Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Two Georges” as Want to Read:
The Two Georges
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Two Georges

3.55 of 5 stars 3.55  ·  rating details  ·  928 ratings  ·  42 reviews
A precious and historic painting has been stolen by terrorists—radical separatists who will stop at nothing to shatter the union. Colonel Thomas Bushell, the government’s most fearless agent, is the only man who can stop them.

But this is not our world. For the stolen painting depicts a treaty between George Washington and King George III—a treaty that has kept America unde
Paperback, 596 pages
Published November 15th 1997 by Tor Books (first published October 5th 1995)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Two Georges, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Two Georges

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,602)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Ben Babcock
Suppose the United States never gained its independence from Great Britain. Instead, George Washington and King George III forge an alliance that results in the North American Union. Instead of a war that weakens Britain’s grip on North America and contributes to the gradual decline of its world-spanning empire, peace ushers in an era of near-total British domination of North America, Africa, China, and Australia. Only Russia, and the Franco–Spanish “Holy Alliance” can possibly challenge it.

This book failed for one reason, and one reason only: complete crap for writing.

I could never bring myself to "believe in" the world that the authors created, it never felt real to me. The characters were wooden cardboard cutouts of stereotypes, and would break that only to do something monumentally stupid and completely out of character. One character is described as being the expert on the enemy, yet within the first page of his introduction he acts as if he has no clue what he is up against.
May 09, 2013 Rick rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: sci-fi
I enjoyed The Two Georges. It was a little clunky in places but it had good central characters and a decent plot line. It's real strength lay in its ability to create a very believable world, always the main requirement of a good Alternative History novel. The world of The Two Georges is one in which the American war of independence never happened and America is still part of the British Empire and a very important part at that, with the Franco Spanish Alliance pushing at its borders in the Sout ...more
Ugh. I thought this would be such an interesting alternate history concept- America stays a British colony rather than gaining independence- that I was willing to overlook having Dreyfuss as a co-author. Never again. This book felt like it was written to be made into a movie starring (surprise surprise) Richard Dreyfus. The movie, like the book, would fail. Awful. Since we didn't gain independence from the british, everyone... flies in dirigibles instead of airplanes? Drives stream powered cars? ...more
When I saw the name Richard Dreyfuss on the cover on a book in my local library it caught my eye and called me over. Yes, it was in fact the same Hollywood actor we all know (and some love) who apparently co-wrote a book with some guy named Harry Turtledove. OK. I read the back, and WOW! this book sounded interesting. What a concept... It was my first exposure to Alternative History. And Harry Turtledove. I was hooked right from the start. This book was absolutely amazing to me in that here was ...more
MB (What she read)
Interesting plot idea but this book failed (for me) in the execution.

I can buy into the fact that since wars lead to advances in technology, science and etc. then the lack of these wars would retard progress. So I was okay with the idea of traveling around in dirigibles and steam-powered cars. BUT, the premise that people were still wearing victorian-style clothes (dresses to the floor, corsets? cheroots, hats), and still living with that outmoded social style and its stratifications (IN 1996 NO
Excellent book. The setting is North America if peace had been achieved between the Colonies and King George. The plot involves the theft of a painting called The Two Georges, telling of the meeting between Washington and George III, and the officer of the Royal American Mounted Police's actions in tracking down the thieves. It moves all over the country and is able to showcase much of this alternate America. Sir Martin Luther King as Governor General is one of many well placed touches.

Written b
When Charles (III) stepped off the zeppelin, I felt like I did when Doogie Howser stepped back into the end of the film adaptation of Starship Troopers. I have since learned to appreciate both the Prince of Wales and Neil Patric Harris, especially. Oh, the book? Um, interesting take on a different America, but the necessity of contrasts in timelines lead me to distrust the absence of the sexual revolution and other cultural norms, tech regressiveness (steam punk nod?), etc. Still a fun read in a ...more
Nachman Kataczinsky
The idea behind the book is interesting: what if George III wasn’t crazy and the British Parliament of the time was reasonable? What if this leads to George Washington going to London and (with the support of Franklin and the other rebels) signs a Union agreement with Britain?

In the book this leads to a strange world. Not to spoil the fun for potential readers I won’t go into details but I was somewhat irritated by the inconsistencies of this universe. This is not to say that the book is bad. It
Joseph Harris
I really enjoyed this book, the story was exciting, but I disagree with some of the authors assumptions about what the world would be like in the 1990's if the US had never become an independent nation. For instance, I thought the steam powered cars a bit contrived. And I was personally offended by the suggestion that the entire German speaking world was dismissed as a potential world super power.

The technology seemed to be mostly stuck in the 1930's. Television has been invented but hasn't cau
Mary JL
Mar 30, 2009 Mary JL rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: fans of alternate history or fantasy
Recommended to Mary JL by: Found at booksale
Shelves: main-sf-fantasy
This story asks the fascinating questions: What if America had not revolted? What if George III and George washington had made peace with each other?

I like Turtledove's brand of alternate histry and this is o exception. The portrai of the alternate America he desribes I find beleivable and interesting.

The characters are adequtely drawn, but it is the ideas that I find fascinating. It is a bit long but goes really quicly.
Michael Plas
I have read many of Turtledove's works, and this is probably the best. Perhaps it is the presence of Dreyfuss as a co-author, but this is the only one of Turtledove's alternative history novels in which there is only one character's point of view. This alone is a great thing.
What is really remarkable however, is the book's atmosphere. Most of alternative history has an air of the unreal about it, but this book seemed so real. It is even more strange in that so much of it is unreal. The final lin
Okay, here's the thing: alternate history is not usually my bag. It's hard for me to turn off the voice in my head that says "Hey, wait a minute ..."

With that confession out of the way, I have to say that "The Two Georges" was a very entertaining read. It starts off with a murder, and the theft of the titular painting of George Washington and George III. You see, in this world, the American Revolution never really happened, and the United States is the North American Union: a colony of Great Bri
So, what do you get when Oscar Award Winner and a Hugo Award Winner get together?

A pretty good book, actually.

The premise is that the United States was never formed. The British government dealt fairly with the colonies in the 1760s and the independence movement was stillborn. Instead, what are now the USA & Canada is called the North American Union and are an integral part of the United Kingdom. The UK is a vast world-wide empire led by the King-Emperor. This union is symbolized by the pai
A whodunnit, about a missing painting, in an alternate universe where the American Revolution never happened.
Nick Wallace
The premise was mildly interesting, but ultimately a big bowl of ham and fluff.
This novel is an altered history of the United States that never became the United States. Instead of a 1776 revolution, the U.S. is part of the North American Union linked with the British Empire in a globe where other empires still function. It is set in the 1980’s but it might as well be Victorian England—air ships are the fastest way to travel cross-country, steam cars rule the ground, clunky long distance phone calls are the norm, and the policemen mainly use night sticks and not revolvers. ...more
Up to par Turtledove alternate history novel in a world where the North American British colonies and Britain managed to negotiate a peace and didn't split apart. The symbol of this unity, The Two Georges, a painting of King George and George Washington painted by Gainsborough has been stolen, apparently by a militant separatist organization called the Sons of Liberty.

Leading the investigation to recover it is Tom Bushell, a distinguished but near alcoholic officer in the RAMs, essentially the F
David Miles
Loved this. One of the books that got me hooked on alternate histories.

Slow travel across the US on zeppelins and the question "why on earth would you want to fly on one of those new-fangled jet things? When would you get your paperwork done?" Americans wearing flatcaps, twirling their mustaches, and heading home for tea at 5 pm?

What more could you want?
I tried to read this book three separate times and couldn’t bring myself to finish it. I really liked Turtledove’s “Guns of the South”, so I thought I would enjoy this alternative history. I think the difference is that Guns of the South was alternative history as it occurred, and this book was alternative history from two hundred years ago and these are the consequences. I thought the changes Turtledove and Dreyfus envisioned such as the lack of airplanes (air travel via blimps) and lack of int ...more
Tome Addiction
Just not sure about this book, the Steam Punk imagery that it invokes and conceptual story sounded entertaining but after the first 70 pages of descriptive detail and characters, I am moving on to another book for now. I may give it another 70 pages or so but if after that I can't get into it off to the used book store pile it goes. "Life is too short to read bad books". Attempted 03/08/15.

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Tyler Harris
I enjoyed this quite a lot. I'm a sucker for counterfactual fiction, and Turttledove does a great job here, even with that guy from Jaws in tow.
Not a book I'd recommend to alternate history fans. It wasn't awful -- I read it all the way through -- but it was needlessly long, and overly amused by itself: Hey look, a fat old Kennedy! Ohmigosh, this alternative-history-equivilent novel, in which the colonies separated from Britain - what rubbish! There's a super-obvious romance, and a plot-twist villian. Both were mildly entertaining but stuffed in between way-too-long descriptions of the British food people were eating, the steam-punk (ai ...more
Peter Boyall
Okay, albeit with some strange quirks. Certain an interesting imagination.
One of my all time favorite Turtledove books.
What if the American Revolution was peacefully avoided? The stripes and the Union Jack fly in the capital city of Victoria. There was no war of 1812, no war between the states, slavery abolished in 1809 by order of the king, and the westward expansion moved at a more gradual pace, respecting Native American tribes. Now a terrorist group calling themselves "The Sons of Liberty" wants the British out, and will do whatever it takes to achieve that goal.
Just what I hoped it would be.
I have been waiting to read this book for 5 years.
Searching until finally it arrived as a gift.
Thank you, Paula.
What a great gift it is.

I stopped looking for comparisons to our own America very early and just went along for the ride.
What a great Tale.

Try this one if you really enjoy “What Ifs”

Oh, wait..
There are a few fun historical drop ins.
You’ll see.
This was a fairly good book, but not up to Turtledove's very high standard. I associate that with having collaborated with someone, vice writing it all on his own. An interesting book of an investigation to find a stolen painting that is key to a British/US treaty that saw the US turn out quite differently than history. However, if you like historical fiction, you will like this book.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 53 54 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Ruled Britannia
  • The Peshawar Lancers
  • 1812: The Rivers of War (Trail of Glory, #1)
  • 1945
  • Roads Not Taken: Tales of Alternate History
  • For Want of a Nail: If Burgoyne had won at Saratoga
  • Stars and Stripes Forever (Stars and Stripes, #1)
  • Resurrection Day
  • The Way It Wasn't: Great Science Fiction Stories of Alternate History (Citadel Twilight)
  • Back in the USSA
  • Lord Darcy Investigates (Lord Darcy, #3)
Richard Stephen Dreyfuss is an Academy Award-winning American actor.

Dreyfuss has dabbled with writing, notably teaming up with Harry Turtledove in 1995 to write The Two Georges, a conspiracy thriller set in an alternate reality in which the American colonies remained under British rule.

More about Richard Dreyfuss...
The Two Georges: A Novel of an Alternate America The Word of Promise Complete Audio Bible: NKJV In the Company of Legends Glengarry Glen Ross The Lincoln-Douglas Debates

Share This Book

“Víte," poznamenal Bushell, když zastavili na semaforu před křižovatkou, "že na vzducholodi se jeden cestující při večeři chlubil, že má doma svůj vlastní televizor?"
Jeho přítel se k němu nevěřícně otočil. "To si děláte legraci, ne?" (...) "K čemu by si někdo takovou věc pořizoval domů?" (...) "Rádio je něco docela jiného, při tom se dá povídat, číst... Ale televizor... Ten přece něco ukazuje a člověk se na to prostě musí dívat! Co když máte hosty? O něčem tak... tak vulgárním jsem snad ještě neslyšel!”
More quotes…