Sign in with Facebook
Loading...
Criminal, Vol. 3: The Dead and the Dying (Criminal #3)
Winner of the Eisner Award for Best New Series, and Winner of the Harvey and Eisner Awards for Best Writer The third collection of Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips' critically-acclaimed noir series follows a different twist of the knife this time -- telling three interlinking stories that take place during the early 1970s and swirl around the fate of a hard-luck Femme Fatale,...more
Paperback, 104 pages
Published
July 23rd 2008
by Marvel
(first published February 2008)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,162)
Just when I thought Ed Brubaker’s Criminal comic series couldn’t get any better, he sets a story back in the ‘70s that had me humming the Shaft theme song while I was reading it.
The main story revolves around a black boxer and his white gangster friend. The two grew up together because their fathers built a criminal empire together, but their friendship has been on a shaky ground since there was some ugliness involving Danica, a beautiful woman they both fell for. Brubaker tells the main story o...more
The main story revolves around a black boxer and his white gangster friend. The two grew up together because their fathers built a criminal empire together, but their friendship has been on a shaky ground since there was some ugliness involving Danica, a beautiful woman they both fell for. Brubaker tells the main story o...more
5 likes
·
like
· see review
view 2 comments
Writer Ed Brubaker and artist Sean Phillips deliver another one-two punch of crime noir in this third volume of their critically-acclaimed series, CRIMINAL.
In "The Dead and the Dying," Brubaker takes a decidedly SIN CITY-esque move by providing three vignettes of characters newly and previously introduced in other stories from the series. Here, though, the stories are wound together a little more tightly than Frank Miller did with his classic noir series, and the result is what keeps this collec...more
In "The Dead and the Dying," Brubaker takes a decidedly SIN CITY-esque move by providing three vignettes of characters newly and previously introduced in other stories from the series. Here, though, the stories are wound together a little more tightly than Frank Miller did with his classic noir series, and the result is what keeps this collec...more
You know when you watch 'Lost' and you jump up a little bit, because you see a character from the Island popping up in Someone else's backstory?
That is the Best part of Criminal. The fictional city that Brubaker made just for this story is a small one. Characters from each story arc pop in and out of each other's stories and in many cases, play a huge role in a characters fate/downfall.
Is Criminal being optioned for a tv show? I have heard rumors. Lord knows, without 'The Wire' or 'The Sopranos'...more
That is the Best part of Criminal. The fictional city that Brubaker made just for this story is a small one. Characters from each story arc pop in and out of each other's stories and in many cases, play a huge role in a characters fate/downfall.
Is Criminal being optioned for a tv show? I have heard rumors. Lord knows, without 'The Wire' or 'The Sopranos'...more
Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips shift the loose chronology of Criminal back a generation for a set of three connected short-crime stories. They don't bring up too many dated references to the 60's and 70's besides the war in Vietnam and social acceptance of boxing, but the book's not a waste. The real star is Danica, the girl on the cover who's not quite smart enough to be a femme fatale. The trick of the book is that she doesn't get her own story until the third issue, but by then her fate is cle...more
If the first book places us in the underworld setting for this hardboiled graphic novel series, and the second cements its formalist approach, the third makes serious music with that approach. This book contains three closely related stories, all focused on a young generation suffering fates due to ties to a criminal organization. It's heartbreaking stuff, and it's to the credit of the author, Ed Brubaker, that despite the tight plotting, the characters never feel like they're being pushed in a...more
Good, but something was missing. It seemed like all backstory, without any tension or resolution to the characters drama. It is definitely entertaining, with some well drawn characters, but it all seems too shallow. I would have appreciated if it had been drawn out longer, with a deeper examination of the characters thoughts and emotions. instead it seemed hurried and without a proper climax or resolution. Still and all, I liked it and look forward to reading much more by Brubaker, who is a true...more
"Criminal" -sarjan kolmas osa "The Dead and Dying" (Icon, 2008) on 1970-luvulle sijoittuva rikossarjakuva, jossa kolme lain väärälle puolelle ajautunutta ihmistä - Vietnam-veteraani, lupaava nyrkkeilijä ja heroiinikoukussa oleva strippari - yrittää keinolla millä hyvänsä selviytyä New Yorkin kaduilla keinolla. Sarjakuva koostuu kolmesta eri episodista, joissa hahmojen reitit risteävät ja koskettavat toisiaan enemmän tai vähemmän kohtaloikkain seurauksin. Jälleen kerran laadukasta jälkeä kovalta...more
A lifelong friendship ending in tragedy. A botched abortion. Robbing a drug cartel. Abused families. Traumatised Vietnam soldiers. Addiction, pain, hardship, death.
Yup, it's another cheerful book from Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips. Taking place in the late 60s/early 70s, the three stories presented here feature a prizefighter sidelining as a heavy for a drug dealing friend, a Vietnam vet who needs to pay off his gambling debts or his family gets it, and a prostitute looking for revenge. They ov...more
Yup, it's another cheerful book from Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips. Taking place in the late 60s/early 70s, the three stories presented here feature a prizefighter sidelining as a heavy for a drug dealing friend, a Vietnam vet who needs to pay off his gambling debts or his family gets it, and a prostitute looking for revenge. They ov...more
Aug 31, 2008
Christopher
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Mature Audience, Ed Brubaker fans, and mafia story buffs.
Recommended to Christopher by:
Self - through normal advertisement.
This was an interesting graphic novel. I first have to say that this book is not for the faint of heart and it is definitely for mature audiences.
Joe Singleton sums it up pretty good in his introduction, "He and Brubaker take us to another place and we are like voyeurs to a world that none of us would want to live in. It's dangerous, seedy and sexy...and you know what? We dig it.
I do not know why I am drawn to stories that involve the underground drug rinks, organized crime, and the mafia, but...more
Joe Singleton sums it up pretty good in his introduction, "He and Brubaker take us to another place and we are like voyeurs to a world that none of us would want to live in. It's dangerous, seedy and sexy...and you know what? We dig it.
I do not know why I am drawn to stories that involve the underground drug rinks, organized crime, and the mafia, but...more
Brubaker and Phillips are a great team, but even the best occasionally have an average game. The third volume of Criminal is one of those. While a challenging structure was attempted... three different stories from three different perspectives about the same events... none of the stories has the real heft or pathos of the past volumes. The stories are almost mundane in their criminality, which is more realistic, but less dramatic in impact. A good read, if not great.
This was presumably supposed to be Brubaker and Phillips' attempt to emulate 70s blaxpoitation films within their hard boiled CRIMINAL world. I don't think it really worked. I enjoyed the sharded storytelling from chapter to chapter, but the overall plot just wasn't that interesting. This was one of those stories that could have benefited from a few more chapters.
And I don't know if it's just me, but Sean Phillips' art looks like it's taking a turn for the worse. Cloudy, muddy, nothing like the...more
And I don't know if it's just me, but Sean Phillips' art looks like it's taking a turn for the worse. Cloudy, muddy, nothing like the...more
This volume goes some way to realising the potential shown in the first two. Instead of focusing on plot and glossing over characterisation. This issue is devoted to examining the main figures backgrounds and motivations. This gives the characters the added depth that was lacking in the previous books and consequently makes the overall narrative stronger going into the next volume.
This was an amazing exercise in perspective, and hey, the seventies are always groovy. Everyone's got a story, whether it be the old guy behind the bar or the man spoken of in whispers. The Lawless clan is my favorite, because of Brubaker's incredible skill at writing characters who aren't necessarily the brightest, but are not Dumb & Dumber.
Well written and illustrated as usual, this particular volume was missing something. The first story is the strongest but the last one felt flimsy and boring. Overall this isn't the best book in the series. I am getting kind of tired of this series anyways so it might be my last. But Brubaker and Phillips are still a good team.
This is the first volume that Ed Brubaker delivers the story written from three angles, each one focusing on a different character. The scenes occasionally overlap, providing just enough back story for people and places. As it happens, the technique also lends the volume a very cinematic feel. A++, would read again.
Another entry in Brubaker's Criminal series. This one is set in the late 60s-early 70s, and gives you some backstory about a few of the characters seen in prior books. There's three interlinking stories here, each telling part of a larger story. We have the sort of cast you'd expect in a volume of Criminal, all shady characters with compelling stories. The real star is Danica, the lady on the cover. Everything that happens revolves around her and her heartbreaking story. If nothing else, she's t...more
My least favorite of the Criminal books, but still pretty good. Brubaker and Phillips are building an urban web of grifters, losers, tough guys, hookers, con men, and other unsavory associations that is just as interesting, but much more subtle, as Frank Miller's Sin City yarns. The Dead and the Dying is a triptych of gutter-level stories: boyhood friends who as grownups get split apart over a woman's charms; a look backward to the down-on-his-luck father of one of the boys; and a close-up of ho...more
A nice collection of short noir stories. The length doesn’t allow for the depth of character of the previous volumes, but the overlapping stories blend together in very interesting ways — particularly the Lawless issue.
brubaker and phillips flip things on us a bit, with a central story told through different character's perspectives. each issue shifts characters and reveals a bit more about the story and about the connections to the previous stories. great stuff.
A trio of short stories join forces to tell the tale of a woman who was chewed up and spit out by the men she had the misfortune of encountering in her life.
Excellent storytelling again in a great series.
Excellent storytelling again in a great series.
The series gets better and better. Enjoyed this trilogy of tales and will have to go back and read the series again with the relish of knowing the backstory of the minor characters in earlier volumes.
I liked this set of one issue stories less than the bigger story arcs. It's still good, but it is my least favorite of the Criminal stories so far. You have to love that artwork though!
Not as good as the first two installments. It lacked the depth, but I missed the single story. What I did like was the interplay between the three seemingly different stories.
this is pretty much the best book of its kind out right now. total crime noir. It's like "Heat" meets 70's blaxploitation. great stuff.
Ditto to the last volume. It is way cool how well Brubaker has developed this world, how he humanizes everyone--even the ugliest among them. Again, if you like crime/gritty/noir stories, there is no reason to pass these by.
Noir and gritty crime books are back, friend. Brubaker's brain keeps all threads weaving together in a perfect perfect way.
The series just keeps getting better and better. I really felt for the characters even the most vile. A must read!
The one and done-ish format of this collection worked really well. My favorite of the series so far.
Amazing chapter in the ongoing "Criminal" series. The story just keeps getting better and better from here.
The city killed me once. Next time won't be so bad. Might not even be there for the final blow.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Ed Brubaker (born November 17, 1966) is an Eisner Award-winning American cartoonist and writer. He was born at the National Naval Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland.
Brubaker is best known for his work as a comic book writer on such titles as Batman, Daredevil, Captain America, Iron Fist, Catwoman, Gotham Central, Sleeper, Uncanny X-Men and X-Men: Deadly Genesis, and The Authority, and for helping...more
More about Ed Brubaker...
Brubaker is best known for his work as a comic book writer on such titles as Batman, Daredevil, Captain America, Iron Fist, Catwoman, Gotham Central, Sleeper, Uncanny X-Men and X-Men: Deadly Genesis, and The Authority, and for helping...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
