered how states got some of the weird little boundaries and jags that they have, this is the book to read. Some of the stories, especially Maryland and Delaware are quite comical. There are reasons how Maryland got to be as odd looking as it is. Great factoids -- Delaware'...more
Got this from the library after catching an episode of the TV show. Turns out the TV show is the better of the two. I give the author kudos for the idea and the research, but the book is poorly presented - each state is addressed alphabetically, giving this book the same problem as Sperm Wars - you have to flip around because the borders of Arizona and Arkansas don't exactly have a lot to do with one another. The first chapter sums up a few points that are important to understanding why certain...more
I was pretty excited about the idea of reading this book, but by the time I was done I was fairly disappointed. If you're curious about how the borders of the states in the USA came to be, the information is in the text, but the book is poorly organized and riddled with errors.
The book runs through all 50 states plus DC and describes why each border is where it is. Probably for simplicity, Mr Stein decided to organize the book alphabetically by state. But in constructing a narrative, this format...more
The book runs through all 50 states plus DC and describes why each border is where it is. Probably for simplicity, Mr Stein decided to organize the book alphabetically by state. But in constructing a narrative, this format...more
I don't know when I will finish this, because I have begun to just read one state at a time--seems to sink in better that way. I think the concept is fascinating, that each state's shape is a story in itself and in the larger story of our nation's history. I also think that it is an example of how I would teach American history if I were starting over and chose History instead of English: I would teach American History as a series of clashes between rival interests. Each state's borders were dec...more
Feb 06, 2010
James82
added it
I found the book interesting up to a point. The author took pains to describe how various parts of states were "snipped" off to avoid problems with jurisdiction. It made me curious what he would say about Point Roberts, Washington.
He didn't mention it at all. Point Roberts is a portion of Washington that requires travel through Canada in order to visit. How is a "wide" river, or a mountain range more daunting? The water route to Point Robers is approximately 20 miles across bays and inlets. What...more
He didn't mention it at all. Point Roberts is a portion of Washington that requires travel through Canada in order to visit. How is a "wide" river, or a mountain range more daunting? The water route to Point Robers is approximately 20 miles across bays and inlets. What...more
At first this book was very interesting but the same stories get rehashed as it continues alphabetically through the states. The book would have been better and shorter had he taken it regionally or in order of founding.
As a native Rhode Islander, I found that his observations about Roger Williams and the founding of RI and Providence Plantations to be inaccurate. For one, Roger Williams did not set up a colony on Aquidneck Island (he founded Providence Plantations in the area north on the main...more
As a native Rhode Islander, I found that his observations about Roger Williams and the founding of RI and Providence Plantations to be inaccurate. For one, Roger Williams did not set up a colony on Aquidneck Island (he founded Providence Plantations in the area north on the main...more
Why doesn’t the northern border of Illinois neatly line up with those of neighboring Indiana and Ohio (which almost line up, but not quite)? What’s the deal with all the panhandles? Why are Texas and California so big? The state borders are permanent reminders of the many political struggles that carved the United States out of the New World, for example: Colonial Royal Deeds (the semi-circle of Delaware’s northern border), New World Diplomacy (the border between Oregon and California resulted f...more
I started out liking this book so much, but ...
The book starts with Alaska and then goes alphabetically through the state--logical right?
Except not really. By the time you get to Wyoming (heck, the Dakotas), you've read most of the information four other times (depending on how many states surround it), because you've read the story about their boundaries.
By O, I was off-put.
By T, I was tired.
And by W, I was weary.
I am saddened that had I written this review a few short days ago, I would have...more
The book starts with Alaska and then goes alphabetically through the state--logical right?
Except not really. By the time you get to Wyoming (heck, the Dakotas), you've read most of the information four other times (depending on how many states surround it), because you've read the story about their boundaries.
By O, I was off-put.
By T, I was tired.
And by W, I was weary.
I am saddened that had I written this review a few short days ago, I would have...more
This book has a lot of interesting information about how the states ended up looking like they do (and I'd never noticed before a lot of the strange little extra pieces added to or taken away from certain state borders). That said, I really can't fathom why the author chose to organize alphabetically a book that is effectively about geography. Instead of discussing, for example, the borders of New Hampshire/Vermont/Maine all in one section, the author goes alphabetically by state name. This mean...more
Being a US history teacher, I think this is a great book for several reasons...
1) It focuses both on the big and small aspects of American history. There are too many books that focus on either one or the other. This book takes into consideration the big events, like the Revolution or the Mexican War, but it also focuses on the small things... like the Mormon War in Utah, the Green Mountain Boys of Vermont and the struggle over the Georgia/Florida border.
2) Even though the book probably wouldn't...more
1) It focuses both on the big and small aspects of American history. There are too many books that focus on either one or the other. This book takes into consideration the big events, like the Revolution or the Mexican War, but it also focuses on the small things... like the Mormon War in Utah, the Green Mountain Boys of Vermont and the struggle over the Georgia/Florida border.
2) Even though the book probably wouldn't...more
For some time, I've been curious about how our United States got their shapes, so when I saw the title of this book, I was excited to read it. The author clearly did his research and I learned about which states were formed first and how many of the earliest states once stretched from the Atlantic to Pacific Oceans. I learned that many states were first part of territories owned by Britain, France, the Netherlands, Spain and Russia and had to be purchased or won by war. I learned that Congress o...more
This was a very enjoyable book. The author did a great job at making each chapter able to stand on its own if the reader is only interested in one particular state, rather than in reading the entire book, as I chose to do. You would think that reading about how Connecticut and Rhode Island got their northern borders and how Massachusetts got its southern border would be repetitive, but in each telling of the history of any one boarder, the author gives different details so that the book is reada...more
I got this book after watching the History Channel television program of the same name. Interestingly, there's some info that was on TV that wasn't in the book.
Informative and entertaining writing for a subject that could become downright mind numbing. Mark does a great service by using informative maps.
Although it may be a losing proposition of a monumental task, I would have preferred the book to be arranged a bit differently. Rather than list the states alphabetically, to make it easy to jump...more
Informative and entertaining writing for a subject that could become downright mind numbing. Mark does a great service by using informative maps.
Although it may be a losing proposition of a monumental task, I would have preferred the book to be arranged a bit differently. Rather than list the states alphabetically, to make it easy to jump...more
Possibly the nerdiest book I have read to date. Literally, this is a state-by-state survey of how the various state boundary lines were drawn. Parts of it are seriously fascinating. (Why is California so big? Essentially because they were a bunch of jerks who refused to have it any other way. Why does Michigan have an upper peninsula? They got it as compensation for having lost a border fight with Indiana and Ohio. Is Ellis Island part of New Jersey or New York? Technically, it depends.)
My one p...more
My one p...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bookcrossers: 50 State Challenge | 32 | 29 | May 08, 2013 01:45pm |
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.
More about Mark Stein...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...































Jul 13, 2009 10:05am
Oct 26, 2010 09:04am