How Jesus Became Christian
Barrie Wilson is Professor of Humanities & Religious Studies at York University in Toronto. A specialist in early Christian origins, this is his first book intended for a general audience. Building on contemporary critical scholarship, it addresses some of the major puzzles he has identified in teaching biblical studies over a twenty-year period. An award-winning educator,
...moreHardcover, 304 pages
Published
March 4th 2008
by St. Martin's Press
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
123)
Readable account of the Christification of Jesus. The book takes a look at why the Christianity we know today won out over rival claims. Wilson describes the historical and political context in which Yeshua, rabbi and leader of the Jesus movement, becomes Christ the Savior of modern day Christianity.
Wilson, a convert from Episcopalian to Judaism, writes from a less than neutral position. He speaks of the Proto-Orthodoxy (early Christianity) pillaging Judaism of its culture and his...more
Wilson, a convert from Episcopalian to Judaism, writes from a less than neutral position. He speaks of the Proto-Orthodoxy (early Christianity) pillaging Judaism of its culture and his...more
This is a long overdue review of a great new book. Wilson highlights the tension of Christianity’s founding movement, and asks the question: Was Jesus a Jew or a Christian? Paul’s brand of Christianity, especially, Wilson finds anti-Semitic, in stark contrast to the Gospel of Matthew and its reliance upon Torah. Paul, Wilson theorizes, hijacked Jesus for himself, turning Christianity into a Gentile religion.
Wilson’s portrayal of conflicting religions—the “Jesus movement” of the Jews, a...more
Wilson’s portrayal of conflicting religions—the “Jesus movement” of the Jews, a...more
I would have given this book more than 3 stars had the tone of it been different and had it been a monograph or essay of about 100 pages.
I read the first half of the book really quickly, as the book, in essence, is non-academic and therefore extremely readable for the everyday audience. However, the author was so bloody repetitive and belabors his points, causing me great ire and frustration at times (especially throughout the second half of the book).
Furthermore, even though...more
I read the first half of the book really quickly, as the book, in essence, is non-academic and therefore extremely readable for the everyday audience. However, the author was so bloody repetitive and belabors his points, causing me great ire and frustration at times (especially throughout the second half of the book).
Furthermore, even though...more
This is an interesting area for me because I am interested in how ideas disseminate. I wasn't that interested in the theology.
That said, the book was interesting if a tad too repetitive. There is a more than pedagogical redundancy to his arguments and he beats on the same issues over and over.
The evolution that the author explains makes plenty of sense. There are basically two religions mixed into a hybrid to make Christianity as it is practised today: Judaism and the mystic Chris...more
That said, the book was interesting if a tad too repetitive. There is a more than pedagogical redundancy to his arguments and he beats on the same issues over and over.
The evolution that the author explains makes plenty of sense. There are basically two religions mixed into a hybrid to make Christianity as it is practised today: Judaism and the mystic Chris...more
A true revelation (no pun intended). Exposes how much theological Christianity should actually be called "Paulism". The "real" Jesus in this account really did see himself as a potential messiah but in the full-throttle Jewish sense. His teachings are therefore designed for the imminent Kingdom of God, hence the strangenes of some of them. As for the God's son sacrifice stuff, the Trinity, Paul and his successors added this as a bolt-on superstruuture. As this is the stuff I'...more
This is a very intriguing book. The main question that the author examines and answers throughout the book is the following.
"How did a young rabbi become the God of a religion he wouldn't recognize, one which was established through the use of calculated anti-semitism?"
Of course, at first glance, this question may seem quite loaded, filled with flawed assumptions. However, throughout the book, Wilson unlocks this question and decompresses it in order to convey his the...more
"How did a young rabbi become the God of a religion he wouldn't recognize, one which was established through the use of calculated anti-semitism?"
Of course, at first glance, this question may seem quite loaded, filled with flawed assumptions. However, throughout the book, Wilson unlocks this question and decompresses it in order to convey his the...more
Although Wilson offers an intriguing point of view, I found his tone so bitter that the entire book came across sour. Before progressing further, I should note that I am not a Bible scholar, and I like to keep my religious beliefs to myself. I was a Classics major in college, so I'm familiar with the time period and can pick my way through New Testament Greek, but that's the end of my qualifications.
Wilson starts strongly with a solid look at the political and religious context of th...more
Wilson starts strongly with a solid look at the political and religious context of th...more
Warning! I disliked the author's anecdotal style so much that I had a hard time reading to the end. However it is worth the effort.
I used to joke with friends that christianity was the most successful jewish cult in history.
However, as the author points out, the Jesus cult actually died out a long time ago. In his book he describes Jesus, quite rightly, as being a proselytizing teacher who taught strict observance of Torah and who believed that the Jewish god was coming ...more
I used to joke with friends that christianity was the most successful jewish cult in history.
However, as the author points out, the Jesus cult actually died out a long time ago. In his book he describes Jesus, quite rightly, as being a proselytizing teacher who taught strict observance of Torah and who believed that the Jewish god was coming ...more
I am so happy to have found this book! This paradox has plagued me throughout my life: "how did Jesus the Jew become the Gentile Christ?"
Just as I suspected, it has to do with powerful people rewriting history to their advantage and stealing someone else's popularity for their own gain.
Stay tuned; will let you know what I learn. So far, Paul apparently has a lot to answer for. (Interestingly, I have never liked or trusted that man!) I will also learn how and why Christia...more
Just as I suspected, it has to do with powerful people rewriting history to their advantage and stealing someone else's popularity for their own gain.
Stay tuned; will let you know what I learn. So far, Paul apparently has a lot to answer for. (Interestingly, I have never liked or trusted that man!) I will also learn how and why Christia...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jesus wasn't Christian. Neither were his followers. A few generations after his death, Paul invented Christianity based on a revelation he had, not based on the teachings of Jesus. Okay, fine, but this author could have just written an essay. Instead, a big thick book where he repeats himself endlessly and bitterly.
What I already knew.
A must read for anyone interested in the beginnings of Christianity. Wilson takes us through early Christian history, including the Jesus Movement and Paul's Christ Movement, to the merging of the two by the author of Acts. Fascinating!
This is a good book on the split in the early Church. I think his portrayal of the Ebionites as Torah-observant Jews is somewhat misleading, though. Yes, they were Jews, but they had their own idea of what the "Law" was which was very deviant from first-century Judaism.
Interesting ideas.
Chris
marked it as to-read
Marissa
marked it as to-read
Ronaldo Martins
marked it as to-read
Sybella
marked it as to-read
Skip
marked it as to-read
K. Clawson
marked it as to-read
Eric Schell
marked it as to-read
Rion
marked it as to-read
Sarah
marked it as to-read
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...



































