The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten: 100 Experiments for the Armchair Philosopher

The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten: 100 Experiments for the Armchair Philosopher

3.83 of 5 stars 3.83  ·  rating details  ·  926 ratings  ·  115 reviews
Both entertaining and startling, The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten offers one hundred philosophical puzzles that stimulate thought on a host of moral, social, and personal dilemmas. Taking examples from sources as diverse as Plato and Steven Spielberg, author Julian Baggini presents abstract philosophical issues in concrete terms, suggesting possible solutions while encouragi...more
Paperback, 336 pages
Published June 27th 2006 by Plume (first published July 5th 2005)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,963)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Aerin
This book had me, at many points while reading it, questioning the reality of reality. Oh, philosophy. Who needs mind-altering drugs when you can just read some of the crazy shit Descartes came up with, or Hume?

This book struck a nice balance between pointy-headedness and understandability - there were a lot of interesting references to classic philosophers, but it was still a very easy read. There are 100 short chapters, each starting with a thought experiment, followed up by a few pages of dis...more
David
I thought this deserved 3.5 stars, but I'm perfectly happy to round up to 4 on the grounds that it was entertaining, thought-provoking, unpretentious and well-executed. Other reviewers have faulted it for lacking philosophical depth, but really - what could they have been expecting? The author makes no pretences, and the format of the book couldn't be clearer. It is what it sets out to be - 100 brief "philosophy" puzzles, each following a strict 3-page format, in which the puzzle/paradox/point o...more
Scotty
Is it right to eat a pig that wants to be eaten? The Pig That Wants to be Eaten by Julian Baggini is a very intriguing book centered on moral philosophy. The book also questions whether thinking morally or thinking rationally would be more acceptable given a number of situations. On top of that, Baggini writes the book in a way that makes the reader question their morality and own thoughts. Baggini writes in reflection of thought experiments. These are obscure stories that isolate the real worl...more
Victoria
Feb 02, 2011 Victoria rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Budding philosophers
Recommended to Victoria by: Rachael Elward
This book was a Christmas gift from an old friend who clearly knows me well. Despite having studied philosophy reasonably intensively in the past, this little book of thought experiments was both entertaining and engaging. One of the things that I love about philosophy is that it can be read and understood at many different levels and this book is no exception. Baggini has taken 100 famous philosophical conundrums, re-written them in his own words and then added a brief discussion of the topic...more
Mike
Jan 10, 2009 Mike rated it 3 of 5 stars Recommends it for: people who never took philosophy in college
Shelves: philosophy
This book endeavors to present 100 mind-puzzles from the world of philosophy, each with a small narrative to introduce the idea followed by a short discussion of the principles involved. The book is wide-ranging, covering many classic philosophic concepts (Zeno's paradox, Pascal's wager, theodicy, the gambler's fallacy) and areas (the roots of identity, sensation and perception, fairness, the basis for ethics, the theory of meaning and language, etc.)

I got the impression that he had gotten to th...more
G
Jul 16, 2009 G marked it as to-read


A edição original inglesa deste livro leva o título de 'O porco que quer ser comido' e refere-se a um dos cem jogos de pensamentos propostos pelo autor. Do paradoxo de Zenão à teoria de Nietzsche do eterno retorno, passando pelo paradoxo do restaurante indiano e a caverna de Platão, utilizando exemplos vivos e pitorescos de filmes como 'Laranja Mecânica' e 'Minority Report', televisão, literatura e clássicos da filosofia, este livro faz com que a filosofia, além de expandir a mente, também seja...more
Sidster
This book is a fun introduction to the wide range of problems that philosophers tackle. I questioned a few of the author's claims and his account of Nietzsche's Over Man is faulted enough to make me reconsider the previous sections that I thought Baggini had misrepresented. His anti-deist approach might mislead prospective students of Philosophy to think that deism has no place in this discipline. I found Baggini solid in discussing a variety of ethical issues, and his accounts of the problems f...more
Jtrockla
This was an entertaining book. Personally, I enjoy exercises in logic, so this was right up my alley. This isn't the type of book you can sit with and read through in an evening. True, the book is short and could be read very quickly...but reading it quickly would defeat the whole point. If you read a few of the experiments...and take the time to actually think about what is being proposed...you will find that you may have read 10-15 pages, but an hour could have easily passed.

This is a good bo...more
Aries
Avendo avuto una preparazione scolastica estremamente tecnica e quindi piuttosto carente dal punto di vista "classico" ed essendo io, come forse si è notato, molto curioso, sono stato sempre piuttosto affascinato dalla filosofia, combattutto tra il ritenerla un insieme di seghe mentali a raffica ed, invece, farmi rapire da qualche testo ad hoc.E' abbastanza naturale, quindi, che un libro come "Il maiale che vuole essere mangiato ed altri 99 esperimenti mentali" abbia attirato la mia attenzione....more
Maria
Aug 07, 2011 Maria added it
Another one of those books I picked up randomly (this time at Sydney Airport) as I was taken by the idea of short, thought provoking snippets that challenge, but not too much ! Overall a mixed bag, some deep, some interesting, some a bit trivial (at least to me). One can zip through it very quickly without thinking too much or it can be quite the opposite. I was most drawn to existential questions and found myself reading & re-reading those chapters 5 or 6 times. Overall an enjoyable read, b...more
Bill
Pithy and mostly thought provoking comments on some classical philosophical questions. Starts to feel over stretched and repetitive around 80 in, as the format doesn't allow for some of the questions that require more preamble to be introduced.

is it overly popularist? introduces the material but doesn't make recommendations for further study, its aim seems to be to amuse rather then to pull one into a more in-depth examination of the questions.

It was my book by the loo for some months, feels tha...more
Daniel Wright
This was without doubt an intriguing and mind-opening book. There probably aren't many better books in the pop-philosophy genre out there. Through a sequence of illustrations, Baggini gives a clear exposition to a wide range of philosophical issues and ethical dilemmas. Moreover, he usually recognises (though not explicitly) that the practice of philosophy is more about asking questions than giving doctrinaire answers.

The operative word in the previous sentence, though, is "usually". There is a...more
Miguel
Baggini's collection of philosophical thought experiments, brain teasers that expose the reader to complicated philosophical problems through simple hypotheticals, is not a novel. Because the book is a collection of thought experiments and not a narrative, the five stars awarded to it are not the same as the five stars awarded to the book are not the same as five stars awarded to a literary classic. Still, The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten is a phenomenal read.

Baggini explores philosophical issues...more
Maggie
In this book, Julian Baggini presents 100 thought experiments, questioning definitions, introducing paradoxes, posing ethical dilemmas, challenging assumptions and identifying fallacies. Each thought experiment is about three pages long, with an introduction in the form of a short, often out-of-this-world scenario that presents a dilemma, followed by a quick summary of the arguments in favour of either side of the dilemma. While he says in the preface that "Many lines of thought can be started f...more
Yasmine Alfouzan


This book delivers what it promises: engaging 100 thought experiments that are a wonderful introduction to the most basic philosophical puzzles. It is a great read for anyone new to philosophy and those who feel overwhelmed by the history of philosophy and keep asking themselves, "Well, where do I start?"
I, being someone who knew about half of the things discussed in this book, did not feel that it's boring or stale since the author cleverly wrote out different hypothetical scenarios as an intr...more
Jody Mena
Some very interesting conundrums to consider. I liked the problems themselves, but some of the observations on them seemed a bit biased, so I prefered to think on the problems themselves before reading the author's analysis of them. I really think I would have liked it better if only the thought problems themselves were presented, without the author's opinions, since in most cases, they are simply one person's opinion, but they have a tendency to influence one's critical thinking process.
Gibb
I bought this as with 100 short one page 'thought experiments' it looked like Martin Cohen's book of 101 short 'Philosophy Problems'. And indeed there are a lot of similarites, but I found the style repetitious and in places, condescending. I don't think it's as 'funny' as it wants to appear (with the quirky title and cover) and it sure ain't going to teach anyone much philosophy. Triumph of marketing over content, I guess. Bit like 'Sophie's World', in that respect.
Holmes
Rarely have I come across such a thought-provoking book. The 100 interesting and mind-boggling - sometimes even otherworldly - questions make me reexamine my logical thinking. What's especially praiseworthy about this book is that it's not all about rationality. It makes references to other considerations such as social responsibility and trust, and does it in a non-didactic way.

All in all, it's a wonderful book for people who like to think about thinking.
Jason
Mar 15, 2009 Jason rated it 2 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Someone standing in a bookstore with five minutes to kill
Recommended to Jason by: Wes B.
Amusing at times, but completely pointless at other times. Baggini's thought experiments seemed to repeat. He goes too far into "what if" land. Throughout the book he takes ideas from philosophers like Descartes and Plato and writers like Douglas Adams (hence the title) and Ray Bradbury and changes the philosopher's original scenario or vignette into his own version. I found this approach useless; I would have rather had the original at my fingertips.
Jesse Winslow
What an interesting little book. Great for people with short attention spans like me as each chapter is only about 2-4 pages long. Basically he takes 100 philosophical arguments and presents them in a new light, then explains where he got them from and why this idea is important. Very simple to read, but you'll find yourself thinking about each subject long after the book is down. A great book to share also as it's fun to talk about each argument.
Fernando del Alamo
El título en castellano de este libro es "¿Se creen que somos tontos?: 100formas de detectar las falacias de los políticos y los medios de comunicación". Consiste en 100 frases que contienen una falacia dicha por alguien famoso (se supone) y a partir de ahí plantea una reflexión sobre dicha falacia. Bastante interesante, ameno y que da qué pensar. Tenéis el libro explicado con más detalle en mi blog http://www.historiasdelaciencia.com/?...
Joseph
I liked this, and some of the thought experiments were truly thought-provoking as described. However I felt that at times it was a bit too ... "mainstream"? Is that the word? I mean, I LOVED some of the experiments, but some of the scenarios used to explain them are about things like soap operas, .. I guess to cater to the mainstream not-too-bookish audience they were targeting? Anyway I just found it a bit irritating. But still liked the book
Judith
Scenarios that could actually happen...instead of the land of the Yes and the No knights
who say "yes" but it could mean "yes, what you say is false" instead of "yes, that's true."
I hated that one...grrr, still makes me mad after all these years.

Ahem...but these experiments are down-to-earth. I am fond of the "Picasso" one. I won't tell
you anything about it; you have to read it.
Chris Bundy
I am not quite finished with it yet but, so far, it is quite good. If you can keep your Christian beliefs (emotions) un-offended, you will enjoy this book. It is thought-provoking (intent of the author!) and a challenge for those of us who defend the faith. It can be used as a tool to study counter arguments using Scripture and logic. I highly recommend.
Jay T.
The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten by Julian Baggini

A random buy for me, found at a book sale and I’m glad I bought this book. Containing 100 philosophical experiments that the author does not answer, but gives you the chance to think and come to a conclusion of your own. This is a fact that I very much liked about this book. The many experiments contain issues ranging from moral to social, religions to politics, zombies to personal dilemmas and vegetarians verses meat. There is no need to be a smar...more
Sean Bode
Im not one to review a book i havent finished. Given the nature of this Conversation starter i couldnt help it. The book has modest claims. It tours philosophical dilemmas that trouble modern minds like a connoisour at a wine tasting. It knows its audiance too: Armchair philosophers. This has lead to many an entertaining debate for me. Enjoy!
Ben
What it lacks in depth it makes up for in accessibility. Drawing on everything from Confucius to Philip K. Dick, it's a good introduction to philosophy, and each scenario is accompanied by a little breakdown which elaborates on the themes and arguments and cracks open the ideas to get the reader thinking. Whilst not always as amusing as it thinks it is, the writing style is engaging and easy to understand. If you're already a thoughtful person, or have some experience with philosophy, then you'r...more
Nikki
Interesting set of scenarios. It's sometimes a bit... oversimplified, for me, although since I did philosophy in my first year of university, that's unsurprising. Sometimes it's a bit repetitive, too: I wouldn't say that there's 100 distinct problems here.

Easy enough to pick up and flick through as interests you.
Heather Browning
A fun glance at many of the most interesting puzzles and thought experiments in philosophy. As a philosophy student, many of these were familiar to me, but I still appreciated that they were entertaining and accessible. I enjoyed discussing the various ideas with my partner, gave us a lot to talk about on a long train ride and new perspectives on some old ideas.
Ana Lopes
Traduzido no Brasil como "O Porco Filósofo" (impresso pela editora Damarã).
Baggini traz as discussões filosóficas - dos mais variados assuntos - para o nosso cotidiano.
Uma forma bem humorada de lidar com os questionamentos trazidos pelos filósofos mais clássicos.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 65 66 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
The Pig That Wants To Be Eaten: And Ninety Nine Other Thought Experiments (Paperback)
The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten (Paperback)
The Pig That Wants To Be Eaten
The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten: 100 Experiments for the Armchair Philosopher (ebook)
The Pig That Wants to Be Eaten: 100 Experiments for the Armchair Philosopher (Kindle Edition)

42326
Julian Baggini is a British philosopher and the author of several books about philosophy written for a general audience. He is the author of The Pig that Wants to be Eaten and 99 other thought experiments (2005) and is co-founder and editor of The Philosophers' Magazine. He was awarded his Ph.D. in 1996 from University College London for a thesis on the philosophy of personal identity. In addition...more
More about Julian Baggini...
Atheism: A Very Short Introduction The Ego Trick: In Search Of The Self The Philosophers Toolkit: A Compendium of Philosophical Concepts and Methods What's It All About?: Philosophy and the Meaning of Life The Duck That Won the Lottery: and 99 Other Bad Arguments

Share This Book

Your website