78th out of 802 books
—
2,129 voters
The Wind Singer (Wind on Fire #1)
The first in a trilogy, The Wind Singer is a mesmerizing and remarkably imagined fantasy novel full of adventure, suspense humor, and warmth. Winner of the 2000 Nestle Smarties Book Proze. An ALA Notable Book.
Paperback, 486 pages
Published
May 1st 2002
by Hyperion
(first published 2000)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Children's books about the horrors of standardized testing are increasingly popular these days. From Edward Bloor's well-intentioned, Story Time to The Report Card by the otherwise talented Andrew Clements, these books have attempted to capture the dangers of this destructive teaching tool. Both books have fallen short, leaving some people to wonder if there could ever be a book that discusses this controversial subject well. What few people know is that there's a fantastic well-written and beau...more
May 08, 2009
Pamela Lloyd
rated it
1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
literary analysts, especially in women's studies programs
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
In the city of Aramanth, the lives of its citizens are ruled by a color-coded caste system of standardized tests. How well one does on the yearly “High Examination” determines what you do for work, where you live, and even what color clothing you wear. Those that test poorly find themselves consigned to the dismal one-room tenements and menial labor of the Grey district, while those who test well can eventually aspire to life in the mansions and illustrious careers of the White district. Free th...more
Apr 29, 2013
Molster
added it
In year 7, my class was split into reading groups. There was six people in my group and we were the more capable group of the class. When it came time to select the book we would read and discuss, our group was divided about what we should read. The four boys in my group wanted to read this book (I assume just to spite us) and my friend and I wanted to read another book (the title escapes me at the moment). After much heated debate about how good our book would be, purely because of the blurb an...more
Mar 30, 2012
Christianne Ellene
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
in-my-kindle
I read this 4 years ago for school, and I never regretted sticking with this book until the end.
William Nicholson introduces us to the twins Kestrel and Bowman Hath, who share a telepathic/empathic connection on top of Bowman possessing the empathic abilities. The city they live in, Amaranth, is bureaucratic to the extreme (e.g. every family has a "family rating" that is determined from the family members' individual performances in written exams and decide the living conditions of the family)....more
William Nicholson introduces us to the twins Kestrel and Bowman Hath, who share a telepathic/empathic connection on top of Bowman possessing the empathic abilities. The city they live in, Amaranth, is bureaucratic to the extreme (e.g. every family has a "family rating" that is determined from the family members' individual performances in written exams and decide the living conditions of the family)....more
It's been a very long time since I found a book I genuinely wanted to keep reading to the point of ignoring my other responsibilities. It's been a very long time since I woke up thinking, "I had better get my stuff done quickly so I can get back to my book." The Wind Singer is a book like that.
The Wind Singer is the first book in the "Wind on Fire" trilogy, but it would stand alone just fine. When Kestrel tires of constant examinations and the focus on ranking of families, she rebels against the...more
The Wind Singer is the first book in the "Wind on Fire" trilogy, but it would stand alone just fine. When Kestrel tires of constant examinations and the focus on ranking of families, she rebels against the...more
This is one of the first real fantasies that I actually read. The Wind Singer is the first book of William Nicholson's Wind on Fire trilogy. I believe I read the first one in either 7th grade and loved it so much that I had to get my mom to buy it for me. She also bought me the second and third to go with it a few months later for Christmas. I was very happy and still am because this trilogy is one of my favorites and they aren't in stores anymore. I have all three hardbacks and have read them a...more
I'm not a kid anymore; really, I'm at the other side of the curve. It would have been simple to look at this book from that perspective and rate it lower for many reasons: in your face points being made about society, simplistic writing style, convenient wrapping up of situations to the favor of the main characters, lack of character development, etc.
But... the book was targeted at the younger set and I wouldn't be doing it (or the author) justice if I didn't try to look at it from the rising si...more
But... the book was targeted at the younger set and I wouldn't be doing it (or the author) justice if I didn't try to look at it from the rising si...more
I started this book when I was much younger (about six or seven) and I was hooked. Unfortunately, I was unable to finish it until much later (about three or four years later) and it still had me hooked. The book made me happy. Of course, there wersome unaswered questions especially about the old children and the windsinger but the rest of it was really charming. I didn't really mind the made-up words because they just added a lighter tone towhat could have been a depressing story. I especially l...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
okay, i thought i found this recommended on cousin stephanies goodreads list, but now i can't find it.
anyways, i was really struck by the city that was created in the story. A city where everyone is tested (starting at 18 months old)according to a standard test and the results of that test is your rating. your rating is added up with the rest of your family's ratings and your family is given an overall standing in society. This is in reference to Standardized Tests in our current world.
Who deci...more
anyways, i was really struck by the city that was created in the story. A city where everyone is tested (starting at 18 months old)according to a standard test and the results of that test is your rating. your rating is added up with the rest of your family's ratings and your family is given an overall standing in society. This is in reference to Standardized Tests in our current world.
Who deci...more
A very interesting novel. You get to know what it is like to live in a society controlled by old and conservative men (not unlike some of today's nations), were the people are controlled in a dictatorship based on phsycology. Instead of classes based upon where people work and what they do, the nation is divided into colours following the rainbow and the social condition depend on the colour which the family live in, where white is best. The city is buildt in a circle and each colour has their o...more
Aug 05, 2007
Chuck
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
upper elementary/middle school
The Windsinger is a wonderful tale of twins who fight against the leaders of a town who reject diversity and independence. The main characters are twins who have the ability to read each other's thoughts. The twins are forced into situations where they learn a great deal about themselves. The various "obstacles" they encounter are a very creative and deal, in some aspects, with fears children may have, such as old age. Highly enjoyable book that I read in one sitting.
I feel terrible giving a book two stars, but "it's okay" was truly how I felt. I didn't dislike it, and it was an entertaining, fast read, but everything happened so quickly that I felt like some of the plot points were over before I really understood what was going on. This book needed less telling and more showing! Give me details! There were a fair amount of minor characters introduced that disappeared so quickly I questioned why they were even mentioned.
I also felt like some of the main ele...more
I also felt like some of the main ele...more
I was such a huge fan of this book that I dragged my parents to a talk by Nicholson when I was about 13 (and now have signed first editions of the trilogy, which makes me a very happy bunny). It is not my favourite of the trilogy and in fact the first two times I read it I didn't actually get to the end. Unlike Harry Potter and His Dark Materials I think you have to read it when you are young the first time. It is a wonderful adventure story for children (the second two deal with more mature the...more
Jun 04, 2007
Leila
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
middle school readers and above. Older readers looking for a good story.
I think it's original, that's really the bottom line. The world he creates is vivid and extraordinary and I love it. My personal asthetic leans towards alternatre worlds and stuggles against totalitarianism, and this book hits both. It's a good middle school read, nothing too challenging but at that point where themes start to have depth. I really liked the whole series.
i read this about 2 years ago. i only read the first book but i was determined to read the second. i couldn't find it and the copy in the library was with someone else and the librarian told me i was in a long line but i didnt have 1 euro to reserve it. i found this book in my recomendations list and i was like "oh yeah! i totally forgot about that book!" i remember the day when i borrowed it from the library. i read it in 2 days because i was so into it. its mainly about a brother and a sister...more
I enjoyed this book as it had engaging characters and an interesting "journey" plot. The details allowed me to picture this alternate world, but I was not overwhelmed with too much information. It is the first in a trilogy, but the ending felt complete (almost too complete, though); since I liked the world Nicholson created, I'm likely to read the other two novels in the series. I would recommend this book for younger readers who are not yet ready for the violence and strong themes of HUNGER GAM...more
I'm reading it right now, but it is pretty action filled so far. I wouldn't go so far as to say it's my favorite book, because I do not tend to like those books that are just one long quest for something that is not resolved until the end. I do however, say that it's extreemly exciting and hard to put down.
I couldn't get into this book at the beginning with all the family ratings and examinations taking place but then I gave it a second chance to discover a brilliant adventure that simply leaped out of the pages! I didn't dare put it down.
The young hero, Bowman, and his twin sister, Kestrel, and an unlikely member of their courageous, ragtag group, Mumpo, took me through the city of Aramanth to the Underlake and its mudnut loving people. More gripping suprises during their great escape from the S...more
The young hero, Bowman, and his twin sister, Kestrel, and an unlikely member of their courageous, ragtag group, Mumpo, took me through the city of Aramanth to the Underlake and its mudnut loving people. More gripping suprises during their great escape from the S...more
A friend gave me this book as a part of a birthday present after I had recommended some books to her. She thought I'd find this book interesting--and she was right. Kess and Bowman grabbed me right away, and the rest of the family did not disappoint either. I immediately felt a connection to Kess and I loved accompanying her on her adventures. The beginning grabbed me the strongest and I felt the pacing of the middle to the end of the book was a little off--things began happening too quickly and...more
Reactions:
Ok. This novel is sort of about a dystopian society. This society relies solely on examinations and a point system. Children and adults are tested, and then based on their smartness, they either advance or get lowered in the inner workings of their city. It's a cruel world and different levels are given different colours to wear. People from the Orange district will not associate with the greys and vice versa. The examiners run the town and won't allow anyone the freedom of voice.
Kestr...more
Ok. This novel is sort of about a dystopian society. This society relies solely on examinations and a point system. Children and adults are tested, and then based on their smartness, they either advance or get lowered in the inner workings of their city. It's a cruel world and different levels are given different colours to wear. People from the Orange district will not associate with the greys and vice versa. The examiners run the town and won't allow anyone the freedom of voice.
Kestr...more
Wow. What an amazing novel. "The Wind Singer" is a must-read for anyone wanting an intriguing, slightly puzzling read. The novel takes place in Aramanth, where the society is divided into color groups. The protagonist, Kestrel Hath lives in Orange County, the third-to-last division in Aramanth with her family. Kestrel and her twin brother Bowman set off on a journey to find the lost voice of the wind singer to bring normalcy to the society.
As I mentioned before, this was such an amazing read....more
As I mentioned before, this was such an amazing read....more
I liked some of the ideas behind this book... the dystopian setting of Aramanth with its rigid caste system was drawn nicely, and I really liked the initial scenario of a family that bucks the system while staying just enough on the right side of the "law" to avoid permanent trouble. I thought there were loads of possibilities, and was disappointed that the promise was squandered a bit as it simply served as a launching point for a more standard adventure scenario, with our main characters escap...more
This turned out to be an interesting story. The Hath family lives in Aramanth where succeeding at exams is everything. Your place in society depends on you "striving harder, reaching higher, and making tomorrow better than today." The thing is, the Hath family is not happy, so they begin to rebel. Twins Kestrel and Bowman take off outside the city across dessert land and forest, along with a mildly retarded boy their own age, to find the secret to make the Wind Singer sing again, to save the peo...more
I read this a while ago, but i still love it! I wouldn't really give it to a ten year old because last time i did the kid had nightmares. William Nicholson creates a funny, entertaining and wonderfully weird otherworldly novel that will draw you in and not let you go until the last page.
In the Walled city of Aramanth, exams are everything. When Kestrel Hath dares to rebel, the chief examiner humiliates her father and sentences the whole family to the harshest punishment. Desperate to save them K...more
In the Walled city of Aramanth, exams are everything. When Kestrel Hath dares to rebel, the chief examiner humiliates her father and sentences the whole family to the harshest punishment. Desperate to save them K...more
The Wind Singer was a fantastic Fantasy read, offering a compelling new world that doesn't feel overly generic. Starting as a dystopia-utopia novel, the story gradually escalates as the two main protagonists embark on a classic adventure to restore something ancient to their imperfect city. The world itself, while not terribly immersive, is very real and very much alive. Many side characters and side cultures are encountered along the way, each having their own distinct flavour to them that dive...more
It isn't easy to enjoy a story when one essentially agrees with the society against which the protagonists are fighting. I have that problem a lot. Here, more than usual.
That said, The Wind Singer is rather enjoyable for it's weird humor, weirder characters, and engaging mythology, not so much for the worldview it preaches (and, yes, the novel is rather preachy in some respects). I particularly enjoyed the perspective changes, how the book focused on Kestrel, Bowman, and Mumpo for a while, then...more
That said, The Wind Singer is rather enjoyable for it's weird humor, weirder characters, and engaging mythology, not so much for the worldview it preaches (and, yes, the novel is rather preachy in some respects). I particularly enjoyed the perspective changes, how the book focused on Kestrel, Bowman, and Mumpo for a while, then...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fantasy | 7 | 37 | Jun 17, 2013 11:36am | |
| What's The Name o...: Trilogy - telepathic twins [s] | 12 | 126 | Dec 09, 2011 02:09pm |
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.
William Nicholson was born in 1948, and grew up in Sussex and Gloucestershire. His plays for television include Shadowlands and Life Story , both of which won the BAFTA Best Television Drama award in their year; other award-winners were Sweet As You Are and The March . In 1...more
More about William Nicholson...
William Nicholson was born in 1948, and grew up in Sussex and Gloucestershire. His plays for television include Shadowlands and Life Story , both of which won the BAFTA Best Television Drama award in their year; other award-winners were Sweet As You Are and The March . In 1...more
Share This Book
2 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“He accepted what each moment brough him, and never troubled himself with matters that were outside his control.”
—
11 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 6 comments






















