Emotionally Weird

Emotionally Weird

3.41 of 5 stars 3.41  ·  rating details  ·  2,436 ratings  ·  245 reviews
Ahilarious and utterly original novel about mothers, daughters, and love, by the author of Life After Life.

On a weather-beaten island off the coast of Scotland, Effie and her mother, Nora, take refuge in the large, mouldering house of their ancestors and tell each other stories. Nora, at first, recounts nothing that Effie really wants to hear--like who her real father was....more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published July 6th 2001 by Picador (first published June 27th 2000)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcí­a MárquezThe Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey NiffeneggerThe Alchemist by Paulo CoelhoLike Water for Chocolate by Laura EsquivelThe House of the Spirits by Isabel Allende
Favorite Magical Realist Novels
229th out of 683 books — 2,745 voters
The Last Sunset by Bob AtkinsonOutlander by Diana GabaldonMacbeth by William ShakespeareThe Winter Sea by Susanna KearsleyDragonfly in Amber by Diana Gabaldon
Books Set in Scotland
35th out of 276 books — 178 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Greg
Can you see the cover of Emotionally Weird that I read? I don't know, but if it's a peach colored cover with a sort of crappy drawing of a redheaded woman smoking and a dog then you are seeing it? Or maybe you are seeing the new cover, which is dark and fits with the covers of Kate Atkinson's later novels? Or maybe you see the British covers with the big and dopey but cute looking dog on the cover? I read the peach colored one, with the girly script. The one that screams early to mid-ought chick...more
daysgoby
My father used to write for a student's journal in college back in the sixties. Students would send in short stories full of twisty, tormented characters who wore black and smoked a lot, their general air of dejection and resolution that the world was ending soon the most striking thing about them. This book (and also the other Atkinson I picked up, One Good Turn) were populated with such characters - people who didn't give a damn anymore and just wanted help getting through the night.

I didn't l...more
Laura
I'm about 2/3 of the way through and I have guffawed and giggled hysterically more while reading this than I have in the past five years altogether. I've HAD to read passages out loud to my poor husband when all he wanted to do was sleep or check his emails. My dog and cat wonder what the heck is causing my bizarre behavior, as I've been hitherto a calmish person. I sure hope Atkinson can bring this to a good conclusion, but even if she can't, I'll be grateful for what she's done so far. Review...more
Jessica
In this clever and humorous novel, Kate Atkinson deploys various post-modern novel techniques (bickering narrators, meta-discussion of the story being told, malleable text, and various novels-within-novels set out in varied--and clever--typefaces) to skewer the academy and its fascination with, well, the post-modern novel.

Effie and her mother (or, rather, "mother") Nora are on a desolate, ruined Scottish island telling their life stories, while Effie's story of university life in 1972--complete...more
Trin
Emotionally Weird fullfilled the promise of Behind the Scenes at the Museum much better than Human Croquet did. As usual, Atkinson has a unique touch, and this story, much of which revolves around a bunch of college students in a creative writing class, seems tailor-made for English major-me. I adore the excerpts from the various students' works-in-progress; delivered by a lesser writer, they would seem clichéd, but in Atkinson's hand, each one is wonderfully awful and hilarious.

I bought my co...more
Kirsty Darbyshire

I really enjoyed Behind the Scenes at the Museum for its twisted up story and uncertain narration but I could never get into Atkinson's second book Human Croquet, I must try again. I picked up this book in the book shop in two minds about whether to try it and it grabbed me instantly and I've really enjoyed reading it.

As in Museum I was never quite sure where this story was going or what the main storyline was but the writing pulled me in and carried me along on a tide of interesting happenings

...more
Joe
At times the epithet “clever” is used to belittle a novel’s worth. Certainly not in this case, for Atkinson’s cleverness plays an intricate role in Emotionally Weird’s theme of “just what is fiction.” A student in a class I taught commented after reading this book that the novel was having a dialogue with itself. That is perfectly correct. Everything--from the narrator Effie’s paper on Henry James’s assessment of Middlemarch as forsaking plot, to Nora’s urgent comments to hurry the plot along, t...more
Kathleen
Kate Atkinson was recommended to me. At the library I picked up the only book by the author, Emotionally Weird. It was a weird book. From amazon:

A thoroughly original and hilarious novel about mothers, daughters, and love, by the author of Behind the Scenes at the Museum.

On a weather-beaten island off the coast of Scotland, Effie and her mother, Nora, take refuge in the large, mouldering house of their ancestors and tell each other stories. Nora, at first, recounts nothing that Effie really want...more
Erin
Emotionally Weird is... weird.

In the beginning, I was drawn in by the complexity of the stories and the narrators telling them. Things were interesting and progressed steadily enough so that before I knew it I had reached the middle of the story. At that point, if you count the stories being told by Effie's classmates, I think there were about seven plots going at once. I was lost, and I'm pretty sure my brain nearly exploded, but I continued on, having already invested so much in the story.

And...more
Sibyl
I was disappointed and it was an effort to get through to the end.

Although Kate Atkinson is rarely dull, this novel is meandering and comes perilously close to being self-indulgent.

It's as if the writer is having so much fun recalling her own time as an English student, satirising her would-be-radical classmates and dysfunctional lecturers, that she loses sight of the fact that this territory has been thoroughly covered by other novelists. (It's like a post-modernist take on David Lodge.) Despit...more
Karen maslen
The latest magical mystery tour de force from one of Britain’s most original novelists – winner of the Whitbread First Novel Award for Behind the Scenes at the Museum.

On a peat and heather island off the West Coast of Scotland, Effie and her mother, Nora, take refuge in the large mouldering house of their ancestors and tell each other stories. Nora, at first, recounts nothing that Effie really wants to hear, such as the identity of her real father – variously Jimmy, Jack, or Ernie. Effie tells o...more
Nancy
This is the last of my reviews in my mad dash to read all the pre-Jackson Brodie books and, of them all, I think I enjoyed this one the most, at least if my repeated snorts of amusement were anything to go by. Descriptions, turns or phrase and character comments, deftly and sharply written, and downright amusing.

The story has the disturbing elements present in her other books, but they were revealed later in the book and they were more third-person descriptions which made for a more indirect imp...more
Derek Baldwin
This might be an entertaining spoof of postmodernism, but then again maybe not. Great fun to read. While the criss-crossing narratives could be a little tricky to keep track of at times, they all knitted together in the end. As the novel reached its denouement the reliability of the narrators completely fell apart, events were rewritten/deleted, burning a page of text meant that the events described were reversed... oh it all got very silly. But then the threads came back together again. I enjoy...more
Josh Ang
What a waste of her incredible talent! Atkinson's wry humor and ascerbic descriptions were perfect for the collection of short stories 'Not the End of the World' as well as comic-detective fiction novel 'One Good Turn'.

However, 'Emotionally Weird' becomes a tangled self-conscious mess as Atkinson tries to weave those elements in with the use of the frame narrative technique and an unreliable narrator, Effie. The interlocutions between her and her mother, Nora, sometimes jar, rather than add to...more
Marcia
I found this a delightful book. It was so much fun to read! The story is one of a mother and daughter who take refuge on an island off the coast of Scotland. The daughter, Effie, was born on the island but taken away as a newborn and has never been back. Her mother, Nora, has also not been back since Effie's birth. While on the island, Effie tells about her life in college. Nora complains how many characters are in Effie's stories. And, there are tons of them. Yet, I would not want to eliminate...more
Adam
Note to self: if I have found an author who instantly becomes one of my favorite detective novelists (in her Jackson Brodie series (almost just wrote Jackson Browne, which is just downright stupid), a character that I expected to be a detective in the Robert Parker's Spenser mold but actually is much more of a sympathetic character (exchange Spenser's love of food and women with Brodie's love-from-a-distance relationship with his daughter and a constant ability/failure to get tangled in the live...more
Karen
Well this is the weirdest book I have read so far this year. Even thinking about trying to describe the plot has me scratching my head and thinking where on Earth can I begin?

Effie, our lead character, is staying with her "mother" Nora on a tiny Scottish island in their inherited (but rapidly decaying) family holiday home and they tell each other stories of their life to pass the time. Effie's focuses on her life as a student at the University of Dundee. Nora slowly reveals the secret of Effie's...more
marg
This novel had a lot of four star moments, but many two star as well, so I rest at three.
It was in many ways the best and worst of Atkinson's style - once again you are on some sort of magical realism journey, and because she is so talented at weaving a hillarious narrative I just went along with it, which is something that amazes me about her because few authors can get me to do that.
That being said, it was an extreme example of her plotlessness, and all the more so because the overall premise...more
Teresa
Although Kate Atkinson is probably best known for her excellent crime novels about former police detective Jackson Brodie, I think I prefer her non-crime novels. It’s a tough comparison for me to make because I’ve listened to three of her crime novels and read two of her non-crime books in print, so the experience is different. But at this point, probably because I’ve just come off the sheer joy of reading it, Emotionally Weird is my favorite.

Effie, the first-person narrator of Emotionally Weird...more
David
Before Kate Atkinson wrote her four highly acclaimed Jackson Brodie novels, she wrote Emotionally Weird. Whilst this book is mainly narrated by Effie (she is marooned on an isolated Scottish island and is telling her "mother, who isn't her mother" a story about her time as a student in Dundee) there is one character who is a private detective. As the strange Professor Cousins remarks "There once was a Private Dick/Who went by the name of Chick". So here is the typical and irresistible mix of hum...more
Ruthiella
“But don’t you think, Archie”, Professor Cousins said mildly, that really all literature is about the search for identity?”. I didn’t enjoy this as much as I have Atkinson’s other books. Emotionally Weird is a meta-fiction mix of genres: a story, within a story, within a story; a satirical farce, a detective story, gothic mystery and a quest for identity, peppered with lots of Scottish dialect, UK pop cultural references and odd goings on. The book centers on Effie, who in an effort to coax the...more
Shay
Weird is about right. I was a student in the 70s, and really enjoyed some of the topical references - caramac bars and lifeboats stickers come to mind. (I was blissfully unaware of a drug scene though.) It is really about everyone having a story, and two main stories are being unfolded. I agree with Nora, there are too many people in the main character's story. I was also very disorientated by some plot reversals - I have not known this in a book before, and, while I can see it is clever, I don'...more
Jen
Part comic novel, part crime novel, part troubled family past and ALL meta-storytelling. Effie, our heroine, is stranded in the middle of a raging storm on a remote Scottish isle with the person she has always believed was her mother. Each of them tell their own stories, with Effie doing the majority of the storytelling, both about her recent experiences at university and the crime novel she's writing for her creative writing class. Nora's story, while much shorter in words, is really the crux o...more
meliss
Kate Atkinson has a great knack for writing characters that can make you laugh out loud. This one is a great adventure of the ordinary. It explores the relationship and history of a quirky young woman and her mother while doing a scathing job poking fun at literary analysis and "real" writing. Lighter content than Behind the Scenes at the Museum, but well worth the read.
Gail Goetschius


Emotionally Weird was a really fun book. I have read and enjoyed Kate Atkinson's Jackson Brodie series and was delighted by her sense of humor in this spoof. Efie, the main character, and I were both 21 year old English majors in 1972 and I'm sure that added to my enjoyment . Her spot on descriptions of campus radicals, self impressed academics, and eccentric classmates were very funny. While the characters were stock (the Trekie, the druggies, the hard nosed feminists, the earth mother, religi...more
Crossfinn
This novel is so "out there" that halfway through I began wondering in a paranoid fashion whether Atkinson was going to appear from behind the text and say "Are you still reading this?" It's mainly (apparently?) about a group of students and faculty in the English program at the University of Dundee, who careen around randomly like pinballs and expend a great deal of energy doing virtually nothing...but that's just the beginning. The main story is being narrated by a young woman to her mother; t...more
Lori Brack
I think it's more of a 3 and a half, but whole stars are all on offer here.

I am a devotee of Kate Atkinson and even though it's Ides of March-y, I have just finished reading Emotionally Weird. It is neither. And I'm not sure as some other reviewers are that one of the multiple stories is true, or being told, or being written. I read it as parallel, simultaneous, and fantastic all at once.

This is a novel about novels, about fiction, and about life and fiction and the strongest thing I can say tod...more
Mary-Beth
What isn't there to love about Kate Atkinson?

Devotees of my reviews will know that Kate Atkinson is one of my favorite authors; her mystery novels beginning with "Case Histories" are extremely well-written. While I had read some of her previous novels (including "Behind the Scenes at the Museum"), I hadn't read this creatively told novel of a 20ish year old university student in Scotland. She's foundering at school and in her personal life (her live-in boyfriend is a loser), and trying to figure...more
Femke
Effie Andrews vertelt een langdradig levensverhaal zonder boeiende gebeurtenissen aan haar wereldvreemde moeder Nora. Het boek is een aaneenschakeling van absurde flarden tekst, afwisselend uit het leven van Effie, dat van haar moeder en stukken uit Effie's misdaadroman "Het noodlot slaat toe". Tientallen personages worden kort en oppervlakkig toegelicht, sommigen worden in het laatste hoofdstuk gebruikt om tot een absurd en zogezegd onthullend einde te komen. Dikwijls leek de nadruk vooral te l...more
elizabeth
Apr 02, 2007 elizabeth rated it 5 of 5 stars Recommends it for: eternal students
My favorite book by one of my favorite authors. I want Professor Cousins to be my grandad and take me kite-flying. Brings back fond memories of Scotland and crime solving. Okay maybe just Scotland.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Emotionally Weird (Paperback)
Emotionally Weird (Paperback)
Emotionally Weird (Hardcover)
Emotionally Weird (Hardcover)
Estranhas emoções (Paperback)

10015
Kate Atkinson was born in York and now lives in Edinburgh. Her first novel, Behind the Scenes at the Museum, won the Whitbread Book of the Year Award and has been a critically acclaimed international bestselling author ever since.

She is the author of a collection of short stories, Not the End of the World, and of the critically acclaimed novels Human Croquet, Emotionally Weird, Case Histories, and...more
More about Kate Atkinson...
Case Histories (Jackson Brodie, #1) When Will There Be Good News? (Jackson Brodie, #3) Behind the Scenes at the Museum One Good Turn (Jackson Brodie, #2) Started Early, Took My Dog (Jackson Brodie, #4)

Share This Book

Your website
“I can't help but think that it's an unfortunate custom to name children after people who come to sticky ends. Even if they are fictional characters, it doesn't bode well for the poor things. There are too many Judes and Tesses and Clarissas and Cordelias around. If we must name our children after literary figures then we should search out happy ones, although it's true they are much harder to find.” 9 people liked it
“Some people spend their whole lives looking for themselves, yet our self is the one thing we surely cannot lose (how like a cheap philosopher I am become, staying in this benighted place). From the moment we are conceived it is the pattern in our blood and our bones are printed through with it like sticks of seaside rock. Nora, on the other hand, says that she’s surprised anyone knows who they are, considering that every cell and molecule in our bodies has been replaced many times over since we were born.” 6 people liked it
More quotes…