Tried by War : Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief

by James M. McPherson
Tried by War : Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief
book data
129 ratings, 3.88 average rating, 63 reviews (more data...)
edit

published
October 7th 2008 by The Penguin Press

binding
Hardcover, 352 pages

characters

setting
The United States

isbn
1594201919    (isbn13: 9781594201912)

description
James McPherson, a bestselling historian of the Civil War, illuminates how Lincoln worked with -and often against - his senior commanders to defeat th...more




Sign in to Goodreads to see your friends' reviews of this book.


topics  posts  views  last activity   
College Students! : * Summer Challenge--Official Record of Points 36 263 10 days ago, 12:58AM  
Our History: BIOGRAPHIES 27 67 03/22/2009 06:33AM  
The Next Best Boo...: OFFICIAL WINTER CHALLENGE - 2008/2009 2174 3162 03/04/2009 07:03AM  

friend reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

other reviews (showing 1-20 of 293)

sort: default (?) | date
filters: all | text-only


Robert
02/16/09
Robert added it

Read in February, 2009
Enjoyed this more than I thought I might. I've always been interested in Lincoln - even before the recent Obama related surge - but never been much of a Civil War buff. The book gave a great chronological sketch of the various leadership styles and strengths not just of Lincoln but other important players. Discussions include McLellan, Grant, Lee and other well know historical generals and other principals. Highly recommended for those intersted in seeing the various sides of Lincoln i.e. no...more
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Michael
01/08/09
Michael rated it: 5 of 5 stars

Mr McPherson has presented a very different view of the genius that was Lincoln. Now known for his emancipation proclaimation, Lincoln did not advance freeing the slaves as his first priority during his administration. Instead, his driving ambition was union, and he was willing to fight to save the Union.

As the civil war progressed, the President and the Union Army suffered several discouraging losses and in fact were near defeat in 1862-3. As a military tactic, Lincoln first declare...more
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Stephanie
01/16/09
Stephanie rated it: 3 of 5 stars

Read in January, 2009
This book was a little bit difficult to get through at times, but I learned a ton. I felt like I was in a history class again in college. Unlike many other Lincoln books, this book focuses solely on his Civil Wars years. I had no idea that he almost wasn't reelected in 1864 or had to read books about military strategy so that he could help his generals fight a better war. Lincoln had to fire so many generals before he finally stopped with General Grant with less than a year left in the war. ...more
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment

Scott Rogers
12/04/08
Scott Rogers rated it: 3 of 5 stars

bookshelves: nonfiction
Read in October, 2008
Disappointing; the book offers far too much linear, chronological narrative, and far too little thematic analysis of Lincoln's performance, his decisionmaking, and his evolution as a wartime commander-in-chief. This is an adequate work of introductory popular history, but there is little here of any value to anyone who is even glancingly familiar with Lincoln's presidency or the conduct of the Union war effort.

On the plus side, the book does offer a surprisingly sympathetic, though ...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Steven Peterson
06/18/09
Steven Peterson rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in November, 2008
This book, well written, is authored by the eminent historian James McPherson. The focus is plainly stated at the outset (Page xiv): "In the vast literature on our sixteenth president, however, the amount of attention devoted to his role as commander in chief is disproportionately smaller than the actual percentage of time he spent on that task."

Lincoln's own military experience was slender, his 1832 service in the militia. However, as McPherson puts it (Page 5), he was "...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Donna
02/28/09
Donna rated it: 4 of 5 stars

bookshelves: biography-lincoln
Read in March, 2009
recommends it for: Lincoln and Civil War buffs
The focus of this Lincoln book is Lincoln as Commander-in-Chief. Up until 1861 the president had not fully claimed this role. In fact, other than giving the president this title, the Constitution does not clearly state what the powers of Commander-in-Chief are. Lincoln fully used this title to allow him to take actions in the "insurrection" that were extra-Constitutional as well as accomplish things that he could not do politically. The Emancipation Proclamation was issued under hi...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Mark
12/17/08
Mark rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in December, 2008
[Audiobook recording from my public library.]

Like the previous Lincoln book I read (about Lincoln's use of the telegraph as near-instant communication to project his leadership and collect information), this one sets out a focused objective . . . then loses its way in a more general telling of the events of the American Civil War. In this case, however, the author does a better job coming back to his central point, and I think it mostly holds up. Not only was Lincoln thrust into an i...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Bookmarks Magazine
01/08/09
Bookmarks Magazine rated it: 5 of 5 stars

Reviewers indicated that they would have embraced any new book by James McPherson on any aspect of the Civil War period. But current events likely compelled them to recommend this highly readable, informative book with special enthusiasm. The nature of the president’s war powers, particularly the precedent set by Lincoln’s suspension of habeas corpus, has been a central question of the Bush presidency. And as the highest office in the land is passed to Barack Obama, who is both a great admirer o...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Jon
11/05/08
Jon rated it: 5 of 5 stars

Read in November, 2008
Like John Lewis Gaddis with the Cold War, James McPherson is more or less the Civil War historian. I picked this up the morning after Obama was elected, figuring it would be at least as relevant as Team of Rivals to understanding some of the historical parallels between Obama's and Lincoln's inaugurations. Even though Lincoln obviously faced much greater challenges upon assuming the presidency, it's hard to imagine any president (maybe except FDR) who's faced as much coming in since Lincoln in 1...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Renay
12/27/08
Renay rated it: 5 of 5 stars

Read in December, 2008
Interesting look at Lincoln. The generals leading the Union forces were truly incapable of aggressively pursuing the war. I can't help but wonder how the war would have gone had the Union generals aggressively pursued the Confederate forces from the start, or even listen to Lincoln's "suggestions" for a war plan. It was amazing to see how Lincoln's leadership during the war and strategy evolved. Gradually moving from a war to keep the Union together to a war to end slavery was inte...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Janis
02/28/09
Janis rated it: 3 of 5 stars

Read in February, 2009
McPherson's offering on Lincoln as commander in chief is thorough and sound but, as someone who has read quite a lot about Lincoln, I found myself wanting more. Especially during the early chapters, I felt that much of this ground had been covered before, and wished instead that the author had focused on a more analytical approach. I thought Perret's 2004 book, Lincoln's War, a more interesting take on Lincoln's (amazing) abilities as commander in chief. McPherson is a great scholar and writer,...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Drew
04/26/09
Drew rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in April, 2009
I've read quite a few books on the Civil War and Lincoln and this was definitely worth the read. This book focuses solely on Lincoln's management of the Civil War. In reality, Lincoln acted not only as President, but also as his own Joint Chiefs of Staff. In addition, the book did a great job of showing how tenuous Lincoln's support for the war was both within the military (McClellan in particular) and the Copperhead Democrats, who wanted to sue for peace. The parallels between War on Terr...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

William
02/05/09
William rated it: 3 of 5 stars

bookshelves: 2009
For those interested in anything associated with Lincoln, this book will not disappoint; it demonstrates once again Lincoln's courage, humility, and wisdom. Much of the text is citation from letters, telegraphs, speeches, memoirs, etc. of Lincoln and his contemporaries. Especially compelling are the exchanges between Lincoln and his often unsuccessful generals during the darkest days of the Civil War. The details may prove tedious, though, for readers who are not already somewhat familiar with t...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Paul
02/19/09
Paul rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in June, 2009
General readers should know up front that this is NOT a general history of The Civil War or Abraham Lincoln. For that purpose, I would strongly recommend McPherson's "Battle Cry of Freedom" for the former and David Herbert Donald's "Lincoln" for the latter.

That aside, McPherson ranks at the very top of Civil War historians, and, along with the late Shelby Foote, the best writer for the general reader. Over the years, he has written a series of short, targeted boo...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Joe
01/18/09
Joe added it

As we are about to elect a new president who greatly admires Abraham Lincoln, Barak Obama will inherit upon his inauguration, the mantle of commander in chief. Yet Lincoln was not much of a soldier. This book is written about the Civil War of the United States, but it's meaning goes far beyond the 1860's and touches modern day. Like Lincoln, our new president will have to deal with a divisive war, an unpopular war, a war not supported by the majority of the people at least in it's infancy. McPhe...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Dadda
11/13/08
Dadda rated it: 5 of 5 stars

Read in February, 2009
I have just finished this book about Abraham Lincoln as Commander-in-chief of the Union armys during the Civil War. The last book I read about Lincoln was A Team of Rivals, which I thought was GREAT, which dealt somewhat with the war and how President Lincoln dealt with all the issues of the war but mostly his cabinet. This book, however, focuses its attention on the role President Lincoln played as hostilities and rebellion occured in the Souther States. First he studied books on military ta...more
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Dan
05/04/09
Dan rated it: 4 of 5 stars

bookshelves: already-read
Solid book that focuses particularly on Lincoln's role as commander-in-chief - and does a good job of explaining how Lincoln had to invent the job as it went along and how he set our modern-day-conception of what a Commander-in-Chief is.

Only negative I would say is that if you've read many other Lincoln bios or Civil War histories (as I have), this won't add a ton of new info - it just focuses on this one angle.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Jean
03/05/09
Jean rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in March, 2009
Probably the most detailed description of Abraham Lincoln's role as commander in chief during the War Between the States that I have ever read. The Union Army was really mismanaged and blundered militarily many times before they finally got a grasp. Thank goodness for Lincoln's vision and understanding of the situations. Lincoln has been and continues to be an inspired hero to me.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Bruce
01/06/09
Bruce rated it: 4 of 5 stars

bookshelves: 2009-reading, history
Read in January, 2009
Extremely well written. Focused on Lincoln's role as the only US President whose entire presidency was encompassed within a war. McPherson argues that much of what we now call the Presidential war powers were taken on for the first time by Lincoln, as a result of the weakness of so many of his generals, and the need for executive leadership in the prosecution of the civil war.
Like this review?   yes  
  add a comment

Keri (kerip)
06/24/09
Keri (kerip) rated it: 4 of 5 stars

Read in June, 2009
My husband Jeremy picked this book for me. I learned a ton about the Civil War and particularly Lincoln's role as commander in chief. McPherson's writing style is very easy to read for those of us who aren't historians. His ideas were clear and concise, and I often found myself saying, "Hey, I didn't know that!" I'm sure Jeremy will be excited that I have more of a base knowledge about his field.

SBC - book your DH picked for you
Like this review?   yes   (1 person liked it)
  add a comment


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 14 15


recent status updates | recommend it | blog it

Tried by War: Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief (Audio CD)
Tried by War: Abraham Lincoln As Commander in Chief (Thorndike Press Large Print Nonfiction Series)
Tried By War - Abraham Lincoln as Commander in Chief







groups with this book

The American Civil War
Presidential Reads






Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era (Oxford History of the... by James M. McPherson
For Cause and Comrades: Why Men Fought in the Civil War (Paperba... by James M. McPherson
Crossroads of Freedom: Antietam (Pivotal Moments in American His... by James M. McPherson
Ordeal By Fire: The Civil War and Reconstruction (Paperback) by James M. McPherson
Hallowed Ground: A Walk at Gettysburg (Crown Journeys) by James M. McPherson

More…