Blank-133x176
As a Driven Leaf
 
by
Milton Steinberg
Rate this book
Clear rating

As a Driven Leaf

4.1 of 5 stars 4.10  ·  rating details  ·  1,325 ratings  ·  101 reviews
The magnificent work of modern fiction that brings the age of the Talmud to life. The characters include the well-known historical figures: Akiba, Yohanan, Joshua, Eleazar, Beruriah, and Elisha ben Abuyah, whose struggle to live in two worlds destroyed his chance to live in either. Foreword by Chaim Potok
Vinyl-bound
Published by Jewish Contemporary Classics (first published 1939)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about As a Driven Leaf, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about As a Driven Leaf

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,625)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Maya
Forward by Chaim Potok
The novel, based on Talmudic sources, admittedly heavily embellished and not holding strictly to pure factual occurrences, follows the life of Rabbi Elisha ben Abuyah, a Jew living during the time after the second Jewish temple had been destroyed and under the thumb of Roman occupation. Born to a father who rejected the Jewish faith and embraced Greek thought and motherless from an early age, he is taught to read Greek and appreciate pagan philosophies. At ten, his father d...more
Helen
I read this back in high school a thousand years ago, as all my friends did.

Rabbi Elisha Ben Abuya is one of the most tragic and charismatic characters in historical Judaism. One of four legendary Mishanaic-era rabbis who undertook the study of Kabbalah, Elisha Ben Abuya was the one who became a heretic.(Of the other three, it is said that one went mad, one died, and one was the great sage Rabbi Akiva.) The novel begins in 70 CE, after the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem, and ends with t...more
Jan Rice
Begins in 80 CE, 10 years after the destruction of the Temple, and goes on through the reigns of Trajan and Hadrian, covering the periods of the Diaspora and Bar Kokhba revolts. "There is no Truth without Faith. There is no Truth unless first there be a Faith on which it may be based." The paradox of the relatedness of Faith and Reason foreshadows the action which then comes full circle, as Elisha struggles not only with Faith vs. Reason, but also with the problem of evil, with loyalty vs. betra...more
Maggie Anton
I first read this novel before I studied Talmud, so I didn't realize it was based on actual Jewish texts. I was fascinated by Steinberg's descriptions of life in Roman Palestine, especially how the Jews lived, since there wasn't any other Jewish historical fiction from this time period. I wasn't so happy with the ending, never quite understanding why Elisha had to completely reject his religion when he couldn't reconcile it with Hellenism.

Later, when I studied the Gemara where his story appear...more
Donny
This book helped me understand so much about the characteristics of faith, the purpose of faith and the problem of faith. You might read that and think "the problem of faith, what is he talking about?", but this book shows, through the life of the protagonist that faith is not a part of this world. It doesn't belong, but that's just the point-it shouldn't belong. There's nothing logical or reasonable about faith, and that's why it's so important. If religion was something to be reasoned through,...more
Tami
It took me a while to get through this book, but I'm so glad I did!

In his book, Steinberg fictionalizes the life of Elisha, a rabbi of the Sanhedrin and sage who lived in Palestine after the destruction of the Second Temple, of whom we know little about for certain. Elisha's struggle to put reason and logic to faith is one I think many people, including myself, can identify with.

Though the book plays fast and loose with historical fact and tradition, it was not only enjoyable to read, but give...more
Salem
Basically, this book was written for me, so it's not surprising that I loved it.

As a Driven Leaf was recommended to me by a rabbi who teaches an Jewish adult education course that I am taking. Two weeks ago we were studying the mitzvot (commandments), and we looked closely at the one in Deuteronomy 22:6-7:
If, along the road, you chance upon a bird's nest, in any tree or on the ground, with fledglings or eggs, do not take the mother together with her young. Let the mother go, and take only the
...more
M
A great read ... Elisha is a very sympathetic figure and for the most part the story is even handed, I think, though I was very troubled by the ending. I found his conflict to be eloquently expressed and extremely relatable. While I found the story to be mostly accurate I was irked by some of the modernizations and places where he clearly took liverties for the sake of fiction - Steinberg's prerogative, of course, but still a little unnerving. Did the tannaim really hang out as couples like some...more
Dani Meier
I greatly enjoyed this book. Steinberg did an amazing job describing the characters and giving me a full picture of all these grand tannaitic sages. Although Steingberg took some liberties with the plot, it seems he really stuck to the general character descriptions as depicted in gemaras and mishnas and I really got a great picture of what it was like to live in that time. Moreover, Elisha ben Avuya's struggle was so great and so interesting and even so relevant to today's times. I am merely le...more
Ronen
Really connected with this book. It brought to life a period in history I know little about, and dealt with the question of the foundations of faith (rational or irrational) that has been asked throughout the ages. Engrossing read for me, as the question is very much on my mind as well.
While the characters sometimes think and act more "modern" than likely, the story still shows how little has changed 2000 years later- humanity's problems and how the individual may choose to deal with them.

Not c...more
Teresa
Since I picked up the book at a thrift store, I had no idea what it was about and was merely tempted by the cover (sad, but true). Then, I put off reading it for about a year or more. Now, after spending the time digging in to Jewish life early in the ad dominum time frame, I am happy to had read this account of a rabbi who lost his faith and tried to use logic and reason to find it again. I had hoped to learn more about the lives of Jews in the time period, but instead was pushed to test reason...more
Elisabeth Jaffe
This book is a timeless story about the unsuccessful search for truth. It takes place during the time of the Roman empire and tells the story about a religious Jewish man who lost his faith and went to search for truth using Euclid's method of reasoning only to find that even the laws and rules of mathematics are based on faith. His search led him back to his people, the same people he betrayed. He is neither hero or villain, just a desperate man who spent his whole life searching for something...more
Tzippy
Elisha ben Avuyah is one of my favorite Talmudic figures, so I had to read this book as soon as I learned it existed. If I had been writing a book about his life, it would have been in a slightly different light and would have put more of an emphasis of the story where R' Meir tries to convince Elisha to get back on the derech and Elisha "proves" to him (suing Talmudic logic) that it can't be done--that scene is so tragic (in the classic sense of the word) I can't even describe it. Anyway, this...more
Rachel
Fictional account of a Jewish rabbi questioning his beliefs in the first century Palestine . . . . yeah. I couldn't get through the book jacket without yawning. But, it was for my book club so I persevered. And - it really grew on me. Like mold. Actually, like in a way that it really made me think and think about it. In the end, I felt that it was a book that was definitely not a "page-turner" but one that I learned so much from. I liked how the author didn't take sides but just presented the st...more
Kandace
This is perhaps one of my favorite books ever. I read it for a history class although it's historical fiction. It takes place about 70AD and shows the role of faith in everybody's life, whether they be devout Jews or the Roman intellectual and cultural elite. I found the story fascinating from a historical standpoint and the ultimate end to the journey almost soul-shocking and, personally, testimony building. I had never thought of faith in the manner it was discussed, trying not to give away th...more
Ellen
Very well researched and written book about historical people, places, times as the basis but fleshed out with believable fiction. Although I slogged through the middle and had to make the effort to finish it, I'm glad I read this book. Reading about how Jews might have lived amongst the Greeks and Romans was intriguing. Also the plot - that a learned, affluent, highly respected and pious Rabbi could reach a turning point in his life where he absolutely questions his religion and way of life - w...more
Karen B
To be true to one's inner voice or to live by faith in the religion to which he was born, that is the dilemma Elisha ben Abuya faces throughout his life. In his quest to gain knowledge he leaves behind his childhood home and friends and ventures to Antioch looking for a greater meaning to life and God. Don't we all question God's infinite wisdom from time to time? Is there a one of us who has not occastionally questioned the meaning of life?
I found parts of the book slow going, but well worth co...more
Jim Leffert
This classic 1939 novel is undoubtedly the best fictional work ever written about the intellectual, spiritual, cultural, and political challenges faced by Jewish elite during the period after the Romans destroyed the Second Temple in 70 CE. During this period, the Mishnah--the compendium of legal discussions and teachings that formed the foundation of Rabbinic Judaism and of the Talmud--took shape. I found As a Driven Leaf to be intellectual stimulating, historically revealing, and personally af...more
Paul
I have some strongly mixed feelings about this book - the female characters seemed mere foils for the men and some of the situations and plots were overly cliched. That said, Steinberg does a great job of putting you into this world and Elisha ben Abuyah's quest. For a book that's obviously so personal, really tremendous how he didn't allow his alter-ego character to go without serious, serious flaws. Some of the religious-philosophical discussions are just fascinating.
Robert
Nicely told story of a difficult time, Palestine just after the destruction of the 2nd temple. Judaism is facing political and religious extinction, and one very intelligent and highly principled man wrestles with what it means to Believe.

If you have some familiarity with the early Rabbinic period, as a bonus you will enjoy portraits of Gamliel II, Meir and Bruriah, Akiba and others. All by a respected scholar of the period.

Bruce
This is a book about rabbinical Judaism around the 100 AC. It is fiction, but it was written by a rabbi and is faithful to the teachings and historical flavor of that era. It is a story of a rabbi who ultimately losses his faith in order to follow Greek reasoning only to find out in the end that Greek reasoning would lead him back to his faith. It is an amazing read and I highly recommend it for those who are interested.
Adam Jacobson
There was a time in my life when this book was very important. On one level, I loved it because of how it took talmudic stories and created a real world.
More importantly, I was on a "religious quest" as it were and it seemed to understand my ongoing crisis of faith.
Now that I'm no longer struggling with Judaism in the same way, I wonder what it would be like to reread it.
Sue
A classic of American Jewish literature. Rabbi Steinberg takes the Talmudic tale of the 1st-century scholar Elisha ben Abuya ("the heretic," also called "Acher" = "the other") & turns it into a compelling & thought-provoking novel.

Elisha ben Abuya was also one of the "four who entered Paradise."

This was my second time reading this book.
Thomas Kinsfather
Packed with cultural and historical information, this historic fiction is as educational as it is entertaining.

A devout Jew was begins to doubt the strict legalism of his faith and soon finds himself ostracized from Jewish society. I don't read many novels, but this was well worth the read.
Elaine Grant
Excellent book on the culture of First Century Judaism. I gained many insights into the sentiment and various movements of the period. I thought it was very interesting, if not the typical 'happily ever after' book but then, historical books rarely are.
Rachel
This was one of the few books I was assigned in school that I fell in love with. I was amazed at how the author made characters who lived over 2000 seem relevant and human. Yes, the plot will break your heart, but you should read it anyway.
Shira
Wonderful book. Confusing, probing, relatable. I thought the last 50-100 pages was a cop out. It made the final answer too easy, and sold Elisha's questions short.
Benjamin
"As a Driven Leaf," the only novel by New York Rabbi Milton Steinberg, and which was published in 1939 during the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl and at the beginning of the Nazi extermination of European Jews, narrates the life of Elisha ben Abuyah, a Palestinian Rabbi who lived during the time of the bar Kosiba (bar Cochba) rebellion (132-135 CE). Elisha ben Abuyah is primarily famous, in the words of Chaim Potok in the foreword to the novel, for "having been one of a minute number of rabbi...more
Judy
Oct 16, 2013 Judy rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: any Jew or anyone who enjoys historical fiction
Recommended to Judy by: Dor Hadash
I read this as a teen and re-read it recently for a book club discussion. It is a bit long, but is probably the best novel (maybe the only novel) set in Roman-ruled Palestine in the 2nd century. The Jews of that time, after the destruction of the temple in Jerusalem, developed what is now called rabbinic Judaism. Jewish law was set by the rabbis of the Sanhedrin, including some central figures in history such as Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Gamliel. The Jews of that time struggled against the rather sc...more
Paula  Obermeier McCarty
This book was engrossing and hard to put down. The whole struggle to find a solid personal philosophical/spiritual foundation in the middle of conflicting cultures and beliefs was fascinating. However, the book's ending was profoundly disappointing to me. Elisha (the main character) and many of his friends and family all suffer tragically from his decision to explore Greek and Roman philosophy.

Were his explorations wrong? It's hard for me to think that. I read this book a few years ago and have...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 87 88 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • God in Search of Man: A Philosophy of Judaism
  • Jewish Literacy: The Most Important Things to Know about the Jewish Religion, Its People, and Its History
  • The Lonely Man of Faith
  • In the Image
  • Rashi's Daughters: Joheved
  • Choosing a Jewish Life: A Handbook for People Converting to Judaism and for Their Family and Friends
  • Jewish Meditation: A Practical Guide
  • Everyman's Talmud: The Major Teachings of the Rabbinic Sages
  • The Jewish Study Bible
  • Souls on Fire
  • A Journey to the End of the Millennium - A Novel of the Middle Ages
  • Tanakh: The Holy Scriptures
  • Outwitting History: The Amazing Adventures of a Man Who Rescued a Million Yiddish Books
  • To Be A Jew: A Guide To Jewish Observance In Contemporary Life
  • The Last of the Just
  • To Life: A Celebration of Jewish Being and Thinking
  • In the Beginning
  • Tales of the Hasidim, Vols 1-2
Basic Judaism The Prophet's Wife Partisan Guide to the Jewish Problem (Brown classics in Judaica) The Making of the Modern Jew Anatomy of Faith

Share This Book

“Then there were so many things to be said that they did not speak of any of them.” 5 likes
“Does man not face life with a greater assurance is he believes that a benevolent providence foresees the future? And yet he must at the same time be confident that his will is free, otherwise moral support is meaningless altogether. Doctrines in themselves are not important to me, but their consequences are. For example, I urge upon men that they regard themselves as embodiments of the divine essence. If I convince them, their days are endowed with a sense of abiding significance and unturning glory. Then not all the misfortunes and degradations to which they may be subjected can take from them their feelings of oneness with angels and stars. And as for our people, persecuted and dispersed, they live under the shadow of death, cherishing a dream that is recurrently shattered by the caprice of tyrants and then dreamed again half in despair. What can enable such a people to persist except a conviction of a special relationship to God?” 2 likes
More quotes…