Boy in the Water
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Boy in the Water

3.33 of 5 stars 3.33  ·  rating details  ·  375 ratings  ·  36 reviews

A masterful psychological thriller, from the author of The Church of Dead Girls.

Another bucolic fall in northern New Hampshire, and the semester is under way at Bishop's Hill Academy. But this year the start of school has been less than tranquil. The new headmaster, Jim Hawthorne, has liberal ideas that the staff find far from welcome. He's also determined to do something
Mass Market Paperback, 448 pages
Published July 15th 2000 by St. Martin's Paperbacks (first published 1998)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 643)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Jonathan Briggs
If this were a just world, Stephen Dobyns' "The Church of Dead Girls" would enjoy the critical and popular acclaim accorded to "The Silence of the Lambs," while "Lambs" would be a moderately successful potboiler that reaped modest rewards for the moderately talented Thomas Harris. If you like the psychological thrillers, you need to get to "Church." Unfortunately, Dobyns' followup, "Boy in the Water," isn't nearly as accomplished or skillful. We get off to a grand start: a dead boy floating face...more
Scooby-Dooby-Doo, Where Are You? We got some work to do now. Oh wait, you mean this isn’t a new episode about that meddling gang from Mystery, Inc and their dog? Well damn, I must have been absent the day that memo was handed out because what we have here kiddies is a true-blue suspense story that must have leaked out from the cartoon network. Crazy, supernatural pranks – check. Murder mystery that unravels as the characters literally stumble upon clues –check. Players that have absolutely no co...more
David Feela
I was intrigued, at first. As a former school teacher myself, I could feel that Dobyns has his finger on the pulse of a school,-- in this case, a private one, but not so far-fetched from the politics and antics of most. And the mystery is both haunting and scary, at first. But (yes, the inevitable but) as the mystery develops, bit by bit, I get the sense that the new headmaster, Hawthorne, lacks the sense to understand his own psychological issues. What's worse, he's a famous psychologist. He be...more
Thriller that takes place at a prep school for troubled children. Too much focus on developing certain characters and not enough on others. Interesting, but was able to figure it out midway through the book.
Dobyns does a good job of setting up your anxious anticipation and characters that appear simply black and white, but have another dimension, if probed. I had actually read this before but still couldn't remember quite who was involved in what and that there were several "whats" going on. In our mystery discussion group, several people felt that the new headmaster was dense and a poor psychologist, but who expects to be dropped in such a toxic environment? And who could clean it up in 12 weeks,...more
I didn't like this book and couldn't finish it.
John Porter
Well written, but oddly uninvolving.
Poor Dobyns - on the back of my edition, Time Out is quoted...."Stephen King with a PhD. Knowing I am a fan of SK, this book was suggested to me and I looked forward to a stonking good read. I can only think that the Time Out reviewer has never read a Stephen King book, or he would know that whilst Dobyns seems to be a competent thriller writer, he doesn't, on this showing, have the skills in characterisation and mood building, of narrative drive and suspense building, that SK can wield before b...more
Siamo nel New Hampshire, alla Bishop's Hill Academy, una scuola che ha avuto tempi migliori e ora è diventata l'ultima spiaggia per tutti quei ragazzi ormai banditi dalla maggior parte delle altre scuole.
Jim Hawthorne, un famoso psicologo, è stato assunto per tentare di rimetterla in sesto. Per la scuola lui è l'ultimo tentativo prima di arrendersi al fallimento, per lui la scuola è una nuova sfida per dimenticare il terribile incendio doloso nel quale sono morte qualche anno prima sua moglie e...more
Neither drama nor thriller in the end, "Boy in the Water" stays indistinct and slurred throughout its whole, nor does it ever turn really good I must sadly say.
The plot dribbles almost insignificantly to its climax to send you home with an epilogue that suddenly tries to squeeze a deeper meaning in, I just wish the story itself had presented that deeper meaning. Where was the wit, the suspense, the atmosphere and the ambiguity of "Church of Dead Girls"? If I wouldn't have known I would have swor...more
Linda  Branham Greenwell
I really liked Dobyns other 2 books that I read - but I had a difficult time with this one.
Hawthorne takes a job as head of a private school with mostly children who have problems. Hawthorne's wife and daughter died several years previously in a tragic fire - and he is trying to start a new life.
The teachers at the school want things to stay the same - and Hawthorne is making changes...changes they don't like. Anonymous notes against Hawthorne begin appearing in the teachers mailboxes... someon...more
I just finished this haunting tale which takes place at a boarding school in Northern New England. Dobyns must have been a teacher at some point and likely one at a boarding school or a small independent school. He captures the close knit community remarkably well. Except for the truly darkest parts of this novel, you can imagine this story taking place at any small independent school where the faculty has been allowed to indulge for far too long and where outsiders are immediately mistrusted an...more
A satisfactory psychological thriller. The new headmaster doesn't know who to trust. Plenty of bad guys to choose from for the villains. I recently reread The Shining and the final scenes in this book are reminiscent of King's book: snowbound with possible help on the way over unplowed roads.
Mystery/thriller set in an isolated boarding school in the New Hampshire forest. The setting lends itself to creepiness and criminal activity, especially with the staff of hostile and homicidal staff that work at the school. Enter Dr. Hawthorne, the new Headmaster, a well-meaning, clueless but ultimately heroic man burdened with guilt and grief after the deaths of his wife and daughter in a fire. The most interesting character is the bad guy, which is not that unusual for this type of book. If I...more
Marie Ashurst
I really enjoyed this book, it should actually have 7/10. The only thing that let it down was the ending. The vast majority of the book was really interesting interweaving stories about some troubled children, an educator with a tortured past, and a criminal, all brought together at a remote New England boarding school. Unfortunately the last 50 pages turned into a not-very-thrilling pursuit. Definitely not as good as The Church of Dead Girls, but I still can't wait to read some more of Dobbins....more
I think Dobyns is an extremely accomplished writer. I have read two of his books, 'The Church of Dead Girls' and this book. Both of his books have a really artistic way of expressing the complexity of identity. This book successfully acts as a page turner, but also poses the question, 'Are people inherently all bad?'. His portrayal of the 'bad guy' is very interesting because he is not portrayed as timelessly evil, and in some respects, we can understand him.
Lisa Barton
Total disappointment. I LOVED Church of Dead Girls and expected Boy in the Water to be just as creepy and intense. Instead, it was plodding and lethargic. The characters were all very uninteresting, especially the main guy who was way too self-loathing and sorry for himself to identify with. Also, the climax was very anti-climactic. This novel was more akin to Dean Koontz fare — kind of cheesy and predictable.
I LOVED this book. And to think I almost didn't read it because of the negative reader reviews on this site. Just goes to show ya... While BITW is certainly was not without flaws, it is a thoroughly engrossing novel in which I had a lot of fun immersing myself on some cold, wintry nights. Dobyns' writing, while not perfect, put a delicious chill in my bones.
Interesting book in that it was a page turner for me almost in spite of itself - you know who one of the bad guys is from about page 5 and I saw the other bad guy coming pretty easily. I wanted to shake the main character through most of the book. But somehow there was something in the writing that still interested me. I will try something else by this author.
Marjorie Kubacki
One of the best American Mysteries I have ever read. Dobyns slowly introduces the characters and the mystery is slowly unravels.
Academic Doctor, who's wife and child were killed by a disturbed patient, takes a position at a boarding school for troubled children. Unfortunately, the staff at this boarding school are also troubled.

Murders, mystery, and intrigue throughout the book, ending leaves a lot
of unanswered questions.
Once the character introductions are made and the story begins, this is a great book. Some of the teachers in the boarding school become more selfish or greedy as time goes by and care less and less about the welfare of the students. This leads to deceit, fraud, and eventually, murder. Very climactic ending!
Das Buch ist kein wirkliches Highlight. Die Personen in dem Buch haben alle ihr Päckchen zu tragen. Es wird jedoch zuviel Zeit damit verschwindet, ihr Seelenleben zu durchleuchten. Interessant? Ja! Spannend? Für einen Krimi zu wenig! An manchen Stellen ist die Geschichte etwas langgezogen.
Creepy boarding school, New Hampshire snowbound, unpleasant people making the decent headmaster's life miserable. Ambience is delivered, but the plot is not the equal of THE CHURCH OF DEAD GIRLS, a great thriller by the same author.
was in the mood for a good thriller and this time Dobyns did it for me; Liked it much better than Church of Dead Girls. Still felt that some loose ends were not all tied up in the end, but all in all a good read.
I read this after reading The Church of Dead Girls and was thrilled to find that it was almost as good. A page turner that kept me up way too late each night because I just couldn't put it down.
Wendy Kobylarz-Chouvarda
I read this a while ago and don't remember much, except after reading the Church of Dead Girls, this one was an extreme disappointment. I sent it to a used book store.
When on the cover it says 'very, very spooky' I really think they are talking about a different book! Only read 59 pages but life is too short. Gave up!
It's not as good as The Church of Dead Girls, but it fulfilled my subgroup within the guilty pleasures of books taking place in boarding schools. Not bad.
Not nearly as incisivelly insightful as Church of the Dead Girls but had some moments and kept me relatively engaged.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 21 22 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Crying Wolf
  • Suspicion of Innocence (Gail Connor and Anthony Quintana #1)
  • Double (Nameless Detective, #13)
  • The Wishing Game
  • Quietus
  • Where Serpents Lie
  • Special Circumstances (Mike Daley/Rosie Fernandez Mystery, Book 1)
  • Beyond Recognition (Boldt/Matthews, #4)
  • Sliver
  • Silent Snow
  • Vanity Dies Hard
  • Stolen Away (Nathan Heller, #6)
  • The Last Whisper in the Dark
  • Deadfall (Alex Jensen / Jessie Arnold, #5)
  • Hoodoo Herb and Root Magic: A Materia Magica of African-American Conjure
  • Caught In The Light
  • The Best American Mystery Stories 2010
  • The Breaker
Dobyns was raised in New Jersey, Michigan, Virginia, and Pennsylvania. He was educated at Shimer College, graduated from Wayne State University, and received an MFA from the Iowa Writers' Workshop at the University of Iowa in 1967. He has worked as a reporter for the Detroit News.

He has taught at various academic institutions, including Sarah Lawrence College, the Warren Wilson College MFA Program...more
More about Stephen Dobyns...
The Church Of Dead Girls The Burn Palace Best Words, Best Order: Essays on Poetry Velocities: New and Selected Poems, 1966-1992 The Wrestler's Cruel Study

Share This Book

“Let's say someone has experienced a violent trauma or betrayal: a child has been raped by a parent or has witnessed the destruction of someone he loves or has been so traumatized by the possibility of beatings and punishments that he's afraid to act. If the trauma is great enough, that person's life may become frozen, emotionally frozen even though he still gets up in the morning, is busy all day, and goes to bed at night. But there's this empty space that begins to fill with rage, rage toward everyone - the perpetrator, the people in the world who haven't suffered, even toward himself. (174)” 19 likes
“There are many reasons for violence. This is just something that sometimes happens. We'd see it in treatment centers - the child who'd suffered something awful. Even in the best recovery there'd be a fear that everything would fall apart and they'd become victims again. And their final loyalty was to themselves. They couldn't be forced. They preferred to wreck everything, preferred self-destruction to surrender. (175)” 11 likes
More quotes…