Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “City of Light, City of Dark: A Comic Book Novel” as Want to Read:
City of Light, City of Dark: A Comic Book Novel
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

City of Light, City of Dark: A Comic Book Novel

3.4 of 5 stars 3.40  ·  rating details  ·  359 ratings  ·  73 reviews
Asterel races against time to locate a token which will prevent the Kurbs from freezing the city.
Hardcover, 192 pages
Published April 12th 2000 by Orchard Books (NY) (first published 1993)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about City of Light, City of Dark, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about City of Light, City of Dark

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 589)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
This graphic novel was just ok for me. I couldn't help wishing the writing went a little deeper than it did and the art was just alright, nothing particularly stylish or interesting about it. The framing device for the story about the sinister alien race could have led to something with more interest and energy, but instead just really only served as a framing device. *Spoilers ahead* I also felt like there was a lot of build up to moments of potential emotional climax and pathos that were never ...more
Matthew Hundley
I love graphic novels. And I love the idea of re-imagining a city. City of Light, City of Dark re-casts NYC into an imaginative tale about Kurbs and a magical power force and those who keep the city from falling into peril. I like all that. The context. The actual style in which it is drawn and lettered is a bit "amateurish" for me. And I wasn't big on all the text used in the prologue. But the story was engaging enough to pull me through; and in some ways the "amateurish" nature of the artwork ...more
Some masterful writers can slip seamlessly between mediums, constructing equally brilliant novels, comics, and film scripts (Neil Gaiman). But Avi is unfortunately not one of them. The story here is good enough, but my feeling reading it was that there was just no reason for it to be in graphic form. The drawings didn't move the plot forward or really add anything to make it more interesting. This seems like a classic example of Avi or his publishers wanting to try to capitalize on the popularit ...more
This review originally published in Looking For a Good Book. Rated 2.5 of 5

I am not particularly familiar with Avi, though I recognize his name as a prominent author in the YA/Children's Book field. What I don't know is whether this is a departure from his other writings, or if this is in line with the bulk of his cannon.

The story is a dark fantasy. Somesort of dark, supernatural beings, Kurbs, living deep beneath Manhattan island have loaned the island to humans. Every year, the humans must fi
Wayne McCoy
This is a reprint of a 1993 graphic novel by Avi. It involves a kidnapped girl, a blind schemer who talks to pigeons and a mysterious subway token.

In a preface that is more text than pictures, we learn about the creatures that supply power to the city of New York, the Kurbs. In a sort of game they hide a token in the city that must be found and returned to the Kurbs, or they turn off power to the city. A scheming man named Underton attempts to steal the token and ends up blinded. The story then
Dominic Tiberio
This was just OK. I love minimal/brushwork art and the cover caught my attention, but unfortunately there is just not much here. The writing is probably the biggest letdown and there are some major flaws to the storyline almost from the beginning and it never improves. The single thought I found myself going over and over as I read was why anyone would even bother writing/publishing a story with such minimal plot and so little to say? With a small amount of effort the plot and conflicts could ha ...more
This is a reprint of the 1993 graphic novel by Avi and Floca to celebrate it's 20th anniversary.
It is unknown to most people that the city of New York is actually owned by shadow creatures called the Kurbs who supply power to the city, also controlling day and night. When people began to settle there, they had to make a bargain with the Kurbs in order to live there. Part of the agreement had to do with a magic token that would be hidden by the Kurbs every year, and every year the chosen woman w
All around, this was just so-so. I'm sure children will enjoy it, but I wanted more depth - from both the plot and the illustrations. The illustrations were just black and white sketches, and I had a hard time distinguishing the mother and daughter. The plot was inventive, however: set in a dystopian New York City, the nondescript alienoid Kurbs loan the power to run the city to the occupants, with the condition that one special person (a position handed down from generation to generation) retur ...more
Leah Wener-Fligner
Very disappointing. I like Avi a lot and wanted to see what he'd do with a graphic novel. The answer is, not much (not entirely his fault--the art was not good at all). A lot of it was typeset, not hand lettered, which left me unable to read the comic booky language (the POWER, the ceremony of the ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF THE POWER) without feeling embarrassed for the writer's sake. The stakes of the story didn't seem high enough to keep me reading and the mystery wasn't very mysterious. I wanted Neil ...more
In the beginning, there were the Kurbs, who flocked toward darkness much as moths flock toward light. When people came to the Kurb island, they made an agreement with the Kurbs to share their power and split the days between dark and light. These days, this power is stored in a special token that looks just like a New York City subway token. As long as this token is in its special place by noon of December 21st each year, the days will begin to get longer, until the token is hidden by the Kurbs ...more
I enjoyed this battle of good versus evil set in New York City. The plot revolves around a special token desperately wanted by Thor Underton. Having been blinded in an accident years ago, he wants the token to help reclaim his sight and his power. The token, though, is essential to keeping the city safe as part of an agreement with frightening beings called Kurbs. Two teens, Carlos and Sarah, with nothing in common are drawn together when Carlos finds the token. As they unravel the mystery behin ...more
Online Eccentric Librarian
City of light, City of Dark is an ode to New York City, a magical urban fantasy unapologetically rooted in the 1990s (pre-9/11 and the digital age). Since I have not read any of Avi's novels, I am reviewing this from the perspective of the book alone - both story and illustration.

The story is simple: supernatural beings have 'lent' Manhattan to the humans but the humans must find and then return a power source yearly to the beings, the Kurbs. If the chosen human female fails even once in the yea
Stacy Bowden
City of Light, City of Dark is a graphic novel that centers around a "Ritual Cycle of Acknowledgment" between the Kurbs, a group of powerful beings, and the people of The People's City. Each year, on June 21st, the Kurbs place their power within a token and hide the token somewhere in The People's City. The people have six months to find it and return it to the Kurb's place of safekeeping no later than noon on December 21st or the city will grow dark, cold, and freeze, and the Kurbs will take ba ...more
Sarah Sammis
Avi is one of those authors who has written an umpty-billion novels across a number of genres. He could easily be his own section in the library or bookstore. In my own local library, Avi's books take up three rows of shelves. I could easily spend a month just reading and reviewing his books.

City of Light, City of Dark is a graphic novel illustrated by Brian Floca. It reconstructs the history of Manhattan island in an urban fantasy framework. The island belongs to the Kurbs but they lease the la
This is a reprinting of Avi and Brian Floca's 1993 graphic novel in celebration of its 20th anniversary.

The Kurbs have agreed to let humans live on their island and also power the city, but in exchange tribute must be paid. Every year, a token must be found and returned or the city will freeze. Mr. Underton is determined to have the Power for himself. Only Sarah and Carlos stand in his way.

This book doesn't seem to know if it wants to be a novel or a graphic novel. The prologue is formatted as a
Reprinted for the 20th anniversary, Avi's story blends science fiction with mythology. Set in a New York City that is only on loan to the humans, every year the Seeker must find the object of power and return it to the Kurbs by December 21st, or the world will freeze. The object of power in this story is a subway token, something obsolete in this day and age, but a common and very appropriate object when the story was written. Found by an unsuspecting boy, who finds himself pursued by both good ...more
This started a little clunky - I'm not sure where the "Kurbs" came from, but it sounds like "Kurdish" which made for some I'm assuming unintended associations. In the end the main story - young boy and girl work together to save her father and their city - was well done and the illustrations were beautifully executed, but with the slow start this won't be one of my favorites.
This is one of the better graphic novels I've read. I liked Avi's take on the seasons. I also enjoyed seeing the twin towers in the drawings as this book was published in 1993.

I'm not a huge fan of graphic novels, but I have many students who won't read anything else, so I am looking forward to taking this one to school. It has a bit of a superhero feel to the story.

In a mythical tale explaining the seasons and solstices in New York as a result of a pact between humans and the mysterious Kurbs, an object (in this case, a subway token) must be found and returned to the Kurbs by a certain date or the city will be plunged into perpetual winter. For years, a chain of women has performed this task, passing the secret from mother to daughter. Unfortunately, the current coin seeker, Asterel, must deal with Mr. Underton, who wants the energy of the coi
I chose this book by its cover because it seemed really interesting to read and also the title. The plot of the book is that two kids go on a adventure to one place to get a coin in order to keep New York City going. So they go and find the coin and give it to the owner of the World And they keep New York City with the humans not the Kurbs. My favorite quote is "Wait a minute. Wasn't that supposed to be a abandoned station". I like that quote because its like a line that is from like a movie, it ...more
I'm not a huge fan of graphic novels and I completely overlooked this one when it was first published. But I picked it up to decide whether or not to move it to the Graphic Novel section of the library and whether or not it should be in J or YA. And I have to say that I was impressed. It had a great plot, was well-written and the artwork was great. I could even tell the characters apart and read all of the words which doesn't always happen with some of the graphic novels I read. I liked the way ...more
Reenie Peppers
Themes: good vs evil, family dynamics, friendship, seeing things from a different perspective, responsibility
Activities: discuss/ research life in New York city, the subway system; writing prompts - what powers would you choose to have, describe your ideal place to live; group project to draw a city for a graphic novel
Oleg Kagan
The drama was clear in the art, but that couldn't save City of Light, City of Dark from simplistic characters and a hokey premise. In the story, A teenage girl must save the island of Manhattan from freezing by carrying out a mission to find a coin set forth by a mystical, age-old tribe. It's a weird overall plot punctuated by subplots in which the girl's father has a strange master-slave relationship with a power-hungry blind inventor (who somehow communicates with pigeons), and an strange mani ...more
I just have to tell all of my readers about the graphic novel City of Light,City of Dark. The great book was written by Avi.It is amazing, and it is about a girl named Estella whom is slowly reavealing who she is, while hunting down, and keeping a token.The token has visual powers which show you where someone is at all times.
According to me, this book was truly engaging, because you are always on the edge of your seat, and always waiting in anxiety to see exactly what will happen next. What I
Avi and Brian Floca come together to create this hybrid novella that explores the power of energy in society. The cast of characters are all drawn together by a mysterious token, bestowed upon the People as an energy source. Once per year the hidden token must be found by the Seeker and returned to the Kurb hiding place so that the cycle can begin anew. Due to the machinations of a blinded neon sign maker, our cast of characters are tasked with continuing this odd game in order to prevent a deep ...more
Sue Jackson
A graphic novel fantasy story set in the real-life world of New York City. Read my full review at:
The story had potential and the illustrations were often quite lush but the text was pretty light and kind of brittle. I wish I had been captured more quickly into the story than I was.
Oct 27, 2009 Rebecca rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: 5th grade and up
Recommended to Rebecca by: Susan
Wow, I liked this so much more than I expected! The older cover and black-and-white interior didn't spark my interest so much as, say, Amulet, but this book is worth a look. Avi's "comic-book novel" was penned in 1993, way before graphic novels were cool, but I still found this modern myth of summer vs. winter to be a page-turner, with intrepid child heroes (non-Caucasian, to boot), a blind villain, parents in disguise, and a dash of real magic. The artwork by Brian Floca is loose and expressive ...more
While the premise of this book appealed to me, the way it played out was almost painstakingly boring to read. I will be very surprised if my students take to this book.
Lauren Kinney
The framing of the story gave it the potential to be a wise fable, but as the story unfolded, it ended up feeling formulaic. I like the idea of an urban myth, but though this story was an origin tale about light and dark, it didn't enlighten when it came to the correlates of light and dark in humanity. The "dark" characters were caricatures and the "light" characters were not developed with much nuance.

I love Avi and I wanted to like this book, but it didn't uplift or surprise me. What I did en
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 19 20 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Rex Libris, Volume I: I, Librarian (Rex Libris, #1-5)
  • Into The Volcano
  • To Dance: A Ballerina's Graphic Novel
  • Courtney Crumrin's Monstrous Holiday (Courtney Crumrin, #4)
  • Clan Apis
  • Uncle
  • Pinocchio, Vampire Slayer
  • The Dream Thief (Abadazad, #2)
  • Medusa Jones
  • Satchel Paige: Striking Out Jim Crow
  • Tyranny
  • Jellaby: Monster in the City (Jellaby, #2)
  • Maddy Kettle: The Adventure of the Thimblewitch
  • The Amazing Remarkable Monsieur Leotard
  • The Manga Bible: From Genesis to Revelation
  • The Silver Six
  • The Savage
  • The Extraordinary Adventures of Adèle Blanc-Sec: Pterror Over Paris / The Eiffel Tower Demon
Avi is a pen name for Edward Irving Wortis, but he says, "The fact is, Avi is the only name I use."
Born in 1937, Avi has created many fictional favorites such as The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle, Nothing but the Truth, and The Crispin series. His work is very much desired by readers young and old.
More about Avi...
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle Crispin: The Cross of Lead (Crispin #1) Nothing But the Truth Poppy (Tales of Dimwood Forest, #1) The Seer of Shadows

Share This Book